Who among the five tiger generals of Shu Han followed Cao Cao? Why didn t Cao Cao keep him?

Updated on history 2024-07-11
27 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-12

    Guan Yu once followed Cao Cao, but Cao Cao failed to keep Guan Yu, mainly because Guan Yu only had Liu Bei in his heart.

    First, Guan Yu had no choice but to vote for Cao Cao.

    Everything has to start with Liu Bei's refuge in Cao Cao, after Cao Cao captured Xuzhou, Liu Bei took refuge in Cao Cao. Because Liu Bei participated in the edict incident, for fear that he would be known by Cao Cao, it happened that Yuan Shu took his soldiers and horses to take refuge in Yuan Shao. Liu Bei asked Cao Cao for permission to lead his troops to intercept Yuan Shu, and Cao Cao agreed.

    And Liu Bei did not go to intercept Yuan Shu, but occupied Cao Cao's Xuzhou. Before the battle of Guandu, many people asked Cao Cao to forget it, and it was important to fight Yuan Shao first. <>

    The strategist Guo Jia said that if you go outside, you must first settle inside, and Cao Cao went to attack Liu Bei, and with Yuan Shao's temperament, he would definitely not come to attack Cao Ying. Cao Cao then took the elite to attack Liu Bei in Xuzhou, and Liu Bei was obviously not Cao Cao's opponent. After Liu Bei's defeat, he ran away with Zhang Fei to join Yuan Shao, but Guan Yu and Liu Bei's daughter-in-law were captured by Cao Cao.

    Guan Yu had no choice but to surrender to Cao Cao. <>

    Second, Cao Cao treated Guan Yu very well, but Guan Yu only had Liu Bei in his heart.

    After Guan Yu surrendered to Cao Cao, Cao Cao was very happy, praised Guan Yu bluntly, and often rewarded Guan Yu, and asked people to give Guan Yu a copy of whatever delicious food he ate. At this time, the battle of Guandu began, and Yuan Shao sent Yan Liangwen Chou to attack Baima and Yanjin respectively, and the war in Baima and Yanjin was tight and needed support. Cao Cao took his men and horses to Yanjin to support, but actually asked Guan Yu and Xu Huang to take their men and horses to attack Baima.

    Sure enough, Yuan Jun didn't expect Guan Yu and others to attack them, Yuan Jun was defeated, and the general Yan Liang was killed by Guan Yu on the spot. Guan Yu took the men and horses and Cao Cao to attack Yanjin, in the battle of Yanjin, the Yuan army was defeated again, and the general of the Yuan army, Wen Chou, was also killed. After Cao Cao considered the reason for the battle, he finally gave up Baima Yanjin.

    After Guan Yu went back with Cao Cao, Cao Cao named him "Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion", and even rewarded him with countless money. But Guan Yu already knew Liu Bei's whereabouts in the Battle of Yanjin, so he returned Cao Cao's reward to Cao Cao intact, and left a letter with his sister-in-law to find Liu Bei.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-11

    Guan yu; Guan Yu is not righteous in Taoyuan, and his own loyalty is unparalleled, and he will not betray.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-10

    The five tiger generals of Shu Han only followed Cao Cao with Guan Yu. Although Cao Cao was very good to Guan Yu, Guan Yu was particularly loyal, and after learning of Liu Bei's whereabouts, he passed five passes and killed six generals.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-09

    Guan yu; Because Guan Yu followed Cao Cao only because he was forced, and nominally Guan Yu followed the Han Dynasty, after learning Liu Bei's news, Guan Yu naturally wanted to abandon Cao Cao.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    Guan Yu followed Cao Cao. Because Guan Yu was very loyal to Liu Bei, after he learned the news of Liu Bei, he rode thousands of miles to escort his two sisters-in-law to Liu Bei.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    Four of the five tiger generals once followed Cao Cao, and Cao Cao did not leave anyone behind, because Ma Chao and Huang Zhong could be said to have missed Cao Cao for various reasons, and Guan Yu and Zhang Fei were completely socks because they were loyal to Liu Bei, and it was impossible for them to betray Liu Bei and really use them for Cao Cao.

    We will find that four of the five tiger generals once followed Cao Cao briefly, but his last one did not stay, in fact, there is a reason for this.

    First of all, we want to mention Ma Chao, Cao Cao can be said to have lost Ma Chao, a fierce general, because of a misunderstanding. At the beginning, Cao Cao coerced the Son of Heaven and ordered the vassal states, and the Xiliang warlord Ma Teng finally surrendered under Cao Cao's persuasion, and Ma Chao also became a military general under Cao Cao, and left Ma Chao to guard Xiliang. Later, Cao Cao went to attack Zhang Lu in Hanzhong, and was misunderstood by Ma Chao that he was going to fight him, so he opposed Cao and defeated Cao Jun many times during this period, but in the end, Cao Cao defeated Ma Chao by beating Brother Ji with a counter-plot.

    After Ma Chao's defeat, he finally took refuge in Liu Bei and became Liu Bei's person.

    Secondly, Huang Zhong and Cao Cao also missed it. Huang Zhong was originally Liu Biao's person, but later when Cao Cao went south, he met Jingzhou Liu Biao died of illness, Jingzhou knew that he couldn't defeat Cao Cao, so he surrendered without a fight, and Huang Zhong and others also became Cao Wei's generals. Later, Zhou Yu burned Cao Cao's warship with fire, which led to Cao Cao's crushing defeat, and then Liu Bei captured Jingzhou, and after several twists and turns, Huang Zhong was almost killed, Wei Yan came to the rescue, and finally they surrendered to Liu Bei.

    In addition, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei were loyal to Liu Bei, and they only followed their brother and had to take refuge temporarily. At the beginning, Liu Bei had no choice but to defect to Cao Cao and wanted to temporarily rely on Cao Cao to avoid Lu Bu, so his subordinates Zhang Fei and Guan Yu became Cao Ying's generals. Although Cao Cao looked at Guan Yu differently and also valued Zhang Fei very seriously, but in the edict incident, Liu Bei left Cao Cao, and Guan Yu and Zhang Fei also left Cao Cao with Liu Bei.

    Although Liu Bei Youzhou was later defeated by Cao Cao, Liu Guanzhang and the three of them were lost, not knowing whether they were alive or dead, which eventually led to Guan Yu demoting Cao Cao. Even so, he was very loyal and unwilling to betray Liu Bei, so he made an agreement with Cao Cao in three chapters, that is, after finding Liu Bei, he was going to leave Cao Ying, and Cao Cao agreed in order to get his help.

    The above is the reason why Cao Cao did not leave alone.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    1.Guan Yu: Because he was loyal to Liu Bei, he didn't want to follow Cao Cao all the time.

    2.Zhang Fei: At that time, Zhang Fei and Liu Bei collapsed under Cao Cao, and finally left with Liu Bei.

    3.Ma Chao: Cao Cao sent troops to attack Zhang Lu, passing through Ma Chao's territory, but was misunderstood by Ma Chao, so he raised troops against Cao.

    4.Huang Zhong: After Cao Cao took Jingzhou, Huang Zhong became Cao Cao's subordinate, but at that time, Cao Sun Chayuancao's energy was focused on Jiangdong and he did not pay attention to Huang Zhong.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    I think Bi Sheng's seepage has something to do with Cao Cao's character, Cao Cao is a repentant and suspicious person, even if there are four people who follow him, but he still can't really trust them.

  9. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Cao Cao is arrogant and does not cherish the generals enough, he does not hesitate to have famous generals, but he cannot give full play to his talents.

  10. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    These three people are Xiahou Shang, Cao Zhang, and Cao Hong. According to later records and circulation, Cao Pi was jealous and fearful of threatening his rule, so he inflicted harm.

    Xiahou Shang was a famous general of Cao Wei during the Three Kingdoms period and the nephew of Xiahou Yuan, the general of the expedition to the west。Xiahou Shang and Cao Pi were friends in their early years, and they were deeply loved by Cao Pi, and even gave him the right to "be powerful and blessed, kill and live" when Shang served as the general of the expedition to the south, but something happened after that affected the relationship between the two.

    Xiahou Shang has a concubine who is very fond of her, and the degree of pampering exceeds that of Mrs. Zhengfang, who happens to be the child of the Cao family. Emperor Wen of Wei Cao Pi was very angry, and in order to give the wife of the main house and the Cao family, he sent someone to kill this concubine, and as a result, this incident made Xiahou Shang sick. The concubine died in 224 AD, and in 225 Xiahou Shang became seriously ill and died of illness in 226.

    Who is Cao Hong? Cao Hong was Cao Cao's younger brother, and followed Cao Cao to make great contributions to Cao Wei's regime, but later he was demoted to a concubine by Cao Pi, why is this. Because Cao Hong's family was rich but stingy, Cao Pi borrowed money from him when he was young, but he didn't give it to Cao Pi, and then after Cao Pi became the emperor, he took advantage of Cao Hong's disciple to break the law, and Cao Hong was put in prison and put to death.

    Cao Zhang was the second son of Cao Wei, Emperor Wu of Wei, the second son of Empress Cao Xuanbian of Wei, the younger brother of Cao Pi, Emperor Wen of Wei, and the brother of Cao Zhi, King of Chen. In 223, Cao Zhang made a pilgrimage to Beijing, during which he fell ill and died violently in his mansion at the age of 35. Later, there was a legend that Cao Pi designed to kill Cao Zhang.

    According to Liu Yiqing's "Shishuo Xinyu" of Liu Song of the Southern Dynasty, Cao Zhang's death was because Cao Pi was afraid of Cao Zhang's martial arts and used a trick to poison Cao Zhang. Cao Zhang likes to play chess, and Cao Pi does what he likes. Cao Pi deliberately showed weakness and asked the maid to bring the black date, so the two of them ate the black date while playing chess, and then the date had been poisoned by Cao Pi and made a mark that he knew.

  11. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Cao Pi reigned for seven years, he was conscientious and diligent in governing the country, but his own shortcomings, small belly, and intolerable shortcomings killed the three fierce generals left by Cao Cao, which brought great disasters to Cao Wei's Jiangshan.

  12. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Cao Pi was too careful, and one of his weaknesses was that he believed that the trio would pose a threat to his rule, and that they might not obey him after his father's death.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Because Cao Pi thinks that those people will threaten his throne, and he already has a lot of talents around him who can be used for himself, and he doesn't need to find the fierce generals arranged for him by his father, Cao Pi has his own plans.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    In what is it, they are all family members. The reason why Cao Pi dared to do it was probably because someone said bad things. I guess it's Cao Pi's most trusted advisor, Jia Zhen.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    The Cao clan was originally full of talents, and there were many generals. Later, he could get it, and Cao Xiu and Cao Zhen were the only ones left with real power, but unfortunately they couldn't survive Sima Yi, and the others could only hehe.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    Because Cao Pi himself also had great ambitions, he felt that these three fierce generals posed a threat to him, and killed them in order to eliminate the hidden danger.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    Because the dynasty has changed, other people's subordinates will naturally not be reused anymore, and it is useless to keep them anyway.

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    Because Cao Pi was a suspicious person by nature, he felt that they threatened his rule, and he was afraid that they would rebel, so he killed them in order to eliminate the hidden danger of rebellion.

  19. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    Cao Pi suffered too much in the battle between the sons in the first half of his life, and Cao Cao always hoped that Cao Zhi could inherit his great cause, so he has been suppressing Cao Pi in various ways. However, in the end, it was discovered that only Cao Pi was the only one who wanted to rule the troubled times, and Cao Zhi was at best only suitable for being a king who rested with the people after unifying the world. Perhaps it was this reason that caused Cao Pi's psychological imbalance, and he suppressed the clan in various ways after ascending the throne.

  20. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    Because Cao Pi felt that these people might threaten his position, and he didn't need these people by his side.

  21. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    What bullshit is written, backwards and backwards, contradictory.

  22. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    Cao Pi is a conspirator, and he can't fight the world.

  23. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    Cao Pi had a narrow stomach and could not tolerate people, fearing that the three members with military power in his hands would pose a threat to him, so he found an excuse to kill them one by one.

  24. Anonymous users2024-01-20

    Because Cao Cao likes Cao Ang, Cao Zhi, and Cao Chong, but he doesn't like him very much, he has not been valued by his father since he was a child, resulting in his narrow-mindedness and revenge.

  25. Anonymous users2024-01-19

    There is dementia. So the descendants were killed by the Sima clan. Extinction.

  26. Anonymous users2024-01-18

    Although Liu Bei sealed the five tiger generals of Shu State, these five tiger generals did not get along so harmoniously. Guan Yu and Zhang Fei are sworn brothers, and the relationship must be very good, but Guan Yu looks down on Huang Zhong, and Zhang Fei doesn't like Ma Chao. But if you want to say that the most opinionated may be Zhao Yun, Zhao Yun is good at everything, but he is too upright, and he is a little too upright.

    Therefore, it will attract some people's eyes, and now Zhao Yun's EQ is a little low, so he is not welcomed. Let's take a look at what Zhao Yun has done, so that no matter how much credit he makes, he will still not be used by Liu Bei.

    Speaking of the most familiar idiom, "three visits to the thatched house" must be among them. "Three visits to the thatched house" tells the story of Liu Bei going to Zhuge Liang's thatched house three times to invite Zhuge Liang out of the mountain. In history, Liu Bei has reused a lot of useful talents in his life, but for some reason he has not reused the people around him who are loyal to him, such as Zhao Yun, Liu Bei did not reuse Zhao Yun until his death, because Zhao Yun did the three things that made Liu Bei completely disappointed in him.

    First, intercept the river to save Adou. When Liu Bei first married Mrs. Sun, there were many family members who came with Mrs. Sun, and they had a good temper, and Liu Bei was also afraid that there were spies among them. In order to solve this kind of thing, Liu Bei let Zhao Yun take full authority to deal with it.

    Later, Sun Quan sent someone to pick up Mrs. Sun, everything was normal, but Mrs. Sun held Liu Chan alive and did not let go, and wanted to take him home, in order to keep Liu Chan, Zhao Yun went to besiege Mrs. Sun. But things are far from being so simple, Zhao Yun was authorized to take full responsibility for this matter, but he didn't leave Mrs. Sun at home, but he could only block the boat and save Liu Chan. Originally, he was obviously blocked at home, and everything was under Zhao Yun's control, but he went to surround Liu Chan on the boat under his uncontrollable circumstances.

    If Zhang Fei couldn't catch up at that time, the consequences would be unimaginable.

    Second, Changbanpo rescued the young master, which was the greatest contribution of Zhao Yun's life, but it was also the thing that initially aroused Liu Bei's suspicions. When Liu Bei heard his subordinates report that Zhao Yun had surrendered, Cao Cao did not believe it, although Zhao Yun was loyal to Liu Bei and quarrelsome, his dereliction of duty did anger Liu Bei.

    Third, stop Liu Bei from attacking Wu. When Liu Bei was preparing to attack Wu, he was very sure that he would definitely be able to take it, and he couldn't even listen to Zhuge Liang's advice, but Zhao Yun kept stopping Liu Bei, which angered Liu Bei the most. Since then, Liu Bei has not reused Zhao Yun.

    After these three incidents, Liu Bei no longer let Zhao Yun do major things related to state power, but only asked him to take care of Liu Chan and no longer participate in politics. These three things made Liu Bei disheartened with Zhao Yun.

  27. Anonymous users2024-01-17

    Because Cao Cao is very suspicious. There are a lot of people who have to doubt every day. In this way, the five tigers will be very uneasy. So he couldn't keep these people.

Related questions
8 answers2024-07-11

The five fierce generals under Liu Bei, Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Zhao Yun, Ma Chao, and Huang Zhong were originally described as "Five Tiger Generals."

28 answers2024-07-11

There are also many powerful generals in Shu Han, such as Guan Yu's son Guan Xing, Zhang Fei's son Zhang Bao, as well as Zhou Cang, Liao Hua and Wang Ping, who are also famous generals of Shu Han, as well as Ma Chao's younger brother Ma Dai.

27 answers2024-07-11

I think that compared with Cao Wei's generals, the five tigers of Shu Han have a very high gold content. Because of the five tiger generals of Shu Han, their force value is better than that of Cao Wei's generals. So I think in terms of force value, it should be a very high existence, with a high gold content.

20 answers2024-07-11

At the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty, Wei, Shu and Wu divided the world. In Shu, there are many famous figures, such as the Five Tiger Generals, Wolong and Phoenix Chicks, etc., these people are all well-known to everyone. But after the death of Zhuge Liang and the Five Tiger Generals, what about the military generals who supported Shu Han? <> >>>More

13 answers2024-07-11

It's useless, Xuanyuan has an exclusive effect of improving skills, but Mrs. is exclusive to the descendant set, the suit has a strong attack, and Xuanyuan doesn't. So it's useless for Madame to take Xuanyuan.