The evaluation of Jiang Wei in history is very divided, how to evaluate him correctly?

Updated on history 2024-04-26
5 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    The evaluation of Jiang Wei in history is very divided, and it should be possible to use the merit to be lowIt's right to evaluate him。He had a lot of controversy about the evaluation of Jiang Wei in history at that time, some people said that he was unfilial, had a bad personality and was disgusted by many people in doing things. At that time, Jiang Wen may have done a lot of excessive things, some people said that he abandoned his mother and betrayed his country, and these two things made many people hate him very much.

    Therefore, people's impression of him is not particularly good, and their evaluation of him is also very different. <

    There are two aspects to a person's personality, and they cannot all be perfect. No one is perfect, there is no perfect person in this world, everyone has their own shortcomings, some people's shortcomings may be smaller, but some people's shortcomings are bigger. But for Jiang Wei, who is not filial to his mother and betrays his country, this thing may be a bit excessive.

    Therefore, it is impossible for people to forgive one thing now or in ancient times. A generation of emperors, Qin Shi Huang, the first king in history

    He has his own talent and his own courage to build this country, transform this country, and make the country's people live more prosperous and powerful, but his character is actually very flawed, his character is very brutal, and suspicious by nature, which is also one of his weaknesses and shortcomings, if his character is a little better, then I believe that Qin can survive for a longer time. <>

    Therefore, there are certain deficiencies in the personality and some other aspects of the talent of each era. So just like when we make friends, like something that we are not good at, then the friend may be good at it, so the two people must really complement each other. Whether it is in making friends or in love and marriage, no, everyone has their own shortcomings, and two people together must complement each other and be considerate.

    Therefore, we have to look at Jiang Wei from two sides, and we can't generalize.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    I think he should be in a neutral attitude towards his platform, after all, he is a person with merits and faults, so you can't praise and disparage him too much. That's better.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Actually, I think he's a very capable person, but his personality is more eccentric, so he has such an evaluation.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Jiang Wei's most correct and objective evaluation should be talent and strategy, but his lack of initiative and flexibility leads to his low achievements.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Jiang Wei's Northern Expedition.

    In the twelfth year of Jianxing (234), Zhuge Liang died in Wuzhangyuan after "dying before leaving the division", Liu Chan, the queen of Shu, added Jiang Wei to the right supervising army and the general of the auxiliary Han Dynasty, commanded the armies, and entered the Pingxiang Marquis. Subsequently, he successively served as Sima, General Zhenxi, and concurrently served as Liangzhou Assassin Shi, General Wei, and General, and was awarded Fu Jie by the imperial court. According to the Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms, between 238 and 262 AD, Jiang Wei carried out a total of 11 Northern Expeditions.

    In the first Northern Expedition, in the first year of the Later Lord Yanxi (238), Jiang Wei and Jiang Wan led their divisions out of Longyou, and they were unable to hold on to the Wei army in Nan'an. In the second Northern Expedition, in the seventh year of Yanxi (244), Jiang Wei and Fei Yi sent troops to prosper and sent Wang Ping to attack the Wei general Cao Shuang, and Cao Shuang was defeated.

    The third Northern Expedition, Yanxi ten years (247 years) out of Longxi, with the Wei generals Guo Huai, Xiahou Ba against Taoxi.

    In the fourth Northern Expedition, in the twelfth year of Yanxi (249), Jiang Wei sent Liao Hua to Taocheng, at this time it was already "no general in Shu, Liao Hua was the vanguard", Jiang Wei fought with many generals of Wei alone, and the two sides won and lost each other.

    In the fifth Northern Expedition, in the thirteenth year of Yanxi (250), Jiang Wei was supplemented by Qianghu and fought with Guo Huai in Taoxi, and the two sides were tied.

    In the sixth Northern Expedition, after Fei Yi was assassinated and killed in the sixteenth year of Yanxi (253), Jiang Wei sent troops to surround Nan'an, and retreated after running out of food.

    The seventh Northern Expedition, in the seventeenth year of Yanxi (254), he went out of Longxi Didao and beheaded the Wei general Xu Qian.

    The eighth Northern Expedition, in the eighteenth year of Yanxi (255 years) and Xiahou Ba out of Di Dao, the great break of the king passed through Taoxi, Wang Jing retreated to Di Dao City, and then Chen Tai sent troops to relieve the siege.

    In the Ninth Northern Expedition, in 256, Jiang Wei sent troops again, and the Shu general Hu Ji did not arrive at the deadline, and Deng Ai broke through the Duan Valley, suffering heavy casualties.

    The tenth Northern Expedition, in 257, the Wei general Zhuge rebelled, Jiang Wei sent troops to Qinchuan, the Wei army held on without fighting, and in the first year of Yong'an (258), Zhuge was defeated and began to retreat.

    In the 11th Northern Expedition, in the fifth year of Jingyao (262), Jiang Wei sent troops again, fought with Deng Ai in Houhe, was broken by Deng Ai, and then returned to live in the middle of the river. This is Jiang Wei's last Northern Expedition, at this time Huang Hao wanted to replace Jiang Wei with Yan Yu, Jiang Wei was disgusted with Huang Hao's abuse of power, and asked the latter lord to kill Huang Hao, but the latter lord did not accept, Jiang Wei felt that this move might anger Huang Hao, in order to avoid trouble, he avoided living in the middle of the river, and Tuntian to avoid trouble. Zhong Hui, Deng Ai led the army to conquer Shu.

    In the sixth year of Jingyao (263), Shu died.

Related questions
9 answers2024-04-26

Although he suppressed the Taiping Rebellion and hindered historical progress, he was the promoter of the Westernization Movement and promoted historical progress.

10 answers2024-04-26

Powerful, Sun Ce's martial arts lie in "deciding before the two formations", commanding the army, not going into battle shirtless. Although he had outstanding performances on the battlefield, Sun Ce in history was not known for his martial bravery, but his courage and ability, good at employing people and his courage became the capital for him to rank among the first-class figures in the Three Kingdoms era. If in various versions of the Three Kingdoms game, Sun Ce's force can basically be equal to Tai Shi Ci, and he can rank in the top ten, and his strategy is not low!

5 answers2024-04-26

Zhao Yun in the official history is indeed not as powerful as in Romance, at least there is nothing in and seven out, but it must not be said to be weak. There are many reasons why Zhao Yun's reputation is not obvious, and the two biggest ones should be his background and his position. Zhao Yun's position is mainly to protect Liu Bei's safety, and the force value cannot be weak, but there are not so many troops leading the army to fight, so he has not made much merit. >>>More

14 answers2024-04-26

Because he knew that the Shu Kingdom would eventually perish, but he still had to do something for the survival of the Shu Kingdom.

23 answers2024-04-26

She is very favored, she not only has strong political skills, but also is virtuous and deeply loved. She respects the emperor's decision and will never be autocratic, which is also where she is smart. She was old and decrepit, and Emperor Wen of Han began to pamper other young beauties, but he still respected Dou Yifang very much.