Which was stronger, the Song Dynasty or the Han Dynasty?

Of course, the Han Dynasty was more powerful, the Han Dynasty was able to drive the powerful Huns, and also subdued the Western Regions, of course, the Han Dynasty was stronger.

In terms of economy, the Song Dynasty was more developed than the Han Dynasty, but in terms of military affairs, the Song Dynasty was not as powerful as the Han Dynasty.

Of course, the Song Dynasty was stronger, and the time gap of 1,000 years is not a joke, because the level of productivity has been improving.

In terms of military achievements, the Song Dynasty is not comparable to the Han Dynasty, which is very powerful in terms of its military ability to protect the country. The Han Dynasty's record is relative to the Song Dynasty, and the Song Dynasty cannot be compared.

Strength and weakness are relative concepts. The science and technology of the Song Dynasty was learned too much by the nomads, especially the manufacturing, and the equipment had no advantage over the nomads, coupled with the serious shortage of horses, which led to the disadvantage of the nomads.

The steel technology of the Han Dynasty was too far ahead of the world in that era, and the equipment of the Han army was a dimensionality reduction blow to any country of the same era. It took 3 Xiongnu warriors to fight against a Han Dynasty soldier.

The Han Dynasty was a unified dynasty, the Song Dynasty was not, and there is no comparison.

Of course, it is the Song Dynasty, the great unification of the past dynasties is all destroyed in the Great Song Dynasty, my Great Song Dynasty, the world is invincible, but in terms of military achievements, the Song Dynasty cannot be compared, or the Han Dynasty is relatively strong.

Economically, the Song Dynasty was strong. Militarily, the Han Dynasty was strong.

In fact, in Chinese history, the most powerful dynasty in terms of comprehensive strength is not the Song Dynasty, the strength of the Song Dynasty is mainly reflected in the economic strength, but militarily, the Song Dynasty in the history of the various dynasties is not really able to get their hands on, the Song Dynasty in science and technology achievements are more obvious, but the Song Dynasty's land area in the history of the dynasties are relatively backward, in history, the most powerful comprehensive strength of the dynasty personally believes that it should still be the Han Dynasty, the Tang Dynasty and the Yuan Dynasty, Because these dynasties not only far surpassed the Song Dynasty in terms of land area, but also far surpassed the Song Dynasty in terms of science and technology, military aspects, and were not very inferior in terms of economy.

The reason why some people exaggerate the Song Dynasty as the most powerful dynasty in history is mainly because of the economic development of the Song Dynasty, in the history of the dynasties, compared with the first place, but the economic level does not represent the comprehensive strength, and the comprehensive strength includes military strength, economic strength, scientific and technological strength, as well as international influence, etc., in terms of international influence in history, the Han Dynasty, the Tang Dynasty and the Yuan Dynasty obviously have more advantages than the Song Dynasty, Therefore, I personally do not agree with the statement that the Song Dynasty is the most powerful dynasty in history, because this statement lacks more basis and is relatively one-sided.

Comprehensive strength does not count. The Four Great Ages of Ancient China. There was no Song Dynasty at all. The Song Dynasty can only call China's ancient feudal science and technology culture in the most glorious period.

At the end of the Song Dynasty, it was only the economic and cultural development that was more prominent, and in other aspects, such as politics and diplomacy, the Tang Dynasty was the pinnacle, and the Ming Dynasty was the leader of military planning. Each has its own advantages. It would be too one-sided to say that the Song Dynasty was the most powerful dynasty in terms of overall strength.

The Song Dynasty can only be said to be the richest dynasty in history with the highest economic strength in history. But the overall strength is weak.

It's not really easy to say. After all, the Song Dynasty was still relatively economically developed at that time, but the military was basically on the defensive.

No, it should be the Tang Dynasty.

1. The Han Dynasty was divided into two phases, which are called "Former Han" and "Later Han", or "Western Han" and "Eastern Han". The first stage is the former Han Dynasty, from the founding of the Han Gaozu Liu Bang in 207 BC to 25 AD, the beginning and end lasted 232 years, and a total of 12 emperors were transmitted. The second stage lasted 196 years from the Guangwu Emperor Liu Xiu's overthrow of Wang Mang's "new dynasty" in 25 AD to restore the Han Dynasty to 220 AD, and a total of 12 emperors were passed down.

Because Xi'an in the west of the former Han Dynasty and Luoyang in the east of the Later Han Dynasty, the former Han Dynasty is also called the "Western Han Dynasty", and the Later Han Dynasty is also called the "Eastern Han Dynasty".

2. The Song Dynasty, like the Han Dynasty, was divided into two stages, which were called the "Northern Song Dynasty" and the "Southern Song Dynasty" by historians. In the first stage, from the accession of Zhao Kuangyin in 960 A.D. to 1127 A.D., it lasted 168 years from beginning to end, and a total of 9 emperors were handed down. Because the capital of this period was Tokyo in the north (now Kaifeng, Henan), it was known as the "Northern Song Dynasty" in history.

The second stage lasted 153 years from the southern crossing of Song Gaozong in 1127 A.D. to the capture of Yashan by the Yuan army in the first month of 1279 A.D., and a total of 9 emperors were passed down from Fantan. Because of this Tongtian period, the capital was Lin'an (now Hangzhou, Zhejiang) in the south, known as the "Southern Song Dynasty" in history.

If you agree with me, please click the [Satisfied] button in time Friends who ask questions on the mobile phone can comment on [Satisfied] in the upper right corner of the client. Yours is the driving force for me to move forward o(o, help each other, I wish you good health, smooth study and work, and a happy life!

The Song Dynasty was a powerful dynasty, and its political and economic power was world-leading at the time. It's just that because Song Taizu had to take the coup d'état in the army, he used civilian officials to control the generals, resulting in a superficial weakness. Therefore, in the period of strength, the Song Dynasty was a powerful unified dynasty like the Han Dynasty.

Due to the different times and the inability to compare, both dynasties won victories in foreign wars.

A: I think the Han Dynasty will be stronger, because the Song Dynasty has a larger civilian power than the military attachés, so the combat effectiveness of its army is not very good.

Of course, the Song Dynasty was stronger, because the Song Dynasty actually had a strong army in history, but the people who led the army were too poor.

The Song Dynasty was a very important dynasty in Chinese history, surpassing its predecessors in many ways. The economy, culture, science and technology, art, and military of the Song Dynasty were all top-notch, and they were also very brilliant.

1. Economy. The economic development of the Song Dynasty was very rapid, and the GDP of the Song Dynasty has always been among the top in the world, ranking first since the Tang Dynasty. By the time of the Song Dynasty, GDP accounted for one-third of the world's.

During the Southern Song Dynasty, the handicraft industry of the Southern Song Dynasty developed very rapidly, not only in Sichuan and Jiangxi and other regions, there were a large number of porcelain manufacturing enterprises, but also set up the highest administrative body of the national porcelain industry - "Guan Yao".

During the Southern Song Dynasty, the level of agricultural production was greatly improved, especially in the northern region, large-scale reclamation activities were carried out. This has also allowed many northern regions to have large tracts of land where crops such as grain and cotton can be grown. The Jiangnan region and the Yangtze River basin were among the most important agricultural production bases in ancient China (during the Song Dynasty, a large number of immigrants from the south entered the south).

2. Culture. The culture of the Song Dynasty is also one of the best in Chinese history. The Song Dynasty produced many excellent literary works, such as Su Shi's "Red Cliff Fu", "Nian Nujiao: Memorials", Ouyang Xiu's "The Story of the Drunken Man's Pavilion", etc., all of which had a profound impact on later generations.

The Song Dynasty also produced many literary scholars, such as Ouyang Xiu, Su Dongpo, etc., who were very famous writers in history, and they made outstanding contributions to China's literature. The Song dynasty was the first dynasty in the world to use printing to conduct imperial examinations and to succeed, ushering in a whole new era. The Song Dynasty also established a very large library of books, with countless books of all kinds.

3. Science and technology. The achievements of the Song Dynasty in science and technology are also breathtaking. In terms of mathematics, the development of mathematics in ancient China has reached unprecedented heights.

The famous "Three Great Mathematicians of the Song Dynasty" are Zhang Heng, Zu Chongzhi and Su Qin, among which Zhang Heng and Zu Chongzhi pioneered the new calculation method of "pi", and occupies an important position in the history of Chinese mathematics, known as the "king of mathematics".

The Song Dynasty also invented "gunpowder", which became the originator of gunpowder in later generations. The compass invented in the Song Dynasty can already accurately point out the north and south directions; built China's first seagoing ship; The compass was invented one step ahead of the compass; A compass more accurate than a compass was also invented; Invented the water transport instrument elephant platform based on water transportation, and so on.

Fourth, military strength.

During the Northern Song Dynasty, the Song Dynasty army consisted of the forbidden army and the militia. The number of forbidden troops reached 460,000, of which the forbidden army was divided into ten grades: four towns in one capital, six towns in two capitals, eight towns in two capitals, and six towns in three capitals.

The Song army was well-equipped, and the well-equipped Song army could easily defeat the invading army. There are more than 8,000 people in the Song Dynasty, including Yue Fei.

First of all, we should understand the development of agriculture in the Song Dynasty, which greatly developed water conservancy, large-scale land reclamation, and paid attention to the improvement of agricultural tools, and the rapid development of agriculture. The advent of new tools has also led to a significant increase in crop yields. Agriculture in the Yangtze River and Pearl River basins has also developed rapidly.

In China's feudal society, which was based on agriculture, its impact can be imagined. It will greatly promote the development of the feudal small peasant economy, promote the development of the entire national economy, and then promote demographic, political, and military development.

1.Economically, agriculture was secured, food was secured, and the people would choose to enter the cities and towns to seek more, and the Song Dynasty was not to be outdone in other economic fields. In this way, the development of handicraft commerce was promoted, and the commerce of the Song Dynasty was prosperous.

2.Militarily, since the founding of the Song Dynasty, foreign invasions have continued, and the development of agriculture has greatly increased the supply of military rations, which has appropriately eliminated the worries of the army.

3.Culturally, since the Song Dynasty, due to the improvement of productivity, the city has developed greatly, and at the same time, the civic culture has also flourished. During the Northern Song Dynasty, Bianjing was the political and cultural center of the country at that time, and the civic culture was quite developed.

4.In terms of population, the population of the Song Dynasty exceeded 100 million, and the labor force increased significantly.

The above is purely a personal opinion, if there is any error, please point it out in time, thank you! It may not be comprehensive, please forgive me. ）

Military: The Han and Tang dynasties were the world's hegemons at the time, which is equivalent to the current global status of the United States. However, the status of the Song Dynasty at that time plummeted, and it was okay in the Northern Song Dynasty and belonged to the middle reaches, but in the Southern Song Dynasty, it completely fell downstream.

Today's China has almost perished because of the colonial rule of the West and the extreme corruption of the Qing Dynasty. Now that China is in a stage of rejuvenation, it is believed that one day, China will regain its position on the earth.

Economically: The Tang Dynasty was one of the most prosperous periods in Chinese history. It can also be in the early Song Dynasty, but this is also stained with the light of the Tang Dynasty.

The economy of the Wenjing period of the Han Dynasty was also the richest at that time, Emperor Wu in the early stage because of the Northern Expedition to the Xiongnu economy declined slightly, but at that time it was still the first, in the later period of Emperor Wu, Emperor Wu took recuperation with the people, the economy improved, to the period of Emperor Xuan and Emperor Zhao, the economy reached its peak again, known as Xuanzhao Zhongxing, and Guangwu Zhongxing of Emperor Guangwu. China is still a developing country.

To sum up the above, the military aspects of the Han Dynasty and the Tang Dynasty were similar, but the Han Dynasty fought for many years and produced many famous generals, so the military of the Han Dynasty was slightly better than that of the Tang Dynasty. As for the Song Dynasty, it was too bad. The Tang Dynasty was richer than the Han Dynasty when its economy was at its peak, but the Han Dynasty had three peaks, the Tang Dynasty only twice, plus the Han Dynasty existed for 400 years, and the Tang Dynasty only had 200 years, so the Han Dynasty was more powerful.

Tang is the most bullish, during the period of Taizong of the Tang Dynasty, a few called him Tian Khan. And reached the heyday of China.

During the Han Dynasty, the Xiongnu invaded many times, until Wei Biao and Huo Qubing drove them out of the pass.

The Song Dynasty was the least powerful of the five dynasties and ten kingdoms.

Han than Tang Niu b Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty fought the Xiongnu to the capital of the Xiongnu Now Azerbaijan Han no matter whether it is civil strife or extinction, there has been no large-scale invasion of foreign races Because the Han Dynasty has beaten the surrounding opponents down It was not until the Jin alien race recovered on the other hand that the Tang Dynasty was far away An Anshi Rebellion was closed Since then, the Central Plains Dynasty has not been able to stop the iron hooves of the aliens.

- Those who commit crimes against me will be punished even if they are far away.

There is a saying called "Wei and Jin Dynasty Wind and Bone Han and Tang Meteorology". In ancient Chinese history, the Han and Tang dynasties were relatively powerful dynasties. Internal security, external expansion.

The political, economic, military, and cultural of the Tang Dynasty was the most influential at that time, and the Han culture deeply impressed other countries. Baibang came to the dynasty, and it was the best in the world environment at that time.

Han, strong militarily; Tang, politically strong; Song, the economy is strong. Modern, the people are strong.

Compared with the economy of the Song Dynasty, but the military strength was weak and the attitude towards the outside world was weak.

The Han and Tang dynasties had a tough attitude towards the outside world, the Han Dynasty defeated the Xiongnu, and the Tang Dynasty defeated the Turks.

The Han and Tang dynasties were more prosperous than the Han dynasty.

Of the three, compared to the territory, the Tang Dynasty is also the most vast, and in general, I think the Tang Dynasty is the best.

Times change, not the same. The Han Dynasty had a good economy and a good military, and during the Tang Dynasty, China's feudal society reached its first peak, regardless of economy, politics, and culture; During the Song Dynasty, literature continued to develop and the economy was unprecedented, but diplomacy did not seem to work.

It depends on how you look at it.

At the beginning of the Han Dynasty, there was the rule of Wenjing, after the Han Dynasty Emperor Wu connected the Western Regions and the Central Plains into one, the territory was vast, the Tang Dynasty needless to say, although the Song Dynasty's military strength was weak, but her science and technology, culture and economy were prosperous, the three major inventions were formed and the Song Dynasty, from Zhang Zeduan's "Qingming Riverside Map" can be seen that the Song Dynasty economy was still very prosperous.