Do you think Liu Feng should be responsible for Guan Yu s death?

Guan Yu was defeated, not that Liu Feng needed to take responsibility, but that everyone needed Liu Feng to bear this responsibility.

When it comes to politics, it's really cruel. On the strange soil of politics, we have seen more than once the loss of humanity, with fathers and sons turning against each other, brothers fighting, friends betraying, and people falling into the trap.

And Liu Feng, unfortunately, he encountered all of this. <>

Let's talk about Liu Feng today.

Liu Feng, his original surname was Kou, he was originally a native of Jingzhou, and his family was still very powerful in the local area, and he was once named a marquis.

After Liu Bei was defeated by Cao Cao, he was exiled to Jingzhou with the remnants of the defeated army, and was temporarily attached to Liu Biao. During this period, Liu Bei had extensive contacts with the locals and got to know the Kou family.

In the war, Liu Bei's family was separated and had no children under his knees, so he adopted the young man of the Kou family as his righteous son, changed his surname to Liu, and named him Liu Feng.

Liu Bei is a person with great insight and a sense of knowledge. He liked this young man who was very promising, "with martial arts and great strength". In the process of following Liu Bei to fight the country, Liu Feng made a lot of contributions.

But not long after Liu Bei arrived in Jingzhou, he gave birth to another son, Xiao Adou, named Liu Chan, who fought his way out of the siege from Changbanpo in Zhao Yun's arms.

Liu Bei has a son, and Liu Feng's position as a godson is more embarrassing. <>

Liu Bei took Yichuan in the west, Liu Feng went out with the army, and it was recorded in the history books that Liu Feng was "in the battle", these four words fully show that Liu Feng is a fierce general and has high military talent.

After Liu Bei took Yizhou, he continued to expand outward. Meng Da, who had previously surrendered, led his troops to capture Zigui and Fangling, and his troops pointed directly at Shangyong. Meng Da is a very cunning person who fights wars, never works hard, relies on intimidation, deception, deception and assassination, and then winning the mediocrity is not a problem at all.

Liu Bei sent Liu Feng down the river in a boat to take over the troops besieging Shangyong under the command of Meng Da, on the grounds that "Yin is afraid that it will be difficult to do it alone", and he is afraid that Meng Da alone will not be able to handle the task of attacking Shangyong.

1.Spend Liu Feng from his side to pave the way for Liu Chan to inherit the cause;

2.snatched the credit of Meng Da's hand;

3.Seize military power, monitor and watch out for Munda. <>

Liu Bei and Cao Cao fought a fierce battle in the Hanzhong region, eventually seizing Hanzhong, and then ascending to the throne of Hanzhong, and appointing the twelve-year-old Liu Chan as the rightful heir.

And Guan Yu, who stayed in Jingzhou, was named a former general, and he was fake.

But we have to pay attention to a problem, since Liu Bei's expedition to Sichuan and Shu in the west, until the capture of Hanzhong, the soldiers under his command have charged into battle and galloped on the battlefield, and everyone has made great achievements for Shu Han. Zhang Fei broke Zhang He and opened the way for the whole army to seize Hanzhong; Huang Zhongzhen beheaded Xiahou Yuan, captured Dingjun Mountain, and laid the foundation for Shu Han Jiangshan; Zhao Yun robbed and burned Cao's army to hoard grain in Micang Mountain, forcing Cao's army to retreat; Liu Feng and Meng Da seized the mediocrity and forced Shen Tan to surrender; Even Wei Yan "has several military exploits", and was also given the responsibility of guarding Hanzhong by Liu Bei.

Everyone was sealed for merit, but what about Guan Yu? He has the highest status, the heaviest real power, and the most rewards, but he is actually a spectator and has not achieved an inch.

Regarding Guan Yu's death, it actually has nothing to do with Liu Feng, because Guan Yu's army was defeated very quickly, and Liu Feng didn't get the news at all and went to lead the troops to rescue Guan Yu.

Should. Guan Yu had asked Liu Feng for help several times, if Liu Feng could have sent troops to rescue Guan Yu at that time, Guan Yu would not have died.

No, he himself was a suspicious person, and of course he didn't dare to act without being ordered.

Liu Feng did not send troops to save Guan Yu for four reasons:

1. Liu Feng did not have the authority to send troops without authorization.

After Liu Bei established himself as the king of Hanzhong, he gave Guan Yu the power to fake Jieyue and handed over all the affairs of Jingzhou to Guan Yu, but Liu Feng obviously did not have such an honor. Liu Feng is only a deputy general, and in addition, he is Liu Bei's righteous son, and since Liu Chan was born, his position has been quite embarrassing. If he directly sent troops without Liu Bei's consent at this time, it was likely to arouse Liu Bei's suspicion or be slandered by others.

Second, Shangyong has just been annexed not long ago, and it is easy to have accidents.

The Battle of Xiangfan took place in the twenty-fourth year of Jian'an, that is, in 219 AD, when Liu Feng and Meng Ju won Shangyong, which was also the year. Moreover, in order to win people's hearts, Liu Bei let the original Shangyong Taishou Shen Tan and his younger brother Shen Yi take important positions. If Liu Feng easily dispatched Shangyong's soldiers and horses to help Guan Yu, then something would likely happen in Shangyong City.

Therefore, Liu Feng did not dare to act rashly.

3. Liu Feng and Meng Da are at odds, and the two are fighting for power.

Liu Bei sent the guards to Shangyong, not only Liu Feng, but also Meng Da, who laid down Shangyong with Liu Feng. Although these two people are colleagues, they are not convinced by each other. According to records, in order to suppress Meng Da, Liu Feng once seized Meng Da's set of propaganda honor guards, and the contradiction between the two intensified again.

When Guan Yu asked for help, it was impossible for the two of them to go together, and at the critical moment of the struggle for power, whoever helped Guan Yu was equivalent to giving up the control of Shangyong.

Fourth, when Guan Yu asked for help, he was not in danger.

Liu Bei and Guan Yu are like brothers, if he asks for help at a critical moment, Liu Feng and Meng Da probably won't refuse so happily, but when Guan Yu asked them to send troops, it was the side that had the upper hand, if it wasn't for Dongzheng's defeat and Yuan Wu's stabbing in the back, Guan Yu would not end up defeated no matter what, therefore, Liu Feng and Meng Da, Kuna were not in a hurry to send troops.

In "Romance of the Three Kingdoms".

Middle, Liu Feng. The reason why he was reluctant to save Guan Yu.

Mainly because of the following three reasons:1. The success rate of rescuing Guan Yu is too low; 2. Liu Feng can't afford to take the risk; 3, Liu Feng's feelings for Guan Yu are average

First of all, the reason why Guan Yu asked Liu Feng to send troops to help at that time was because Guan Yu had already been beaten to the ground, and Guan Yu and his army at this time could be wiped out at any time, so Liu Feng sent people to the past not to help, but to serve as the main force of this war.

Liu Feng guarded Shangyong at that time.

The city, Shangyong City itself is easy to defend and difficult to attack, and the Shu Han at that time.

did not send too many troops to Liu Feng, so there were not many soldiers in Shangyong City who could send out to rescue Guan Yu, and they could not become the main force in this battle at all.

has also been persuading Liu Feng, so Liu Feng is even more reluctant to rescue.

Secondly, although Liu Feng is not Liu Bei.

's own son, but he still got the errand to guard Shangyong City, in Shangyong City, Liu Feng is the biggest leader, if something happens to Shangyong City, then Liu Feng will bear the brunt of being held accountable. The above has been analyzed, Shangyong City itself is not much troops, if Liu Feng sent troops to rescue Guan Yu at that time, as long as Shangyong City does not have an accident, then even if Guan Yu dies in battle, it doesn't matter, if Shangyong City is broken by someone, Liu Feng will be unlucky.

In the end, Liu Feng himself is not Liu Bei's own son, Guan Yu had told Liu Bei about this before, Guan Yu thought that Liu Feng was not Liu Bei's biological son, so Liu Feng should not be considered when passing on the throne in the future, Liu Feng was very concerned about this, so Liu Feng did not save Guan Yu, and there were also some personal emotional reasons in it, but Liu Feng also paid the price for his actions in the end.

Because he knows that he can't change any outcome if he goes, but will bring him killed, in fact, he is also a shrewd person.

This was because the circumstances at the time did not allow it. The two of them were so far apart that if he went to the rescue, it would be easy for the enemy to take advantage of them.

This is also relatively normal, because the situation at that time was relatively serious, there was no way to save it, and it was too late in time.

Because Liu Feng's troops were limited, coupled with the long distance, and he had a certain amount of selfishness, he did not save Guan Yu.

When Liu Bei was preparing to set up the crown prince, he once asked Zhuge Liang and Guan Yu, who Liu Feng and Liu Chan should appoint, Zhuge Liang's answer was "This is Liu Bei's family matter, he can't ask" and Guan Yu's answer was "Liu Feng is a righteous son, how can he be established as the prince", so later Liu Bei made Liu Chan the prince.

Later, Guan Yu was trapped in Maicheng, Zhou Cang (or Liao Hua) broke through to Liu Feng and Meng Da where Shangyong asked for help, Liu Feng's original intention was to go to the rescue, at that time he said "Guan Yu is his uncle, if he doesn't save it, I'm afraid Liu Bei will blame him".

And Meng Da said, "You treat him as an uncle, he may not treat you as a nephew", and then told Liu Feng about the establishment of the prince at that time.

Later, Liu Feng delayed sending troops. So ......

Later, Liu Bei knew that Liu Feng did not save Guan Yu and wanted to immediately raise troops to ask for the guilt, Zhuge Liang suggested that if they were forced too quickly, they would surrender to Wei, so he later used a trick to trick Liu Feng into Chengdu and immediately executed.

The real reason of history is that it cannot be saved.