If Mi Fang and Liu Feng went all out to rescue Guan Yu, can Guan Yu really break out of the encircle

Guan Yu should be able to fight his way out of the encirclement, and maybe the battle of Xiangfan will not be defeated.

1. Guan Yu launched the Battle of Xiangfan until Guan Yu was killed.

After Liu Bei captured Hanzhong, Guan Yu was also very happy, and in order to celebrate himself, he privately launched the Battle of Xiangfan. At the beginning, Guan Yu was indeed very heroic, and he broke several cities of Cao Wei in a row. Later, the Seventh Army was flooded and captured by the forbidden Pang Dewei shocked Huaxia, and even Cao Cao almost gave up the land of Xiangfan at that time.

By this time, Guan Yu's battle of Xiangfan was relatively smooth. When Guan Yu was captured, he captured many horses, so he asked Liu Feng to send troops to support. However, Liu Fengyi did not receive an order not to support Guan Yu.

At this time, the rear Eastern Wu privately allied with Cao Wei and sent Lü Meng to cross the river in white clothes to attack Jingzhou. At that time, because Liu Feng was unwilling to send troops, Guan Yu had to transfer troops from Jingzhou by himself, resulting in too few soldiers and horses in Jingzhou. Guan Yu also didn't expect that Dongwu would attack Jingzhou, and Jingzhou was lost by surprise.

At this time, Cao Cao sent Xu Huang to support Cao Ren, and at this time, Lu Meng was attacked on three sides, and finally Guan Yu was defeated and Maicheng was killed by Ma Zhong. <>

Second, if Mi Fang and Liu Feng support Guan Yu to rescue Guan Yu, then Guan Yu will not be able to die, and the Battle of Xiangfan may still be won.

Mi Fang was Guan Yu's logistics unit at that time, specifically responsible for Guan Yu's logistics, and also served as the task of garrisoning Jingzhou. But Mi Fang has always been at odds with Guan Yu, because Guan Yu looks down on him. So he was not active in the matter of logistics, and when Lu Meng called, he surrendered directly.

If Liu Feng supports Guan Yu, then Guan Yu's troops will definitely not be so lacking, even if Xu Huang comes, he will not be afraid. <>

And there is no need to transfer troops from Jingzhou to the front, at this time, if Mi Fang also fully supports Guan Yu, does not surrender to Lu Meng, and does not hold out, then Guan Yu will not suffer from the enemy on his back. Moreover, with Jingzhou's troops, he could barely resist Lu Meng for a while. Lu Meng is here, Guan Yu can return to the defense as soon as possible, or send troops to support.

Even if the front line loses, at least Guan Yu has a place to retreat, and he will not be killed. Guan Yu died at that time, mainly because there was nowhere to retreat.

Not necessarily. At that time, Guan Yu had been jointly besieged and killed by Cao Wei and Eastern Wu, in contrast, Mi Fang and Liu Feng had limited military strength, even if they fully supported Guan Yu, they might not be able to succeed, and it was very likely that they would end up with Guan Yu.

OK. In this way, Cao Cao didn't dare to act rashly, and Cao Cao's health was not very good, so he might be able to succeed if he dragged it out a little longer.

can fight out of the encirclement, Guan Yu failed because his troops are too small, if you add Liu Feng's soldiers and horses, you can fight your way out of the encirclement.

Yes, because without Mi Fang's surrender, the soldier's heart will not be scattered, and if Liu Feng's support is added, Guan Yu will definitely be able to fight his way out of the encirclement.

Liu FengNo rescueGuan YuThere are three reasons why:

1. Not long after Shangyong City was captured, there were still signs of rebellion in the city, and the local wealthy families Shen Tan and Shen Yi were even more inclined to Cao Wei.

This point was clearly shown in the anti-water immediately after Meng Da brought the Wei soldiers to come, if Liu Feng sent troops to help Guan Yu, it was possible that the backyard would catch fire and hurt himself. Liu Feng didn't dare to leave rashly, so he didn't dare to send troops to rescue Guan Yu at all.

2, Liu Feng and Meng Da are not in harmony, the two are fighting for power, whoever goes to help Guan Yu is equivalent to giving up the control of Shangyong, Liu Feng and Meng Da are not fools, they naturally don't want to be the one who was sent out.

3, Liu Feng opposed Liu Bei because of Guan Yu.

let Liu Feng inherit the great cause, so Liu Feng was dissatisfied, so he refused to save Guan Yu.

Character Analysis:

Guan Yu was defeated and killed in Maicheng, and Liu Bei resented him very much. Meng Da was afraid of sin and surrendered to Wei. With Xu Huang.

Waiting for the army to attack Shangyong, he repaired the book to Liu Feng and persuaded Liu Feng to surrender to Wei. Liu Feng was furious and pulled the book to behead. During the decisive battle, he failed to flee due to internal rebellion and fled back to Chengdu.

Liu Bei and Guan Yu are like brothers, if he asks for help at a critical moment, Liu Feng and Meng Da probably won't refuse so happily, but when Guan Yu asked them to send troops, it was the side that had the upper hand, if it wasn't for Eastern Wu.

stabbing a knife in the back, Guan Yu will not end up defeated no matter what, so Liu Feng and Meng Da are not in a hurry to send troops.

After all, no matter how much they wanted to break their heads, they couldn't imagine that things would eventually come to such a result. It is precisely because of this that Meng Da was "afraid of crime" after the incident and switched to Cao Wei.

Liu Feng did not send troops to save Guan Yu for four reasons:

1. Liu Feng did not have the authority to send troops without authorization.

After Liu Bei established himself as the king of Hanzhong, he gave Guan Yu the power to fake Jieyue and handed over all the affairs of Jingzhou to Guan Yu, but Liu Feng obviously did not have such an honor. Liu Feng is only a deputy general, and in addition, he is Liu Bei's righteous son, and since Liu Chan was born, his position has been quite embarrassing. If he directly sent troops without Liu Bei's consent at this time, it was likely to arouse Liu Bei's suspicion or be slandered by others.

Second, Shangyong has just been annexed not long ago, and it is easy to have accidents.

The Battle of Xiangfan took place in the twenty-fourth year of Jian'an, that is, in 219 AD, when Liu Feng and Meng Da won Shangyong, which was also the year. Moreover, in order to win people's hearts, Liu Bei let the original Shangyong Taishou Shen Tan and his younger brother Shen Yi take important positions. If Liu Feng easily dispatched Shangyong's soldiers and horses to help Guan Yu, then something would likely happen in Shangyong City.

Therefore, Liu Feng did not dare to act rashly.

3. Liu Feng and Meng Da are at odds, and the two are fighting for power.

Liu Bei sent the guards to Shangyong, not only Liu Feng, but also Meng Da, who laid down Shangyong with Liu Feng. Although these two people are colleagues, they are not convinced by each other. According to records, in order to suppress Meng Da, Liu Feng once seized Meng Da's set of propaganda honor guards, and the contradiction between the two intensified again.

When Guan Yu asked for help, it was impossible for the two of them to go together, and at the critical moment of the struggle for power, whoever helped Guan Yu was equivalent to giving up the control of Shangyong.

Fourth, when Guan Yu asked for help, he was not in danger.

Liu Bei and Guan Yu are brothers, if he asks for help at a critical moment, Liu Feng and Meng Da probably won't refuse so happily, but when Guan Yu asked them to send troops, they were the one who had the upper hand, if it wasn't for Dongwu stabbing him in the back, Guan Yu would not have ended up defeated no matter what, so Liu Feng and Meng Da were not in a hurry to send troops.