If you were Rose in Titanic, would you choose Carl or Jack?

Seeing this question, choose Carl or Jack? This is probably asking about our view of love. Carl must represent worry-free food and clothing, and Jack must represent a simple life?

I think only time will tell in the years after the choice.

There was a popular saying for a while, "I'd rather sit in a BMW and cry than sit in the back seat of a bicycle and laugh", which is that some girls think that things that money can solve are more important than sincerity, happiness, and joy, so they advocate money more. I don't comment on this point of view, after all, I haven't experienced her life, and I don't know when or under what circumstances she said it. It's just that I think that choosing a person, just from the perspective of the wealth he represents, is incomplete.

I think that if I choose someone, I will definitely look at it from the bottom of my heart, that is, I will choose Jack. Because whether you choose a rich boy who only likes to eat and drink all day long, or choose a young man with high potential, you will suffer to a certain extent: the former may be that after he squandered his family property, you and he became displaced, and you may also be accused of suffering for nothing; The latter is in the first years of his hard work, he has an empty heart that loves you but cannot promise you anything practical, so he will also suffer.

Then the question arises, which one do you choose, first bitter and then sweet and then bitter, our traditional always thinks that it is more appropriate to first bitter and then sweet. However, there will also be people who think that if you look at the present, no one can say for sure what will happen in the future, right, after one is squandered, there is another one that can continue to be squandered, so it seems that you will never suffer yourself. As a traditional familist, I have always hoped that if I choose someone who loves me, I will never give up, witness him grow and age, witness his career rise and all the unhappiness, witness him grow from a boy to a gentleman, and witness all the rest of his time.

All I will choose Jack, choose one who loves me and is willing to walk into a better future with me, and watch all the sunrises and sunsets in life together.

In fact, this question asks, bread or love, which of the two will you choose? Of course, any normal person is more greedy, and they will want both bread and love. When the two are not both, the choice of one becomes a natural criterion for evaluating one's character, especially for women.

For those women who choose bread, choose women who would rather cry in a BMW than laugh on a bicycle, we always do not hesitate to show our contempt, as if a woman who chooses bread will be labeled as a "money worshipper".

However, in fact, I always feel that love and bread, which to choose, is a modern woman's right to choose, in fact, others do not have the right to criticize. But here it is necessary to sort out the fact that since you have chosen bread, you should be responsible for your choice. In the same way, if you choose love without bread, you will either work together to ask for bread, or you will endure a poor life with peace of mind.

Returning to this question, Carl represents a comfortable life where we can meet, and after Ruth marries him, as long as there are no accidents, she should be able to spend a life without worrying about food and clothing. And, objectively speaking, Carl doesn't love Ruth, but he loves more selfishly. For him, in addition to being a fiancée, Ruth is also an object that can be taken out to show off, which is what the stubborn and individual Ruth is most disgusted by.

And Jack, as for him, seems to be unable to give anything but love. Marrying him is estimated to be a poor life, and maybe he will not be able to take the next meal.

Between Carl and Jack, I might have chosen Jack. Although I may live a poor life for a period of time, although I also know that poor couples mourn everything, but if you don't try, there will be no results. I think Jack's affection deserves this attempt.

And, for Carl, Ruth was nothing more than an expensive ornament, which I would never accept.

I would choose Jack, and I would not hesitate to choose him based on his looks and talent. Common topics are really important, Rose and Carl have different values, neither can understand each other's thoughts, which is the saddest in love and can also cause conflicts in life.

If I were Rose, I would choose Jack because I would choose to be with love.

I would choose Carl, and then earn my own bread so that it would be easier to work, I was afraid that if Jack suddenly had money one day, he would have a wonderful mother-in-law, and I would .........be miserable

I'll be honest, I'll choose Jack. But once I choose, I'm sure to break Jack's heart.

If you were old at the time, you would definitely choose Jack!

What's the point of engaging in false propositions all day long, there is no such thing as if I am who I am in this world, and it is better to use it to read more books if I have time to daydream.

Is it just these two people? All the other men are dead? Why isn't there one that's the most suitable?

It can be seen that Carl really loves Rose very, very much, but Rose in the film is obviously a woman in the new century, she has received a new education, and what she pursues is freedom, which Carl can't give, and Rose will always be bound with him, and Carl's possessiveness is really strong, arbitrary and arbitrary, and ordinary women who pursue freedom will not like him.

The film is only a clip of Carl and Rose getting along on the Titanic, at least at that time Carl did not give Rose the physical and psychological freedom she wanted, and then Jack could give it to her.

Jack! For Rose, even his life was put in! For Carl, Rose is just the icing on the cake of his life, a rich boy must have a beautiful wife!

Carl Bar Ruth is his heart of the ocean Jack likes Ruth mainly because Ruth is good-looking and funny.

Of course it's Jack, I don't want my life, but Carl wants too much.

It must have been Jack, who could have died for Rose.

I think it's Jack who loves Rose more

Time is too short to talk about love, it can only be said that everyone has different ways of expressing feelings. Carl is more pragmatic and Jack is more extreme. Jack's understanding of life is to experience and burn. He shouldn't have cared much about how long he lived.

Carl is selfish and says he loves shredded meat, what a joke! Jack won't crack the shredded meat anyway! What about Carl!

If you don't get it, you will be destroyed! Is this called love? What is love?

It's to make the other party good, not to destroy! Don't forget that he shot the shredded meat! Carl is Xu Moumou from Hangzhou, and if he marries him, he will not die in a deep sleep like Ms. Lai.

Carl is just possession, Jack is true love, transcending life and death.

Of course, Jack loves her more, and Carl is just attracted to her beauty and has a feeling of being a good match. And Jack can give up his life for her.

I feel like it's Carl, he's not as hot as Jack.

Jack in Titanic who loves Rose more

I think it's Jack, he's all dead.

What kind of character is Rose in Titanic, does it have anything to do with her choice to go with Jack? Why? Here's the answer:

Rose is very strong, she is not constrained by the top in the slightest, and her character must not lose confidence because of the difficulties of life. I was still shocked when I saw Rose go back to find Jack in the confinement cell. Another point, Rose didn't find the key, and when she went to find someone to help, the corridor was complicated; And when she returned, Rose was crawling over the pipe at the top of the hallway.

It's hard to imagine such a strong and courageous woman and how Rose was able to jump back from the lifeboat to find Jack at the end, what gave Rose such strength, and at the same time, when OldRose finally recalled, she can still feel the emotion she has for Jack, 80 years later. Rose's love for Jack is unquestionable.

Titanic is a romance film produced by Twentieth Century Fox Film Company and Paramount Pictures, directed by James Cameron and starring Leonardo DiCaprio and Kate Winslet.

Love is two-sided, and the love of only one party is unrequited love, and touching is not the same as love.

Carl and Rose are people of two worlds, there is no spiritual intersection, Carl likes money and power, and power, wealth and these things are like dung to Rose, she wants another life (freedom, try new things, see new things, get close to nature instead of light in a banquet). If you change to a girl who likes the luxurious life of high society, Carl happens to be the lover of her dreams. The main two people's different pursuits and preferences determine that they cannot love each other.

If Carl is like Jack and will take her to travel, horseback riding, and amusement, he still lacks some things compared to Jack, it is estimated that Rose will still not love him, these things are: open-minded outlook on life (not only reflected in fun and relaxation), decency, courage, sunshine, and talent. You must know that Rose is a girl with a high vision, she will not fall in love with a tall, handsome and rich man because of his fierce pursuit, she pays more attention to spiritual communication, pays attention to the other party's character, and pays attention to the other party's talent.

Carl didn't love Rose, he knew that Rose went to the underground cabin, he didn't understand the emptiness in her heart, but he scolded him, making Rose even more afraid to approach, what he needed was possession. Loving someone is about thinking about her. Rose pursues a free life, and Carl can't.

He didn't really love Rose, a little, while eating lamb chops on the boat, he asked. My dear, you like it, but Rose said it was a sausage, which shows that he doesn't even know what he likes to eat, and it can be seen that he only loves that kind of hypocritical appearance, not with his heart.

Carl is in love with Rose, but his love has been distorted by his identity and wealth.

Jack is genuinely in love with her, but Karl Step is. Jack is sincere and sincere, Carl is just a hypocrite.

Love one not because he loves you.

The love story of Jack and Rose is fictional, while the sinking of the Titanic is real.

The Titanic (RMS Titanic), also translated as Titanic, is an Olympic-class cruise ship under the British White Star Line, with a displacement of 46,000 tons.

At about 23:40 on April 14, 1912, the Titanic collided with an iceberg, causing the starboard bow to the middle of the ship to break, and five watertight compartments flooded. At around 2:20 a.m. on April 15, the Titanic's hull broke into two and sank to the bottom of the Atlantic Ocean 3,700 meters. Of the 2,224 crew members and passengers, 1,517 were killed, of whom only 333 were recovered.

Only the story of Jack and Rose in this movie has no prototype, and most of the others are true. The passengers in the first class cabin were given priority to board the lifeboats, and only four women among them died in the shipwreck. Of the 272 women in the second and third classes, only 96 survived.

At one point, the door to the deck of the third-class cabin was even locked to prevent passengers below from flooding onto the deck. On the increasingly sloping deck, the band played ragaltay music non-stop. The Carnard passenger ship, the Karpathia, was the first to arrive at the scene of the accident, and there was no real prototype of Heart of the Sea.

There seems to be such a thing. However, it is not a true story, but the protagonist has a prototype.

The love story inside the Titanic is real. Jack died at the time. In the true story, Jack is Italian and Rose is American. Everything else is basically the same as the script.

No, it's just a fictional character from the movie. Cameron took advantage of the worldwide attention of the sinking of the Titan Vic to make this movie.

This is just the sinking of the Titanic through a love story.

There are indeed two people, but the ending is not right, the real thing is that both of them survived, but they were not together in the end, separated, and later Rose lived in Beijing for a while.