Qian Zhou s persuasion of Liu Chan was a wise move to deceive the monarch and mislead the country or

I think it's a wise move to follow the trend, because Liu Chan is not a talent for governing the country in the first place, and the war has made the people's lives miserable, so I think it's a wise move.

Bullying the king and misleading the country. When Liu Chan surrendered, there were still tens of thousands of soldiers in Chengdu who could fight, and if they took advantage of the situation to fight with the Wei army, Shu Han might not perish.

It's a smart move to follow the trend.

At that time, the Shu Kingdom had already suffered from a sharp decline in the population of the country, and the people were miserable, and if they did not surrender by taking advantage of the situation, they could not avoid extinction.

Therefore, it is a wise move to follow the trend.

It is to ask for the people's life and find a way out, and carefully grind Wang Because of the situation at the time, even if he fights again, Shu Han will die, it is better to surrender Brother You as soon as possible, so that the people will suffer less from the war.

Because the situation of the whole country at that time was already very bad, even if the war was won, nothing could be recovered, and the country still had no way to preserve.

Because he believed that Liu Chan did not have the ability to fight, and there were no generals in the court who could fight against the enemy, he would persuade him to surrender without a fight.

At that time, the national strength of Shu and Wei was a drop in the bucket, and Shu had been fighting for many years, the national strength was also lacking, and the generals were almost exhausted.

Because they don't want to fight anymore, and they also understand the current situation, even if they fight, they can't win, so it's better to surrender on their own initiative and maintain their strength.

Mainly because Qian Zhou wants the people of Yizhou to get a better life, and it is also for the reunification of the country as soon as possible.

Because he saw the end of the matter, he felt that Mingzhe could save himself, and the temporary concession would leave room for himself, and he would let himself fight back.

This person should not be said to be a villain, because at that time, Liu Chan could only save his life by surrendering, and Qian Zhou still had a certain vision.

I think he is a villain, for his own glory, but Qian Zhou can also be regarded as a meritorious person, knowing that he can't do anything, he kept Liu Chan's name despite being infamous, and it is really difficult to evaluate the merits and demerits.

I don't think he is a villain, because the content of the historical record is different, which also leads to the difference in everyone's understanding of Qian Zhou.

I don't think he is a villain, because everyone has a different view of history, so there will be mixed reviews, and he persuaded Liu Chan to surrender from the overall situation, the situation has been decided, and nothing can be changed.

Qian Zhou is not a villain, this person has been poor since childhood, studied diligently, knows astronomy and geography, speaks out, opposes the war and the Northern Expedition, and strongly persuaded Liu Chan to surrender after the collapse of the Shu State, and saved the lives of hundreds of officials and people, which was also a last resort.

It's not a villain, because with the strength of Liu Chanshu at that time, he definitely couldn't carry the Wei State, and if he carried it hard, it would only make the lives miserable, and the people would not be able to make a living, but there were quite a lot of defenders of feudal etiquette and religion, who felt that he was selling his way to seek glory.

The hatred of the country is not a scolding of Liu Chan.

The Theory of Hatred of the State was written by the Shu Han Zhongsan doctor in the Three Kingdoms period in the twentieth year of Yanxi (257 AD), and is an article against Jiang Wei's reckless military force and the launching of the Northern Expedition for many years. The article was also seen as a rebellion by the locals of Yizhou against the foreign ruling clique of the Shu Han dynasty.

"The Theory of Hatred of the Country" did not prevent Jiang Wei from continuing the Northern Expedition, but Qian Zhou was not punished in the end, but was promoted to one level and became a doctor of Guanglu, which shows that many people in the court also thought deeply of his remarks, and then the resistance of the local people in Yizhou to Shu Han became more intense, until Qian Zhou persuaded Liu Chan to surrender and Shu Han perished.

In his later years, he was deliberately transferred by Sima Yan, and the ending was bleak.

Ordinary readers know very little about Zhou Zhou, far less than the prestige of Zhuge Liang, Zhou Yu and others. And his world-famous event is due to the fact that when he was surviving Shu Han, he strongly persuaded the latter to surrender, so that Deng Ai's bloodless capture of Chengdu came to a successful end.

As an authentic Shu person, Qian Zhou has never had much influence, and he himself is only a Guanglu doctor at the highest, and he has no real power. As a local Confucian, but he ended up in such a field, it should have been a grudge for a long time, and the Shu Han regime has always had a big problem, that is, the confrontation between the Yizhou Group and the Jingzhou Group brought by Liu Bei, but the result is clear to everyone.

Therefore, Qian Zhou's group of people are very aggrieved, and they look down on a small court like Shu Han in their hearts, and dream of being an official and a half-time official in the Cao Wei Group, so that they can have face. So when it really arrived at Deng Ai and led the army to Chengdu, these people in Qian Zhou may not be happy, what are you Liu Chan loving, surrender to me first.

But after Sima Yan ascended the throne, things became different: Sima Yan originally set out to attack Wu, but he also had to take into account the situation in Shu, so as not to cause chaos and suffer from the enemy at that time. And Qian Zhou's prestige in Shu at that time was enough to catch up with another Liu Chan, so Sima Yan considered this and transferred him to Luoyang.

At this time, Qian Zhou was too old to be old, and he had lived in Shudu all his life, and suddenly changed the environment, and soon died in a foreign country, which was very sad and miserable.

After Sima Yan came to power, he couldn't get used to a traitor like Qian Zhou who sought glory, and his high status in Shu was prone to variables, so he moved him to Luoyang, and as a result, Qian Zhou reluctantly fell ill and died.

Wei State attacked Shu on three roads, and Qian Zhou was named the Marquis of Yangcheng Pavilion because he persuaded Liu Chan to surrender. After Sima Yan became emperor, he recruited Qian Zhou to Luoyang as an official, and Chen Zhou went to Luoyang with illness in desperation, and soon died of illness.

How can the sleeping couch tolerate others, and it is not easy to collect the Han land, how can he let others become the emperor of the soil.

, under the couch, may others sleep soundly.

Recalled Luoyang, made an official, and let him euthanize.

It is said that he died of illness, and I think he took chronic poison and euthanized.

Qian Zhou was born in the fifth year of Emperor Liu Xiejian'an of the Han Dynasty in the late Eastern Han Dynasty (201 AD) in a famous scholarly family. He lost his father at an early age, and was nurtured by his father, and was diligent and studious since he was a child, reading the scriptures and books, and knowing astronomy. During the Jianxing period, Zhuge Liang was the prime minister of Shu Han, so you have to pay attention

In fact, I think that from a long-term perspective, it is a lifesaver who leaves a note.

Qian Zhou still has a lot of ideas, and this head is also very flexible and capable.

The reason why he is called a capitulationist is not for his own selfishness, but for the consideration of the people of the whole country.

This person is very far-sighted, and he considers things more thoroughly, and he is also very recognized by Zhuge Liang from the point of view of knowledge.

From the overall situation, it was actually Liu Chan's life-saving benefactor, because the Shu Kingdom at that time was no longer good and was already devastated.

I don't think either of these definitions can describe this person very well, after all, there are right and wrong things he does.

Surrender does not mean defeat, nor does it mean that you are betrayed, it may just be a temporary helplessness.

What is the main aspect of analysis? I think he can be regarded as Liu Chan's life-saving benefactor.