Lu Xun is just a scholar, why was he able to take the lives of Guan Yu and Liu Bei?

Updated on history 2024-05-28
29 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-11

    Lu Xun is just a scholar, but he was able to take the lives of Guan Yu and Liu Bei because Lu Xun is not an ordinary weak scholar, Lu Xun is particularly scheming, he is good at using other people's weaknesses to attack other people's sore spots, so Lu Xun designed to kill Guan Yu and capture Jingzhou, and then skillfully used tactics in the Battle of Shiting, not only killed tens of thousands of soldiers of Shu Han, but also made Liu Bei die soon after being deeply hit。It was with his ingenuity and strategy that Lu Xun took the lives of Guan Yu and Liu Bei.

    Lu Xun was originally born in a famous family in Kanto, but their family withered, after Lu Xun's grandfather died, the burden of the Lu family fell on Lu Xun's shoulders, Lu Xun had to abandon literature and martial arts for the prosperity of the family, entered Sun Quan's shogunate, and became a staff member of Sun Quan's army. At that time, Dongwu was worried about internal and external troubles, suppressed externally by Cao Wei and Shu Han, and internally by the armed uprisings of other scholars in the Kwantung region. In the face of such a situation, Sun Quan had a special headache, but Lu Xun passed the policy of Zhao'an, and either sent money or fields to these armed uprisings, and the turmoil in Eastern Wu was soon quelled.

    Sun Quan was particularly satisfied with pacifying the rebels of Eastern Wu without spending a single soldier, so he married his niece to Lu Xun.

    After Soochow decided to seize Jingzhou, Lu Xun took advantage of Guan Yu's arrogant and conceited character, and Lu Xun wrote a letter to Guan Yu. In my heart, I talked about how powerful Guan Yu was, how humble Lu Xun himself was, and how much Lu Xun admired Guan Yu. Guan Yu really landed on Lu Xun's way, so he also let down his guard against animals and left Jingzhou with heavy troops.

    But he didn't want him to leave, and the army of Eastern Wu rushed to Jingzhou, which was weakly defended. In the end, Lu Xun also devised rumors to make Guan Yu's army collapse and lose its combat effectiveness, and Guan Yu was defeated and killed in Maicheng.

    Soon after Guan Yu's death, Zhang Fei was also killed by his own men and defected to Eastern Wu, Liu Bei kept Zhuge Liang's advice, one of which led an army of more than 100,000 Shu Han to attack Eastern Wu, wanting to avenge Guan Yu and Zhang Fei, and also to recapture Jingzhou. At that time, the governor of Eastern Wu was Lu Xun, although Lu Xun did not have much experience on the battlefield, but his mercenaries skillfully knew how to arrange troops, and Lu Xun took 50,000 troops of Eastern Wu to meet the battle. But Lu Xun closed his door at first, and when Liu Bei's army was exhausted, Lu Xun led the army to counterattack, and then Lu Xun burned more than 40 villages of the Shu army, so that the Shu Han army suffered heavy losses, and Liu Bei fled.

    Faced with the loss of Shu Han, Liu Bei was depressed and died soon after.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-10

    Because this person is very good at summarizing, he can summarize the secrets of success that other people have used in his own practice.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-09

    Lu Xun is a generation of Confucian generals, so he can skillfully show weakness, hide clumsy, hide needles in the cotton, and ask for the life of the arrogant Guan Yu; Liu Bei, who made the "dog jump off the wall in a hurry", was in a hurry.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    Because Lu Xun's reputation was not great at that time, Guan Yu and Liu Bei both underestimated the enemy, giving Lu Xun a chance, and negligence on the battlefield caused Guan Yu and Liu Bei to lose their lives.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    was able to defeat Guan Yu because he took advantage of Guan Yu's pride after flooding the Seventh Army, so that he relaxed his vigilance, and then crossed the river in white clothes and caught him off guard, and also used psychological warfare to make Guan Yu's soldiers have no fighting spirit, and in the end, Guan Yu was left alone, of course, he was defeated.

    He was able to defeat Liu Bei because he avoided the edge of the Shu army, consumed the sharp spirit of the Shu army through confrontation, and then took advantage of the powerful weather to launch a fire attack on the Shu army.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    We all know that Liu Bei was in order to avenge Guan Yu at that time, and then went to attack Sun Quan, but in the process, in the end, he failed miserably, he lost to Lu Xun of Eastern Wu, why did he lose to Lu Xun so badly?

    In fact, I think the biggest reason is that Liu Bei won all the way, so in this process, it is inevitable that the arrogant soldiers will be defeated, and then in this process, Lu Xun also took advantage of the time and place, because in this process, the weather became hotter and hotter, and then the soldiers were difficult to maintain such a state, and finally Liu Bei made a wrong decision to transfer to the woods, and finally used a fire to burn them and leave no pieces of armor.

    First of all, I think it was because he was too careless, and then because he was too proud in the process, and in the end, it was also because of this wrong decision that he made the wrong move when he shifted his position, which led to failure.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Guan Yu was defeated by Lü Meng because Guan Yu was too proud to be copied when he sent troops (that is, the flooded Seventh Army). Dongwu has arranged a strategy to take Jingzhou from the beginning of Zhou Yu, and finally found a breakthrough when he arrived at Lu Meng, Dongwu has been a thief for a thousand years, and Liu Bei was defeated by Lu Xun The reason is that Liu Bei himself is not good at fighting, and there are no generals around him. (Zhuge Liang, Zhao Yun is in the rear, Guan Yu is dead, and Zhang Fei died before he went on the expedition.) Huang Zhong died not long after the fight began...

    The front is too long again, and they can lose. And Lu Xun can't do it, he will lose the country if he loses Dongwu, so Liu Bei will lose.

    My opinion.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    1. Guan Yu's death.

    This is the Sun family's betrayal. Guan Yu launched the Xiang-Fan Campaign, and the ally of Eastern Wu attacked from behind.

    Second, Liu Bei's defeat.

    In the second year of Zhang Wu (222), Liu Bei sent troops to attack Eastern Wu in order to recapture Jingzhou and avenge Guan Yu and Zhang Fei (the number of troops is unknown, it is said to be 750,000 in romances, and later generations usually believe that it is between 5 100,000). The morale of the Shu army was strong, and the momentum was like a bamboo, and it successively defeated Lu Xun's generals Li Yi and Liu A. Lu Xun held on without a fight, and Liu Bei marched to Yiling.

    The two armies held each other for half a year, and the Han army was tired and slack. In order to protect the soldiers from the poisonous sun, Liu Bei moved his tent to the woods, Lu Xun took the opportunity to use fire attack, blocked the river, held the Yiling Road, attacked on all fronts, advanced by land and water, the Shu army was defeated, and Liu Bei fled to the White Emperor City under the escort of Zhao Yun.

  9. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    Lu Xun was originally a literati, why was he able to defeat Liu Bei, who had experienced a hundred battles? Personally, I think there are several reasons. The first reason is that Lu Xun is very smart, and he is also a literati with good intentions; The second reason is that Lu Xun is very low-key, modest and does not like to show off, and no one knows this character; The third is Liu Bei's underestimated enemy, who looks down on the young Lu Xun.

    Under the combined effect of these factors, it is normal for Liu Bei to fail.

    The first reason is that Lu Xun is very smart, and he is also a literati with good intentions; It has already been said that Lu Xun is a literati, and he must have read poetry and books, and since he is favored by characters like Sun Quan, he must have two brushes. If you don't have an IQ, I'm afraid you won't even be able to see Sun Quan's face, let alone be recommended to Sun Quan.

    From his marching deployment, it can be seen that this young man has a good plan, deliberately sold it to Liu Bei, and invited you to enter the urn step by step.

    The second reason is that Lu Xun is very low-key, modest and does not like to show off, and no one knows this character; Lu Xun was born before almost no one knew that there was such a number one person, if it wasn't for the fact that this person was really very talented, I am afraid that no one would know about him. You can see how low-key this person is.

    It is precisely because of this that Lu Xun and Liu Bei are facing each other, Liu Bei can be said to have no knowledge or even the slightest understanding of Lu Xun, but Lu Xun knows Liu Bei very well. There is such a first-mover advantage, Liu Bei has already made a move. Coupled with Lu Xun's various clumsiness, Liu Bei thought that he was incompetent and entered his trap.

    The third is Liu Bei's underestimated enemy, who looks down on the young Lu Xun. It is said that Liu Bei has experienced a hundred battles and can be said to be very experienced in combat. But in this battle of Yiling, Liu Bei did not follow the routine.

    One is that he thinks that Lu Xun is a yellow-haired child and is not his opponent at all, and Lu Xun deliberately sells such a flaw that makes Liu Bei relax his vigilance. So the arrangement of troops was very casual, and there was a way of arranging the troops in a long snake formation, which gave Lu Xun the opportunity to burn the eighteen-mile joint camp.

  10. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Although Lu Xun was born as a literati, he was also a famous general in the late Wu period during the Three Kingdoms period, so he was able to win against Liu Bei, who was swayed by hatred.

  11. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    His ability to defeat the battle-hardened Liu Bei is inextricably linked to his way of life and excellent qualities.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Although Lu Xun was a literati, he was full of poetry and books, diligent in political affairs, and a generation of Confucian generals. The reason for Liu Bei's failure was more because he was blinded by hatred, so he lost his mind, which led to a big defeat!

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Liu Bei underestimated the enemy, made a serious low-level mistake, set the general camp in the jungle, and was burned by Lu Xun for 800 miles, and returned defeated.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    No, Liu Bei's career in the first half of his life also went through several twists and turns. Most of the images of Liu Bei depicted in history give people the feeling of hypocrisy, but it is this hypocrisy that gives Liu Bei the emotion of righteousness.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    No, the main reason is because Liu Bei was too light on the enemy and did not take Lu Xun seriously, and there was a serious mistake in decision-making, which would eventually lead to failure.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    In order for Liu Bei to let the army escape the scorching heat, Lu Xun thought that the time was ripe, and the Wu army was recuperating, so Liu Bei would be defeated, so he ordered the sergeant to attack Liu Bei's camp with fire at night, and the fire was everywhere in an instant.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    In the face of Liu Bei's attack, Lu Xun did not choose to fight hard, Lu Xun's chosen strategy was to close the door, which caused Liu Bei's logistics to be insufficient, and the soldiers were tired, and Liu Bei lost.

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    That's because Liu Bei was too anxious, and people didn't take the initiative to attack him, but he took the initiative to attack others, resulting in not even figuring out the foundation of others, and this did not achieve the expected goal, so it failed.

  19. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    Looking at the reason, the reason why Liu Bei failed was because he was too eager to achieve success, and after the war began, he repeatedly violated the taboo of soldiers, so that in the end, he failed to achieve the predetermined goal before sending troops.

  20. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    Because Liu Bei was proud of the enemy, he thought that the young Lu Xun had no strength and was too eager to succeed, while Lu Xun was very sober and intelligent, decisive, and killed with one blow.

  21. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    Liu Bei fought all his life and relied on Zhuge Liang's talent to win the battlefield. Later, he was defeated by Lu Xun, and blamed him for being in a hurry and carelessly underestimating the enemy.

  22. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    Because Liu Bei was too anxious at that time, he was eager to take that land, but it was because of such eagerness to win that he lost to Lu Xun.

  23. Anonymous users2024-01-20

    The main reason is that Liu Bei was in a hurry at that time and did not recognize the situation at all, but Lu Xun was scheming and recuperating, so Liu Bei was bound to lose.

  24. Anonymous users2024-01-19

    Because Liu Bei was too eager to achieve success at that time, he was bent on winning the battle quickly, but he did not analyze the enemy, so he failed.

  25. Anonymous users2024-01-18

    Lu Xun adopted a certain strategy, and the strategy Lu Xun chose was to close the door, which caused Liu Bei's lack of logistics and supplies, and the soldiers were tired.

  26. Anonymous users2024-01-17

    Lu Xun is also a contemporary genius, and the first person behind the scenes of Dongwu who can take back Jingzhou is Lu Xun, and this battle has also become a turning point in the lives of Guan Yu and Liu Bei。There have always been two forces in the Eastern Wu regime, one led by Zhou Yu advocated taking back the territory of Jingzhou by force, and the other led by Lu Su advocated uniting Liu Bei's forces against Cao Cao in the north, they all have their own ideas and ideas, the purpose of which is to make Eastern Wu more powerful, Zhou Yu was alive and repeatedly used force to capture Jingzhou but was unsuccessful, Lu Su has been adopting a peaceful policy to maintain the relationship between Eastern Wu and Liu Bei after replacing Zhou Yu.

    After Sun Quan's death, Lü Meng became the governor of Eastern Wu. Lu Meng and Zhou Yu have the same idea, they both advocate the idea of using force to take back Jingzhou, Lu Xun was born in a scholar clan and received a good education since childhood, although he is a scholar, but he has the ambition to unify the world. He hopes to engrave his name in the times in this troubled era, and give Zhou and Lu Xun an excellent opportunity to show his talents in such a background of the times.

    Guan Yu is an extremely proud person, and everyone knows Guan Yu's fatal flaws. Lu Xun also took the initiative to grasp this shortcoming of pride and complacency, he knew that Guan Yu didn't look down on Lu Xun who had not dried up, in his eyes Lu Meng was his only opponent, Lu Xun crossed the river in white clothes to meet Guan Yu When he saw Guan Yu, he showed his humility and made Guan Yu swell up even more, which was also Lu Xun's ultimate goal, Guan Yu finally let go of his vigilance against the Eastern Wu regime and let Lu Xun have a chance, and the Eastern Wu and Cao Wei regimes had already reached an agreement in private, Guan Yu finally lost his life under successive calculations.

    Under the guise of avenging Guan Yu, Liu Bei actually wanted to regain his own territory。This war almost lost all the family resources of the Shu Han regime, and Liu Bei and Guan Yu both fell to the bottom of their lives at a starting point.

  27. Anonymous users2024-01-16

    Because Lu Xun grasped the shortcomings of Guan Yu's pride and complacency, he showed his humility when he saw Guan Yu, which made him swell up rapidly, and finally Guan Yu let down his guard against Soochow and was calculated to lose his life.

  28. Anonymous users2024-01-15

    Scholar Lu Xun, when Liu Bei led the army to the east, he was worshiped by Sun Quan as the governor of the capital, and led the army of Eastern Wu to meet Liu Bei, using the strategy of burning 800 miles, defeated Liu Bei, and greatly reduced the strength of Shu Han.

  29. Anonymous users2024-01-14

    Because of Guan Yu's death at that time, Lu Xun can be said to have accounted for a lot of reasons, Lu Xun went to Guan Yu at that time to pretend that he was a scholar, useless, and also touted Shu Han, causing Guan Yu to underestimate the enemy. So much so that Guan Yu later died, and Liu Bei broke with Eastern Wu.

Related questions
12 answers2024-05-28

Zeng Guofan was actually very poor in terms of military literacy, and the tactic he invented was siege, no matter which city was attacked, it would be surrounded first.

3 answers2024-05-28

Lu Xun (183 245), whose real name is Lu Yi, is a native of Wu County, Wu County (now Suzhou, Jiangsu). During the Three Kingdoms period, he was a famous politician and military strategist, and successively served as the governor of Wu, the general, and the prime minister. The son-in-law of Emperor Wu Sun Quan's brother Huan Wang Sun Ce, who has been a Jiangdong clan for generations. >>>More

3 answers2024-05-28

According to the "Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms", Lu Xun was repeatedly reprimanded by Sun Quan's Oak Qinghe, and was overly saddened, and died of hatred in February of the eighth year of Chiwu (245) at the age of sixty-three. >>>More

9 answers2024-05-28

Liu Xiu is indeed a scholar, and it can even be said that he was originally a farmer, but in the end, he relied on his own ingenuity to unify the country, which has something to do with his personal wisdom and experience. >>>More

12 answers2024-05-28

When I was in college, I studied liberal arts, and when I was working, I was doing sales work, and sometimes when I saw Party A's face, I really felt that my years of study were in vain, even if I was a liberal arts student, I couldn't play the wind and the moon all day long, but I had to live in real life.