In the Three Kingdoms, why didn t Liu Bei let the third brother Zhang Fei protect his family?

In the troubled times of the Three Kingdoms, there are many talents, and Liu Bei is one of them. He shuttled through the troubled times as Uncle Liu Huang, after Liu Sheng, King Jing of Zhongshan, and used Kuang to help the Han family out of the righteous teacher, and Cao Cao Sun Quan divided the world, Dingding Sichuan Shu, the country name Shu Han, is a generation of heroes. In the process of Liu Bei's establishment of the Shu State, his second brother Guan Yu and third brother Zhang Fei made great contributions, and the three of them formed a righteous alliance in Taoyuan, not seeking to be born in the same year but to die on the same day, and established the Shu State from scratch.

In the process of Liu Bei's proclamation as emperor, he encountered many crisesMachine. Once Liu Bei was separated from his wife, Liu Bei did not have a certain strength at that time, he and his wife were separated, and he sent his second brother Guan Yu to find it. Another time Liu Bei was separated from his wife, and Zhao Yun killed seven in and seven out of the 100,000 Cao army alone before rescuing Liu Bei's son Adou.

But the only thing is that Zhang Fei has no experience of protecting Liu Bei's family.

Did Liu Bei deliberately prevent Zhang Fei and his third brother from protecting his family? The answer is yes, and why? It stands to reason that Zhang Fei is bold and careful, and his force value is by no means lower than that of Zhao Yun, why didn't Liu Bei let Zhang Fei protect his family.

There are many reasons, first of all, Zhang Fei's strategy is insufficient, although he is careful enough, but this can't make up for his bad brain, which leads to Zhang Fei acting alone.

For example, in Changbanpo, Zhang Fei alone drank back tens of thousands of Cao troops to protect the main retreat. But after Cao Jun retreated, he still cut the bridge, allowing Cao Jun to see through his plan and catch up again, which was just one of the many stupid things Zhang Fei did; Then Zhang Fei loves to drink, he is not like Guan Yu who knows how to control everything, he will get drunk when he drinks, and he will beat people every time he gets drunk, which is very similar to Wu Song; In the end, Zhang Fei is not very good to his subordinates, so there must be someone around him to control him, so why didn't Liu Bei let Zhang Fei protect his family, it was too dangerous.

Liu Bei asked Zhao Yun to help him protect his family, because Zhang Fei was more reckless, not smart, and liked to drink, and he would make mistakes when he drank, so he was not a reliable candidate.

Zhang Fei was originally a careless and unruly person, and he liked to drink, and if he drank too much, he would make mistakes, and his personality was impulsive, so Liu Bei did not let Zhang Fei protect his family.

Because Liu Bei felt that Zhang Fei was unreliable, too reckless, and always impulsive, Liu Bei was not at ease to hand over his family to Zhang Fei.

Because Zhang Fei is conceited and not careful, let him protect his family, Liu Bei is not at ease, Zhang Fei will not be killed by his own subordinates if he can do something.

Zhang Fei was not resourceful enough, drank and misbehaved, and could not be a corporal of courtesy, these shortcomings may not affect Zhang Fei to lead his troops to charge, but Liu Bei may not be at ease to let Zhang Fei protect his family.

Zhang Fei is reckless, and likes to drink, always drinking and making mistakes, Liu Bei definitely does not worry about him protecting his family.

He is too reckless, he doesn't use his brains too much, and if he is handed over to him, he is afraid that his family will not be able to live.

Because Liu Bei felt that Zhang Fei was unreliable, always too impulsive and informal, Liu Bei really didn't feel at ease about handing over his family to him.

No; Zhang Fei met Liu Weiyun, who sold straw sandals, when he was shopping, and then the two hit it off at first sight, and quietly made an appointment to go to the tavern to drink.

They are not the third brother of the blood relationship, but the godbrother of worship, and when they were recruiting troops and horses in the place, they met Liu Bei, who was like-minded.

It's not like this, it's just that it's still the same relationship after the worship, and they met through a chance relationship.

Speaking of Taoyuan Righteousness, everyone must think of true brotherhood, but among the three of them, there is such a rumor, Zhang Fei killed Guan Yu's whole family, and Liu Bei was unmoved? This is because this is a mutually agreed thing, just for the sake of not being burdened by your family in your future career.

On this day, Liu Guanzhang and the three of them worshiped as brothers in Taoyuan, not seeking to be born on the same day, the same month, and the same year, but to die on the same day, the same month, and the same year. The relationship between the three of them laid the foundation here, and it gradually deepened. However, after worshipping heaven and earth, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei were very enthusiastic, but Liu Bei looked a little melancholy, which made them worry as the second and third brothers, and hurriedly asked the eldest brother why this was, shouldn't it be a happy thing to worship.

Liu Bei said: "I am alone, there is nothing to worry about, you can let go and go on a journey, but you are all family people, which means that you can't fully devote yourself to your career, I am worried that the two of you will give up your career because of the family, and I will be left alone." ”When the second brother and the third brother heard this, this is indeed the truth, so the family can't be a drag on the three of us.

In order to reduce the burden of their careers, they came up with the idea of killing their own families, but they couldn't do it themselves, so the two of them discussed and asked each other to kill their own families. Liu Bei pondered for a long time, and finally decided to agree with the two of them. After speaking, the two set off separately and killed each other's whole family, Guan Yu went to Zhang Fei's house with a big knife, and Zhang Fei also entered Guan Yu's house with a knife.

In fact, this story is too exaggerated, but it is not very trueHowever, this can also be regarded as a reflection of their passion for their careers and the brotherhood between the three of them.

In fact, there is such a rumor that Zhang Fei killed Guan Yu's whole family, and Liu Bei was unmoved, this is because this is a mutually agreed matter, just to avoid being burdened by his family in his future career. Liu Bei once said: Family can't be a drag on the three of us.

Because they said at the beginning that they couldn't let their families affect their careers, Liu Bei didn't stop it.

Because they have made an agreement that they can't let their families delay their careers.

Probably there was some misunderstanding in it, and it was just for the sake of the future.

Because this is all the things they agreed on before, they agreed that in order to complete their ideals and goals, they would not let everyone be burdened by their own family, so when Zhang Fei killed Guan Yu's whole family, Liu Bei would not care.

I only know the general's order, but I don't know that there is an emperor, and the edge is too exposed.

He knew that there were indeed some deficiencies at that time, so he would not do things

Summary. Historically, Liu Bei and Zhang Fei were both figures who had intersections with Cao Cao, but it was not directly stated whether Liu Bei knew about the relationship between Zhang Fei and Cao Cao. However, according to historical records, Liu Bei has always had a suspicious and distrustful attitude towards Cao Cao, which has also become one of the main reasons for some contradictions between Liu Bei and Cao Cao.

As for whether Liu Bei knew about the kinship between Zhang Fei and Cao Cao, there is no clear record in the history books.

In history, Liu Bei and Zhang Fei were both characters who had intersections with Cao Cao, Bi Mao, laughing at the old man, but did not directly state whether Liu Bei knew the relationship between Zhang Fei and Cao Cao. However, according to historical records, Liu Bei has always had a suspicious and distrustful attitude towards Cao Cao, which has also become one of the main reasons for some contradictions between Liu Bei and Cao Cao. As for whether Liu Bei knew about the kinship between Zhang Fei and Cao Cao, there is no clear record in the history books.

Excuse me, but please go into more detail?

According to the description in "The Romance of the Three Kingdoms", when Liu Bei had just escaped from the Yellow Turban Rebellion, he met a warrior named Zhang Fei in Yingchuan. After some conversation, Liu Bei developed trust in Zhang Fei and decided to take him as his righteous brother. After this, Liu Bei met Guan Yu, and the three of them became Taoyuan Sanyi.

Although Liu Bei, Zhang Fei, and Guan Yu became brothers, they did not realize that Cao Cao was also their relative under the circumstances of the time. According to the records in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", Liu Bei and Cao Cao were distant relatives, while Guan Yu and Zhang Fei were not related to Cao Cao by blood. Therefore, Liu Bei did not know the fact that Zhang Fei and Cao Cao were related to each other.

Cao Cao and Zhang Fei were well-known historical figures during the Three Kingdoms, but recently some researchers have suggested that these two rivals in different camps are actually relatives! According to Sichuan's "Tianfu Morning Post", Shen Bojun, a researcher at the Sichuan Academy of Social Sciences and executive vice president of China's "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" Society, recently revealed this astonishing discovery.

This is not a strange story, but a real historical fact. Shen Bojun, who has been concentrating on the study of the Three Kingdoms for 20 years, told the story that the relationship between Cao Cao and Zhang Fei was established through the Xiahou Yuan family.

Cao Cao's father, Cao Song, was the adopted son of Cao Teng, a great eunuch in the late Eastern Han Dynasty, but his family was the Xiahou family. From the perspective of blood relationship, Cao Cao is actually a descendant of the Xiahou clan, and his number one general Xiahou is his cousin, and another general, Xiahou Yuan, is also his brother.

Shen Bojun said that by chance, Zhang Fei became the son-in-law of the Xiahou family.

According to the "Three Kingdoms Book of Wei Zhu Xiahou Cao Biography" notes "Wei Luo", the thing is like this: in the fifth year of Jian'an (200 AD), Xiahou Yuantang's niece and Xiahou Ba's sister traveled to Qiaocai, which was obtained by Zhang Fei. Fei knew that he was a daughter of his conscience, so he thought that he was a wife, a daughter who gave birth, and was the queen of Liu Chan.

In terms of seniority, Zhang Fei is Xiahou Yuan's cousin-in-law. Cao Cao is Xiahou Yuan's brother, and Zhang Fei is Xiahou Yuan's cousin-in-law, so Zhang Fei can also be said to be Cao Cao's cousin-in-law. Not only that, but even Liu Chan, the queen of Shu Han (Zhang Fei's daughter is his queen), can be regarded as Cao Cao's nephew and son-in-law.

How was the relationship between Cao Cao and Zhang Fei verified? Shen Bojun said: "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" was written by Luo Guanzhong more than 600 years ago based on historical facts, and the research on the relationship between Cao and Zhang is mainly to find clues from the vast historical materials.

The Romance of the Three Kingdoms is the most important research tool. In the Cao Wei Group, the Xiahou and Xiahou Yuan families are extremely honorable. Therefore, when Chen Shou wrote "Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms", he simply combined Xiahou, Xiahou Yuan, Cao Ren, Cao Hong and other Cao clan relatives into one biography, and labeled it "Zhuxiahou Cao Biography".

As for Luo Guanzhong's writing of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", he did not mention this point at all, not only did Zhang Fei's wife not show up at all, but when he wrote that Xiahouba defected to Shu Han, he did not give a brief explanation by the way. In this regard, Shen Bojun said: "This is a mystery that is difficult to solve.

Whatever the mystery, I regret it. ”

According to Shen Bojun, Zhang Fei's "word Yide" is a habitual mistake, and the correct statement should be "word Yide".

Shen Bojun believes that when literary works describe a real historical figure like Zhang Fei, his surname, first name, and character should be directly recorded according to the historical books, and cannot be arbitrarily changed. This is completely different from artistic fiction in order to organize the plot and shape the characters. "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" designed many wonderful plots in order to shape Zhang Fei's artistic image, which is allowed in the art of burial.

Changing the font size of the character will not help to shape the image, but will only cause undue mistakes. According to Shen Bojun's analysis, some people may have changed "Yide" to "Yide" without authorization because of Zhang Fei's name "Fei", ignoring the clear records of historical books, and without knowing the meaning of the text.

The third reason is that compared with Liu Bei's other generals, Zhang Fei's shortcomings are more prominent. At that time, there were other very talented generals under Liu Bei, and Guan Yu and Zhao Yun's martial arts were very high. Guan Yu is a very considerate person, he can think about everything thoroughly, and Zhao Yun is also not bad, his character is very cautious.

In Liu Bei's opinion, it was enough for these two people to protect their relatives, and Zhang Fei's obvious shortcomings compared to them would be magnified.

At that time, Zhang Fei and Guan Yu had more important things to do, and Zhao Yun had always been by his side, so he had been more trusting and accustomed to it for a long time, so he didn't need Zhang Fei.

I think maybe Liu Bei is still not very worried about Zhang Fei, so he didn't let him protect his family.

Zhang Fei is very powerful, the reason why Liu Bei didn't let him protect his family was because Liu Bei didn't trust him so much.

Because although Zhang Fei is very powerful in martial arts, he is more reckless in doing things, and sometimes he doesn't go through his brain, so it's like this.

Yes, Liu Bei attaches great importance to Zhang Fei and Guan Yu, and after conquering the country, he sealed Guan Yu and Zhang Fei's high titles, and formed a family with Zhang Fei.

I think Liu Bei really regarded Guan Yu and Zhang Fei as brothers, handed over the important land of Jingzhou to Guan Yu to guard, and was heartbroken after Guan Yu's death, and did not hesitate to give up the Northern Expedition Cao Cao also insisted on attacking Eastern Wu, this feeling will not be fake.

There should be, after the death of Guan Yu and Zhang Fei, Liu Bei vowed to exterminate Dongwu to avenge the two.

Treat them like true brothers. Because these two people have been very helpful to the start and development of Liu Bei's career, and they are also his right-hand men in the process of starting his career.

Yes, because Liu Guanzhang has the Taoyuan Three Alliances, although they are not brothers, they are better than brothers.

Liu Bei really regards Guan Yu and Zhang Fei as brothers, has absolute trust in them, entrusts them with important tasks, and has never changed his mind after becoming emperor, and regards them as brothers.