Romance of the Three Kingdoms Battle of Fancheng, why couldn t Guan Yu defeat Xu Huang, and finally

Because Sun Quan carried out a sneak attack, Guan Yu's troops were not very strong, so he died in the end.

Because Guan Yu was very old at that time, and he had an injury on his arm, his strength had become smaller, and he was still a defeated general at that time, so he couldn't beat Xu Huang.

Because Guan Yu is no longer at his peak, as he gets older, his strength has declined greatly, so he is not Xu Huang's opponent.

"Romance of the Three Kingdoms" Guan Yunchang defeated Maicheng Main content: Guan Gong started to fight Cao in Dazhou, and he did not fight. Wu Lumeng took advantage of the situation and attacked Jingzhou (actually Jiangling).

Guan Gong returned to rescue Jingzhou, the troops were insufficient, and the reinforcements of the Cao army had arrived, Guan Gong not only did not recapture Jingzhou, but fell into the front and back attacks of the Cao and Sun families, and the abdomen and back were accompanied by the enemy, so he led the remnants of the army to retreat to Maicheng.

The nearest reinforcements were in Shangyong, and the guard Liu Feng Mengda chose not to save (in fact, Shangyong's troops were insufficient, so if he went to save it, he was likely to get in), so Guan Gong trembled and the whole army was wiped out.

Reasons for failure

Guan Yu is a hero admired by everyone, he killed six generals after five passes, beheaded Yan Liang and Wen Chou, flooded the Seventh Army, captured him alive, killed Pang De, and shocked China. but ended up with a tragic end of defeat and death in Maicheng.

The reasons are as follows: 1. Guan Yu is stubborn and arrogant. As a result, he fell for the strategy of Lu Meng and Lu Xun, lost Jingzhou, and defeated Maicheng.

When he was in Maicheng, Guan Yu was already facing great danger, and said that even if there was an ambush, what was there to fear, arrogance, arrogance and arrogance would be defeated, and defeat would become inevitable.

2, "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" commented on Guan Yu and Zhang Fei: "Yu treats the soldiers well and is proud of the scholars, and Fei loves and respects the gentleman but does not care for the villain." Although Guan Yu cherished the soldiers, he looked down on people like the scholars, causing Liu Feng and Meng Da to hold a grudge and not save them when they saw death.

From this, Guan Yu's failure is not difficult to find.

After Guan Yu flooded the Seventh Army, he was a little arrogant and ready to attack Fancheng, but he was afraid that Eastern Wu would take advantage of the situation to seize Jingzhou. But this was just his ploy, and he knew that Guan Yu would definitely let his guard down if he looked down on the weak scholar. Sure enough, Guan Yu transferred all the defenders of Jingzhou to attack Fancheng, and as a result, Lü Meng occupied Jingzhou without a single soldier.

However, Fancheng could not be captured, Jingzhou was also lost, and Guan Yu had no choice but to defeat Maicheng. He asked Liu Feng and Meng Da for help, but they were at odds with Guan Yu, so they saw death and did not save him, Guan Yu had no choice but to break through the siege, and walked to Maicheng at night, but was ambushed, captured by Eastern Wu, and then beheaded by Sun Quan.

Because Guan Yu's age is relatively old, and Xu Huang's age is relatively young. Therefore, Guan Yu is naturally not Xu Huang's opponent, and he will only take this step if he is forced to do so.

Because Guan Yu was already old at that time, and he had wasted a lot of physical strength in breaking through before, he would not be able to beat Xu Huang, if it was Guan Yu at his peak, he would definitely be able to cut Xu Huang under the horse.

At that time, Guan Yu was attacked by Cao Wei and Eastern Wu, and he had already lost his first move, and his soldiers suffered serious battle losses.

Guan Yu defeated Cao Ren in Fancheng, and Cao Cao sent a leader to rescue Fancheng. As a result, he encountered autumn rains. He did not kill the Seventh Army. In the end, the public Xu Huang led the army to save Fancheng, Xu Huangxun was not as good as Guan Yu, but was defeated?

Xu Huang (?.)-227), a native of Yang in Hedong (southeast of present-day Hongdong, Shanxi). Xu Hua turned out to be Yang Feng, and after Cao Cao's team was defeated, Xu Hua turned Cao Cao and participated in the Battle of Wuwu, the Battle of Chibi, the city governance, and the city of Hanzhong.

Especially in the battle of Fancheng, Xu Hua led his team to defeat Guan Yu, and Zhou Yawu, who was called "windy" by Cao Cao.

Guan Yu is surrounded by Fuyang, Funan, Cao Ren and Lu Chang. Xu Huang's soldier is a new soldier. I didn't train very often.

It's hard to resist Guan Yu's army, so I have to go to Yangling. Cao Cao sent the general Xu Hai Lu Jian and other orders to Xu Huang: "After waiting for the soldiers and horses, attack."

At that time, Guan Yu was stationed in Yucheng. After Xu Huang arrived, he pretended to establish what he had been waiting for a long time, showing the back of Guan Yunjun. Guan Maize was afraid of the surroundings, I had to burn the camp, Xu Huang then led the army to occupy Yucheng, both sides, close to Guan Yuanjun, Xu Huang's Yinghai was only three feet away from Guan Jun.

The battle had not yet opened, and Cao Cao sent Yin Quan and Zhu Jia and other twelve camps to support Xu Huang. Guan Yun's main force is in front of the head, there is a busy camp for four days, Xu Kai, is the main force of crime, and the secret attack four, Guan Yu went to see the army of four, the personal rate of five thousand people played, Xu Hua attacked, Guan Yu retired, at that time, Xu Huang led the army to continue the attack, Guan Yun was defeated, and many people were drowned in the water.

After Cao Cao heard this, it was appreciated that the enemy was besieged, the defenders were ten, and the Xu army was winning, killing so many enemies. I am more than 30 years old. I've never heard of the use of soldiers.

I had a long drive. Target. Moreover, the fan, Xiangyang, is better than the previous Ju, that is, ink, so Xu's reputation is better than that of Sun Wu and Sui Tho.

When Xu Huang led the army, Cao Cao personally went to Ying Yingqi to welcome Xu Hua. The banquet will be celebrated. Cao Cao took out the wine glass to Xu Huang and kept Fuyang, all Xu's credits!

At that time, Cao Cao patrolled the village. Many soldiers came out. Only Xu Huang's barracks were very neat, the sergeant was still standing, Cao Cao sighed, Xu Jun was really windy!

Romance of the Three Kingdoms Xu Huang Biography": When the army is set up, taizu case duo camp, the soldiers are salty, the barracks are completed, and the soldiers are still in Chen. The prince sighed

Xu Jun can say that Zhou Yafei is windy. ”

Later, after Cao Yu called the emperor, Xu Hua was blocked as a suitable general, and I died 227 years ago. A generation of famous, finally defeated by Xu Huang, it can be seen that Xu Huang's ability is very good, although the martial arts are not as good as Guan Yu, but the leader is still very strong. Xu Huang is strict, relying on his talent and bravery to defeat Guan Yu.

Because Xu Huang came to the rescue, Xu Huang's troops were more than Guan Yu, but most of the soldiers under Huang were new recruits, and it was actually difficult to compete with the army led by Guan Yu, so Xu Huang did not rush to send people to the head, but chose to enter Yanglingpo to station and wait for reinforcements. When reinforcements arrived, Xu Huang began to attack.

At that time, Xu Huang's men and horses were tens of thousands, while Guan Yu's troops were relatively scattered, and the men and horses used to resist were about 5,000. Although Yizhou is the backing, Jingzhou and Yizhou are too far apart, and it is difficult to transfer troops. So in terms of the comparison of troops, Xu Huang has an advantage.

With the advantage of troops, Xu Huang did not choose to fight hard, but used the strategy of attacking the east and the west, which not only caused Guan Yu's troops to be scattered, but also caught Guan Yu off guard. Guan Yu hurriedly led his troops to the battle, but was repelled by Xu Huang.

It should rely on his own wisdom and his own troops, because his army is relatively powerful.

Xu Huang relied on his strong military strength to defeat Guan Yu, and Guan Yu was not fully prepared at that time, so he was not Xu Huang's opponent.