What is the basis for Guan Yu to beat Xu Huang? What s your opinion?

In fact,Some fans of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" said that Guan Yu couldn't beat Xu Huang, just because when Guan Yu and Xu Huang were heads-up, it was Xu Huang who wonBut at that time, Guan Yu himself was attacked by the enemy and was not in good shape, and he was still injured at that time, but Xu Huang fought against Guan Yu in good spirits, and the result was only a narrow victory, which is enough to show that Guan Yu's strength is actually better than Xu Huang's.

First of all, let's take a look at the situation when Xu Huang defeated Guan Yu, when Guan Yu led his troops to capture Yu Ban and kill Pang De, he directly shocked Huaxia, Cao Cao was stunned when he heard the news, you must know that Xu Huang's ability is actually similar to Pang De, so if it was Guan Yu against Xu Huang at that time, Xu Huang would have to die.

Since Guan Yu had already spent a lot of energy in this battle, Guan Yu was not at a normal level at that time. On the other hand, Xu Huang was assigned by Cao Cao to come to support, so Xu Huang was energetic against Guan Yu.

Secondly, after Guan Yu shocked Huaxia, Sun Quan actually couldn't sit still, so he began to unite with Cao Cao to prepare for a sneak attack on Guan Yu, that is to say, Guan Yu at this time was actually attacked by the enemy, and Guan Yu himself was the one who commanded the whole army, so he naturally had to worry about a lot of things. And when Xu Huang played against Guan Yu, Guan Yu was actually a little exhausted at this time, of course, he couldn't compare to Xu Huang who was wholeheartedly and in good spirits, but even so, Guan Yu still lost the battle with Xu Huang after many rounds, so this alone does not mean that Xu Huang is stronger than Guan Yu.

In the end, Guan Yu was actually seriously injured in the process of arresting Yu Ban and killing Pang De at that time, this injury was mainly in Guan Yu's left shoulder, so Guan Yu was not handy when he played the big knife when he was fighting against Xu Huang, so Xu Huang's victory over Guan Yu was also a victory, and no one at that time felt that Xu Huang was really stronger than Guan Yu, but he just felt that Xu Huang was lucky.

If you talk about personal force alone, Cao Cao's general Xu Huang is estimated to be not Guan Yu's opponent, but in terms of military ability, Xu Huang is not under Guan Yu at all, and the most powerful proof is that Xu Huang defeated Guan Yu in the Battle of Fancheng, causing Guan Yu to defeat Maicheng and be in a different place. Guan Yu's Northern Expedition can be said to be the first large-scale attack of the Shu Han group on the Cao Cao regime in the north, taking advantage of the fact that Cao Cao's army was trapped in Hanzhong and had not completely withdrawn, and directly surrounded the two important military towns of Xiangyang and Fancheng on Cao Cao's southern front line with lightning speed.

Guan Yu fought very well in the early stage, flooded Cao Cao's Seventh Army, captured Yu Ban, and killed Pang De!The Fan City that Cao Ren handled surrounded three layers inside and three layers outside. Cao Cao ordered Xu Huang to lead the army to rush to help.

One of the biggest mistakes made by the Shuhan group in this battle was the mistake of strategic decision-making, dividing the troops into three routes, resulting in the dispersion of forces. Liu Bei's war in Hanzhong was not over, Zhuge Liang wanted to divide his troops to pacify the resistance forces in Shu, and Guan Yu at this time wanted to go north to Cao Cao. As a result, when Guan Yu was defeated and retreated in the later stage of the Northern Expedition, there were no reinforcements.

Guan Yu did not have tens of thousands of troops on hand, and coupled with his arrogance, he divided his limited forces into three parts, one part to besiege Fancheng, one part to besiege Xiangyang, and some to defend against the Eastern Wu sneak attack on Jingzhou.

Guan Yu thinks very highly of himself, divides his troops into three ways, and is proud of the enemy, which can be said to be a taboo for soldiers, and naturally has no chance of winning in three-line battles. Cao Ren, who was stationed in Fancheng, was arguably the most defensible general under Cao Cao, especially good at motivating his soldiers when facing a desperate situation. And Xu Huang, who cooperated with Cao Ren, was a fierce general who was good at strategy.

Xu Huang led the army to come to the rescue, but he was not in a hurry to fight with Guan Yu's army, so he first used Feishu to project into the city to appease the soldiers and civilians in the city, and let him know that my Xu Huang's rescue has arrived. After Xu Huang set up camp, he widely disseminated false offensive news to paralyze Guan Yu's army, and then attacked Guan Yu's army by attacking the east and the west. After the 10 lines of defense set by Guan Yu were broken through, Xu Huang sent the main force to drive straight in and killed Guan Yu's Jingzhou soldiers with a big defeat, which led to the tragic ending of Guan Yu's soldiers being defeated and taken away from Maicheng and captured by Lu Meng.

In a real war, the generals of the two sides will not meet, the most important thing is strategy, the ability to mobilize the army, not to fight personal force, don't be deceived by literary works such as the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, the main general will not be singled out before the battle to decide the outcome of the war.

I think these bases are still quite reasonable, this is because Xu Huang's martial arts are particularly strong, and Guan Yu injured his arm at that time, so his ability also declined, and then he couldn't beat the other party.

There is such a saying, in fact, it is because Xu Huang won when Guan Yu and Xu Huang went head-to-head, but Guan Yu's situation at that time was that he was in a bad state, and if the overall state was very good, Guan Yu could completely defeat him.

I couldn't agree more. The most famous of them is that Guan Yu was defeated by Xu Huang, and then walked to Maicheng, and finally had a different head, which can prove that Xu Huang is very powerful.

Xu Huang can beat Guan Yu but Yu Ban can't? What is the reason?

When Xu's army arrived, Guan Yu had already surrounded Fancheng, but Xu Huang still asked Cao Ren to wait. Cao Ren took possession of Fancheng, but Guan Yu could not conquer it easily. In addition, Cao Ren and Guan Yu had been fighting fiercely for a long time and did not want to fight first.

For front-line generals, there is leadership management, mass control, and institutional norms, Yu Ban, Cao Ren, and Xu Huang are absolutely unaffordable and unaffordable, but Cao Ren and Xu Huang are luckier than Yu Ban. After Cao Ren, Xu Huang's luck was better than Yu Ban.

Guan Yu's main force did not exceed 30,000 people.

These 30,000 men fought with Cao Ren, pushed back to Xiangfan, and finally defeated Cao Ren. Then, Yu Ban's Seventh Route Army had a total of 30,000 men. To sum up, Guan Yu's army has been fighting Cao's army on the front line for nearly half a year.

During this time, Guan Yu defeated the Cao army, which had twice as many troops as Guan Yu. However, Guan Yu killed 1,000 enemy soldiers after all, and he also lost 800 of his own.

When Yu Jian was reinforced, Cao Ren was in a better position. Guan Yu hadn't approached Fancheng yet, so Yu Jian didn't want to entangle with Guan Yu first.

<>After all, Cao Ren is the protagonist of the whole play, and he has not been surrounded by "Forbidden Land First", which green onion are you? So don't do anything. Rescue teams arrived one after another and began to fight Guan Yu.

Later, Guan Yu retreated and still held his position in Mianyang. Later, when Sun Quan attacked Jingzhou, Guan Yu retreated. After Xu Huang arrived in Fancheng, although he faced many objective reasons, he had the same problem as Yu Jin at that time, that is, he wanted the entire battle to focus on Cao Ren's self-salvation instead of wasting his own strength.

When the Xu army arrived, Guan Yu had already surrounded Fancheng, but Xu Huang still asked Cao Ren to wait. Cao Ren took possession of Fancheng, but Guan Yu could not conquer it easily. In addition, Cao Ren and Guan Yu had been fighting fiercely for a long time and didn't want to fight first.

For front-line generals, there is leadership management, mass control, and institutional norms, Yu Ban, Cao Ren, and Xu Huang are absolutely unaffordable and unaffordable, but Cao Ren and Xu Huang are luckier than Yu Ban. After searching Cao Ren, Xu Huang's luck was better than Yu Ban.

Speaking of Guan Yu, many netizens know that this person is still relatively powerful, I think he should be regarded as the most powerful figure during the Three Kingdoms period, and even Lu Bu I don't think it's Guan Yu's opponent, of course, many people don't agree with this view, but it doesn't matter, let's talk about Guan Yu and Xu Huang, in fact, many people say that Xu Huang defeated Guan Yu, I think the interesting thing is that the two of them fought for 80 rounds at that time, and Guan Yu's side withdrew his troops. Why is it said that Guan Yu was defeated? Let's take a look at this problem together!

First of all, the eighty rounds of the battle between Guan Yu and Xu Huang happened at this point in time, Guan Yu surrounded Xiangyang and Fancheng, at this time, if Cao Wei did not make relevant moves, it would only be a more terrible result, so Xu Huang was too rough to bring troops to the rescue.

Guan Yu surrounded Xiangyang and Fancheng, if Cao Wei didn't make relevant moves at this time, he was afraid that there would be more terrible results, so Xu Huang led troops to rescue at this time. In the romance, Xu Huang fought with Guan Yu for eighty rounds, and then Guan Yu withdrew, on the surface, it was actually Xu Huang who won and solved the siege of Fancheng, but if you really analyze it carefully, then Xu Huang is actually not Guan Yu's opponent!

We can't help but analyze the situation at the time, Guan Yu has actually been besieging the city for several months this time, and his men actually only have about 30,000 soldiers and horses, but they can flood the Seventh Army and eliminate tens of thousands of Cao Wei elites, and then look at the force value of Yu Ban and Pang De who were captured, everyone must know it, especially Pang De, I don't know how tenacious the battle is, and Cao Ren Manzhong and others are vegetarians, so Guan Yu has consumed too much energy to fight Fancheng.

So when Guan Yu was asked to fight Xu Huang, of course Guan Yu didn't choose to retreat, so he accepted it, and fought for eighty rounds before and after, but it didn't divide the winner at that time, and it ended with Guan Yu's side Mingjin withdrawing troops.

In fact, Guan Yu at this time has always been injured, his arm is an arrow wound, as far as the romance is concerned, he has to take an eighty-pound broadsword, and he has to fight Xu Huang, in fact, it is too embarrassing, everyone also knows that Xu Huang and Guan Yu are fellow countrymen, and Guan Yu had the best relationship with Zhang Liao and Xu Huang when he was in Cao Ying, in fact, it should be a martial art that often communicates in private, so in the end, Guan Yu was in front of such a familiar opponent, and Ming Jin withdrew his troops with injuries, I don't think it was defeated, Under normal circumstances, how could Xu Huang be an opponent?