The United States has not yet won the war against Afghanistan

The United States is a superpower, so its combat goals are very high, so the standard for measuring victory is also high, and the United States is a responsible power, and it cannot defeat a regime and leave (the Taliban regime was eliminated in one month), so the United States' combat goal is to rebuild a democratic and stable Afghanistan, so as to gradually eliminate the environment in which the Taliban breed. Judging from this goal, the United States has not yet won the war.

The United States helps Afghanistan rebuild a democratic and stable country, which is not only in the interests of the Afghans, but also in the interests of the United States (only when the country achieves stability and the people live and work in peace and contentment can Afghanistan become a hotbed of terrorism, this is just like Somalia, Somalia is in turmoil, the people are not living, many civilians go to participate in piracy in order to survive, causing great harm to the international community), the Taliban is a civilian army, and the current remnants of the force are in some closed and isolated mountainous areas in the southeast, There are still many people there who support the Taliban, unless they kill all the people here (this is obviously impossible, in this civilized society, the accidental killing of a few civilians will set off a wave of condemnation in the United States and internationally), so it can only divide the relationship between the Taliban and the civilians, that is, help the civilians, and selectively fight the Taliban (but the Taliban themselves are a civilian army, so it is difficult to effectively identify).

Mainly look at the performance of Afghanistan's new democracy, if Afghanistan can afford to maintain the stability of the country, then the United States has won the war, if Afghanistan is still a "dead dog can't hold up a tree", then the United States can only abandon Afghanistan and withdraw its troops, the most unlucky is the Afghan people (the country will fall into a protracted war, under the rule of extreme religious forces), and then the national society, Afghanistan will become a paradise for terrorism and a place for drug cultivation (the Taliban are extremely backward, Therefore, the vast majority of the economy is dependent on opium cultivation).

This battle can never be finished, Afghanistan is a very special country, the whole country is basically mountainous, not conducive to the combat of mechanized troops, and the people are fierce, the Soviet Union suffered a big loss because of the invasion of Afghanistan, and the United States is now following in the footsteps of the Soviet Union.

The U.S. military's war on terror in Afghanistan is a war that will never be won. Terrorism cannot be eliminated by war, and the US military's war against Afghanistan can only intensify Muslims' hatred of the United States and can only intensify terrorist activities.

Question: The United States has not won the war against Afghanistan?

Answer: It seems that the war was won within a month.

According to people familiar with the matter, the US military was able to win some key battles in the Afghan War, and "Viagra" contributed a lot. To pave the way for U.S. forces, they say, the CIA** provides a diverse range of 'personal services' to leaders of local armed and tribal forces in Afghanistan."

Q: Why is it not a win now?

A: McChrystal, the top commander of the U.S. forces in Afghanistan, admitted that the U.S. military underestimated the Taliban's armed strength and did not have the trust of the Afghan people to guarantee victory in the Afghan war.

Q: Could it be that there are also guerrillas in Afghanistan?

A: In the late 70s and early 80s of the last century, the United States **invested a lot of money and money to finance the Afghan guerrillas.

Q: How long is this going to be?

A: Ask Obama for a few questions.

It will never be able to win, if you think that the United States is only fighting the Taliban, then you are very wrong, stationing troops in Afghanistan can bring the United States a huge military advantage, deterring Russia, China and other neighboring countries, just by virtue of this, as long as the United States needs to strategically, it will always deal with the Taliban, even without him, it will have to create another one.

When the United States announced to the world that it had won the war on terror, it certainly did not expect how the war in Afghanistan would end now. According to the U.S. scenario, a month ago, it gradually withdrew from Afghanistan and then handed over Afghanistan to Afghanistan, which it had supported for 20 years, and the United States continued to enjoy its benefits in Afghanistan. For this, the United States will win the cheers of the world, because the United States has brought peace, Afghanistan has been peaceful, and the United States has won.

But now the anti-** war in Afghanistan has ended, but it ended with the complete defeat of the United States.

20 years ago, how quickly the United States fought the Taliban, then now the United States has failed in Afghanistan as quickly as possible. Even the United States did not expect that a month ago, the United States controlled most of the cities and provincial capitals in Afghanistan, firmly controlling American interests in Afghanistan. But in less than a month, the tide turned.

The Taliban poured out from all directions, taking up most of the provincial capitals in two weeks, leaving the world stunned. In the vast majority of cities, the ** army, which is pinned on by the United States, is basically a routine, that is, they disperse in a hurry. Basically, the Taliban are very confused, but the defeat is like a mountain, which is the fate of the Afghan ** army and the fate of the United States.

In the past month, the United States has repeated many failures, whether it was the retreat of the peninsula in the 50s, or the Saigon moment in the 70s, and now, it is the Kabul retreat. From one incident, we can see how panicked the United States is, because it wants to evacuate in a hurry, and the United States actually shoots at the poor, which is enough to know the embarrassment of the United States. Moreover, the United States said that it would increase its troops, but in fact, it was also thunderous and rainy, and it did not dare to go at all.

In fact, so far, it is not the United States that has declared the end of the war in Afghanistan, but the Taliban, because only the victor is qualified to declare the end of the war, and the United States is a complete loser. Only now did the West begin to realize that it had been deceived by the United States. The powerful intelligence system of the United States should have known for a long time that the situation in Afghanistan is irreversible, and even if the United States increases its troops, it will not be a good thing.

The former Soviet Union did not win, the United States did not win, and Afghanistan did not win. There are no clear winners in the two wars in Afghanistan. If you insist on determining a winner, there is a high probability that China will win.

There are no winners, and the innocent people of Afghanistan who suffer the most. Xing, the people are bitter. Death, the people suffer. In a war-torn country, the common people are really like ants.

Today's Afghan Taliban armed forces can be equipped with American-style equipment, because the United States has invested more than $80 billion in Afghanistan to fully arm the Afghan security forces supported by the United States. The U.S. began its war in Afghanistan in 2001, and now it appears that in addition to the Taliban's victory, U.S. arms dealers have also emerged as winners.

There is no war to win or lose, only the people are hurt, and only with the support of the people will you win the war.

There is no winner in the war in Afghanistan. It doesn't matter if it's the Taliban or Afghanistan, ** or the United States. They all lost the war in a mess. Just look at the chaos in Afghanistan. None of them won.

No one wins, they are all losers, fighting back and forth, so many people have died, the country is in turmoil, people are panicking, how can there be a winner.

Of course, it was the Taliban who won, and they stormed the capital, Kabul, to regain power.

Are you talking about that war in Afghanistan? If it was the Soviet Union, it was Afghanistan that won with the help of Western countries. If it was the U.S. military's invasion of Afghanistan, no one would have won.

The unfortunate ones are the Afghan people. The incompetence of the Afghan government, the unpopularity, and the inability to control the situation, Afghanistan is rich in drugs, and with the support of drugs, products, terrorism, organizations, and funds, Ta Li Ban has made a comeback in many places, except for the capital Kabul, which is barely maintained.

In the end, the Taliban won.

The Taliban won and US imperialism lost.

Judging from the specific battlefield situation, of course, the United States won, and there is no doubt that with the United States' science and technology and superpower, it will face a country like Afghanistan. There is no doubt that it is crushing.

Strategically, the Taliban won. The United States did not achieve its goal of eliminating the Taliban, they survived, and the next step is obviously to unify Afghanistan and establish an Islamic state, so it won.

There are no winners in the war in Afghanistan, but it has caused a huge disaster for the Afghan people, and the United States is to blame for this disaster.

Judging from the battlefield situation, it seems that the United States has won, but it is certainly not the United States that has the last laugh. More than 10 years of war have brought heavy disasters to the Afghan people, and the United States has suffered a lot of losses, such as dead soldiers and huge investments, which have made the United States cry bitterly, and now it has announced the withdrawal of its troops, resulting in another civil war in Afghanistan.

If no one wins, that's a war of attrition, and no one can take advantage of it.

The United States killed three birds with one stone in Afghanistan :

1. Transform domestic contradictions.

On September 11, 2001, the World Trade Center in the United States suffered a "terrorist attack" (the "terrorist attack" of the American Xuancheng may have been directed and acted by itself), killing and injuring thousands of people.

In order to divert the people's attention from **, the United States began to look for scapegoats.

2. Enter Russia's traditional sphere of influence.

During the Cold War, Afghanistan was occupied by the former Soviet Union for 10 years.

Since World War II, British power has withdrawn from Central Asia, and the former Soviet Union has quickly filled the void.

After the end of the Cold War, Russia still has unrivaled influence in Central Asia (Afghanistan and the five Central Asian countries), and in order to expel Russia's power and further compress Russia's strategic living space, the United States decided to fight in Afghanistan and Afghanistan.

3. Complete the strategic encirclement of China.

After World War II, the United States established a strategic encirclement (first island chain) against the former Soviet Union and China along the lines of Alaska, the Kuril Islands, Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, and the Philippines.

However, in the western part of China, the United States has not been able to complete the strategic encirclement of China.

The US military stationed in Afghanistan will not be able to fill this shortcoming.