Why didn t the literati of later generations continue to write the Dream of Red Mansions according t

It is likely that they don't like the plot arranged by Mr. Cao Xueqin, or it may be because no one has studied the information revealed by Fat Yan Zhai. We all know that the extant version of the Dream of Red Mansions was continued by Gao E, and the last forty chapters of Dream of the Red Chamber written by Mr. Cao Xueqin were lost. However, after research, modern scholars have found that a lot of information has been revealed in the annotations of Fat Yan Zhai, and even the endings of some characters.

And the more I study the annotations of Yan Zhai, the more I find that the ending of Gao E's continuation of the Dream of Red Mansions is very unreasonable. The Dream of Red Mansions version of Gao E's continuation did not follow the lines of thought that Mr. Cao Xueqin envisioned at all. Why is this so?

The reason may have to be asked Gao E. We must know that Gao Yi is not only a reader, but also a bookseller. The Dream of Red Mansions was not famous when Mr. Cao Xueqin was alive, and the reason why Dream of Red Mansions became popular was due to Gao E's publication.

It is said that Gao He accidentally saw some chapters of Dream of Red Mansions, and was immediately fascinated, and he felt that the book was very valuable. So he inquired in many ways and found most of the chapters of Dream of Red Mansions from many people, but he couldn't find the last forty times. When it was first published, Dream of Red Mansions only had 80 episodes, but I didn't expect it to be so popular.

The content of Gao E's book is definitely different from that of Mr. Cao Xueqin's book. Although it is true that Fatty Yanzhai has left a clue to the version of Dream of Red Mansions written by Mr. Cao Xueqin, it is still a question whether Gao He recognizes or disapproves of Fatty Yanzhai's annotation. Because the love tragedy of Jia Baoyu and Lin Daiyu in Gao E's continuation of the book is very conflicting, Gao He wants to give readers a dramatic ending, and he starts from the perspective of Dream of Red Mansions publishing.

In addition, it is also a question whether Gao Yi will study the annotations of Fat Yan Zhai. Because the annotations of Fat Yan Zhai have always been scattered, and the notes are under the original text, will Gao Yi spend a lot of time studying these contents? I think it's more likely that he's based on his own bookseller's experience to meet the needs of his readers and compose a new and appealing ending.

In general, the original ending of Dream of Red Mansions can no longer be found, and later literati cannot fully continue the book.

Because Cao Xueqin's Dream of Red Mansions is a very complex character structure, and the content left by Fat Yan Zhai is not very comprehensive, so people have no way to continue to write Dream of Red Mansions according to what Fat Yan Zhai revealed.

Because the rulers at that time already knew about Dream of the Red Chamber, in order to suppress the ideas of Dream of Red Dreams, they only disseminated sequels that were in line with the interests of the ruling class.

Because of fame and fortune, if the literati of later generations continued Cao Xueqin's thinking, they could only write a sequel comparable to the Dream of Red Mansions at most, and the literati of later generations wanted to write a sequel that surpassed the Dream of Red Mansions.

Gao He and Cheng Weiyuan lived in the second half of the eighteenth century, and the manuscript of the Dream of the Red Chamber should be much easier to collect, and the manuscript of the Dream of the Red Chamber will not be a manuscript they collected, and there is no mention of the Fat Yan Zhai, which can roughly indicate that the Fat Yan Zhai re-evaluation of the Stone Record should be a forgery from later generations. If the fat inkstone is faked, then the so-called Dream of Red Mansions author Cao Xueqin is simply untenable. As Gao and Cheng said, it is impossible to verify who the author is.

It can be imagined that if the last 40 episodes are Gao Continuation, then before Cheng and Gao Wei collected all the Dream of Red Mansions, they must have worked hard and had no choice but to continue. Cheng and Gao didn't mention the fat inkstone; If Gao did not continue the last 40 times, then Cheng and Gao should have been the whole book, and the commentary on Fat Yan Zhai is a far-fetched understanding and should be a forgery.

Because they don't have that level, including everyone after that, of course, including the so-called red scholars now, they are actually all skins, and the level is too different! What you can see in the continuation instinct is actually a ghost book, and you don't need to watch the rest!

Because later generations of literati didn't know that Yan Zhai was Cao Xueqin!

Before there was no Dream of Red Mansions. "Stone Records" and "Fat Yan Zhai" are vacuum. Why? Because of the "fat inkstone" n re-evaluation. It's all a re-evaluation of "The Stone"! Never spoke about it; Dream.

Who is Cao Xueqin? Lin Daiyu, Jia Rui anti-Qing Wen Tianxiang, Lin Hongyu Zhang Daoshi's brother. I can't understand this, and I still keep a secret record of history every day.

Maybe there was no such thing as a "fat batch" in the beginning

It should not be in line, Cao Xueqin's wish is somewhat anti-feudal, but Gao He did not interpret it well in the sequel.

I don't think it should be in line, after all, everyone has a different ending for Dream of Red Mansions in their hearts, even if Gao He understands Cao Xueqin again, he may not know what kind of ending he wants.

I don't think it's too different from Cao Xueqin, Dream of Red Mansions can see at a glance that Cao Xueqin's writing is different from that of the later person, so the ending is not necessarily the same.

It shouldn't be in line, after all, Gao He doesn't know Cao Xueqin's mind very well, and this result just belongs to Gao E's mind.

Yes, an ending of Dream of Red Mansions that is more in line with Cao Xueqin's original intention has been verified by experts to be like this: After 80 times, Mrs. Xing and Aunt Zhao colluded to fight for property and status, and jointly dealt with Baoyu and Sister Feng.

Get something off one's chest. The main story is all over. But it was premature to pass away. These Grandma Liu didn't have time. The remnants of the manuscript were divided into five tigers.

The final ending of Dream of Red Mansions may not be as good as the ending imagined in Cao Xueqin's heart, but it is already very good, after all, not everyone has that ability.

The final ending of Dream of Red Mansions is actually different from the ending in Cao Xueqin's heart, and if Cao Xueqin wrote it, it might be more realistic.

I think it should be in line, because "Dream of Red Mansions" in Cao Xueqin's heart is also such a tragedy.

Who knows this kind of problem, I don't think it fits, how can it be so coincidental, it's in line with Cao Xueqin's idea, it's far from it.

Not true. The main reason is that by reading the part of Gao E's continuation, we can find that Gao E's beautification of the imperial court at that time, and according to Cao Xueqin's character, he was partially anti-feudal, expressing his resistance to feudal ideas through Bao Dai's love, and the final ending did not follow Cao Xueqin's hints in the first eighty episodes. Gao E's continued writing is highly political, and it seems that the dog's tail continues to be mink.

Haha, Cao Xueqin's original intention is not important, because the original intention of Dream of Red Mansions is not Cao Xueqin's, Dream of Red Mansions is rewritten This is obvious, Cao Xueqin's wisdom can only be written 80 times, and he himself doesn't know how to rewrite it later, because he can't hide the original intention!

Writer Cao Xueqin's chapter hui style long **, also known as "Stone Records", "Jin Yuyuan", and "Fat Yan Zhai Re-evaluation of Stone Records". There are 120 "Cheng Ben" and 80 "Fat Ben" versions of this book. The first 80 chapters of the new edition are based on the fat book and the last 40 chapters are based on the Cheng book, signed "by Cao Xueqin, anonymous continued, Cheng Weiyuan, Gao He collated".

Dream of Red Mansions is a world-influential work of human feelings, recognized as the pinnacle of Chinese classics, an encyclopedia of Chinese feudal society, and a collection of traditional culture. **With the rise and fall of the four major families of Jia, Shi, Wang, and Xue as the background, with the family trivia of Jiafu and the leisure of the boudoir as the context, and the love and marriage stories of Jia Baoyu, Lin Daiyu, and Xue Baochai as the main line, it depicts the human beauty and tragic beauty of the lovers of good and evil centered on Jia Baoyu and the twelve hairpins of Jinling. Through the tragedy of the family, the tragedy of the daughter and the tragedy of the protagonist's life, the crisis of the last days of feudalism is revealed.

The author of Dream of Red Chambers has a preliminary democratic ideology, and he has made profound criticisms of the real society, including the darkness of the court and officialdom, the decay of the feudal aristocratic class and its families, the feudal imperial examination system, the marriage system, the slave and maid system, and the hierarchical system, as well as the corresponding social ruling ideas, that is, the Tao of Confucius and Mencius, Cheng Zhu Lixue, and social morality, and put forward vague ideals and propositions with the nature of preliminary democracy. These ideals and ideas were a tortuous reflection of the embryonic factors of the capitalist economy that were growing at that time.

Dream of Red Mansions is self-exhorting to "talk about love and record its affairs", only according to its own body and reason, follow the traces, get rid of the old clichés, and achieve extraordinary artistic achievements in a fresh and chic way. In particular, the special penmanship of "the real thing is hidden, and the fake village dialect" is even more aroused.

The last 40 episodes of Dream of Red Mansions written by Gao He will definitely not fully conform to Cao Xueqin's original intention. Mr. Liu Xinwu's latest research results are 108 times, not 120 times. Mr. Liu is currently continuing to write the last 28 times.

You can pay attention to Mr. Liu Xinwu's "The True Story of the Dream of Red Mansions after 80 Times".

Yes, after all, Gao is not Cao Weng, and there is no experience of Cao Weng, although he likes Daiyu very much, but the ending of Daiyu is not particularly sad, after all, he is the head of the twelve hairpins, and he has been weak and sick since he was a child.

1) Many of the parts that Gao He continued to write did not conform to Xueqin's original intention, such as the ending of the big group members that he continued to write, which greatly violated Cao Lao's creative intentions.

2) This can not erase the wonder of Gao E's sequel part, his writing is smooth and beautiful, it is the inheritance of Cao Lao, but Gao He does not have Cao Lao's rich and tortuous experience, his thoughts are not very profound, his understanding is not in place, and the discrepancies and all aspects of the plot of the continuation make him far inferior to the original work.

Under normal circumstances, the study of red studies is Cao Xueqin's Dream of Red Mansions in the first eighty chapters. Do not study the high osprey. Because there is already a lot of evidence that Gao E's continuation is in the wrong direction, and the ending is wrong.

When he continued to write, Cao Xueqin was dead, so it had nothing to do with him, and it wasn't what he meant.

There are three regrets in life, one hates the begonias without fragrance, the second hates the prickly anchovies, and the third hates the unfinished Red Mansion.

Yes, more or less certainly not Cao Xueqin's original intention.

Well. So now there are scholars who are continuing to write.

Don't think that "Dream of Red Mansions" is not finished. It's just that the manuscript at the back is missing.

The world needs to study Cheng Gao's theory, and half a word is not titled.

The law of heaven and the balance of heaven and reason, Fang knows the whole book of Red Mansion Qin.

- Geng Ge.

I believe that many people like "Dream of Red Mansions".

Readers, will not be unaware of the fat inkstone.

It can be said that his status is as important as "Dream of Red Mansions" itself. He annotates the original text in red between the lines of Dream of Red Mansions, or expresses his own interpretation and views on the plot and characters, or discloses the connection between the current paragraph and the following text, so as to attract the reader's attention and lead the reader to think. This form of commenting on the book is actually very interesting, making us feel that we are not reading alone, but as if we are interacting with our friends, just like today we like to open the barrage, and Fat Yanzhai may be called the "ancestor of the barrage".

Red scientists also attach great importance to Fat Yan Zhai, not only to study the content of the annotations, but also to ** the true identity of Fat Yan Zhai. There are reasons for this, one is that Yan Zhai is different from other storytellers, his aesthetics and ideas seem to be very close to the will of the collaborator and the author.

In a word, it can be inferred from this that he had a close relationship with the author, and may even have participated in the creation. The second is that he is not only the "ancestor of the barrage", but also a "spoiler maniac", many of the annotations involve the plot of the last forty episodes, which shows that Yan Zhai must have watched the complete "Dream of Red Mansions", so in the case of the loss of the last forty episodes, the content of his annotations provides a basis for everyone to speculate on the ending.

There are generally several theories about who is Yan Zhai:

First, he is Cao Xueqin.

Relatives of the uncle's generation.

According to the speculation of red scholars, after Cao Xueqin wrote "Dream of Red Mansions", it was first circulated among each other within the family, because it may involve real events and politically sensitive issues, and there is no standardized manuscript widely circulated in the market. Then the most likely person to make a comment on it is a relative of the uncle's generation.

Second, he is the author himself.

This statement is also supported by many people in the red academic circles. Because Yan Zhai "understands" Cao Xueqin too well, and as we all know, the philosophical ideas embodied in "Dream of Red Mansions" have a critical and rebellious nature towards the society at that time, and it is unlikely that people who can interpret it so deeply are just relatives.

3. "He" is Cao Xueqin's confidante.

The prototype of Shi Xiangyun.

This view was developed by Zhou Ruchang.

Mr. put forward it, and it was also supported by many people. The argument is that the name "Fat Yan Zhai" is too feminine, and most men would not give themselves such a pen name with fat powder, and the tone of some annotations is a bit frivolous if you imagine it as a man.

disrespectful, and it is more appropriate to imagine it as a woman, and the annotations of Fat Yan Zhai also have Shi Xiangyun's coquettish, innocent and straightforward feeling.

He may not have read the last 40 chapters, because there is no ancient book left in his annotation of the last 40 chapters.