Which is better radiator floor heating? Compare advantages and disadvantages, and analyze them in de

1. Traditional radiators.

Traditional heating radiators, cast iron radiators, plate radiators as their typical representatives, in our country has been used for hundreds of years, due to its high energy consumption in the production process, serious environmental pollution, low thermal efficiency, slow heat transfer, rough appearance, bulky, has become a dead end of home decoration, many home decoration, have to "wrap" the cast iron radiator, so that although "covered" the "ugly", but brought a series of problems: one is to occupy space; Second, it is easy to form sanitary dead ends; Third, the durability is poor, and the material of the "packaged" radiator is easy to deform after a long time.

2. New type of radiator.

The new heating radiator is divided into steel radiator, aluminum alloy radiator, copper radiator, copper-aluminum composite radiator, steel-aluminum composite radiator, stainless steel radiator, etc. according to different materials; According to the shape characteristics of the product, it is divided into column radiators (two columns, three columns, four columns), tube radiators (single row of pipes, double row of pipes), fin radiators (double-sided fins, single-sided fins), finned radiators (annular fins, square fins), and radiant radiators and convection radiators according to the heat dissipation mode. The commonly used new heating radiators are steel column radiators, steel pipe radiators, aluminum alloy column airfoil radiators, and copper-aluminum composite column airfoil radiators.

Floor heating and radiators are the rise of independent heating methods in the past two years, the market share of these two heating methods is not much different, but they belong to two different forms of heating. Compared with underfloor heating and radiators, both have certain advantages and disadvantages.

Advantages of underfloor heating:

1. Better comfort: Floor heating is heat from the feet, and traditional Chinese medicine calls the feet the second heart acupuncture point dense concentration area of the human body. As the saying goes, "cold is born from the feet", which can be very effective in treating people with rheumatism.

2. Space saving: There is no radiator or fan coil unit and pipe indoors, which increases the usable area of the building, improves the effective floor height, and makes the interior beautiful and tidy.

3. Relatively low operating costs: of course, this statement has a lot to do with your use time, just like a car on the highway, floor heating belongs to a uniform speed, has been maintained at a speed, and the radiator belongs to a will be 60m, a will be 80m, a will be 10m, the same stroke, must be the most energy-saving.

4. Comfort and hygiene: The ground radiant heating system is one of the most comfortable air conditioning methods, the indoor surface temperature is uniform, the indoor air temperature field is reasonably distributed, the comfort of the human body is high, and the indoor is clean and clean, which is conducive to human health.

5. Good thermal stability: due to the large energy storage and good thermal stability in the ground and floor heating aluminum foil layer, the room temperature can be kept stable even under the condition of intermittent operation.

6. Long operating life: The floor heating pipe that meets the European standard is a material that can be used continuously for more than 50 years.

Disadvantages of underfloor heating:

1. It is necessary to choose the ground material suitable for the ground radiant heating methodThe ground radiant heating system mainly radiates heat to the room through the ground and the ground material, so the ground material will always be continuously heated by a certain temperature during the heating season, so the ground material is suitable for stone or composite floor with good heat dissipation and material properties that are not sensitive to temperature changes, and the solid wood floor is not suitable for the ground radiant heating system at present.

2. Occupy a certain floor height. The insulation materials and coils of the ground radiant heating system are all laid under the ground, so it is necessary to occupy a certain floor height in the room.

Advantages of radiators:

1. Fast heating, a good radiator starts to emit heat in about 10 minutes, and reaches the preset temperature (20 degrees plus or minus 2 degrees) in half an hour.

2. There is no requirement for the ground material, whether it is PP-R copper pipe or PP-R aluminum-plastic pipe or aluminum-plastic composite pipe, it can be used as an insulated conduit without affecting the ground at home.

3. Ready-to-use, no need to wait, saving time.

Disadvantages of radiators:

1. The radiator has a certain volume and will occupy the space at home (the radiator needs to be placed).

2. The temperature of the radiator rises quickly, and the comfort is relatively insufficient.

Whether it is better to install floor heating or radiators needs to be decided according to your own residential environment and usage habits. Floor heating is more suitable for large households, 24 hours in winter need to heat the priority of floor heating, and radiators are more suitable for small and medium-sized households to heat quickly, usually young office workers prefer radiators.

You can get it for free

Floor heating and radiators are a better choice for citizens to heat in winter, and these two different heating methods are different in terms of design, use, function, and quality, so how should we choose?What are the pros and cons of each?

Radiator, the installation of radiators occupies indoor space, affects the overall layout of the room, and will cause uneven heat and cold in the house (very small), easy to dust is not easy to clean, but radiators are easier to install and maintain and low, if there is no forced planning for the indoor layout, and the budget is limited, you can choose radiators, and the difference between floor heating and radiators is not very large.

Underfloor heating is in line with the modern lifestyle - simplicity. It well avoids the shortcomings of the warm bi fiber return gas, no need to clean, ** more expensive than the radiator, but compared to the characteristics of the heating fee, this investment is not a loss. The big disadvantage of floor heating is that in case the pipe is blocked and ruptured, it will seep water down (so be sure to do a good job of waterproofing before installing floor heating), and you may also face the fact that you will remove the floor and redo the floor heating, which will make many owners regret choosing floor heating.

Which is better, floor heating and radiators, these two heating methods have their own advantages and disadvantages, users can understand the advantages and disadvantages of the two heating methods, and then according to their own habits, use environment and budget, weigh the pros and cons to choose a more beneficial heating method.

You can get it for free

Heating effect.

The heat dissipation method of floor heating is mainly radiant heating, and the heat is radiated from the bottom to the top, giving people a very comfortable feeling. However, the underfloor heating rate is slower, especially when it is turned on for the first time, and it takes 5-8 hours for the temperature of the whole room to rise.

Radiator heating is a convection-based heating method, which evenly heats the surrounding air, so that the air in the room forms a convection flow and raises the room temperature. The water temperature of the radiator is very high, and the room temperature can generally rise in about 1 hour, so the user will not be put up with the cold for too long.

<> comfort floor heating although in line with traditional Chinese medicine"The feet are warm and the heads are cold"However, it is easy to cause the introduction of indoor dust, inducing diseases such as upper respiratory tract infections, especially not conducive to the health of the elderly and children.

The radiator heats the room temperature evenly, does not blow strong hot air, gives people a very comfortable and warm feeling, and is more suitable for home use compared to other heating methods.

Construction & Installation.

Floor heating is a concealed project, and the pipe configuration is all buried underground, which does not occupy indoor space and does not affect the placement of furniture. However, underfloor heating will increase the net height of the room, which should be increased by 4-8cm under normal circumstances, which will affect the overall visual effect of the room.

The radiators are mostly surface-mounted, the pipes are laid under the ground, and the radiators are exposed, and they are generally installed under the window or close to the wall. Unlike traditional radiators, the current radiator models are relatively small, which has little impact on the area of the room and will not affect the placement of furniture.

The vast majority of floor heating maintenance is buried in the ground, once there is a problem, it is difficult to find and repair it in time, and it is also very inconvenient to maintain it at ordinary times. Even if there are some minor problems, the entire ground needs to be destroyed, inspected and repaired, and the impact on home life is inevitable.

The radiator is exposed to the outside, there is no heating, water leakage and other problems, it is easy to be found, only the problematic parts need to be repaired, or replaced, will not affect the normal home life.

Through the comparison of floor heating and radiator in terms of construction and installation, heating effect, comfort, maintenance, etc., you can choose the right one for your own use.

1. Comparison of radiator and floor heating comfort.

So many people when they carry out home decoration, they will definitely compare the advantages and disadvantages of radiators and floor heating, so as to choose a more suitable way, then for floor heating its comfort is better, and more space-saving, its operating cost is relatively low, in terms of comfort is also very comfortable, at the same time, its stability performance is also relatively good, its operating life is also relatively long, and the disadvantage of floor heating is that he needs to choose the right ground, The ground material of radiant heating mode mainly transmits heat to the room through the ground and ground materials, so the solid wood floor is not suitable for the ground radiant heating system, and it also needs to occupy a certain floor height.

2. Comparison of advantages and disadvantages of radiators and floor heating.

The advantage of the radiator is that it heats up quickly, generally a good radiator begins to dissipate heat in about 10 minutes, and it does not have any requirements for the ground material, nor does it affect the ground at home, it can also be used immediately, no need to wait, very time-saving, and its disadvantage is that it occupies a certain volume, will occupy some space at home, its radiator temperature rises quickly, but its comfort needs to be improved relatively speaking.

So the above is the comparison of the advantages and disadvantages of radiators and floor heating, so through the explanation of these knowledge, we also have a clearer understanding, and at the same time, we can also choose more suitable products according to some of our actual conditions, so that we can have a more comfortable range of living is particularly important, so only suitable for the geographical location and space of their own family or living products, is more suitable for their own products. Then you also need to decide according to your own residential environment and usage habits, and floor heating is more suitable for large households to use, and radiators, it is more suitable for small and medium-sized households to heat quickly, usually young office workers prefer these radiators.

Floor heating is cost-effective, because daily use of floor heating generally needs to be prepared before the ground is laid, the probability of damage is relatively small, and durable, and the temperature diverges evenly. The room that allowed you to live in had a very nice sense of comfort and warmth.

I think floor heating is more cost-effective, because the heat released by floor heating is higher, there is no need to continue to clean up, and it can provide humans with a more comfortable living experience, and his upfront investment is not particularly huge, and the heat released by the radiator is limited.

It should be more cost-effective compared to radiators, because radiators once cost a few cents, but floor heating once cost about a few dollars.