Why didn t the defenders knock down the ladder and throw stones down?

Because the ladder of the siege of the city is particularly strong, it is not easy to push down at all, and there are people on the ladder, it is even more difficult to push, and it is more convenient to choose to throw stones, and it can also kill people.

Because the siege ladder is too long and there are many people lying on it, the weight is so heavy that it cannot be pushed at all, so you can only throw stones to hit the enemy.

It can't be pushed down, the ladder is on the city wall and the city wall is triangular, it is the strongest shape, it is not easy to push, and it is faster and more offensive to throw stones directly.

The siege ladder in the TV looks vulnerable, but the actual siege ladder chassis is super stable. It's hard to even shake. Therefore, it will be better to throw stones down at this time and damage the engineering ladder.

Because the ladder is not easy to push, when the soldiers are attacking the city, the ladder is supported from below, and it is more effective to push and throw stones from the top down.

Because the siege ladder is not so easy to knock down, there is a very stable triangular base at the bottom of the ladder, which is not like the ladder we commonly use.

<> "Why don't the soldiers defending the city just knock down the enemy's ladder?"

When the ancient soldiers were attacking the city, they would choose to use ladders to build the city wall, so when the ancients were fighting, why didn't the soldiers defend the city push down the ladder, but threw stones down at the risk of death?

It is said that the earliest person who invented the ladder in ancient China was the public loss class, that is, Lu Ban, during the period of King Chu Hui, Lu Ban made the first ladder in history, this ladder is not only equipped with wheels, but also grappling hooks and other instruments, and the role of the design of the grappling hook is to avoid the ladder being pushed down by the soldiers defending the city, the so-called "pillow on the city", the stability of the ladder has become more reliable, and the ladder is generally very heavy, and ordinary people can not shake it at all.

If the soldier defending the city wants to push the tower, then he has to risk his own life and come out to knock down the enemy's ladder, but if he is exposed in this case, because this ladder is very heavy, and from the actual situation, when attacking, this ladder is very strong, very practical, and it can't be pushed at all, which is also the main reason.

Secondly, according to the ** rate recorded in this relevant information, if the soldier defending the city wants to push the tower, then he has to risk his own life to come out and push down the enemy's ladder, if it is exposed in this case, it is very likely to be killed by the enemy, if the soldier dies but does not push the ladder down, it is not a very loss, so generally speaking, no one will come out to push the enemy's ladder down.

In this way, no one dares to push the ladder, in the face of the local ladder siege, may choose the rolling stone, dumping the method of oil to inflict heavy damage on the enemy, but no one chooses the seemingly simplest Peicha ladder, because in comparison to push the ladder is too dangerous, we can all think of the method, the ancients Xiangwan is bound to think of, after various battles, they are more cautious in these aspects.

However, due to the advancement of science and technology, the use of the Tijin Zhongzi to attack the city wall gradually withdrew from the historical stage, because this method would cause a large number of people.

In ancient times, in that era of cold weapons, the cost of waging a war was very huge. Because the economy was not developed at that time, the various production processes were not perfect.

Of course, what is more important is the issue of population, a war will naturally cause a certain amount of population loss, which is naturally what a country's rule does not want to see. Therefore, the wars at that time were for a certain purpose, such as for the expansion of territory, or for the plundering of resources. In this way, the war has a certain purpose, so the ruler will carry it out desperately.

At that time, it was necessary to capture a city, whether for territory or resources. If you occupy the city, it is naturally possible to have territory, and the resources in the city will be your own.

However, in such an era when technology is not developed, how to capture a city with the flesh and blood of ordinary people. At that time, the rulers were all in order to maintain their own territory, and they would build strong cities. This made the siege extremely difficult, but it had to be done.

Their usual siege method is either to use a battering ram to hit the city gate, if in a long impact, the city gate is broken, then the siege battle is naturally stable, but if the defenders are unusually persistent, this method will naturally not work.

There is also the use of cloud ladders, the long ladder is leaned against the city wall, and the soldiers climb up one by one to fight with the soldiers defending the city. Naturally, this way is the most cruel.

In that war, it could take years to capture a city. Because cities are generally easy to defend and difficult to attack, as long as there is enough food and grass, it is okay to hold on for a few years.

But a war cannot avoid the final battle, and the besiegers may die on the way without even seeing the shadow of the enemy. Because they had to carry the ladder to the edge of the city wall, a rain of arrows might be waiting for them on the way there. So the ** of a war is extremely tragic.

But in the process of going forward and successing, there is always a small team carrying a ladder to the wall, they will set up such a tall ladder, maybe more than ten meters, they will start to climb up one by one, and if they can climb the tower, they can fight the opposing defenders.

They hoped to be able to defeat the enemy army in the tower, and then work with the soldiers downstairs to break down the city gate, so that they could attack the city in one fell swoop. Although this idea is very smooth, there will be many difficulties in the implementation process.

Because it is very difficult to push the ladder, and the whole body has to stick out of the city, it is easy to become a live target for the enemy troops under the city.

It takes a lot of effort to push down the ladder, and it is simply difficult to do.

Because the ladder for attacking the city in ancient times was not easy to knock down, it was not as simple as the ladder we use now, not only was it particularly large, but also had a very stable base.

In Chinese history, wars were very serious, because of the occupation of regions and the change of dynasties, wars naturally occurred.

But the siege of the city is a very tricky thing, in the face of the high city walls, the soldiers inside do not come out, and the people outside can only watch.

In recent years, due to the popularity of costume dramas, everyone has some basic understanding of history.

However, in order to increase ratings, film and television dramas have more or less adapted real history. For example, in the TV series, during the siege of the city in ancient times, the guards defending the city cut down the ladder and pushed the ladder down.

But in fact, when the city was actually attacked, the guards who defended the city never pushed down the ladder, but threw stones down with great effort.

Why didn't the ancient defenders push down the ladder and smash the stones instead? 1. The structure of the ladder is not what we think

The ladder used to attack the city in ancient times was not the kind of ladder that our engineering team used to repair wires, and it was complicated underneath.

It's the same as our current sedan, with a chassis underneath, and this chassis is quite sturdy. After these siege ladders were put up on the city wall, the soldiers below fixed the chassis from below, so that a relatively stable structure was formed.

Not to mention overthrowing it, even if a strong man comes and pushes it with all his might, it may not even shake.

2. The top of the ladder will be smeared with venom, poison needles, etc

The ladder used for siege has long been prepared, and there is a practice of applying poison to arrows in ancient times, and the top of the siege ladder will be sharpened and coated with deadly poison as long as there are conditions, so that the soldiers defending the city are not easy to start.

3. For the safety of the soldiers on the city wall

If you push the ladder, the soldier will be completely exposed, and it is possible that he will be killed by an arrow before he even touches the ladder.

Therefore, the soldiers will not joke with their lives, and as mentioned earlier, pushing a ladder is not a job that one person can do, and it requires many people to work together, so that it is not one person exposed.

Even if you are lucky enough to stand up and not be shot, the weight of hundreds of soldiers on the ladder that the enemy has set up, but it cannot be pushed down at once, so the process of pushing is not only time-consuming and laborious, but also a threat to life if you delay every tenths of a second.

The advantages of moving stones seem that this kind of thing may not be able to hit a few people at a time, but it can be rolled down in the direction of the siege ladder, as long as the weight of this stone is strong, there will hardly be many people left on this siege ladder.

Moreover, the stone is more likely to damage the siege ladder during the fall, whether it is broken on both sides or in the middle, the life of the siege ladder will come to an end.

Because the ladder for siege in ancient times was very long and not easy to be knocked down, and the effect of smashing with stones was better, so the soldiers defending the city did not push down the ladder, but had to work hard to move the stones.

Because there are hooks on the ladder, which have been hung dead on the city wall, the soldiers defending the city cannot push down the ladder for a short time.

Because the ladder in ancient times was specially manufactured, it was not as simple as in film and television works, and it could not be pushed at all under normal circumstances.

Because the ancients were not stupid, they would smear the top of the ladder with all kinds of poison, and in such a cruel environment as war, no soldier would dare to push the ladder in it.

Because it is more difficult to knock down ladders, the ladders used for siege in ancient times are not the same as the ladders we see now, not only have a very stable base, but also have a very large volume.

Because stones fall from a height and are more lethal than pushing them to a ladder, they don't push ladders, but throw stones.

Because it's safer to throw stones. Ladders are heavy and difficult to knock down, and if they haven't been pushed down, the enemy has already climbed up and can be killed, and throwing stones can kill the opponent.

Because the soldiers defending the city could not knock down the ladder at all, the ladder was generally very heavy, and the most important thing was that the ladder was not enough at the entrance of the city wall.

Because it is very difficult to knock down ladders, the ladders used for siege in ancient times were not like our current ladders, but had a very stable base.