Cao Ren can defeat Zhou Yu and Ma Chao, why can t he beat Guan Yu?

According to the records of "Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms", Cao Ren fought Zhou Yu, fought Ma Chao, and rejected Guan Yu, but he didn't lose. Cao Ren deserves to be the first general on Cao Wei's side. Cao Renli relied on Zhou Yu's army for more than a year, and finally gave up Jiangling and retreated, but it did have something to do with Guan Yu.

Guan Yu brought thousands of people to harass the grain route of Jiangling City, making it difficult for Cao Ren to supply. When Cao Cao learned of the situation, he ordered Cao Ren to abandon Jiangling and retreat to nearby Xiangyang. Judging from the final result, it should be Guan Yu who lost to Cao Ren, how can it be said that Cao Ren can't beat Guan Yu. ‍‍

Zhou Yu, Cao Ren did not defeat Zhou Yu, but Zhou Yu defeated Cao Ren, the victory or defeat of a war cannot be judged from the injury of the main general, and it is possible to be injured in a war. Cao Ren only surrounded thousands of Gan Ning's men and horses in Yiling, and Zhou Yu led the army to rescue and broke Cao Ren under Yiling City, and Cao Ren ** more than half. ‍‍

Guan Yu, Cao Ren didn't lose in the battle with Guan Yu! At that time, the main generals Pang De and Yu Ban were flooded by Guan Yu and the Seventh Army, and Yu Ban surrendered to Guan Yu. Cao Ren led thousands of men and horses to resist Fancheng, and the whole city was almost a water city at that time, and Cao's army was basically cut off from food and grass.

Cao Ren inspired his generals and was determined to defend Fancheng to the death, and thousands of people and horses were encouraged by Cao Ren to stick to the city with one heart. Until the tide receded, Xu Huang's reinforcements arrived, and he and Cao Ren flanked Guan Yu and repelled Guan Yu. ‍‍

It can be seen that when Cao Ren and Zhou Yu's forwards and Guan Yu's army fought, they were at a disadvantage in terms of the number of soldiers, or a big inferiority, and it would have been over a long time since they were ordinary generals. ‍‍

There was a battle against Ma Chao, and Cao Ren led the generals to defeat Ma Chao. The third time is the battle with Guan Yu, Guan Yu defeated and captured Yu Ban, led the water army to continue to attack Fancheng, at that time the water was very strong, there was not much in the city was not flooded, Cao Ren led thousands of people to resist, but also inspired his subordinates, and waited for Xu Huang to rescue the army, Cao Ren was able to relieve the siege. ‍‍

After the battle of Chibi, Zhou Yu sent tens of thousands of people to attack Cao Ren, thousands of pioneers went first, Cao Ren looked from afar, recruited more than 300 people in a hurry, the enemy arrived, he sent his subordinate Niu Jin to lead 300 people to challenge, the other side was many, and his men were surrounded. Regardless of the obstruction of his subordinates, Cao Ren led more than a dozen people to rush into the ground to rescue Niu Jin, and the enemy retreated. In my opinion, there is no Zhou Yu in the forward troops. ‍‍

In the battle between the two sides, Zhou Yu was injured and retreated, Cao Ren heard that Zhou Yu was seriously injured, and personally supervised the attack on Zhou Yu, but fell into Zhou Yu's strategy, and finally the battle ended in Cao Ren's defeat, but Cao Ren and Zhou Yu fought for a year, which played an important role in the development of Cao Wei after the defeat. ‍‍

Since ancient times, those who defend the city have taken advantage, and 10 times the number of soldiers who can attack the city has explained everything, so the battle between the two armies, the winner does not mean that it must be stronger than the loser, Cao Ren is famous for defending the city, but let Zhou Yu defend the city Cao Ren try to attack the city? Don't want to win against Zhou Yu in this life, in the same way, let Guan Yu guard Fancheng and Cao Renbing besiege Fancheng, and the results will definitely not be better than Guan Yu.

I all know the result, but there is no mention of the process, it was Cao Ren who first begged Guan Yu to be counter-killed, and when Guan Yu attacked Fancheng, he was not full of favor and pulled Cao Ren to abandon the city and run away. Guan Yu's later defeat was also the result of the joint efforts of more than a dozen first-line generals of the Wei and Wu families, saying that Cao Ren won and Guan Yu did not dare to agree.

Guan Yu defeated Cao Ren there, and in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Luo Guanzhong favored Guan Yu, and he did not write that Guan Yu defeated Cao Ren. ‍‍

If only the romance is said ... It can only be said that Guan Yu has been in Cao Ying, and everyone is empty Guan Yu... The momentum is weak...

Yu Ban, as the head of Cao Cao's five good generals, won not by force but by command. Pang De was a younger military general and did not make an inch, but Cao Cao treated him well, so he thought about making meritorious service. Everything else is empty.

Guan Yu, the first fierce general of the Three Kingdoms.

Cao Ren defended Fancheng, Guan Yu couldn't conquer it, and in the end, it wasn't that he lost, it was Cao Ren who won.

To put it the other way, wasn't Cao Ren defeated by Zhou Yu? Guan Yu didn't defeat Cao Ren either.

Wuxia Amon. And the strength of Cao Ren in Fancheng is indeed too weak, so he has to win more with less to say that Cao Ren is stronger than Guan Yu? If you really can't hold on and wait for death?

Zhou Yu fought against Cao Ren, in fact, Wei Shu and Wu are all recorded! Guan Yu, Juebei Province, 2,000 soldiers and horses, dragged half of the Wei State to the national essence. Facts: Guan Yu has done a meritorious thing, and there is no record of Guan Yu's biography!

The two parts of the Three Kingdoms: The Biography of Yuan Shao and the Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms: Emperor Wu recorded the ugliness of Guan Yu's killing, Guan Yu was in Cao Cao's position at that time, and it is really funny to say that Cao Cao killed! It's just that many of you don't know Guan Yu's strength!

Can Cao Ren defeat Zhou Yu with force and intelligence? It's ridiculous.

I remember that in the Book of Wu of the Three Kingdoms, it is recorded that Zhou Yu won Cao Ren, not Cao Ren won Zhou Yu.

Cao Ren held Fancheng to the death with the inferior troops, and I don't see how he was defeated.

Cao Ren commanded the battle more than Guan Yu.

In the round of field battles, Guan Yu is absolutely the first. All opponents are defending the city in the face of Guan Yu.

In fact, Ma Chao was named General Zuo by Liu Bei not long after he surrendered to Liu Bei, which shows that Ma Chao's status is very high, only second to Guan Yu, and even higher than Zhang Fei's status, so Guan Yu is also particularly unconvinced. You must know that Ma Chao has just taken refuge in Liu Bei, and he can actually receive the most attention, so it is actually normal for him to be unconvinced.

If we think about the problem from Guan Yu's point of view, it is not difficult to understand why Guan Yu is angry. You must know that several people followed Liu Bei from birth to death for several years, and finally relied on their own efforts to achieve today's achievements, but Ma Chao only relied on his family background and became one of the five tiger generals just after surrendering, so Guan Yu must also be particularly unconvinced, and at the same time there will be some inferiority. <>

When Huang Zhong was in his 70s, he was named a rear general by Liu Bei, but Guan Yu was young at this time, and Guan Yu was particularly arrogant, so he felt that comparing himself with Huang Zhong was the biggest insult to himself, so he naturally wouldn't be too convinced. <>

Although Huang Zhong is relatively old, he is indeed a crazy person, for example, Huang Zhong often asks to fight to the death with the enemy Naizaling, and in the battle of Hanzhong, Huang Zhong has repeatedly asked to go on the field and fight with the other party 300 times back to Changqi. Therefore, Huang Zhong is more crazy, but Guan Yu is even more crazy than him, in this case, Guan Yu must look at Huang Zhong unpleasantly. <>

All in all, our second master Guan Yu Guan is indeed a very arrogant person, maybe in his eyes, except for Liu Bei and Zhang Fei, other people can't get into their own eyes at all, so it's normal to look down on others.

1 All Zhou Yu didn't take Cao Ren in his eyes, so he was injured.

Cao Ren set up the Eight Gates Golden Lock Formation back then, but it was broken by Xu Shu. But Xu Shu is only commanding behind the battlefield, even if Cao Ren's formation Xu Shu can't be broken, Xu Shu will not die. Zhou Yu is the commander-in-chief, and he is a pro-arrow.

I like to go to the battlefield to play for my life, and it is only a matter of time before I get injured. Besides, it was Zhou Yu who defeated Cao Ren. Cao Ren relied on Cao Cao's 100,000 troops and a large amount of grain and grass to hold out for a year, but the war was only lost, and finally forced to retreat.

Cao Ren is similar to Sima, that is, he will stick to the city and never send troops. At that time, the number of men and horses of Wu State did not exceed 120,000, and the number of men and horses attacking Cao Ren would not exceed 50,000 (to leave some to defend Jianghuai and pacify South Vietnam), 50,000 besieged 100,000, and forced Cao Ren to abandon the city and leave, Zhou Yu had already won.

Pang Tong, who is as famous as Zhuge Liang, died, he is not smart, and when people are proud, Zhou Yu didn't take Cao Ren in his eyes, so he was injured.

Cao Ren is just a military general, defeating Wu General Niu Jin, a small confrontation of hundreds of people, it's a fart.

Romance of the Three Kingdoms: Guan Yu's Biography: Yu Wen Ma Chao came to descend, the old is not an old man, Yu Shu and Zhuge Liang, ask who can compare supertalents. Liang Zhiyu guarded the front, and replied:

Meng Qi is both civil and military, heroic, the master of the first generation, the disciple of Huang and Peng, when he and Yide are driven to be the first, and he has not yet reached the peerless Yiqun. "Yumei beard, so Liang is called beard. Yu Province book Dayue to show guests.

Romance of the Three Kingdoms: Ma Chao's Biography: And prepare to enter Shu, stay in Jingzhou, Yuyu Town, and Yu has not tasted Yitu. Therefore, Yu heard that Ma Chao had surrendered, and asked Zhuge Liang in a book, "Who can compare with supertalents", but it is not as the book says.

Romance of the Three Kingdoms: One day, Xuande was chatting with Kong Ming, and suddenly reported that Yun Chang sent Guan Ping to thank him for the gold silk. Xuande summoned. Say goodbye and present the book.

The letter said: "My father knows that Ma Chao is excellent in martial arts, and he wants to enter Sichuan to compete with him." Teach my uncle about this. Xuande was shocked

If the cloud grows into Shu, he will compete with Meng Qi, and he will not be able to stand on the other side. Kong Ming said: "It's okay. Liang wrote his own book back. "Xuande is only afraid of clouds.

was anxious, so he taught Kong Ming to write a book, and sent Guan Ping to return to Jingzhou on a starry night. Ping returned to Jingzhou, Yun Chang asked: "I want to get up with Ma Meng."

Test, did you say no? Ping replied: "The military advisor has a book here." Yun Chang opened his eyes. His book said: "Liang Wen General wants to be with."

Meng Qi is superior and inferior. In terms of brightness: Although Meng Qi is heroic, he is also the disciple of Duo Bu and Peng Yue; When competing with Yide to be the first, it is still not as outstanding as the beautiful beard. Today's public is appointed to guard Jingzhou, which is not important; If you enter Sichuan, if Jingzhou is lost. The sin is great.

Then. But I hope it will shine. After Yun Chang finished reading it, he smiled and said, "Kong Ming knows my heart." "The book was shown to the guests, and there was no way into the river.

meaning. The gist is that Guan Yunchang is proud of himself and feels invincible in the world, and he is very popular when he sees Ma Chao's new arrival, and he knows that Ma Chao's martial arts are superb, and he wants to compete with him, Zhuge Liang will be a peacemaker, saying that although Ma Chao's martial arts are superb, but it is still not as powerful as you (referring to Guan Yu), you (referring to Guan Yu) are in an important place, which is very important. The sin is great. Guan Yu saw it and said with a smile

The military advisor knows my heart! often told Zhuge Liang's words to his friends and guests.

Many historical games should have a historical plot, and this kind of plot is just for you to enjoy, and it's useless.

Ma Chao is also a fierce general. He will never lose to any of the 5 Tiger generals. Historical negligence and his record of success....

He believes that belonging to the same Five Tigers as Ma Chao will lose his identity.

He heard others praise Ma Chao, and he was not convinced!

Because Guan Yu heard that Ma Chao was very violent, Liu Bei and Zhuge liked it very much, and was named General Zuo, stealing Guan Yu's limelight, Guan Yu was jealous and unwilling to be left out in the cold, so he wanted to compete with Ma Chao.