Wei Yan rebelled against Shu, in addition to his own reasons, how much responsibility did Zhuge Lian

In Wei Yan's personal opinion, it was not treason, it was just an internal contradiction in Shu Han. But Zhuge Liang has indeed been on guard against Wei Yan.

1. Although Wei Yan was a general in the late Shu Han Dynasty, he was always guarded by Zhuge Liang.

Wei Yan was Liu Bei's general who entered Sichuan and surrendered to Liu Bei, Liu Bei attached great importance to him, for example, when Liu Bei captured Hanzhong, everyone thought that Zhang Fei should be stationed in Hanzhong, and as a result, Wei Yan was stationed. But Zhuge Liang thinks that Wei Yan has a backbone, and he will definitely rebel in the future, which is the beginning of the grudge between the two. After Liu Bei's death, the Shu Han regime was controlled by Zhuge Liang, and although Zhuge Liang also reused Wei Yan, he was always wary of Wei Yan.

Later, during the Northern Expedition, Wei Yan proposed the "Meridian Valley Strategy", he wanted to take 5,000 elite soldiers to detour from the Meridian Valley, directly attack Chang'an, and then make peace with Zhuge Liang in Tongguan. Zhuge Liang refused because he was too risky to use this strategy, and Wei Yan proposed this plan several times, but Zhuge Liang never did. Wei Yan said that Zhuge Liang was cowardly and timid, and his talent could not be shown.

So in Wei Yan's eyes, Zhuge Liang is the one who suppresses himself and prevents his talent from being displayed. This is the contradiction between Wei Yan and Zhuge Liang. <>

Second, Wei Yan is not treason, but an internal contradiction in Shu Han.

Zhuge Liang held a small meeting before he died, and Wei Yan was not among them. Zhuge Liang said to Yang Yi and others, after you die, you will take my body back to Chengdu, let Wei Yan break off, Jiang Wei is second, if Wei Yan doesn't listen, just go with him. After Zhuge Liang's death, Wei Yan really didn't listen to Zhuge Liang's orders, thinking that the Northern Expedition could not withdraw the army because of the death of one person, and he Wei Yan could do the same.

Yang Yi and the others ignored Wei Yan and retreated quietly, and after Wei Yan found out, he led his troops to retreat first, and burned the road and bridge. <>

Yang Yi wrote a letter saying that Wei Yan was treason and rebellion, so Wei Yan was killed. At that time, Yang Yi said that Wei Yan was going to surrender to Cao Wei's villain Shu Han, and I personally felt that this was unreasonable. If Wei Yan wants to surrender to Cao Wei, why don't he just break off the front line, isn't it more convenient to surrender?

Why do you want to withdraw your troops and return to Chengdu to expose yourself to the enemy? And Yang Yi and Wei Yan have long had personal grievances, which I think is unreliable. Wei Yan's mutiny was just to compete with Yang Yi for power, which belonged to the internal contradictions of Shu Han.

If Zhuge Liang hadn't suppressed Wei Yan so much, Wei Yan's anger and resentment would not have been so heavy, and he might not have mutinied, so it had something to do with Zhuge Liang.

Zhuge Liang is also partly responsible, he did not manage his subordinates well, but betrayed the country.

Zhuge Liang said that Wei Yan had a backbone in the back of his head, and Wei Yan was Liu Bei's most trusted in his later years, and became the leader of Shu State, except for Zhuge Liang, no one else could match, which caused Wei Yan's character to be arrogant, and the two had too deep grievances, which eventually led to a turn against each other, and Wei Yan rebelled.

I think Zhuge Liang's responsibility is also very great, because Zhuge Liang has always believed in his heart that Wei Yan will rebel, and has always suppressed Wei Yan everywhere, does not reuse Wei Yan, and is wary of Wei Yan everywhere, causing Wei Yan to feel that he has no status in the army, and over time he has different intentions.

No, Wei Yan has no backbone in the back of his head at all, that's just Lao Luo's description. There is no record of it in the official history. Then why was Wei Yan looked down on by Zhuge Liang?

Just because he first did Liu Biao and Liu Brown, then Han Xuan, and then Xuande. Of course, Zhuge Liang disagreed, he was worried that he didn't know which day he would be killed by Wei Yan. Determined to behead the public.

Fortunately, he was rescued by Liu Bei, and later helped Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang to kill Zhou Yu, capture Xichuan, shoot Cao Cao in Hanzhong, capture Meng Shu seven times, and sacrifice the Meridian Valley and kill Wang Shuang. Wei Yan's contributions are not something that Zhuge Liang can erase if he wants to. His status in Shu is second only to that of the Five Tigers, but Zhuge Liang is still not worried about Wei Yan, otherwise how could Zhuge Liang not adopt the strategy of entering the Meridian Valley.

Later, after Zhuge Liang's death, Yang Yi escorted Zhuge Liang's coffin back to Chengdu. Wei Yan disagreed and was ready to lead the army to capture the Central Plains with Jiang Wei, but Yang Yi brought the whole army back to Shuzhong, which annoyed Wei Yan and forced him to burn the plank road. However, Yang Yi was later arrogant and said something that Liu Chan was dissatisfied with, and was reported by Fei Yi, but Yang Yi was ashamed and committed suicide.

Wei Yan is not rebelling, but relying on the wrong person, if he votes for Wei, he will definitely be reused with his martial arts and strategy.

Want. Because Zhuge Liang always felt that Wei Yan was anti-voluntary, he was in a state of embankment and arranged a lot of back-up hands to prevent Wei Yan from rebelling.

Definitely. Because Zhuge Liang hated Wei Yan very much and thought that Wei Yan had a backbone, Zhuge Liang was responsible for Wei Yan's killing.

Because the political ideas of Zhuge Liang and Wei Yan at that time were incompatible. Therefore, Zhuge Liang's apprentice finally killed Wei Yan.

This problem only exists in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, and does not exist in the official history. In the romance, Wei Yan did not get along with Kong Ming, but he did not switch to Wei, because Wei Yan was loyal to Liu Bei, and even if he rebelled in the end, he only seized power and continued the Northern Expedition, not betrayed Shu.

The reason why Wei Yan did not go to the Wei State. It was because the Shu State had already given him a very high salary, and Liu Bei asked him to serve as the Taishou of Hanzhong, so there was no need for him to switch to the Wei State.

I think the main reason is that he had some contradictions with the rulers of Wei, and those contradictions were the result of irreconcilable contradictions.

Zhuge Liang was worried that after his death, Wei Yan would not obey his orders to continue the Northern Expedition, but the situation at that time no longer allowed the Northern Expedition, and Zhuge Liang was afraid that Wei Yan would drag the Shu Kingdom down.

Because Zhuge Liang felt that Wei Yan was unruly, Shu Han might not be able to tolerate him in the future, and he might oppose Shu Han and bring great disasters to Shu Han, so he was determined to kill Wei Yan.

Zhuge Liang had no intention of killing Wei Yan, Wei Yan was killed by Yang Yi, if Wei Yan did not die, Shu Han would continue to fight, and the general direction of being destroyed by Wei would not change.

Because Wei Yan, a general, is brave, but he has a backbone in the back of his head, when Zhuge Liang dies, no one can control him in terms of seniority, so he must be eliminated.

Because of the problem of political power, he made up his mind to kill Wei Yan, because Wei Yan had no one in his eyes and was arrogant.

After Zhuge Liang's death, Jiang Wei had not yet grown up, and the power of Shu Han fell into the hands of Yang Yi. Yang Yi was narrow-minded and at odds with the arrogant Wei Yan, so there was a struggle for power. Before Zhuge Liang died, he confessed to Changshi Yang Yi, Sima Feiyi, and Jiang Wei, the protector, and others to retire after their deaths, and Wei Yan was responsible for the rear.

Wei Yan had soldiers in his hands, so he chose not to cooperate with Yang Yi, but took advantage of the main force of the army to retreat, and made a detour to catch up with the army. Wei Yan attacked the army led by Yang Yi, which can also be regarded as a rebellion. In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Wei Yan was later bequeathed by Zhuge Liang and asked Ma Dai to pretend to defect to Wei Yan, and when the two armies confronted each other, he took advantage of Wei Yan's unpreparedness and attacked and killed Wei Yan from behind.

The record in Chen Shou's Three Kingdoms is that the army led by Wei Yan was unwilling to confront the main force, and disbanded without listening to Wei Yan's orders. Therefore, the reason for Wei Yan's rebellion was his great ambition, and he wanted to be the boss after Zhuge Liang's death. Hope.

Because after Zhuge Liang's death, Wei Yan became the first general of Shu Han, but it was Yang Yi who succeeded Zhuge Liang, and Wei Yan refused to accept it and finally chose to rebel.

If we talk about the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, the main reason for Wei Yan's rebellion was that he wanted to go on a northern expedition and complete Zhuge Liang's legacy to make meritorious contributions to Dashu.

The pillars are gone, why not the opposite.

This is because Wei Yan stayed in Shu Han, which still had a certain role in promoting the development of Shu Han, he was a general who could take charge of Shu Han alone, and he was very loyal to Shu Han in the early stage.

Because Wei Yan was an excellent general and made a lot of contributions to Shu Han, Zhuge Liang kept him because he cherished the performance of talents.