How to look at the old and new Dream of Red Mansions 15

The old version of Dream of Red Mansions can be said to be a classic that is difficult to surpass, director Wang Fulin selects actors on the street, and when he sees the right one, he joins the crew, not like today's draft. Although it can't be compared with the current one from the scene layout to the makeup, it should be unmatched in the choice of actors. Chen Xiaoxu doesn't have to act as Sister Lin, no matter how innocent a person's temperament is, he can't go back to the past, or Zhang Yimou wouldn't have to go to great lengths to choose actors if he didn't have to shoot the hawthorn tree.

See what you like.

I like the old version of the Red Mansion.

Maybe you like the new version.

That's it.

The old and the new Dream of Red Mansions have their own shortcomings, but I prefer the old ones. The old version of the actor lived in the Grand View Garden for 3 years to experience the Dream of Red Mansions, and the new version sent the actor to a 5-star hotel, saying that he wanted to cultivate temperament, is this cultivated? There is also the new version of Sister Lin, she is very beautiful, but Sister Lin is a weak person, she is too healthy to act, and the old version of Sister Lin is born with a weak temperament, so she is very suitable for acting.

The details in the new version are not in place, because the filming time of this drama is too short, and every time the details are corrected, Dream of Red Mansions is one of the four great Chinese masterpieces, and it should not be as hasty as the new version. There are many characters in the new version that do not conform to Cao Xueqin's description, and the old version was carefully selected at that time. The makeup of the new version is better than the old version, but this is normal, when the makeup was not good in the past, the characters can be played so well, which shows how beautiful the person looks.

To paraphrase Guo Degang's words, the sister Lin in the old version of the Dream of Red Mansions seems to have fallen from the sky to the world, and the sister Lin in the new version of the Dream of Red Mansions looks like she came from the heavens and the earth. Ha.

Old and New Dream of Red Mansions? Don't know how you categorize. It should be a different version, it's the passbook and the other version.

The popular version is the last forty chapters of Gao E, the general version, which is suitable for readers who are reading Dream of Red Mansions for the first time. Other versions, such as Qi Xuben, Yi Mao Ben, Gengchen Ben, etc., most of them have comments from Yan Zhai, which is suitable for researchers who love Dream of Red Mansions.

I think that although the new version of the Red Mansion has many shortcomings, we should also take a look at his good side. Also, many people scold the new version of the Red Mansion as worthless, as for it. How many of those people have really seen it, and they are there to coax and scold.

To be honest, I also don't think the new version is good, but after all, this is something that people have spent their time shooting. Let's not look at a problem too subjectively. The actors in the old version did play better, but there will be shortcomings.

I'm thinking about a question, what would be the situation if the new version of the Red Mansion came out before the old version? Also, some people have never really seen the people in the Red Mansion, so they say that this should be like this, this should be like this. I'm depressed, uh.

In short, let's not look too subjective. The old version and the new version each have their own strengths and weaknesses.

Works of different eras and styles.

All of them are beautiful, and they are all rare works of art.

To answer you directly, the "Encyclopedia of China" commented that the value of Dream of Red Mansions cannot be overestimated. Encyclopedia Britannica commented that the value of "Dream of the Red Chamber" is equal to that of the whole of Europe. These, can you say that Jin Yong's ** can reach this level?

Cao Xueqin wrote this Dream of Red Mansions in her life, and she has not finished writing it, only the first eighty times. The generic version is Gao E's continuation, and there are many sequels, and no one knows what the real ending is. There is a theory that Cao Lao's manuscript was lost.

That's why so many people study its outcome.

It is not just a **, it is almost a microcosm of the aristocratic life of the feudal society at that time. And it's not all fiction, it shows the decadence of feudal society at that time. The clothes, diet, rules, social atmosphere, etc. described in Dream of Red Mansions are not fiction, let's put it this way, there is a person named Zhen Shiyin in Dream of Red Mansions, homonym True Things Hidden.

This book is the brainchild of Cao Lao's life. If you go through the textbooks of the first year of high school, you will understand why it is one of the four great masterpieces and not the martial arts of Jin Yong or Gu Long**.

Invent? To put it mildly, who can make up such a dream of Red Mansions in contemporary times? Not to mention that it's not fiction!! It's all true!! I don't know if you can understand that.

Well, I'm excited. Compare Jin Yong's martial arts** with Dream of Red Mansions? Ignorance isn't like you, is it?

You'd better go watch those fictional martial arts**. I beg you to spare Dream of Red Mansions.

You can look for it on the Internet, and the text about its value will make you stunned.

You can actually not watch Dream of Red Mansions. Since you're just treating it as a fictional **, can I say you're insulting Dream of Red Mansions?

Because it covers a wide range of contents, including literature, economics, politics, philosophy, medicine, aesthetics, and so on, it can be said that almost all existing traditional disciplines can start from the Dream of Red Mansions.

Dream of Red Mansions is at the pinnacle of reading points, and it is a "big encyclopedia" of the ancient world, customs, etc

1. Dream of Red Mansions is an encyclopedia. The etiquette, clothing, food, housing, decoration, customs and customs of the Ming and Qing dynasties are all reflected. This is its contribution to the study of ancient society, history, and folklore.

Understanding these things is more helpful for us to understand our own culture, and it is also helpful for the interpretation of some literary works, calligraphy and painting works, and historical events.

2. Dream of Red Mansions is a very charming literary work. Although some people can't stand it, there are countless people who are fascinated by it and take the Red Chamber as their hobby. The foreshadowing, article structure, phrasing, description, narrative, content, philosophical principles, and details in Dream of Red Mansions are enough for people to study for a long time, and people can gain something.

, Zhang Ailing, Sanmao, Wang Guowei, etc. are all people who love Dream of Red Mansions and love them immensely. Because of their love for Red Mansions, many people discuss it as a hobby.

3. There are too many places where Dream of Red Mansions can enlighten people, such as Confucianism, Buddhism and Taoism, such as the use of instruments for people, such as emphasizing religion rather than art, such as being heart-oriented, such as the moon is full, the water is full and overflowing, which are the essence of thousands of years of Chinese culture, and there are also innovations.

4, Jin Yong's ** is also great, but it is not worth the Dream of Red Mansions after all. It's not me talking nonsense, if you ask Jin Yong about this, he will never dare to compare his works with Dream of Red Mansions.

5. Studying whose prototype is who, Tanchun marrying **, these are all things that people start to discover when they are bored, not for the sake of being more serious, but for their own hobbies. The study of the Dream of the Red Chamber should focus more on the literary techniques, the society, the theme, and the philosophical implications of the Dream of the Red Chamber. A lot of the research that you have done in this area is very valuable.

1.Visually speaking, it is beautiful, and although the hairpins' foreheads (copper coin heads) have been criticized, they are also beautiful if they are combined with the background. 2.

In terms of plot, although it is basically the original book, many important plots are still deleted, which affects the coherence of the story. 3.Judging from the selection of the version of Dream of Red Mansions, the 120-fold version of the Great Joy style is obviously not suitable, because according to Cao Xueqin's meaning, the Jia family should be defeated.

4.Judging from the shooting and background of the TV, Li Shaohong's lens shines, and the weird ** is quite in harmony with the story. However, some people feel that it is a bit excessive, a bit like a ghost movie, their own feelings are the most important, let's taste it yourself!

Before the release of the new version of Dream of Red Mansions, the various characters of the old version of Dream of Red Mansions were deeply rooted in the hearts of the people and preconceived, so it is to be expected that it did not receive the desired response. Personally, I think the new version of Dream of Red Mansions and the old version have their own merits, the new version of Tanchun is more "radiant and forgetful" than the old version, and the new version of Daiyu is also very good (of course, I prefer the old version of Chen Xiaoxu), the new version of Li Kun is not good, there is no old version of the "heart is like ashes" look. Besides, I think the narration of the new version of Dream of Red Mansions is too much, and it is all read according to the original book, which may be more suitable for children, because children like to read stories and like to be directly told the cause and effect.

Older people have a certain amount of life experience, and some things need to be savored and thought about by themselves, and they need to speculate on the inner world of the characters through the plot before and after, and too much narration will subjectively guide the audience's thinking, which is not advisable.