In the battle of the giant deer, was Xiang Yu s victory a fluke?

Because Xiang Yu killed himself in Wujiang in the later period, the end was very miserable, and he himself was indecisive and didn't seem to have much ability, so now many people question: Is the battle of Julu just Xiang Yu's lucky victory, but his luck?

It's funny to ask this question, although Xiang Yu has many flaws, but his outstanding military talent is affirmed by history, how can it be said that this is just a fluke?

The Battle of Julu is one of the famous battles in history, and the background of the rise of the war was that the Qin Dynasty army attacked Zhao, and Chu and other vassal states participated in the battle as reinforcements to rescue Zhao in Julu. The main characters are the generals of the Chu State Song Yi, Xiang Yu, Liu Bang, the generals of the Qin Dynasty Zhang Han, the long history Sima Xin and so on. Why is Xiang Yu's victory not a fluke?

An idiom can be summed up: courage and resourcefulness.

When the allied forces of the princes were afraid of Qin and did not dare to face the battle, when Song Yi, the general of Chu State, flinched and stayed for nearly 50 days, Xiang Yu stepped forward, killed Song Yi, and led the army to fight, which was brave. Then he led the soldiers to break the cauldron and sink the boat, rose up to attack, went straight to Julu, surrounded Wang Li's army, repelled Zhang Han, and rescued Julu, which was a plan.

But that's not the end of it, it's far from showcasing his talent. There is an allusion called "watching from the wall". It is said that under the leadership of Xiang Yu, the Chu army was majestic, and all the vassal states were afraid, so when they saw Xiang Yu, they all knelt forward, and it can be seen from here how much courage and talent he has to have such majesty.

Evaluating a historical figure cannot be generalized, even if Xiang Yu's final ending is not very optimistic, but his exploits in the battle of Julu are indelible, and he is a well-deserved hero.

It was the reason for the strategy, Xiang Yu used the relevant strategy to choose the siege strategy of breaking through one by one, and Wang Li's army was improper, so he won.

In the battle of the giant deer, I think Xiang Yu's victory was not a fluke. Xiang Yu is a very strategic emperor. He didn't leave a way out for himself and his soldiers, so he went all out, and I think the success of the Battle of Julu was the result of Xiang Yu's efforts.

I don't think it's a fluke, because Xiang Yu is very courageous, very powerful, there are Yingbu and Pu generals led 20,000 people to cross the Yellow River to cut off the Qin army's grain transportation channel, and he led the army to attack and ordered the whole army to break the cauldron and sink the boat with only three days of grain to fight to the death, and to vote for the determination of a death battle, so I don't think it's a fluke.

I don't think it's a fluke, it's because his outstanding strategic talent doesn't leave some way for his soldiers to retreat, that they fought desperately to win.

I don't think it's a fluke, because Xiang Yu still has strength, and I think it's because of his outstanding operational command and talent, so he won the battle completely on his own.

It shouldn't be considered a fluke. At that time, Xiang Yu had already relayed the morale of the whole army, so Xiang Yu's victory was the result of the people's desire.

It's not just that there is a fluke, but more because they have a kind of determination, a determination to die, and Qin Jun can't, they have their own family, once they die, the family will be ruined, and they don't have the determination to die.

In my opinion, Xiang Yu's victory was not a fluke, it was Xiang Yu who fought hard with his excellent operational command and fearless fighting spirit, had the courage to deny Song Yi's erroneous strategic command, and broke the boat, leaving no way for himself and the soldiers to retreat, which made the soldiers bravely kill the enemy and defeat the Qin army.

Xiang Yu's victory had an element of fluke. There are several factors that affect the outcome of the battle in the Battle of the Giant Deer. First, the Chu army was brave, and the morale of the princes' coalition army was greatly shaken:

second, Zhang Han watched from the wall and abandoned Wang Li at the critical moment; Third, after Zhang Han withdrew his army, Wang Li's army was cut off from grain and grass, which would affect the morale of Wang Li's army; Fourth, the joint strangulation of the princes' armies and the Chu army. It was political factors that caused Wang Li's army to be destroyed, otherwise with the strength of Wang Li's army and Zhang Han's army, as long as the two generals cooperated sincerely, the outcome of the Battle of Julu would be difficult to predict.

It's not a fluke, Xiang Yu is not only strong in martial arts, but also has a very strong team command ability, so for him, the victory in this battle is inevitable.

It has increased Xiang Yu's popularity and made many people willing to follow Xiang Yu, which has contributed to Xiang Yu's success, made many people admire Xiang Yu very much, and also destroyed their enemies.

If this article is used alone, then the reason is military strength and prestige.

First of all, military strength: the princes' army rescued more than ten walls under the giant deer, and they did not dare to set up troops. This shows that the princes' armies were all afraid of the Qin army.

Of course, we do not rule out the factors of having ghosts and holding a wait-and-see attitude, but the fear of the strong military strength of the Qin army is the fundamental reason. And the Chu army defeated the Qin army by itself, the so-called "Chu soldiers crown the princes". In any case, military strength is the first prerequisite, and this is especially evident in troubled times.

Secondly, might: Might can actually be said separately. Might, in the final analysis, still comes from strong military strength, but the process of the Chu army's victory undoubtedly pushed this kind of power to the extreme, so that the princes were convinced, and at the same time, Xiang Yu had already established a prestige for killing the champion of Qingzi and standing on his own.

Again, potential. The so-called potential is an inevitable situation, a pressure, and an atmosphere caused by the objective environment. At that time, it was already an inevitable trend for Xiang Yu to become the leader of the princes after the victory, even if some people were not convinced, in this trend, the opponents could not get the "opportunity" to raise objections, and forcibly proposing it would only lead to their own destruction, which is that people cannot, and they have no ability to move against the trend.

If we don't just talk about this short article, then there is another important reason that Xiang Yu's uncle Xiang Liang has a very high status in the rebel army. The state of Chu was the leader of the rebellious states, and the real power figure of the state of Chu was Xiang Liang, and this political capital was transferred to Xiang Yu after Xiang Liang's death.

If you want to ask Xiang Yu about the reasons for his victory in the war, I personally think there are two.

First, at that time, Xiang Yu was the righteous party. Qin has no way, self-destruction, caused by the Mandate of Heaven, and the trend of history. Xiang Yu stands at the forefront of this trend and occupies the name of righteousness.

Some people think that this is not important at all, and it does not help the number of winners and losers, but in fact, it is the root cause.

Second, Xiang Yu's courage and correct decision-making. War, the competition is the will of the boss, at this point, Xiang Yu's qi cover is unmatched. Husband war, courage also.

Xiang Yu used the cauldron to boost morale and defeat the enemy again. There is a saying in the book of war, put it in the place of death and then live, and put it in the place of death and then survive. Xiang Yu's approach has a theoretical basis.

There is no guaranteed victory, and in war, there is no way to win except self-confidence.