What do you think of those people of the Black Ming Dynasty?

Tartars hinder the continuity of the development of the group! It's continuity! What a civilization fears most is the interruption of continuity!

The Sumerian civilization and the ancient Egyptian civilization were 1,000-3,000 years earlier than the Xia, Shang and Zhou dynasties in China, and the Chinese civilization is the only civilization with continuity in the world. The connectedness of a civilization is very important.

The views are more extreme, the problem is not comprehensive enough, and the Ming Dynasty also has better aspects, but they only choose to see the bad side.

Anyway, the sunspots of the Black Ming Dynasty that I have seen almost don't even understand the most basic history. Especially for Hei Yuan Chonghuan, the battle of Ningyuan and the battle of Ningjin are indistinguishable.

The emergence of an era will have its own historical needs, this is a historical civilization, we can only discuss history but not judge, we should learn from experience, do our best.

The historical stage of the Ming Dynasty is also relatively special, and if it goes well, the historical trajectory is different, and if it doesn't go well, it's just like the history we see, the last glory of orthodox classical China. Ming's flaws also led to his eventual demise.

I think it's a very stupid behavior for those who go to Hey Ming Dynasty people, because those people are long gone, so what's the point of hacking them?

I think everyone has their own opinion on everything, and it's good to be tolerant and don't need to care too much.

Those people in the Black Ming Dynasty must have his black spots, and the Ming Dynasty sometimes really makes people hate this dynasty, such as the Jinyiwei of the Ming Dynasty that period of time was worrying.

is that in fact, everyone has their own ideas, so everyone has a different opinion on each concept, so the Black Ming Dynasty does not represent everyone.

One powder is top ten black, and Ming Fan is a bunch of historical whites, and if you can't win, you can only deduct your hat.

There is black when it is blown, and some Ming powder is very excessive, and how the Ming Dynasty is blown will be black. There are also some bright black, catching a little black spot, infinitely boasting and exaggerating, and taking out the Qing Dynasty's smearing of the Ming Dynasty, even a three-year-old child.

I think the Ming Dynasty people did have a lot of black spots, so it is very normal to be hacked, and there are indeed some things that are very much in the modern era.

My favorite dynasty is the Emperor Ming, the most backbone dynasty in history.

There are no black fans in that dynasty, and no one is perfect, and there will always be one or two things that are not good, which is normal.

Pure black and pure powder are ignorant of history.

Those who blindly fan a single nation are also ultra-nationalists.

What history reflects on is not a struggle of wills.

Black Ming Dynasty? The whole history of China has been invaded, and what else is there to hack is inherently bad.

Disdain, that's all du who watch too much on TV

Listen to zhi commentaries and listen to rumors, because of the exaggeration of the eunuch eunuch's answer, as well as the misunderstanding of Jinyiwei and the East and West Factories, in fact, the Ming Dynasty is a rare unification in history, more than 200 years of dynasties, the germ of capitalism was also produced at that time, to be honest, without the subversion of the Qing Dynasty, maybe China will enter the capitalist society ahead of Western countries, and Zhu Di is an emperor comparable to Li Shiming in history, look at the official history.

Then you go to the Ming Dynasty. I like Tang and Song.

There are historians, the reason for the Qing Dynasty's smear is the same as Zhu Di's revision of "Ming Shilu", all of which are to whitewash his reasonable and legal inheritance of the orthodoxy of the Central Plains Dynasty, in order to cover up the fact that he won the country unjustly.

I'm sorry, the most powerful thing about the Black Ming Dynasty is precisely the "Ming Shilu" written by the Ming Dynasty's own historians, but the "History of the Ming Dynasty" repaired by the Qing Dynasty not only did not black the Ming Dynasty, but also spoke highly of most of the emperors of the Ming Dynasty. This is a great irony.

There were certainly historians in the Ming Dynasty, but this is the case with every change of dynasty. The winners will always write the losers worthless. For the victorious Qing Dynasty, in order to consolidate its rule, it was necessary for the people to accept the current dynasty and no longer miss the old dynasty.

Naturally, it is necessary to write some bad so-called history books of the Ming Dynasty, and these history books, after they have been handed down, are naturally the negative ones we see. The relative Ming Dynasty was the same for the Yuan Dynasty, all of them came in black with the Yuan Dynasty.

The Qing Dynasty did it. Just like the King of the Rings. is obviously a good person, but he was hacked into a heinous person.

Whichever victory will always make the previous dynasty corrupt You can go to any one dynasty.

Don't take the Ming Dynasty to the extreme, how can the mite Qing rule and enslave the people.

How can you write such a thing as not going to court for 36 years?

The Ming Dynasty is one of my favorite dynasties, and in my opinion, it has endless charm. In the Ming Dynasty, Zhu Yuanzhang, an inspirational model in Chinese history, appeared, and the story of his growth touched me a lot. He went from being a man with no name to becoming the founder of the Ming Dynasty, which I admire!

There are few such people in history, although there are also Liu Bang.

Such people exist, but according to the research of scholars, in fact, Liu Bang has a certain economic strength, and the conditions are much better than Zhu Yuanzhang. Returning to the theme, in the face of the situation that some people have been black in the Ming Dynasty and the Fan Qing Dynasty, I think there are the following reasons:

Ming Taizu Zhu Yuanzhang).

First of all, the Ming Dynasty was overthrown by the Qing Dynasty. This has established a basis of understanding in the hearts of some people, who think that the Ming Dynasty is not good at war, and the emperor is not good, and what kind of eunuchs interfere in politics. Their idol is Nurhachi.

Huang Taiji and others. Indeed, as the founders of the foundation of the Qing Dynasty, these two people have many praiseworthy points and worthy of respect.

But in the history of the late Ming Dynasty, there were also people who deserved our respect, such as Yuan Chonghuan.

The patriotic spirit he displayed when the building was about to fall is worthy of the admiration of every Chinese son! At the same time, he was facing the Jurchens.

When the iron cavalry showed outstanding military strength, he achieved great victories in Ningyuan and Ningjin, and killed the military wizard Nurhachi, which is very rare.

In addition, those people in the Black Ming Dynasty made the mistake of generalizing. I think they regard the history of the late Ming Dynasty as the entire history of the Ming Dynasty, and think that the entire Ming Dynasty is the state of the later period, which is a big mistake. In the history of the Ming Dynasty, Zhu Yuanzhang and Zhu Di appeared.

and other outstanding emperors, such as Zhang Juzheng.

Such a "prime minister's master" (Li Zhenyu), there are also noble people like Yu Qian, and Wang Yangming also appears.

People with a capital letter, etc. If the above-mentioned people are placed in any other era, they are all first-class characters, and those people of the Black Ming Dynasty can't see it?

"The Prime Minister's Master" Zhang Juzheng).

Finally, those who fan the Qing Dynasty still make a mistake when looking at the history of the Qing Dynasty. It is not advisable to regard the history of the early Qing Dynasty as the entire history of the Qing Dynasty. They forgot that it was Qianlong's arrogance that led to the fact that he was derailed from the world at that time, and they also forgot that it was Weng Tonggong.

The private fight with Li Hongzhang led to the First Sino-Japanese Naval Battle to a certain extent.

of failures. The history of these humiliations is all in the Qing Dynasty!

National Hero Deng Shichang).

Finally, I believe that both the Qing Dynasty and the Ming Dynasty are very important eras in the history of our country, and they have their own values, and we should look at them more comprehensively, rather than generalizing about them.

Because the Qing Dynasty and the Ming Dynasty were very different, every emperor of the Qing Dynasty was very productive, so some people would do it.

The most powerful dynasty in Chinese history is the Han and Tang dynasties, and I also like the Han and Tang dynasties the most, followed by the Ming Dynasty, and I don't like the Song Dynasty, and the Qing Dynasty is even worse.

It's not clear, it's probably just a matter of personal preference. But the truth of history should be understood.

The Ming Dynasty was founded in 276 years, which can be divided into four wonderful historical stages: Hongwu Entrepreneurship, Yongxuan Zhizhizhi, Hongzhi Zhongxing and Longwan Shengshi. Among them, the Longqing and Wanli years (1567-1620) lasted for 54 years, which was a rare period of enlightenment, openness, prosperity and stability in ancient Chinese history.

It is a pity that due to the habitual thinking caused by the slander and smear of the Qing Dynasty's "History of the Ming Dynasty", this period of Longwan Shengshi, which was not inferior to Kaiyuan and far superior to Kangqian, was rarely mentioned and understood, and even more lacked concepts and research. The good news is that the academic community is now starting to propose and study this topic.

In the first year of Longqing (1567), the benevolent and enlightened emperor Ming Muzong Zhu Zaiyuan issued an edict to lift the sea ban, open overseas, and allow private people to sell the east and west oceans, which is known as "Longqing switch" in history. Since then, the private overseas ** has gained a legal status, which has promoted the prosperity and development of the social economy, and the germ of capitalism has appeared in the relations of production. In the Wanli period (1573-1620), Zhu Yijun, a benevolent and promising Mingshenzong, continued and developed this trend, and the country's comprehensive strength became stronger, and the Ming Dynasty entered a new historical period - the prosperous era of Longwan.

For more than half a century, the Ming Dynasty made outstanding achievements in economy, culture, science and technology, national defense and other aspects, the political system gradually moved towards a constitutional monarchy, and the people were generally happy, healthy, clean, civilized, self-confident, and polite, which was envied, studied and studied by all countries in the world at that time. Therefore, this glorious history is also fully worthy of the pride and pride of today's Chinese people.

Facts speak louder than words, let's first look at the feelings of the ancient Chinese about the prosperous era of Longwan——

Cautionary Words" (Feng Menglong).

swept away the remnants of Hu Li Diji, and the dragon and phoenix danced Cui Wei;

The left ring is the sea and sky, and the right is surrounded by Taihang Mountain.

The nine sides of the halberd are overwhelming, and the clothes of all countries hang down;

The Taiping people are happy to be in the world, and the eternal golden ou is full of sunshine.

This poem only praises the prosperity of our dynasty and the establishment of the capital of Yanjing. Speaking of the situation of Yandu, the north leans on Xiongguan, and the south presses the area of Xia, which is really Jincheng Tianfu, the foundation of ten thousand years of perseverance. At the beginning, Hong Wuye swept away Hu Chen, and Dingding Jinling was for Nanjing.

When Yongle Ye started his troops from Beiping and moved to Yandu, it was for Beijing. Just because of this move, the bitter cold ground has been transformed into a brocade world.

Since the ninth generation of Yongle Ye to Wanli Ye, this is the eleventh generation of the Son of Heaven in my dynasty.

This son of heaven, smart and martial, virtuous and prosperous, ascended the throne at the age of ten, reigned for forty-eight years, and leveled three rebellions.