The ending of Dream of Red Mansions is poignant or miserable

Dream of Red Mansions has no ending, what we see is the ending written by Gao E, which is not convincing. According to Mr. Cao's original intention, the ending of Dream of Red Mansions should be miserable, unbearable!!

I think it should be poignant, and Dream of Red Mansions should be tragic aesthetics.

Tragedy is the destruction of valuable things for others to see (Lu Xun). Its aesthetic characteristics are magnificent and sublime, and its aesthetic value is edification and liberation. —Wang Guowei's Commentary on Dream of the Red Chamber.

Compared with comedy aesthetics, which examines the audience's recognition and understanding of witty and irony, tragic aesthetics examines the audience's resonance and understanding of human nature and social suffering, pain, and helplessness.

The tragedy of Dream of Red Mansions is not the tragedy of the four families, it is the tragedy of the whole society.

Dream of Red Mansions will leave us blank, different readers have a very different understanding of his ending, in my eyes her ending is a poignant, a great beauty.

Shakespeare said: The death of a person is a tragedy, and the death of no one is an even greater tragedy. Of course, no one is referring to the beauty of the appearance and the beauty of the soul. Do you think it's miserable or poignant?

I can only say that love is poignant, and the ending is miserable.

"Dream of Red Mansions" in the sense of Cao Xueqin will definitely have a tragic ending. The shattering of the former alliance of wood and stone, the withering of the Grand View Garden, what else is worth the author's nostalgia, and what else is worth waiting for?

I don't think it's beautiful at all.,I'm just angry.。。。

In fact, "Dream of Red Mansions" ends at the beginning. Illusory, illusory, true and false, under the pen of the author Cao Xueqin, he got the most indulgent catharsis. And the real ending of Jiafu was cleverly hidden by the author in a deserted ancient temple outside Yangzhou as early as the beginning of "Dream of Red Mansions".

The story of Jiafu in "Dream of Red Mansions" actually starts with Jia Yucun entering Jiafu, and in the end, it also ends with Jia Yucun seeing Jia Baoyu in the ancient temple in the wilderness. "Dream of Red Mansions" begins and ends, which is Cao Xueqin's most clever design.

The story of Jiafu in "Dream of Red Mansions" actually starts with Jia Yucun entering Jiafu, and in the end, it also ends with Jia Yucun seeing Jia Baoyu in the ancient temple in the wilderness. "Dream of Red Mansions" begins and ends, which is Cao Xueqin's most clever design.

As the saying goes, the incomplete is the most beautiful, just like the Venus with a broken arm, the Dream of Red Mansions with only 80 episodes has reached the pinnacle of classical ** in terms of writing, plot and character portrayal, and the heavy foreshadowing laid by the author makes the whole ** always have a sense of oppression that the mountain rain is about to come and the wind is full of buildings, which makes people really can't help but guess the plot and character endings after 80 times. It is a pity that neither Gao Yi nor the ending of the modern writer continues to write, but there is no version that particularly fits the original author's thoughts.

"Dream of Red Mansions".

Formerly known as "The Stone Record", it is a long story in ancient Chinese chapters and hui, and one of the four great classics of Chinese classics. There are a total of 120 chapters of its popular version, and it is generally believed that the first 80 chapters were written by the Qing Dynasty writer Cao Xueqin, and the last 40 chapters were written by Anonymous, and the collators were Cheng Weiyuan and Gao E. **With the rise and fall of the four major families of Jia, Shi, Wang and Xue as the background, from the perspective of the rich and noble son Jia Baoyu, and the tragedy of Jia Baoyu's love and marriage with Lin Daiyu and Xue Baochai as the main line, it depicts the life of some boudoir beauties, showing the real beauty of human nature and tragic beauty, and is an epic work that shows the beauty of women and ancient Chinese society from all angles.

1, the ending of "Dream of Red Mansions": Daiyu died, Baochai married Baoyu, and the Jia family fell, but Baoyu finally became a monk. Baoyu has enjoyed all the wonders of the world, and has also eaten all kinds of pain in the world.

In the end, he turned into stone again and returned to the bottom of the nonsensical cliff of the Great Wilderness Mountain.

2. The implication of "Dream of Red Mansions": It takes the daily life of Rongguo Mansion as the center, the tragedy of love and marriage of Baoyu, Daiyu and Baochai and the trivial matters in the Grand View Garden as the main line, and the history of the four major families of Jinling aristocracy Jia, Wang, Xue and Shi from their prosperity to decline is the dark line. It shows the inevitable trend that the desperate feudal society will eventually go to extinction.