Guan Yu s Qinglong Yanyue Knife and Zhang Fei s Zhangba Snake Spear , do they both exist?

In advance of the Three Kingdoms, people can always recall a few heroes of the Three Kingdoms. It can be seen that the story of the Three Kingdoms is still very exciting. During the Three Kingdoms period, there were countless heroes and heroes in the troubled times.

Compared with other historical stories, the story of Taoyuan Three Knots is very exciting, and the Taoyuan Three Knots are the story of Liu Bei, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei becoming brothers. Liu Bei was the leader of the Shu Han regime and an overlord in the Three Kingdoms, while Guan Yu and Zhang Fei were the generals under Liu Bei, and the two of them were also the generals of the Five Tigers.

Guan Yu and Zhang Fei are both well-known figures in the Three Kingdoms. Guan Yu's body is burly, his strength is outstanding, he is holding a Qinglong Yanyue knife, the combination of human and knife is very suitable to describe Guan Yu, countless people have died under his knife, so Guan Yu was also one of the characters that people were very afraid of at that time. And Zhang Fei is also a loyal and courageous, jealous and hateful person, although he has a rough temperament, but he is still loyal to others, his ** is the Zhangba snake spear, he has such a magic weapon, his combat effectiveness is also very strong.

In fact, Guan Yu's Qinglong Yanyue Knife and Zhang Fei's Zhangba Snake Spear are both fictional. Most of the stories of the Three Kingdoms that we know are obtained from ** and TV series, and most of the TV series are adapted from **. The author of ** has actually adapted a part of the real history.

The Qinglong Yanyue Knife and the Zhangba Snake Spear, these two kinds of weapons were actually only available in the Jin Dynasty and the Ming and Qing Dynasties. These two weapons can be said to have come through time, so they are not entirely credible. ** In order to portray the tall image of the character, the author fictionalized these two weapons.

It is this kind of portrayal that characters like Guan Yu and Zhang Fei can be known to us. In this way, the purpose of the ** family has been achieved, so some elements of fiction are still helpful for us to understand history.

What does not exist, the technology of casting dragons on the knife was only available in the Song Dynasty, and the snake spear was also created in the Tang and Song dynasties.

Just look at the martial arts.

These two **s do not exist, and Guan Yu actually doesn't use a knife. Zhang Fei only used an ordinary spear, not a spear in the shape of a snake. Therefore, future generations will not be able to find such treasures.

From the perspective of historical authenticity, it should not exist, but Guan Yu and Zhang Fei are too true among the people, and everyone thinks they exist.

exists, because it is recorded in the ancient military books that there is indeed such a **, and their users are Guan Yu and Zhang Fei, so it is said that they exist.

Everyone has seen the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, and the ** used by Guan Yu in it is the Qinglong Yanyue Knife. At that time, after Liu Guan and Zhang Taoyuan were three uprisings, Guan Yu carried the Qinglong Yanyue Knife and followed his brother to fight in the south and the north, and left a lot of heroic deeds, such as passing five passes and killing six generals, Wen Jiu cutting Huaxiong, etc., and also achieved the chivalrous heroes in everyone's minds.

From the birth of the Qinglong Glaive Knife, it originated in the Tang and Song dynasties, mainly used for soldiers to practice arm strength, so Guan Yu in the late Eastern Han Dynasty was definitely not used the Qinglong Glaive Knife, and at that time the forging and craftsmanship level in the late Eastern Han Dynasty could not make this kind of long-handled broadsword.

There are not many descriptions of Guan Yu ** in the historical records, let's take a look at the relevant descriptions in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, the first chapter wrote that Guan Yunchang's Qinglong Yanyue knife weighed 82 catties, according to the weights and measures of the late Eastern Han Dynasty, one catty is about 222 grams, so the Qinglong Yanyue knife weighs 18263 grams, which is converted to the current unit of about 98 catties.

Just imagine what it would be like to carry such a heavy object and kill enemies on the battlefield with such a heavy experience. Even if he doesn't fight with such a heavy weapon, I don't know how long he can hold out, even if Guan Yu is tall and can bear it, but have you considered the feelings of the horse?

From another point of view, the Fang Tian painting halberd in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is all fictional. Many ** in the Three Kingdoms period used a wooden pole or bamboo pole to tie a sharp iron piece in front.

So to sum up, Guan Yu in history did not use the Qinglong Yanyue Knife, but the author and the circulation of folk tales gave him such a ** in order to highlight Guan Yu's tall and mighty.

When we watched "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", we saw Guan Yu, who was a hero holding a green dragon glaive knife, slashing Huaxiong with warm wine, and punishing Wen Chou. For Guan Yu, we will naturally have in our minds the picture of Guan Yu riding a red rabbit horse and carrying the Qinglong Yanyue Knife, fighting on the battlefield. However, in the real history, Guan Yu killed Yan Liang with a spear, not the Qinglong Glaive, and it can even be said that the real Guan Yu in history did not hold the weapon of the Qinglong Glaive.

The Romance of the Three Kingdoms was originally a lot of fiction, and after research, from the Eastern Han Dynasty to the Three Kingdoms period, there was no such weapon as the Qinglong Yanyue Knife at all, so this is most likely the author's fiction in order to highlight Guan Yu's power.

No, the Blue Dragon Glaive was only available during the Tang and Song dynasties, and it was only used for training and guards.

Guan Yu used the Qinglong Moon Occultation Knife, and the only long ** used immediately during the Three Kingdoms period was spears and halberds, and the long-handled knife appeared later**. Even during the Three Kingdoms, when the generals rode horses, there was no horse pedal, and there was no way to fight three hundred rounds without moving if they were clamped completely by leg strength.

The author of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is Luo Guanzhong in the late Yuan Dynasty and early Ming Dynasty, and the Qinglong Yanyue Knife about is likely to be made up by the author according to his own environment at the time.

The Qinglong Yanyue Knife is the Daguan Knife, which was only available in the Ming Dynasty, and there is no One in the Three Kingdoms In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Zhang Fei used the Zhangba snake spear, and Guan Yu used the Qinglong Moon Covering Knife.

It is definitely impossible for Guan Yu in real history to use such a heavy Qinglong Yanyue Knife, it is just a fiction, and people exaggerate the facts in order to reflect Guan Yu's strength.

The Romance of the Three Kingdoms is fictionalized, and some of the plots and character settings are made up. There is no historical basis for research. Therefore, the ** history books used by Guan Yu are not recorded. It should be fictionalized for the sake of character setting.

The Romance of the Three Kingdoms is indeed recorded like this, but this should be just an exaggeration, and the Qinglong Glaive Knife should just be fictionalized in order to match Guan Yu's identity.

The Qinglong Glaive Knife, also known as the "Leng Yan Saw", is Guan Yu's in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms". The Green Dragon Glaive is one of the types of Glaive Blades. According to the literature and unearthed cultural relics, the glaive knife began to appear in the Song Dynasty, due to the weight relationship, it was mainly used to practice arm strength, not the first in the war.

In China's ** "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", the Qinglong Yanyue knife is a weapon used by Guan Yu, and the book describes that the Qinglong Yanyue knife weighs 82 catties (about equivalent to modern kilograms), also known as Leng Yan saw. Guan Yu used it to kill many generals, so later generations also called the Qinglong Yanyue Knife Guan Dao. After Guan Yu was killed, the Qinglong Glaive was taken away by the Eastern Wu general Pan Zhang, and later, Guan Yu's son Guan Xing killed Pan Zhang to avenge his father and recapture the Qinglong Glaive.

Therefore, Guan Yu and the Green Dragon Glaive are seen as symbols of each other.

In history, Guan Yu used a big knife, not like the Qinglong Yanyue Knife in the Romance, and the Qinglong Yanyue Knife could not be done in reality, especially in the Eastern Han Dynasty at that time, there was no such powerful technology at all.

Guan Yu must be long**, after all, there is an element of artistic rendering in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. However, it is certain that Guan Yu's ** appearance is also powerful. A spear or something like that would suit him well.

It should be a long knife, not a Qinglong Glaive Knife. The Qinglong Glaive in history was only available in the Ming Dynasty.

Guan Yu used a spear or something, and the ** used in the Three Kingdoms was really the Qinglong Yanyue Knife.

No, Guan Yu's weapon is a spear.

Guan Yu uses a knife, as a horse general, Guan Yu must use a long knife instead of a short knife, because the killing surface of the short knife is too small, which is not conducive to large-scale horse warfare, in addition, the defensive surface of the short knife is too narrow, if the infantry attacks Guan Yu in a group, then, Guan Yu who uses a short knife will definitely be killed or captured. In fact, Guan Yu should use a long knife, and it is written in "Ancient Chinese Weapons": "After the Eastern Han Dynasty, the use of steel long-handled knives increased, and Guan Yu, Pang De, and Huang Zhong used long-handled knives."

However, according to research, the glaive knife first appeared in the Song Dynasty, written in the Song Dynasty's "Wujing General Essentials" There is a record of the glaive knife, and there is also a drawing of this knife, however, Guan Yu is a figure in the late Eastern Han Dynasty, so in the official history, Guan Yu is impossible to use the glaive knife.

Guan Yu's ** is the Blue Dragon Glaive Knife.

Guan Yu was a famous general in the late Eastern Han Dynasty, with a long word and a long life, and was a native of Xie County, Hedong County (now Xie Zhou Town, Yanhu District, Yuncheng City, Shanxi Province).

In the fifth year of Jian'an (200 years), Cao Cao marched eastward, defeated Liu Bei, Guan Yu was captured, and then followed Cao Cao to meet Yuan Shaojun in Guandu, assassinated Yuan Shao's general Yan Liang in the crowd, sealed the Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion, and soon resigned to Liu Bei, and then followed Liu Bei to attach himself to Jingzhou Mu Liu Biao.

In the twenty-fourth year of Jian'an (219 years), worship as the former general, besieged Cao Cao will conquer the southern general Cao Ren in Fancheng, when the Han River flooded, General Zuo supervised the seven armies in the forbidden place were submerged, and beheaded the general Pang De, since Xu (now Xuchang, Henan) to the south often responds from afar, and shocks China. Cao Cao sent the Pingkou general Xu Huang to the rescue, while Wu took the opportunity to attack Jiangling, and Guan Yu was defeated and took Maicheng (now southeast of Dangyang, Hubei), and was captured and killed by the Wu army along with his son Guan Ping.