At the end of the Ming Dynasty, the Eight Banners Army was short of money, so why didn t they ask th

Because the landlord bureaucracy in the late Ming Dynasty was very powerful, even Chongzhen did not dare to provoke them easily and damage their interests, so he could only tax civilians to subsidize the military.

Because the landlords and bureaucrats were the ruling class, if the emperor taxed these people, these people would disobey the yang and the yin, and in the end they would be ruined, with no effect. So the emperor could only tax the commoners.

Because the landlords and bureaucrats at that time had their own private soldiers in their hands, if they could not get along, it was very easy to have conflicts, and on the contrary, it was even more likely to lose their troops and lose more than they lost.

But if you have the strength to ask for money, you won't be able to defeat it.

The financial burden of the Ming Dynasty clan at that time and the financial burden of the Qing Dynasty's Eight Banners affirmed that the burden of the Ming Dynasty was heavier, and the Ming Dynasty not only had to resist the Qing army outside the Guan, but also assessed the uprising of the peasant army at home, which required a large amount of financial revenue.

I think that the burden on the finances of the Eight Banners of the Qing Dynasty was relatively serious, because in the Qing Dynasty, the Manchu and Han were integrated, which made the Qing Dynasty need to support more people.

I think the Ming dynasty was more financially burdened because it required a lot of resources at the time, and many people didn't create value because of it.

The hundreds of thousands of clans in the Ming Dynasty consumed resources and did not have any positive role and output, while the Eight Banners Army was a military unit that shouldered the responsibility of national defense.

The burden of the Eight Banners in the Qing Dynasty was relatively serious, and at that time, as long as the children of the Eight Banners had money, the number of people was too much, which was a large expenditure.

The burden of the Qing Dynasty was relatively heavy, because the Qing Dynasty also had to support a group of soldiers of the Eight Banners, which cost a lot of money.

In the Ming Dynasty, the Ming Dynasty royal family formed by Zhu Yuanzhang's family as a whole became a moth to the society at that time, and in the Qing Dynasty, the Manchu Eight Banners, represented by the satisfaction, also became a major burden on the imperial court's finances. Compared with the two, it should be that the Ming Dynasty royal family caused a heavier burden on the imperial finances.

1. The Ming Dynasty royal family occupied a larger area, which caused serious damage to the finances of various regions.

Because Zhu Yuanzhang learned the lesson of the Yuan Dynasty's policy of concentrating too many royal families, to a large extent, it restricted its descendants from staying in **, but divided them into various places, and absorbed more financial ** in the local area to supply itself. This resulted in the fact that during the Ming Dynasty, the royal family occupied almost all the land in the world at that time. The fact that these royal families took root in the local area caused a heavy burden on the local finances.

And these overburdens also crushed the finances of the Ming Dynasty, making the Ming Dynasty more and more unbearable in the later period, in which the state eventually collapsed. Although the Manchu Eight Banners of the Qing Dynasty were a little larger in number than the Ming Dynasty royal family at the beginning, they were more concentrated in Beijing and a series of small places in the northeast. As a result, the financial impact they can have is limited to one place, not to a larger area.

Although the Manchu Eight Banners were brought by the entire Manchu nation in the northeast at the beginning, its total number has been surrounded by a relatively fixed state, but the imperial family of the Ming Dynasty is far different, their population base at the beginning is very small, only Zhu Yuanzhang and his relatives, but with the continuous reproduction of the population to the later period has occupied most of the local forces and places, and some of the most important positions are almost all members of the royal family. This has led to a large number of their populations becoming local moths. In terms of population, the burden on the imperial court's finances is even heavier.

In the Eight Banners of the Manchu Dynasty and the imperial family of the Ming Dynasty, I think that the burden on the finances of the Eight Banners of the Manchu Dynasty was even heavier, because the policy of closing the country to the outside world was implemented at that time, and the economy was very closed.

The Manchu Eight Banners were heavier, because the Qing Dynasty was responsible for all the expenses of the Manchu Eight Banners.

Manchu Eight Banners. Because there are many children of the Eight Banners who do not work hard and survive by the royal family's gifts.