What is the ending of Dream of Red Mansions? Why is it so tragic? Is Xue Baochai a good person?

Dream of Red Mansions theoretically has no ending, Mr. Cao Xueqin did not finish writing when he died, and what I see now is continued by posterity, Gao E's continuation is most often used as the ending, but his writing completely subverts the author's original intention. The end should be ruined and destitute. The tragic ending is because it is a story that takes place in a hopeless context, and in that context no one deserves a good ending.

Only such a tragic ending can embody and sublimate the artistry, epochality and theme of Dream of Red Mansions. Xue Baochai doesn't care if he's a good guy or a bad guy. She's just being a little selfish.

In fact, you should know that the last forty episodes were written by Gao E, but whether it is Gao He or Cao Xueqin, the ending of the Dream of Red Mansions they gave is destined to be tragic, you shouldn't just read him as a **, think about why such an ending, in fact, he is a piece of history, and the darkness he exposes and reflects is where his value lies. Xue Baochai is not a good person or a bad person, she is also a regrettable product of that era. Personally, I still like Xue Baochai very much.

Cao Xueqin didn't finish writing Dream of Red Mansions, and Gao He continued to write it, so the ending we see now is the ending written by Gao E. However, according to the ending of the characters contained in Cao Xueqin's front, Xue Baochai was widowed, Baoyu became a monk, Lin Daiyu died of illness, Wang Xifeng was retired instead of dying, Rongguo Mansion and Ning Guofu were all defeated, and the family was ruined, and each found its own way.

Human nature is complex, there are no absolute bad people, and there are no perfect good people, Dream of Red Mansions has done a particularly good job at this point, okay, I just saw that the question of is Baochai a good person is a bit hot....Ignore me.

I remember watching Liu Xinwu's hundred pulpits, he thought that Daiyu should sink into the lake and die, "Dream of Red Mansions" is a tragedy, as for Baochai, she is just a victim of feudal rule, and she is also worthy of pity.

You can't read it once, read it a few more times, read a few more versions, combined with Liu Xingwu's **, Zhou Ruchang's interpretation, you can understand one or two. If you want to know everything, then look at your own experience.

The ending is that Lin Daiyu is dead, Jia Baoyu is a monk, and Xue Baochai is a good person.

The final ending was continued by Gao E, but Daiyu died of illness in the 96th episode, on the night of Jia Baoyu's wedding. Baoyu knew that Sister Lin also became a monk after her death, and Baochai was widowed in Jiafu. But it should be said that Gao Yi served the rule of the Qing Dynasty, and the last thing he gave was the son of Li Kun in Jiafu, and Jiafu was brilliant again.

As for Baochai, I think she is also quite miserable, her talent and appearance are not worse than Daiyu, but she married someone who doesn't love herself. Living in that era, it should be said that she is already the best among everyone's ladies. It's not her fault that Bao Dai didn't get together in the end, she was also a victim of feudal rule, so naturally she can't be said to be a bad person.

You can't judge Xue Baochai by "good people or bad people".

Families are scattered! Ask the author! No!

Judging from the sentence against her in the fifth episode of "A Dream of Red Mansions", "It's a pity to stop the morality, and the golden hairpin is buried in the snow", Xue Bao, as the heroine of "A Dream of Red Mansions" and Lin Daiyu, did not have a good ending. Judging from Gao E's continuation book and the research of many red researchers, her ending is nothing more than two kinds:

The first ending is that Gao He continued to say in the book: In order to make Baoyu happy, she pretended to be Lin Daiyu and Jia Baoyu got married, and Lin Daiyu burned the manuscript and died after learning about it. Although Jia Baoyu still became a monk in the end, she left her bloodline, that is, she gave birth to a son, named "Jia Gui", and later called "Lan Gui Qi Fang" together with Jia Lan, reviving Jia Mansion.

This kind of ending is not tragic for Xue Baochai, she doesn't look down on Baoyu's lack of progress, and after conventional persuasion, Baoyu is disgusted by her "downtime virtue", if the ending is really like this, she can cultivate her son according to her own wishes, and let her son realize his long-cherished wish of "going to the blue sky". As a feudal moral flaunt, Baochai can be regarded as a good end.

The second ending: Although Baochai finally married Baoyu, after Lin Daiyu's death. At that time, Baoyu was already "dead and ashes", and although it was difficult for Baochai to get married, he did not have a round house, let alone a son.

At the beginning, Baochai got Baoyu's people, and every time he didn't get his heart, he kept the empty room alone.

Later, Jia Baoyu simply became a monk, and Baochai had nothing. For her who is so strong, this is such a big blow, so she should have died in the end in grievances and hardships. The ending is not tragic.

I agree with the second ending, according to Cao Gong's previous layout: "A thousand red holes, ten thousand Yan share sorrow", the ending should be a big tragedy. After the collapse of the Jiafu Building, the people who clinged to it, especially the daughters, all had a tragic end.

Whether it is Lin Daiyu, who has the spirit of resistance, or Xue Baochai, who follows feudal etiquette, they can't escape the fate of being sacrificed.

As for Jia Baoyu, whether it is Gao Yi or the research of other experts, they all believe that he is indeed a monk in the end. For there was a prophecy before: "He who sees through it will flee into the empty gate; It's like eating all the birds and throwing them into the forest, and the white land is really clean! There are also many references in the book that Jia Baoyu said that he wanted to become a monk.

After the defeat of Jiafu, King Jia Bao, who grew up in small brocade clothes and jade food, finally saw through the red dust and escaped into the empty door after experiencing life and death, the cold and cold of the world, and the cold and warm people.

Not necessarily. People should bear the consequences for everything they do, but the old mother of the Xue family should still be good.

I think Xue Baochai's ending is still relatively good, and the ending of everyone in Jiafu is actually fate.

Definitely, yes, because he was able to marry into a rich family and live his whole life without worrying about food and drink, in fact, I think this is all fate.

She is Xue Baochai in Dream of Red Mansions, quit the showbiz and entered the business world for many years, and is still single at the age of 55, when it comes to classic characters in film and television dramas, many people first think of the four famous novels, "Journey to the West" and "Dream of Red Mansions" The characters in "Dream of Red Mansions" impressed the audience even more, there were not so many film and television works at that time, and a "Dream of Red Mansions" has also become a good memory for several generations. The acting skills of the actors in the play have not been surpassed so far, she played Xue Baochai in "Dream of Red Mansions", after becoming popular, she quit the entertainment industry and entered the business world for many years, and now she is still single at the age of 55, she is the actor Zhang Li.

This is the evaluation that Xue Baochai received in Jiafu when he first entered Jiafu. Later, Jia Baoyu's nurse Mama Li said that Lin Daiyu "This mouth speaks, sharper than a knife", Xue Baochai also said that Lin Dai and Shenheyu "The mouth of the girl is not loved, nor is it hated", and Lin Hongyu, the girl of Jia Baoyu in Dicuiting, also said that "Miss Lin's mouth loves mean people". From the words of these people, we know that Lin Daiyu was labeled as a vitriol.

Jia Baoyu is the one who is teased the most by Lin Daiyu, he has a special relationship with Lin Daiyu, he belongs to the children in love, and it is normal for the two of them to be noisy. In addition, Lin Daiyu will also tease Xue Baochai, because of the rumors of Jinyu's good relationship, of course, it is also related to Jia Baoyu's "seeing my sister and forgetting my sister", three people in a delicate relationship, Lin Daiyu teasing the two of them is a normal psychological reaction, and this situation often happens in daily life.

The second impression is that Lin Daiyu is mean to Zhou Rui's family, Zhou Rui's family is desperate to send palace flowers, and the last one is given to Lin Daiyu, Lin Daiyu came to the sentence "I know that others pick the rest to give it to me", which made Zhou Rui's family embarrassed. At other times, it is no longer easy to find Lin Daiyu's mean sentences. However, Lin Daiyu said these mean words, all of which were said in person, and if she was dissatisfied, she immediately expressed her dissatisfaction, and did not comment on the rights and wrongs of others behind her back.

Three people in a delicate relationship, Lin Daiyu's blind teasing of the two of them is a normal psychological reaction, and this situation often happens in daily life.

Died a miserable death. To analyze the ending of the twelve hairpins, the verdict can not be ignored, Baochai and Daiyu lead brigade together use a judgment, about the ending of the socks Baochai, it seems to be revealed in the sentence "golden hairpin buried in the snow", many people also believe that Baochai finally died, and tragically died in a winter, and the body was covered by snow.

Although Jia Baoyu and Xue Baochai are married, Jia Baoyu has been immersed in the grief of Lin Daiyu's death.

The final ending was hanging, because Xue Baochai was abandoned by Jia Baoyu, which was very humiliating in ancient times, so Xue Baochai hanged himself in grief and anger.

There are many kinds of final endings, either lonely old age, remarrying Jia Yucun, or dying miserably.

In the dream of Red Mansions, Xue Baochai finally married Jia Baoyu, but unfortunately Jia Baoyu never forgot Lin Daiyu, even though Baochai bent mu is a model of a good wife and mother, but friends have never gotten Baoyu's sincerity, and the evening scene is bleak and lonely.