Is filial piety a spontaneous emotion or a kind of responsibility, and what the heart demands of one

There are both, and in my opinion, filial piety is formed in the day after tomorrow. Filial piety is to set an example for our parents to their elders, and to influence the environment of our own lives, so as to influence our own responses. Under this subtle influence, filial piety will become a part of one's subjective consciousness.

There will be two forms of expression: from the heart and from one's own consciousness. So, I think it's both. Who is in charge depends on your environment and the influence of your education.

The so-called filial piety of Confucianism refers to the control of independent consciousness, because the Confucian classics are a book that teaches people to educate people, since it is a book, his original intention is to limit people's self-consciousness, in order to achieve human resonance, so as to imperceptibly influence the person who reads, hoping to further convey the inner meaning of better acceptance, and finally form emotional approval, and even become the principle of behavior in people's lives, just like instinct.

In my opinion, the Confucian practice of filial piety hopes that people will do it from the heart, but he starts in a form of gratitude, hoping to influence people, in order to achieve the recognition of inner feelings.

That's my understanding.

Filial piety is indeed the traditional virtue of the Chinese nation. In fashionable terms, it can make this society more harmonious. Filial piety is also needed by the state.

Because from a small aspect, filial piety to parents will lead to family harmony. When the family is peaceful, everything will be prosperous. From the country's side, it will be more stable.

I believe that filial piety is a kind of inheritance, a continuation of care and love. From birth to adulthood, we are full of the grace of our parents. So filial piety is a reward for them.

How can a crow feed back, let alone a man? Filial piety is first and foremost a thought, and then it governs his actions. Filial piety is also a kind of education.

If parents don't set an example, then this kind of education will fail in their next generation. Personally, I think filial piety should be education plus spontaneity.

I think it's a bit of both!!

This should be a combination of both!!

Personal understanding, filial piety is the heart of gratitude, is the responsibility and obligation that drives you to take the initiative from the heart, and she is pure. Of course, human nature is a combination of complex bodies, and many times it should be that feelings produce consciousness, and consciousness controls behavior. The reason why we know gratitude is because of the existence of feelings, a person who has nothing to do with you will not have filial piety between you.

For example, if you support an old man who has nothing to do with you, is this filial piety? Definitely not, it's just a kind of care, love. Why is filial piety a traditional virtue, there is a inheritance in this, not only the inheritance of blood thicker than water, but also the inheritance of feelings.

On the contrary, if it is only a kind of responsibility, the responsibility and obligation that the heart is driven by the requirements of oneself, then the behavior that arises in this way is not filial piety. For example, if you assume the obligation to support your parents only under the intervention of the law, it is not filial piety, it is forced, and it is not filial piety. Filial piety is positive, proactive, upward, and sunny.

The problem itself is not contradictory, in the interpretation of filial piety, feelings and responsibility, feelings and self, feelings and consciousness, feelings and gratitude, are inseparable friends.

Since ancient times, people have regarded parents raising their children and children honoring their parents as the basic morality of life. Confucius said: "Filial piety is the foundation of virtue." Only a person who honors his parents is a responsible and noble person.

Filial piety is the psychology of children's respect, obedience, and gratitude to their parents and younger generations to their elders. The Confucian "Book of Filial Piety" begins with a clear chapter: The body is skinned, and the parents who receive it dare not destroy it, and the beginning of filial piety is also; Standing on the road, making a name for yourself in future generations, in order to show your parents, and the end of filial piety.

Filial piety begins with the family, the middle is the king, and the end is established. Filial piety is the result of the involuntary interweaving of the involuntary feelings and the conscious requirements of the self, and it is an act of the id and the superego to complete the self-reality.

People are animals, but they are still social animals, in fact, they are not Chinese culture, any culture has filial piety, I have not heard that the old people in Western countries were starved to death, this is a social requirement and social responsibility. But filial piety must also have an emotional element, no matter who it is, the person who gave birth to you, educated you and lived with for many years, if you abandon it, it is not emotionally acceptable.

Filial piety is a spontaneous feeling in everyone's heart! (Such as festivals and pilgrimages).

It's not just because of a sense of gratitude that should be done!

It's not what emotions want!