Compared with Zhang Liao s Marquis of Jinyang and Guan Yu s Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion, who has a h

This Marquis of Jinyang and the Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion are not official positions but titles, and the title of Marquis of Jinyang is higher than that of Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion; But when it comes to the official positions of Guan Yu and Zhang Liao, the last official positions of the two are the same.

01, the Marquis of Jinyang is greater than the Marquis of Hanshouting. At the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty, it was divided into three kingdoms, so in the early days of the Three Kingdoms, most of their official positions and titles were not far from those in the Eastern Han Dynasty, and it was only when Emperor Wen of Wei that the title was awarded the ninth rank. Zhang Liao's Marquis of Jinyang or Guan Yu's Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion were actually sealed by Cao Wei, but Guan Yu was sealed by Cao Cao, while Zhang Liao was sealed by Cao Pi.

Guan Yu was named the Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion by Cao Cao because Guan Yu had a meritorious role in killing Yan Liang in the White Horse, while Zhang Liao was a Cao Pi who succeeded to the throne and read more of his merits and was named the Marquis of Jinyang.

The Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion is the Marquis of Ting, while the Marquis of Jinyang is the Marquis of County. In the Eastern Han Dynasty, it was very difficult to divide the title, because the ruler believed that too many titles were not conducive to the unity of the country, so this title was a rarity during the Three Kingdoms. There are four kinds of titles, namely county marquis, township marquis, pavilion marquis, and Guannei marquis.

Among them, the worst is the Hou of Guannei, there is nothing but a title, and then there is the Pavilion Hou, the Township Hou, the County Hou, the county Hou is the highest, Zhang Liao's Jinyang Hou's fief is Jinyang County, so it belongs to the County Hou, which is higher than Guan Yu's Tinghou.

02, on the official position, two people are half a catty and eight taels. Guan Yu was a famous general of Shu Han, while Zhang Liao was a famous general of Cao Wei. The two are very fateful, during the time when Guan Yu threw himself into Cao, Guan Yu and Zhang Liao had a good relationship, and the two also attacked the white horse together.

And one of the two was called one of the "Five Tiger Generals" in later generations, and the other was called one of the "Five Good Generals".

And the official positions of these two people are still the same level, Liu Bei proclaimed himself the king of Hanzhong, and appointed Guan Yu as the advance army, Zhang Liao was first appointed as the general of Zhengdong, and later was promoted to the general of Zuo. This General Zuo is an official position of the same level as the former general, and they both belong to the third-grade official position. It's a pity that both of them died relatively early, otherwise with the ability of the two of them, they could be hussar generals or even generals.

Zhang Liao is the Marquis of Jinyang of Cao Wei, and compared with the Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion of Guan Yu of Shu Han, Zhang Liao's position is higher, but in terms of real power, Guan Yu's real power is much higher than Zhang Liao's.

Zhang Liao's is higher, we can see from the name of their marquis alone. Zhang Liao is Jinyang, and Guan Yu is just Shouting, one is the place name and the other is the pavilion. It is not difficult to see that Zhang Liao is taller.

The Marquis of Jinyang is higher than the Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion, but they are not official positions, but titles, the Marquis of Jinyang is the county marquis, and the Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion is the Marquis of the Pavilion.

In "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", there is a story about Guan Yu's title.

At first, Guan Yu was named the Marquis of Shouting, but Guan Yu directly refused to accept it. Guan Yu said that his merits did not deserve such a title, but in fact, he was unwilling to accept it. Later, Cao Cao saw Guan Yu's intentions, so he revised the edict and named Guan Yu as the Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion.

Guan Yu refused to accept it, so he accepted it. This is too"Descend to Han and not to Cao"story.

<>However, it is not accurate to think that it is Hu Han Evil Shan Yu.

First of all, there is no information and record about Guan Yu in the "Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms", and the title of Guan Yu recorded in the "Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms" is the Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion.

Second, although there were various princes at that time, the royal family of the Han Dynasty was still the only accepted orthodoxy, so there was no need to add one to the title"Han"Word. Otherwise, when Cao Cao ascended the throne to welcome the Constitutional Emperor, he would not have been named Fei Tinghou, but Han Fei Tinghou.

Therefore, it can be confirmed that the statement of shouting Hanhou is incorrect.

This is a misunderstanding of Tinghou Hanshou.

That's a statement that most people agree with.

At the end of the Han Dynasty, the titles from large to small were county marquis, township marquis, and pavilion marquis.

Normally, the townsmen and pavilions will add their full names, that is, xx + townspeople, xx + pavilions, such as Cao Cao's Yue Jin is Guangchang Pavilion Marquis, and Yu Ban is Yishou Pavilion Marquis.

And the county marquis can be referred to as Hou, such as Cao Cao himself is the Marquis of Wuping, who is the Marquis of Wuping County.

Guan Yu's Hanshou Pavilion Marquis can obviously only be a Pavilion Marquis.

First of all, Cao Cao is the only county marquis who stands on Guan Yu's side, and it is impossible for Guan Yu to be the county marquis.

Second, the top general under Cao Cao was only the Pavilion Marquis, and Zhang Liao was not even the Pavilion Marquis, but the lower Guan Nei Hou.

From this point of view, since it is the Marquis of Ating, it is correct to think that it is the Marquis of Hanshou Ting.

The origin of the Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion. Yuan Shao sent generals Yan Liang, Chun Yuqiong, Guo Tu and others to attack Liu Yan, the Taishou of Dongjun, in Baima. Xun You put forward a strategy to rescue the white horse.

Cao Cao accepted Xun You's suggestion and personally led his army to the rescue. Yan Liang was shocked and hurriedly entered the battle. Cao Cao ordered Zhang Liao and Guan Yu to be the vanguard.

When Guan Yu saw that Yan Liang was under his command, he launched a charge and killed Yan Liang in the army. The generals of the Yuan clan were defeated, and Guan Yu was named the Marquis of Han.

The difference between these two titles is that they have different statuses, different powers, different abilities of representatives, different powers of representatives, different help to the country, and different roles they can play.

The official positions of these two people are not the same era, and there is no distinction between high and low. Both positions were honors of the highest generals at the time. It also has a lot of power.

Different names, different natures, different positions, different responsibilities, different treatments, and different levels.

The Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion was given to Guan Yu by Cao Cao. Many people think that the pavilion is such a small organization, so the official position should be very small. In fact, this official position is not very small, and the Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion is a title name, and the Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion at that time is also the lowest marquis in the highest level of the title - Pavilion Marquis.

First of all, as early as the Zhou Dynasty, there were six titles of "king, duke, marquis, earl, son, and male", that is, Zhou Tianzi was the king, and each vassal state was the title of "duke, marquis, uncle, son, and male". At that time, the Marquis could only be said to be an upper-middle title. However, after Liu Bang, the ancestor of the Han Dynasty, established the Western Han Dynasty, it was stipulated that non-Liu clans could not be crowned kings, and before Cao Cao was called the Duke of Wei, only Wang Mang was promoted to the Duke of An Han in the history of the Han Dynasty, so the duke was not established during the Han Dynasty.

Although the status of the pavilion marquis is lower than that of the county marquis and the township marquis, compared with the Guannei marquis, who did not have a feudal country and a food estate, the pavilion marquis had a certain food estate. That is to say, among the four grades of marquis, the marquis of Guannei is more of an honorary title, and the marquis of the county, the township, and the pavilion are not only an honor, but also have tangible benefits, which are reflected in the food. In the pre-Qin period, the food yi refers to the fields that the princes gave their ministers and doctors as Shilu, also known as caiyi, quarrying, and fiefdom.

The status of the pavilion marquis is lower than that of the county marquis and the township marquis, but they can have a certain amount of food. At that time, how many such food could Guan Yu, as a pavilion marquis, be shared? Take the Western Han Dynasty as a comparison, the pavilion marquis can be divided into 300 households, of course, at the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty, the princes divided each other, wars and other reasons, a small pavilion can get a share of the food is naturally going to shrink.

Therefore, the pavilion is not bad. However, Guan Yu's status at that time was relatively special, after all, Guan Yu was a person from Shu, and if Guan Yu did not work under Cao Cao, he would not be able to obtain hereditary qualifications, so Tinghou was just an honorary title for Guan Yu.

This official position is particularly high, essentially a kind of title, belonging to the administrative system, and only royal nobles or who have made very outstanding contributions to society can obtain this official title and title.

The Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion is just a title, such a title does not take on the task of the position, and is just a symbol of status.

Such an official position is equivalent to a military general at that time, and Guan Yu also fought the world with Liu Bei, so Liu Bei is still better for Guan Yu.

The title of the Marquis of Jinyang is higher than the title of the slag bridge of the Hanshou Pavilion, Jinyang belongs to the county level in the administrative unit at that time, and the Hanshou Pavilion belongs to the pavilion level, and the county side Liang mu level Kenyun Sending is greater than the pavilion level.

Zhang Liaolian's position as the Marquis of Jinyang will be higher; Because Jinyang is equivalent to a county penghu-level unit, and a small pavilion marquis has no way to compare with a county marquis of a large county like Annihilation.

The position of the Marquis of Jinyang is higher, this is because Guan Yu died relatively early, so there is not much power in his hands.

Guan Yu's Marquis of Hanshouting is a knighthood, not an official position, and it is already the third highest title for non-royal members.

Hanshou Pavilion is not an official position, but a title, a symbol of status, and this identity is officially certified, so Guan Yu cherishes it very much.

This is a knighthood, not an official position, the status is relatively high, and you can see how high the status is.

The Marquis of Hanshouting is the name of the title, not the name of the official position. put"Hanshou Pavilion Marquis"Taken apart as"Han"、"Shouting Hou"。said"Han"It's the Han Dynasty,"Shouting Hou"It is the name of Hou.

The Eastern Han Dynasty marquis system is no different from the Western Han Dynasty, but the scale of the Hou Kingdom is getting smaller and smaller, the big one is only four counties, and the small one only eats one pavilion. At the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty, Cao Cao placed the name of the Hou 18th level under the Liehou and the Guannei Hou, the 17th level of the Guanzhong Hou, the 16th level of the Guanwai Hou, and the 15th level of the Five Doctors Hou. In fact, Cao Cao's "Hanshou Pavilion Marquis" to Guan Yu is just an honorary title.

Book of the Later Han Dynasty Baiguan Zhi V: Liehou ......Those who have great merit eat the county, and those who are small eat the township and pavilion. It means that those who eat in the county, township, and pavilion in the liehou are called county candidates, township marquis, and pavilion marquis.

However, during the Three Kingdoms period, due to war, the titles awarded often had their titles, but there were no feudal countries. Generally, it is a reward for generals with military merits, and there are several households in the food estate, and they have the right to collect taxes according to the number of households. Guan Yu's Hanshou Pavilion Marquis is the lowest waiting in the highest level of the title-Pavilion Marquis.

Hanshou Pavilion Hou Guan Yu, how big is his official position, he has been using it for the rest of his life, but it is only an honorary title!

The one who made a mistake at the beginning of the dismantling was not "Hanshou Tinghou", but "Hanshou Tinghou". Hanshou is the name of the place, and the Marquis of Ting is the title.

The titles of marquis of the Han system can be divided into king, duke, county marquis, township marquis, pavilion marquis, and Guannei marquis according to their size. The rights of the three princes without Bozi are quite large, and they have absolute rights in their own territory. As for the marquis, the first three have fiefdoms, but they can only benefit from them, but they have no right to control their own fiefdoms.

County, township, pavilion all refer to the size of the fiefdom, but also refers to the dignity of the title, a pavilion is only ten miles, so the pavilion is not very large. Like Zhuge Liang is a marquis of Wuxiang, but not just a marquis, because his fiefdom is Wuxiang, but it is actually a county marquis, and he is a feudal marquis. In a sense, the county marquis is often referred to as the marquis of ten thousand households.

During the Three Kingdoms period, the Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion was the Marquis of the Dunei. The positions of the Marquis of Guannei and the Marquis of Duting are indeed very different - the way of listening to the dispatch is different, the ability to transfer troops and generals is different, and the degree of attention is different.

There are different ways of waiting for dispatches

It should be said that in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, what impressed us the most was Guan Yu's Hanshou Tinghou, because it was the embodiment of absolute loyalty in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, and Guan Yu's loyalty to Liu Bei was indeed praised by later generations.

Zhang Liao's Guan Nei Hou

Zhang Liao's position of Guannei Hou is actually much smaller than that of Hanshou Tinghou. In other words, Zhang Liao only has the power to obey the orders of others, but he does not have the power to dispatch troops by himself, and every time he encounters a major event or a huge battle in front of him, he must report to the imperial court, Cao Cao or his top boss!

Zhang He's capital pavilion marquis

Zhang He's official position at that time was called Dutinghou, and Dutinghou's position at that time was equivalent to the position of another general, and the position of the general was equivalent to the position of Zhao Yun, the general of the Five Tigers. This position is actually very high, in other words, Zhang He's position is much higher than Zhang Liao's position, which also proves that Duting Hou is much bigger than Guan Neihou. If these two are to be compared with Guan Yu's Hanshou Pavilion Marquis, it must be Guan Yu's Hanshou Pavilion Marquis who is the biggest, because Guan Yu can do his own thing, and he can cut it first and then play in front of some major things!

The tradition since the Han Dynasty is that non-military meritorious people are not allowed to be marquis, but Cao Cao coerced the Son of Heaven to order the princes and gradually broke this tradition, most of the generals under his command have titles, of course, the duke is impossible, since Wang Mang is the only Cao Cao who was named the Duke of Wei, so Cao Wei is basically a marquis, so Zhang Liao Guan Nei Marquis, Zhang Hedu Pavilion Marquis, Guan Yu Hanshou Pavilion Marquis, how big is the difference between these titles? Let's take a look at them one by one.

Zhang Liao Guan Nei Marquis, Zhang Hedu Pavilion Marquis, Guan Yu Hanshou Pavilion Marquis, how big is the difference between these titles?

The two Han Dynasty followed the Qin 20-rank marquis system, of which the nineteen-level Guannei Marquis, the twentieth level Che Marquis (renamed the Liehou in order to avoid the Han Wu Emperor Liu Che) are the two highest titles (of course, the Western Han Dynasty set up a higher prince above the marquis), the Liehou is divided into three levels of county marquis, township marquis, and pavilion marquis.

So what is Du Tinghou? Du Tinghou is also a kind of Tinghou, "all those who say are pavilions, and the pavilions in the city." "Because the inhabitants of the city have better material living conditions than the inhabitants outside the city, he can be treated better for the recipient, but the rank may be slightly lower than that of the Tinghou, here are two examples that may illustrate one or two.

Zhang Liao Guan Nei Marquis, Zhang Hedu Pavilion Marquis, Guan Yu Hanshou Pavilion Marquis, how big is the difference between these titles?

First, Cao Cao's five sons were knighted as the earliest, as early as 194 he was named the Marquis of Guangchang Pavilion, and Yu Ban was awarded the title of Yishou Pavilion Marquis in 197 for his meritorious service in the Battle of Wancheng, the original two had a difference in food, but in 216 the two of them were 1200 households; Zhang Liao was named the Marquis of Guannei when he surrendered, and in 206 he was made the Marquis of Duting, while Xu Huang and Zhang He were also Marquis of Duting. Judging from 216 years, on the one hand, Zhang Liao, Xu Huang, and Zhang He are not as good as Yu Ban's Zuo General and Lejin's Right General, and on the other hand, the three of them are also much worse than Yu Ban and Lejin's Tinghou 1,200 households.