Guan Yu was attacked by Cao Cao and Sun Quan, why didn t Liu Bei make a move?

Updated on history 2024-07-24
17 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-13

    Because Liu Bei's army was somewhere else at that time, there were no other troops near Jingzhou to rescue Guan Yu.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-12

    Liu Bei didn't make a move, he didn't have time to make a move, and when he knew that Guan Yu was besieged, he was already dead, and the two were hundreds of miles apart, so he didn't have time to save him.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-11

    Because Guan Yu was attacked suddenly, Liu Bei was still in Yizhou at that time, and he couldn't get the information at the first time. It was not until after Guan Yu's death that the news reached Liu Bei, causing Liu Bei to be extremely painful.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-10

    Even Guan Yu himself didn't expect Sun Quan to sneak attack, how could Liu Bei know? At that time, Jingzhou and Xichuan were far away, and it basically took Guan Yu only one day to lose Jingzhou, so Liu Bei was too late.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-09

    Because Liu Bei didn't know the news. At that time, Liu Bei was far away in Xichuan and didn't know the news that Guan Yu was attacked.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-08

    Clause.

    First, it is more advantageous for Eastern Wu to send troops from Jingzhou, but it is difficult to make a difference from other parts of the Yangtze River, and it should occupy Jingzhou in terms of its own interests.

    Today, Cao is far away in Hebei, newly breaking Zhu Yuan, Fuji, Ji, and not having time to look east. Xu Tu guards, hearing inadequate, go to Keke. However, the terrain is land-based, and the horsemen are hired, and the supreme has Xuzhou today, and he will fight for it in the next ten years, although he guards it with seventy or eighty thousand people, he should still be worried.

    It's better to take feathers, all according to the Yangtze River, and the situation is good."

    Clause. Second, Jingzhou is the gateway to Eastern Wu, and the final demise of Wu is precisely because Jingzhou is lost, if Jingzhou is not occupied, it is equivalent to Shu putting a knife on its neck.

    Clause. Third, Wu Guo once proposed to cooperate, but Guan Yu refused, regardless of whether Wu Guo was sincere or not, Guan Yu had to pay a lot of responsibility.

    Clause. Fourth, the purpose of Guan Yu's dispatch of troops should be to echo Liu Bei and transfer Cao Cao's troops, because Liu Bei had attacked Hanzhong before this. This is also the reason why Liu Bei did not assist Guan Yu, because the original purpose was not to conquer the city, so it was not profitable for Dongwu to cooperate with him at all.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    The first thing to say is that the alliance at that time belonged to two weak and one strong, Sun and Liu were weak, and Cao Cao was dominant, so it was logical for the two to form an alliance. After the Battle of Chibi, Liu Bei entered Shu and stayed in Guanyu to guard Jingzhou. From top to bottom, Eastern Wu believed that Jingzhou should belong to him, and Zhou Yu also used a trick to take Jingzhou (let Liu Bei marry Sun Shangxiang), but it ended in failure and died.

    It was Soochow who had always coveted Jingzhou. After the death of Lu Su, the period of stability between the two sides ended, and the Eastern Wu was ready to move, so there was a matter of courtship, just imagine that Guan Yu would marry Guan Feng to Sun Quan's son, it is difficult to guarantee that the Eastern Wu will not threaten Guan Feng's life in exchange for Jingzhou. Guan Yu saw through Dongwu's tricks and categorically refused.

    However, Guan Yu is arrogant by nature and insults Soochow, which will intensify the contradictions. This is also the source of his failure. Besides, Soochow's capture of Jingzhou was a defeat both in terms of timing and strategy.

    Jingzhou's four battles, there is no danger to defend, Jingzhou's naval advantage is gone, and he offends his allies and leaks himself under the two major enemies. It's unwise. The correct strategy of Soochow should be to capture Huainan, the so-called defense of the river must defend Huai, Huainan Shouchun is the gateway to its capital Moling, to obtain Shouchun, you can continue to attack Xuzhou, in short, to Huainan as a springboard, and then Xu Tujing, Xu Erzhou.

    Therefore, although Lü Meng's plan succeeded, it can be said that from the overall point of view, Eastern Wu laid the groundwork for the future defeat.

  8. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Because Liu Bei and Sun Quan united because they were too weak and forced by the situation, later they both grew stronger, thinking that the other party was a threat and wanted to strangle the other party in the cradle, so they started a war.

  9. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Because Sun Quan wanted to subdue Guan Yu, and remembered how Cao Cao treated Guan Yu, he felt that Guan Yu would not surrender, so he killed Guan Yu.

  10. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Sun Quan plotted against Jingzhou, so he conspired with Cao Cao to attack Jingzhou. Guan Yu is the pastor of Jingzhou, although brave but also stubborn, first defeated Cao Ren to attack Fancheng, then defeated Lü Meng, and finally defeated Maicheng.

  11. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    At that time, Liu Bei had just defeated Cao Cao in Hanzhong, and his momentum was no less than Cao Cao's. Let's balance it.

  12. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    For the sake of interests, the interests of the country are the most important, Guan Yu has no one in his eyes, he is too arrogant, and Liu Bei's military strength was the largest at that time, so he was a threat to himself.

  13. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Well, this one! In a nutshell, there are no eternal friends, no eternal enemies, only eternal interests!

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Lianwu and Cao have always been the central idea of Zhuge Liang, and although Wu Guo also has the heart of Lianshu Han, he does not think that he can not exist alone without Shu Han! Moreover, Sun Quan always thought that Jingzhou was his own, and he was only temporarily lending it to Liu Bei, but now that Liu Bei has sat firmly in Shu Han, he does not plan to return it, so he is very unhappy in his heart. And Sun Quan's ambitions are not limited to Jiangdong, he also wants to capture Shu Han, and now he is preempted by Liu Bei, and he is not happy.

    In fact, attacking Jingzhou, it should be Sun Quan's careful thinking that is at work, because he thinks that Liu Bei will not dare to turn his face with himself!

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Well, actually. Sun Quan saw that Liu Bei would not return Jingzhou, so he was very angry, so he secretly united with Cao Cao. Then Lu Xun took advantage of Guan Yu's pride to capture Jingzhou and kill Guan Yu.

    After that, Liu Bei launched an army of 700,000 to take revenge, but was burned by Lu Xun, and Liu Bei fell seriously ill, and later died with Cao Cao. It is hoped that the three kingdoms can unite in heaven to create a peaceful and prosperous world.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    In a word: Jingxiang's rich land, threatening Sun Quan and containing Cao Cao, is a place where soldiers must fight, so Cao Cao and Sun Quan both want it. Zhuge Liang said in "Longzhong Pair":

    The general is the emperor's family, Xinyi is written in the four seas, the heroes are generalized, the sage is thirsty, if there are Jing and Yi, protect its rock resistance, the west and Zhurong, the south Fu Yiyue, the outside of Sun Quan, the internal cultivation of political affairs; If there is a change in the world, then a general will be ordered to bring the army of Jingzhou to Xiang Wan and Luo, and the general will lead the people of Yizhou out of Qinchuan. If this is the case, then the hegemony can be achieved, and the Han family can be prosperous. ”

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    Jingzhou is a place of contention, and it is inevitable to fight.

Related questions
21 answers2024-07-24

The story of the Three Kingdoms is very exciting, heroes and heroes abound, but everyone's fate or result will be embarrassing, and some will be praised, which is different. Of course, there are also many controversial plots in the middle, such as Guan Yu's defeat in Maicheng and his attack by Sun Quan and Cao Cao, why didn't Liu Bei send reinforcements at that time? >>>More

18 answers2024-07-24

In my opinion, I think Liu Bei is better for Guan Yu, because Cao Cao himself belongs to a treacherous and cunning person, he will not be sincere to anyone, he is actually a relatively big traitor in this country, and Liu Bei is Guan Yu's master, so he will treat him better.

27 answers2024-07-24

Cao Cao's poetry, martial arts, politics, and military affairs are very powerful. >>>More

6 answers2024-07-24

Cao Cao implements the meritocracy system, no matter how good or bad you are, as long as you have the talent to learn, you can apply, the advantage is that there are many talents, the enterprise develops rapidly, but the character of the talent is not good, it will bring a bad image to the enterprise. >>>More

9 answers2024-07-24

It has little to do with it, because its image was mythologized after the Song Dynasty, and Buddhism and Taoism flourished during the Song Dynasty.