How to understand Guan Yu s loyalty? How to evaluate Guan Yu?

Guan yu. Is it really loyal? A romance infinitely exaggerates Guan Yu and Zhuge Liang.

Let future generations really think that these two people are like gods, but what about the facts? Guan Yu voluntarily surrendered twice in his life, once Cao Cao.

did not persuade Zhang Liao to surrender, but surrendered on his own initiative, and there is no record in the history books that Guan Yu protected his two sisters-in-law, Liu Bei.

In Xiaopei, Guan Yu guards Xiapi, not to mention ancient times, even now, how many men are in Xiaopei by themselves, throwing their wives in Xiapi?

After Guan Yu surrendered to Cao Cao, Cao Cao borrowed Liu Xie in order to win over Guan Yu.

Hand, Feng Guan Yu is the Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion.

And everyone in the world knows that this reward has nothing to do with Liu Xie, it was Cao Cao's own reward, but it was just borrowed from Liu Xie's hand, and Guan Yu was very excited, and specially made a banner that said Hanshou Pavilion Hou Guan, until his death, he was already the Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion. As for Guan Yu leaving Cao Cao, who knows whether it was for a woman to return Liu Bei? Because before Guan Er left Cao Cao, something happened to happen, and after this incident, Guan Er left Cao Cao, Guan Er took a fancy to Qin Yilu's wife and asked Cao Cao for it, which roughly means that as long as Qin Yilu's wife is given to him, he will be loyal to Cao Cao.

As a result, after Cao Cao saw Qin Yilu's wife, he directly became his own woman. Guan Er was furious and left Cao Cao directly, Cao Cao may be ashamed of Guan Yu, and ordered to be released all the way, so that Guan Yu passed the five levels. Anyone with a little brain will know that after five levels and six generals, this must be nonsense, one person fights one city, and breaks six cities in a row, why didn't Liu Bei unify the world?

The second voluntary surrender was the defeat of Maicheng, and in order to survive, Guan Er took the initiative to surrender to Sun Quan.

In the end, Sun Quan didn't bother Guan Er, so Guan Er died in the end.

Look at the official history, Hua Xiongwen Chou was not killed by Guan Er, it was Lu Su who went to the meeting with a single knife, scraping the bones and healing the wounds unless Hua Tuo crawled out of the coffin, Hua Rong Dao Liu Bei's, the annotation in the history of the flooded Seventh Army is a natural disaster, and a few people know the Three Kingdoms Liao Li, and the biography of Liao Li of the Three Kingdoms records Liao Li's evaluation of Guan Yu, (Liao Li is deeply trusted by Liu Bei, but this person has a very hard temper, which makes people afraid) Guan Yu is arrogant, arrogant, and has no talent for commanding troops.

Guan Yu's loyalty is only loyalty to Liu Bei, because he knows that Liu Bei no longer wants to restore the Han family, but wants to establish his own regime, but he is still loyal to Liu Bei, so I think his loyalty is mainly based on friendship with Liu Bei.

Personally, I think Guan Yu's kind of loyalty is chivalrous and courageous, and it also represents that he is very upright, and his three views are particularly positive, and this kind of loyalty is also worth learning from.

Guan Yu's loyalty is great loyalty, the kind of righteous and chivalrous loyalty, he is unwilling to betray his sworn brother, and he is loyal to Liu Bei.

I think Guan Yu is a person with special military talents, and his martial arts are particularly high, he is very good at leading soldiers to fight, and he is particularly righteous, and he is particularly good at the soldiers under his hands, some people with relatively humble status, and they are especially respected. But the biggest drawback is that it is too self-righteous and too arrogant.

I think Guan Yu is still very righteous, and his force value is very high.

Guan Yu is loyal, filial piety, benevolence and righteousness, and is respected as a martial saint by later generations and admired by tens of thousands of people. But he has shortcomings, such as conceit, and does not see the big picture.

What you are talking about is deduction, Guan Yu only beheaded Yan Liang in the official history.