Did the Xia Dynasty ever exist? Did the Xia Dynasty exist?

Updated on history 2024-07-12
13 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-12

    The issue of controversy, as far as the evidence is objectively concerned, tends to be "cannot prove the existence of", which is just a legend.

    Moreover, Sima Qian himself said that there was not enough evidence to prove the existence of such a dynasty, so Sima Qian also tended to "discard" hearsay-style records;

    2. It has been scientifically proved that in the stage of the "Ninth Five-Year Plan" in China, there was a "dynastic project" in an attempt to prove the existence of the Xia Dynasty.

    But in three international public debates, Chinese experts were questioned on the spot by international scholars, and Chinese experts were dumbfounded on the spot.

    So, even if it really exists, there is no way to prove it at the moment.

    Just a legend.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-11

    Although there are no unearthed artifacts to confirm it, judging from the legends and historical books (mainly historical records), the current research view is that most historians still believe in the historical existence of the Xia Dynasty.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-10

    The Xia Dynasty existed, but it was only a tribe.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-09

    The Xia Dynasty existed about the 22nd century BC - the 17th century BC, the Xia Dynasty (about 2146 BC - 1675 BC), which began with Xia Yu and ended with Ji, a total of 17 emperors. In the summer, private ownership began to appear, and the Zen system of clan society came to an end and was replaced by a hereditary system. Society evolved from a primitive society to a slave society.

    Xia Chaoji's surname. In the last years of the Xia Dynasty, the internal politics of the Xia Dynasty were not repaired, external troubles continued, and class contradictions became increasingly acute. Shang Tang saw that the time was ripe for the slaughter, so he called on the Mandate of Heaven and asked everyone to attack vigorously to carry out the will of God. In the Battle of Narujo, Shang Tang's army defeated Xia Wei's army, and Ji fled and died in Nanchao, and the Xia Dynasty perished.

    Shang Dynasty - c. early 17th century BC - 11th BC

    The Xia Dynasty "Ji" is the last emperor, so there is no way to have Xia Ji, and the Xia Dynasty of the Yin Shang Dynasty has a history of nearly 500 years.

    The background of the "Fengshen Bang" we have seen is taken from the Shang Dynasty, and the previous dynasty was the Xia Dynasty.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    Xia Dynasty The Xia Dynasty, the first hereditary dynasty recorded in Chinese history books. The Xia Dynasty is generally considered to be a state in the form of a tribal alliance, while Chinese Marxist historiography characterizes the Xia Dynasty as a slave state.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    No evidence of the existence of the Xia Dynasty can be found in Chinese archaeological documents.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    In fact, what did not exist in the first place was the recently discovered capital of the Xia Dynasty, which confirmed the existence of the Xia Dynasty

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    It exists in Chinese textbooks, but it does not exist in foreign textbooks.

  9. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    There exist, there have been archaeological excavations of the city site of the Xia Dynasty and some cultural relics.

  10. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    existed. The continuation of history is gradually evolved, the bronze casting technology of the Shang Dynasty has been very developed, it is impossible to appear out of thin air, and the Xia Dynasty laid the foundation for the development of the Shang Dynasty.

  11. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    I think it must have existed, because there are historical artifacts from the time to prove it.

  12. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    I am from Kaifeng, and I will talk about Xia Qi and Kaifeng. The Four Famous Towns....Zhuxian Town (Yue Fei defeated the Jin army garrison), 45 miles south of Kaifeng City, called in the Spring and Autumn Period....Kaifeng, meaning: the place where Qi was sealed by Yu.

    In that era, Kaifeng was originally known as the beam, and after the Han Dynasty, the beam was changed....Kaifeng name, Kaifeng changed....Zhu Xianzhen. This is also evidence that Xia Qi has his own person. At that time, the Xia Kingdom had already existed, and Kun and Yu were both Xia kings, but they were not the Kingdom of the Son of Heaven.

    At that time, except for the Son of Heaven, there were thousands of large and small countries. A small county can be a small country. Tang Yao....Tang is Yao's small country, Yu Shun...Yu is the small country where Shun is located.

    At that time, the name of the Son of Heaven should be...Hua, founded by the Yellow Emperor. The original capital of the country was ....It's a place where people are worried. Today, Kaifeng Qi County, Henan Province, has not changed its name for thousands of years.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    There have been, and it is impossible for things recorded in history textbooks to be made up randomly, and some historical materials have also recorded them.

Related questions
7 answers2024-07-12

Don't doubt it. The history of the Xia Dynasty was recorded at that time. There are many tribes or states in Xia, such as Dog Xia, Yuexia, Xiong Xia, and so on. >>>More

6 answers2024-07-12

Whether the Xia Dynasty has always influenced the beginning of Chinese civilization (the symbol of civilization is the production of writing), surely people believe that the Xia Dynasty has been circulating in ancient China, and it has also "examined" the emperors of the dynasty. >>>More

11 answers2024-07-12

It is not known whether the Xia Dynasty really existed in the history of our country, and the debate in the academic circles is divided into two factions, one does not exist, and the other exists, and whether it exists depends on whether the cultural relics of the Xia Dynasty can be found.

15 answers2024-07-12

There is no clear evidence that the Xia Dynasty actually existed. >>>More

15 answers2024-07-12

This is because the Great Xia Dynasty was a regime established by the Red Turban Army at that time, and from the perspective of the nature of the country, the Great Xia Dynasty could not be regarded as a dynasty怂I believe that many people have memorized the songs of Chinese historical dynasties, and they are very familiar with the Yuan, Ming and Qing dynasties, but in the real history of our country, there is a history of the Great Xia Dynasty between the Yuan Dynasty and the Ming Dynasty. It is worth noting that the Great Xia Dynasty was not the historical Western Xia, but a new regime established by Ming Yuzhen. >>>More