Pang Tong offered a plan for Liu Bei, Liu Bei chose Article 2, why did he indirectly kill him?

When Pang Tong conquered Shu for Liu Bei, he gave Liu Bei three strategies. The first article of this plan is the best, but Liu Bei's second article is the middle, and the third article is the worst, but after Liu Bei read the plan he gave, he thinks that the second plan is relatively implementable. Therefore, the second was chosen, but when the second article was implemented, Liu Bei lost on the way and was surrounded by the enemy, and Pang Tong was also killed by the enemy when he led the army to attack the city.

Pang Tong was a very talented man in military strategy. He and Zhuge Liang are known as Wolong and Phoenix Chick。But because he was ugly, he was also more upset in his early years.

He first took refuge in Soochow, but because of his looks, he was not reused by Soochow, and finally Lu Su of Soochow introduced him to Liu Bei. Liu Bei appreciated his talent after talking to him, and did not pay too much attention to his appearance, so he implemented heavy use of him.

He can be regarded as showing his strength in Liu Bei, when Liu Bei fought in Shu. Pang Tong followed Liu Bei on the expedition. On the way, Pang Tong gave Liu Bei three suggestions, and the first of these three suggestions was to let Liu Bei prepare to attack Chengdu, and after winning it in one fell swoop, he could solve a lot of problems.

The second sentence is to plan the plan, deliberately saying that he wants to return to Jingzhou, and then catch them all。After Liu Bei heard this, he preferred the approach of the second article, so he implemented the second plan.

At the beginning, the attacks were very successful, so Liu Bei was also very happy, but Pang Tong was also relatively unhappy because Liu Bei did not choose the first one, but in the end, the two still reached a consensus. Then, in the process of continuous conquest, Liu Bei was finally defeated and surrounded by the enemy. And Pang Tong's words were also killed by the enemy when he led the army to attack the city, and he was only 36 years old at that time.

Liu Bei chose to directly lead the army back to Jingzhou and give up the attack target. This strategy caused Liu Zhang to have enough time to guard against Liu Bei, so he almost killed him.

Because Pang Tong was shot to death by Zhang Ren, who had already been ambushed. And Liu Bei couldn't help but regret when he learned the news, if he had listened to Pang Tong's "best policy" and attacked Chengdu directly, Pang Tong would not have died in Luofengpo.

Liu Bei's benevolence and righteousness made him unbearable to break the relationship between his own brothers, and forcibly occupied Xichuan, but he didn't expect others to rebel and kill his own military advisor.

Pang Tong died on the way to the west, because Liu Bei had not been able to make up his mind to go west, Pang Tong could only die to give Liu Bei a reason to go west, if it weren't for Liu Bei's hesitation, it would not have caused Pang Tong to make this decision, so Liu Bei indirectly killed Pang Tong.

Liu Zhang invited Liu Bei to Shu and sent him to lead troops to attack Zhang Lu in Hanzhong. The strategist Pang Tong offered a plan to Liu Bei and said: "You don't want to attack Zhang Lu, but secretly select elite soldiers, advance day and night, and attack Liu Zhang in Chengdu; Liu Zhang was cowardly and unguarded, and when a large army suddenly arrived, he was able to capture Chengdu in one fell swoop.

Yang Huai and Gao Pei are famous generals under Liu Zhang, each with strong troops and defending in danger. I heard that they wrote to Liu Zhang several times and advised Liu Zhang to let you go back to Jingzhou. You can send someone to tell them that Jingzhou is in an emergency, and that they want to return to Jingzhou to rescue them, and that they will return to Jingzhou as a filial piety.

These two people must be happy about your departure, and they will probably come to see you off. At that time, you can take the opportunity to catch them, seize their forces, and kill Chengdu, this is the middle plan. If you return to Jingzhou and then march to take Xishu, it is the worst plan.

Time is pressing, and you can't hesitate anymore, so please choose one of the three strategies as soon as possible. Liu Bei agreed to Pang Tong's plan, earned and killed Yang Huai and Gao Pei, and his troops killed Chengdu, and they were able to occupy Xishu.

This is the scoring situation if Pound is following Ma Chao.

Together in 215, they took refuge in Liu Bei.

Liu Bei would have reused Pound, if Pound had surrendered during Guan Yu's Northern Expedition to Xiangfan in 219 AD, Liu Bei would not have had a chance to reuse Pound.

1. If Pang De followed Ma Chao to join Liu Bei Pang De was Ma Chao's general, and when Ma Chao surrendered to Liu Bei, he took Ma Dai with him.

and Pang De's cousin Pang Rou surrendered to Liu Bei, but Pang De stayed in Hanzhong, and Pang De later defected to Cao Cao.

Target. If Pang De followed Ma Chao to join Liu Bei at this time, Liu Bei would reuse Pang De for three main reasons:

1. Pound is different from Ma Chao.

Ma Chao was a prince, and he was a merciless person, killing his father, his own brother and the entire family of more than 100 people, although Ma Chao took refuge in Liu Bei, but Liu Bei did not reuse Ma Chao, although Ma Chao was given a very high false position, but there was no real power, this is Ma Chao's status is determined, Liu Bei is always on guard against Ma Chao will take the opportunity to grow on his own, this is when Liu Bei took refuge in Liu Biao, Liu Biao guarded Liu Bei everywhere.

It's just that the roles have been reversed, Liu Bei empathizes with this feeling, and Pang De is different, Pang De is just a subordinate under Ma Chao, in today's words, he is a worker, unlike Ma Chao is the boss, Liu Bei will reuse Pang De.

2. Pound is brave.

Judging from the later history, Pang De is indeed a fierce general, Liu Bei is still good at employing people, as long as it is a talent, he will reuse it. Pang De once killed Yuan Shang's subordinate general Guo Yuan on the battlefield with his own hands, and this person was still Zhong Xuan.

's nephew, this is Pound's performance of combat bravery, such a fierce general, of course Liu Bei will reuse it.

3. Pound loyalty

Pang De is a loyal and righteous person, from the later in the battle of Xiangfan, he would rather die than surrender to Guan Yu can see Pang De's loyalty, such a person, any lord will like it, including Liu Bei, so Liu Bei will reuse Pang De.

2. If Pound surrendered to Guan Yu in the Battle of XiangfanIf Pound surrendered to Guan Yu in the Battle of Guan Yu's Northern Expedition to Xiangfan, then Pound's fate is likely to be the same as Yu Ban. After Yu Ban surrendered to Guan Yu, he was escorted by Guan Yu to Jiangling City and imprisoned, Sun Quan.

The sneak attack on Jingzhou led to Guan Yu's defeat on the Xiangfan front, and later Lü Meng.

Captured the city of Gangneung, captured Yu Ban, and Yu Ban was sent to Sun Quan.

Sun Quan in order to win over Cao Pi.

Later, Yu Ban was returned to Cao Wei.

After Yu Ban returned to Cao Wei, Cao Pi comforted him on the surface, but behind his back, he let Cao Cao's mausoleum be worshipped, and painted the plot of Yu Ban's surrender on the wall, which made Yu Ban ashamed, and finally Yu Ban died of depression.

If Pang De surrenders to Guan Yu, Yu Ban will be an example, and he will eventually be given to Cao Pi by Sun Quan like Yu Ban, while Liu Bei will not see Pang De at all, so why come back? Nor is it likely to be reused.

Yes, because Liu Bei is a person who cherishes talents very much, and Pang De's martial arts are very high. He will definitely be reused by Liu Bei.

Of course, because Pang Tong's ability is very strong, if he surrenders at that time, Liu Bei's words will definitely be reused.

Personally, I don't think you can get it, just refer to Ma Chao specifically, after Ma Chao surrendered to Liu Bei, he basically had no real power.

I think it's okay, because he is a talented person, and Liu Bei is a talented person.

Then there really are five tiger generals! Don't use one to make up the number, the military level is not enough!

Rhetorical question: Has Ma Chao, who surrendered to Liu Bei, been reused?

1. Send elite troops to directly copy the path day and night to get Chengdu 2, take Gao Pei Yang Huai, and gradually advance into Chengdu step by step.

3. Return to Jingzhou and take Chengdu later.

Liu Bei adopted Gao Pei Yang Huai, and gradually advanced into Chengdu step by step Original text: Xuande said: "So, what if?" Pang Tong said: "There are three strategies, please choose your own way." ”

Xuande asked, "What are the three plans?" "Tong said:

Only today will select elite soldiers, day and night and attack Chengdu: this is the best plan. Yang Huai and Gao Pei are famous generals in Shu, and they resist guarding the pass with strong soldiers; Now the lord pretends to return to Jingzhou in the name of the second general, and he will come to see each other off; On the send-off place, capture and kill, seize the pass, first take Fucheng, and then to Chengdu:

This is also a plan. Returned to the White Emperor, returned to Jingzhou overnight, and Xu Tu enterprising: this is the next plan.

If you can't go down, you will be in great distress and cannot be saved. Xuande said: "The military adviser's plan is too hasty, and the next plan is too slow; It can be done without delay.

Upper, middle and lower three counts.

The best policy: send elite troops, directly copy the path day and night to get Chengdu middle strategy: take Gao Pei Yang Huai, step by step to enter Chengdu.

The next policy: return to Jingzhou, and then take Chengdu later.

It's a plan from the top, middle and bottom, and neither romance nor official history is a strategy.

Liu Bei took a middle strategy.

Pang Tong offered Liu Bei three secret plans on strategic issues:

Selecting elite soldiers, day and night, and directly attacking Chengdu, can be decided in one fell swoop, this is the plan.

Yang Huai and Gao Pei are famous generals in Shu, with elite troops under them, and according to the guards, we can pretend to return to Jingzhou and lead them to meet them with light horses, so that they can be captured and killed, and then march into Chengdu, which is a medium plan.

Return to the White Emperor, lead Jingzhou, and slowly enter Tuyizhou, this is the next plan.

Liu Bei adopted the plan.

There are three strategies, and Liu Bei adopted the middle policy.