Pang Tong advocated winning by surprise, but Liu Bei didn t listen, why was it said by later generat

Liu Bei just felt that it was not cost-effective after weighing the pros and cons, so he pretended to use benevolence and righteousness as a guise and did not support Pang Tong's proposition.

Because later generations felt that Liu Bei was a hypocrite, he did not take the proposition put forward by Pang Tong, so he was said to be a hypocrite.

Pang Tong hoped to set up a Hongmen banquet and directly take Yizhou without blood. Liu Bei did not listen because he was worried that his reputation would be damaged.

Because Liu Bei once served under Cao Cao's account, it stands to reason that Liu Bei is benevolent and righteous and will not rebel against Cao Cao, but in the end, Liu Bei seized Cao Cao's Xuzhou and took away 80,000 soldiers, which made Cao Cao very angry and scolded him for his hypocrisy.

Because Liu Bei didn't find benevolence at all, he took advantage of the difficulty in Yizhou and directly sent troops to seize it, and at the same time occupied Sun Quan's Jingzhou and did not return it.

Liu Bei's benevolence and righteousness are all purposeful, in order to gain more people's support and support. It is not a pure act of benevolence and righteousness, so in the eyes of a generation of heroes Cao Cao, this is nothing more than false benevolence and false righteousness.

is because Liu Bei's suspicion is very heavy, even if he is very loyal to him, he can't fully trust him, and he will have reservations.

Because some people think that Liu Bei said that he would restore the Han family on the surface, but in fact he claimed to be the emperor, and felt that he was only superficially benevolent.

Because Liu Bei guarded against Zhuge Liang before he died, and he did not reuse Zhao Yun in his life, some people think that Liu Bei is a hypocrisy.

Throughout Liu Bei's life, benevolence and righteousness are true, power and fraud are also true, benevolence and righteousness are internal, power and fraud are external, there are black and white, yin and yang, this is a complete character image.

Because some people barely look like people.

For example, if you didn't hit it, why did you help? If you don't take the people on your back, why do you cross the river with the people?

Some people are just bad, but does he think he's bad? In his world, selfishness and self-interest are the norm, and of course he can't accept good people and good deeds.

Liu Bei was born as a grassroots entrepreneur, has no power and no power, and relies on his ability to buy people's hearts, starting from Xuzhou, and then to Liu Biao's entrustment to Jingzhou, Zhao Yun rescued Adou and broke Adou away, etc., it can be seen that Liu Bei is good at buying people's hearts and hiding his true feelings.

Because Liu Bei has always considered his own interests in the process of discussing military affairs with Zhuge Liang, there is such a statement.

Because he threw his children out of the carriage just to reduce the weight of the carriage and run for his life, in fact, he knew in his heart that the soldiers next to him would not let him do this, and take advantage of the loyalty of others to make them more convinced of him.

Some people think that Liu Bei is hypocritical and righteous, such as Liu Bei pretending to throw his own child to buy people's hearts, which is enough to see that he is a hypocritical person.

It has something to do with Liu Bei's own personality. There is a joke that Liu Bei's country is crying, but in fact, if you think about it carefully, there is indeed nothing wrong with it. Not only Liu Bei's country was crying, but even the generals were crying.

Because Liu Bei is really a Sui Qi who is cautious of accepting the banner of the Kuang Kuan clan and not supporting the Han family, and finally became the emperor himself, Liu Bei is really a person who is hypocritical and righteous, full of benevolence and morality, but he doesn't think so in his heart.

The reason why some people think that Liu Bei is fake benevolence and righteousness is because Liu Bei is sometimes polite and polite to people on the surface, but he is very conspiracy in his heart.

Because he often says one thing and does another, he is obviously under the slogan of supporting the Han family, but he was called emperor during the lifetime of Emperor Xian of the Han Dynasty.

Because Liu Bei's generals except Guan Yu and Zhang Fei, none of the people who took refuge in Liu Bei were reused, and they had no chance to display their talents.

Because Liu Bei is too greedy and wants to have both fish and bear's paws.

Liu Bei wanted to get the land of Xichuan again, and he didn't want to lose the name of benevolence and righteousness, so he spent money and food in Xichuan and was entangled. Pang Tong saw that there was no way, and the loyal Pang Tong sacrificed himself to fulfill the lord. So now when people look at Liu Bei, they feel quite greedy.

When entering Yizhou, Pang Tong suggested that Liu Bei set up a Hongmen banquet to trap Liu Zhang, but Liu Bei felt bad and refused. Killing Liu Zhang can take Yizhou without a single stroke, so many people think that Liu Bei's rejection of Pang Tong is to maintain his good name.

Pang Tong hoped to hold a Hongmen banquet and take Yizhou, but Liu Bei seemed to be worried that his reputation would be damaged, so he was unwilling to follow Pang Tong's advice, leaving a pretext for those who thought that Liu Bei was famous.

Because Liu Zhang wanted to cooperate with Liu Bei against Zhang Lu, Pang Tong suggested that Liu Bei kill Liu Zhang and replace him, but Liu Bei felt that this would hurt his reputation and refused.

Pang Tong wanted Liu Beibing to have a Hongmen banquet at that time, but Liu Bei refused for fear of carrying a bad reputation, and finally Pang Tong sacrificed for Liu Bei's so-called reputation.

According to historical records, Pang Tong wanted to hold a Hongmen banquet and take Yizhou, but Liu Bei did not listen and was unwilling to follow Pang Tong's advice, and was criticized by later generations for fake benevolence and righteousness.

Because Liu Bei had high requirements for his reputation at that time, such a strategy, which was equivalent to a Hongmen banquet, would damage his reputation, so Liu Bei did not adopt it.

Liu Bei has always been benevolent and righteous to spread the world, and he will not agree to Pang Tong taking Yizhou with a Hongmen banquet, and then Pang Tong died, and people said that Liu Bei was fake benevolence and righteousness.

Pang Tong, who was eager to make meritorious contributions, hoped to hold a Hongmen banquet and directly take Yizhou without blood. However, Liu Bei seemed to be worried about the damage to his reputation, so he was unwilling to follow Pang Tong's advice.

Pang Tong wanted to set up a Hongmen banquet and take Yizhou without seeing blood, but Liu Bei refused, saying that it would affect his reputation and not need Pang Tong's idea.

The idea was to set up a Hongmen banquet and get Yizhou without much effort, but Liu Bei felt that it would damage his reputation and did not adopt Pang Tong's idea.

Pang Tong's plan was to hold a Hongmen banquet, but doing so would damage Liu Bei's reputation, so he did not take his advice.

Because Pang Tong died because he did not accept this opinion, the people think that he is false and benevolent. The people think that since he Liu Bei is going to fight the world, then he must take a good opinion when he takes his opinion, and he can't let anyone die, but they feel that if Pang Tong was taken at that time, no one will die, and they can also get good benefits, but in the end, Liu Bei did not take this opinion, which led to the death of Pang Tong, it can be said that he killed Pang Tong directly, so the people feel that he is fake benevolence and fake benevolence.

In fact, such a thing happened at that time, and Liu Bei was in a dilemma. No matter what he chooses, the end result is that the people will think that he is pretending to be benevolent, not really benevolent. But Liu Bei had indeed been thinking about the people at that time, and after weighing the pros and cons, he still chose the side with less risk.

The people felt that since he was well, he wanted to win the world, so it was inevitable to think about them, but later Pang Tong died, and they felt that Pang Tong, a person who served Liu Bei wholeheartedly, died in the end, but Liu Bei didn't care, so that the people had a misunderstanding about him, that is, they felt that he was a hypocrisy.

The people were actually deceived by the appearance of the time. They felt that Liu Bei later chose this path and caused the death of others, and at the same time he also got a lot of benefits, so they thought that Liu Bei deliberately used Pang Tong's death in exchange for these benefits, so they felt that Liu Bei was a villain, he was just pretending to be benevolent, and in order to get his own interests, he disregarded the lives of his subordinates.

First of all, Liu Bei hated Pang Tong at first because of his appearance. Friends who are familiar with history may know that in the Three Kingdoms period at the end of the Han Dynasty, the implementation of talent is still the ancient "inspection system", under such a system, one scholar recommends another scholar to become an official, and the person who can be recommended is either from a prominent family or with complete talent and appearance. Especially as a strategist, you must look dignified and take the lead.

Zhuge Liang, who is as famous as Pang Tong, is "eight feet tall and has a great appearance", and the Romance of the Three Kingdoms goes further, saying that he is a lupine scarf and wearing a crane, and the whole person is simply "fluttering and fairy". Compared with Zhuge Liang, Pang Tong's appearance is a bit unsightly, although Liu Bei recruits talents, but he can't change the traditional problem of "judging people by their appearance"., at the beginning, he really didn't like Pang Tong.

To sum up, Liu Bei began to dislike Pang Tong because he was too ugly.

Because this person only pays attention to economic development, but Liu Bei's idea is to plot the world, and the ideas of the two are different.

Although he has made a lot of military exploits, Liu Bei still thinks that he is a very bad person, so he is like this.

Although Pang Tong has so many military exploits, he is arrogant and arrogant, and he doesn't take anyone seriously, so that's why it's like this.

Among the Three Kingdoms, the most praised for benevolence and righteousness is the emperor's uncle Liu Bei, thinking that Liu Bei was weak and lonely at the beginning, relying on his reputation as a good gentleman to recruit many talents, and "Wolong, phoenix, two people get one, can settle the world." This sentence must be familiar to everyone.

But the fame of the two of them among them can be described as worlds apart, and now Wolong Zhuge Liang has become the embodiment of wisdom, while Feng Xiao Pang Tong has been reduced to a passerby.

The most direct reason for the huge difference in reputation is the huge difference in the number of appearances between the two in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", and the fundamental reason is that Pang Tong died too early.

As for the cause of Pang Tong's death, after carefully studying the Three Kingdoms, he found a shocking secret, it turned out that Pang Tong was killed by Liu Bei.

I heard a cannon in front of the hillside, and the arrows were like flying locusts, and I waited for the white horse rider to shoot them. Poor Pang Tong died under the random arrows. He was thirty-six years old. ”

The four words "rider on a white horse" are the key, why should the enemy concentrate their fire on the man on a white horse? It turned out that there was a password in the enemy army that "the one who rides a white horse must be Liu Bei", so Pang Tong, who rode a white horse, became the object of fire.

It's not just a coincidence, it's fate. The white horse that Pang Tong rode was sent by Liu Bei. Before going into battle, Liu Bei once said to Pang Tong: "The white horse I ride is extremely tame, and the military advisor can ride it, and it is foolproof." Bad horses, I ride on them. In this way, he changed horses with Pang Tong.

Liu Bei's change of horses was done with good intentions, but it was not long-hearted. Because as early as a few years ago, Yi and Xu Shu had said that Liu Bei's name was "Lu", and this horse would hinder the owner and was not suitable for riding.

This is indeed true, and Zhang Wu, the first owner of Lu Ma, died because of this horse. At that time, when the two sides were fighting, Liu Bei was full of praise for Zhang Wu's horse, and his subordinate Zhao Yun saw that Liu Bei liked it so much, so he killed Zhang Wu and snatched the horse.

However, it may be because Liu Bei is not an ordinary person, so Lu Ma's nuisance to him has not appeared. At that time, Xu Shu also concluded that Luma "will eventually interfere with a master". also gave Liu Bei a bad idea, "If there is a grudge in the public will, you can give this horse to you, wait for this person, and then take it."

At that time, Liu Bei Yizheng verbally refused, and almost drove the family away. At the same time, he emphasized in a particularly serious way that this kind of thing was not done by good people, but in the end, he handed over Lu Ma to his military advisor, causing people to be shot into hedgehogs in Luofengpo.

If you look at it this way, does Liu Bei have to carry the pot where Pang Tong was killed?

Personally, I think that Liu Bei is a fake benevolent and righteous, and Cao Cao is a real traitor.