Do you think Shang Ying s death was really because of the change?

No, because Shang Ying's reform punished the prince and the prince's teacher, Gongzi Qian, and attracted their resentment. After the death of Qin Xiaogong, Gongzi Qian falsely accused Shang Jun of rebellion, and King Qin Huiwen brutally killed Shang Ying.

Of course, the death was just right, Gongzi Qian was very smart, and he used Shang Ying's death to alleviate the hatred of the conservatives, and successfully stabilized the results of the reform. ‍‍

Yes, but not comprehensively. Shang Ying was a victim of the succession of King Qin Huiwen, who killed Shang Ying, on the one hand, he could reclaim power and increase his prestige, and on the other hand, he could temporarily gain the support of the noble family and stabilize his position.

I think it was because of the change of the law, and the change of the law offended the nobles of the Qin State and was framed by the nobles. Die by your own law. ‍‍

The direct cause of Shang Ying's death was a love of power caused by selfishness, and Shang Ying's power was too great, which directly threatened the royal power. ‍‍

It shouldn't be, according to the "Historical Records", Shang Jun deserved it, and he owed Qin yes, but he really rebelled.

Shang Yang was the focus of the conflict of interests between the dynasty and the aristocracy, and was the target of the aristocracy; All because the change of law touched their interests.

Shang Ying punished the calendar strictly, did things too desperately, offended too many people, everyone hated him, and the law he set was too strict, cutting off his own way of retreat.

Yue Fei didn't change the law, but he had to die! Shang Ying died, but the legal system remained; Yue Fei died, and was later rehabilitated. Therefore, Shang Ying's death was not fundamentally because of a change in the law, but a victim under the imperial hereditary system.

In the feudal era, Shang Ying advocated changing the law, completing the strengthening of Qin, and facing the new monarch, he would definitely die. I think it's really because of the change.

privately thought that Shang Ying had chosen to die, which may be the only way to defend the law in his opinion. ‍‍

The main reason for the success of the Shang Yang reform is that Qin Xiaogong and Qin Huiwen Wang are strong enough to suppress the domestic aristocracy, and Shang Yang is just a chess piece.

Shang Ying's death and Wu Qi's death were both due to the implementation of reforms, and the interests of the old nobles were harmed the most, so as soon as the old monarch died, these old nobles would have to eliminate him.

Throughout history, only the emperor can implement the change, everyone else is blindly busy, successful, the benefit is the emperor, and the masses, the emperor has not lost if he fails, and the responsibility has been pushed one by one.

Changing the law is just a change of power, which is feasible at the right time, and undoubtedly disaster when it is not appropriate.

There are many explanations for this kind of thing, and there can be many reasons, but for King Huiwen, it is enough to kill the simplest and better than to live! It's just a matter of unloading the mill and killing the donkey, it's not that complicated, because it doesn't exist emotionally, and even with a little hatred, it's killing from a utilitarian point of view.

Shang Ying's reform succeeded but the person died, and Wang Anshi's reform failed but the person is still there? Is it Shang Ying's misfortune or Wang Anshi's misfortune?

Those who achieve great things have long had a heart that would die

Shang Ying's change offended almost everyone, including some **, because some of the rules of Shang Ying's change were too strict, and the emperor was more afraid of Shang Yang at that time, and felt that such a person could not go to other countries, and if he went to other countries, it would be a big hidden danger to Qin, so he had to die.

Shang Ying's change of law offended the powerful people at that time. Because the Shang Dynasty Reform Law proposed to emphasize agriculture and suppress business. This affected the economic interests of these magnates, so they were executed.

If Shang Yan does not die, it may cause changes in the Qin State, and it will also affect the turmoil in the Qin State. That's why he had to die.

Although the Shang Dynasty reform law could strengthen the imperial power, it is true that the magnates at that time were greatly impacted and affected the status of the magnates at that time, so Shang Ying had to die.

Because the strength of the old nobles of the old family is still strong, the legal foundation of the Qin State is not stable, which can be seen from the death of Shang Ying, the new monarch's understanding of the law change is not deep and long-term, until Qin Shi Huang unified the world and reused Li Si to begin to establish the Chinese feudal system, and then Zhao Gao did not raise objections to the feudal system, Li Si's death was in political struggle, not system restoration.

Shang martingale change. It is an epoch-making change that makes the Qin State.

From a weak and impoverished country to a country with super comprehensive strength during the Warring States Period, it laid the foundation for Qin's unification of the Six Kingdoms.

Qin is located in a remote area and has always been a very weak country, and the vassal states at that time all looked down on Qin, which was relatively backward economically, politically, and culturally, and its neighbor was Wei.

After Li Kui's change of law became strong and invaded the land west of the Qin state, the king of the Qin state wanted to recapture the land west of the river, but the strong state of Wei could not get his wish.

Qin Xiaogong. After succeeding to the throne, he was very sad about the weakening of the Qin State, he vowed to make the Qin State strong, and in order to recruit talents, he issued a merit search order, and at this time Shang Ying came to the Qin State because he could not be reused in the Wei State.

After Qin Xiaogong got Shang Ying, after three meetings, Shang Ying dedicated his domineering strategy of governing the country to Qin Xiaogong, Qin Xiaogong felt that this was what he wanted, and it was a good way to quickly enhance the national strength of Qin, so Qin Xiaogong appointed Shang Ying as the head of the left and changed the law in Qin.

Shang Ying changed the law and abolished the Jingtian system.

Attach importance to agriculture and mulberry, reward military merits, and implement the county system.

The unification of weights and measures made the Qin State a centralized state, allowing the common people of the Qin State to have the opportunity to be promoted by virtue of their military merits, weakening the privileges of the nobles and officials, and allowing them to also participate in labor production.

The most powerful country in the country.

The Shang Dynasty reform was the most thorough reform in the Warring States Period, involving political, economic, military and other aspects, through the reform, completely dismantled the slave social system, promoted the process of feudal society, implemented the county system, made the Qin State quickly strong, and established the first centralized feudal dynasty in Chinese history.

Of course, I think that when looking at a problem, we should start from both positive and negative aspects, the Shang Dynasty reform has both its progressive side and its limitations, but it is also a product of historical development, and to a certain extent, it also promoted the economic development at that time.

Pretty good. The Shang Dynasty Reform is one of the few successful reforms in history, and my favorite is the policy of rewarding cultivation and weaving, which has increased everyone's enthusiasm and promoted economic development.

I think the intention of Shang Ying's reform of the law is better, and it also made the Qin State a powerful country, but it hurt the interests of the nobles.

I think that the Shang Dynasty reform promoted the development of the Qin state, and it was precisely because of the Shang Dynasty's reform that the Qin state became stronger and stronger, and finally unified the six countries, which I think is a very good political decision.