The new version of the four famous novels compares who is better than the old version

Romance of the Three Kingdoms: The old version is in line with the original work, and the acting skills are superb, but it is semi-literary; I didn't read the new version because I didn't like it, but I just read some comments, and there were more picks;

Dream of Red Mansions: The old version is very in place in terms of staffing or something, although some of them have not been performed, but on the whole, it is much stronger than the new version, and the new version has not been watched directly, and I don't like the atmosphere and personnel.

Water Margin: Now I directly hate Song Jiang very much, why do you want to recruit An, it can be seen that the old version of the actor acted more expressively, and I didn't watch the new version, but it seems that the evaluation is better than the new version of Romance of the Three Kingdoms and Dream of Red Mansions;

For me.

The new gravitational pull of the old version is greater.

The new version is for me.

That's ruining China's masterpieces.

Everyone's styling.

It's all thunderous. The merits of the new edition.

It's better than the old one in terms of stunts.

It's also more perfect.

But for the strength of the actors.

And. A test of acting skills.

The old version is still better.

The People's Literature Publishing House and Zhonghua Book Company are better. The books published by these two companies are not only authoritative and rigorous, but also have great advantages over others in terms of font teaching accuracy and browsing and reading. Four Masterpieces:

It is "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", "Water Margin", "Journey to the West", and "Dream of Red Mansions". These four works have endured for a long time and are rare classics in the history of Chinese literature. The stories, scenes, and characters have deeply influenced the ideological concepts and value orientation of the Chinese.

All four works have a high literary level and artistic achievements. The meticulous portrayal and the profound ideas contained in it have been praised by readers of all generations. It is one of the four great monuments in the history of Chinese literature.

The status of these four masterpieces in the history of Chinese literature is indistinguishable.

1. People's Literature Publishing House.

Founded in Beijing in March 1951, it is a state-level professional literary publishing institution and is now a member of China Publishing Group Corporation.

In addition to publishing a large number of books under the name of the People's Literature Publishing House, it has also used the Writers Publishing House (1953-1958, 1960-1969), the Art Publishing House (1953-1956), the Literature and Ancient Books Publishing House (1954-1957, 1987-1989), the Chinese Drama Publishing House (1954-1979), and the Foreign Literature Publishing House (1979-2009) to publish various literary and artistic books.

2. Guangming ** Publishing House.

Guangming ** Publishing House (hereinafter referred to as "Guangming Society") was founded on January 10, 1981, and belongs to the Guangming ** Society (Group) sponsored by the Communist Party of China, which was transformed into an enterprise legal person on December 30, 2010, and is the executive director unit of the Publishers Association of China.

The most outstanding of the four masterpieces is "Dream of Red Mansions".

Extended information: "Dream of Red Mansions", alias "Stone Records", etc., ancient Chinese chapter hui style long **, one of the four classical Chinese classics, a total of 120 times, most people think that the first 80 times are written by the Qing Dynasty writer Cao Xueqin, the last 40 times the author is anonymous, and the organizers are Cheng Weiyuan and Gao E. **With the rise and fall of the four major families of Jia, Shi, Wang, and Xue as the background, from the perspective of the rich and noble son Jia Baoyu, and with the love and marriage tragedy of Jia Baoyu and Lin Daiyu and Xue Baochai as the main line, it depicts the life of some boudoir beauties, showing the real beauty of human nature and tragic beauty, which can be said to be an epic work that shows the beauty of women and ancient Chinese society from all angles.

The Dream of Red Mansions version has two systems: 120 "Cheng Ben" and 80 "Fat Ben". The Cheng book is a typeset copy by Cheng Weiyuan, and the lipo copy is an early manuscript copied and commented by Yan Zhai at different times. The fat book is the base of the Cheng book.

Dream of Red Mansions is a world-influential encyclopedia of human feelings, Chinese feudal society, and a collection of traditional culture. The author of the book exhorts himself to "talk about love and record his affairs", only according to his own situation, follow the traces, get rid of the old clichés, fresh and chic, and have achieved extraordinary artistic achievements. The special penmanship of "the truth is hidden, and the false words are preserved" has opened the minds of later readers, and there have been many speculations over time.

Since the beginning of the 20th century, Dream of Red Chambers, with its rich and profound ideological heritage and outstanding artistic achievements, has given rise to a specialized study in the academic circles that it is the object of study.

Synopsis. "Dream of Red Mansions" tells the story of the Zhuzhu fairy on the bank of the Western Spirit River, on the bank of the Sansheng Stone, in order to repay the irrigation grace of the Shenying attendants, to repay the tears of his life, he went down to the mortal calamity. Baoyu is the reincarnation of the Shenying attendant, and Lin Daiyu is the reincarnation of the Zhuzhu fairy, and this marriage is called the "Wood and Stone Alliance".

The stubborn stone left by the ancient Nuwa refining stone to make up for the sky, psychic, is the "Tongling Jade" titled by Jia Baoyu when he was born, and the story of "Tongling Jade" experiencing the bitter sorrows and joys of the world is "The Story of the Stone", that is, "Dream of Red Mansions".

"Dream of Red Mansions", the first of the four famous novels, is unparalleled in terms of literature and aesthetics.

The first of the four famous novels "Dream of Red Mansions".

Today, I have nothing to do, browsing on the Internet, and accidentally saw a set of books, which are China's four famous novels "Water Margin", "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", "Dream of Red Mansions" and "Journey to the West", which are sold in sets and priced at 99 yuan.

Lao Yan speculated that many friends were a little drumming in their hearts against this **: Could this be a pirated book? This ** is not too high, but too low.

Because each of the four famous books is hundreds of thousands of words, for example, Dream of Red Mansions has more than 730,000 words. If it is a contemporary ** of the ordinary Ming bureau cover, 730,000 words are printed in fascicles, then ** is also more than 200 yuan. If the four famous works are published in this way, it should be around 1,000 yuan.

However, Laying is only sold for 99 yuan here, which is equivalent to a few catties of pork and a few boxes of cigarettes. Lao Yan generally smokes cigarettes for 16 yuan, and 6 boxes of cigarettes can buy a set of four famous books.

As an industry insider, Lao Yan solemnly tells you: If there are really pirated books of the four famous books, sell them for 99 yuan per set, and you will definitely lose money. However, genuine books do not lose money, and there is a proper profit. Why is that?

Lao Yan calls himself an industry insider because he used to work in a publishing house. Publishing house is an all-round profession, involving the whole process of a book from writing to printing and distribution, so when you come back to a publishing house, you are basically familiar with the entire publishing industry.

Lao Yan still doesn't brag about how professional he is, let's talk about why genuine books can be so low. First of all, the four famous books are public editions. The so-called public version of the book is a book that does not require payment of manuscript fees.

According to China's copyright laws, 50 years after the death of the author, his work becomes a public book, and the authors of the four famous works have all passed away for more than 200 years, and the publisher does not have to pay their descendants for manuscripts. According to the current market price of about 200 yuan per thousand words, the book Dream of Red Mansions alone can save nearly 150,000 yuan. The four famous works add up to more than 3 million words, saving more than 600,000 yuan in manuscript fees.

If it is a contemporary book, it needs to be edited from beginning to end, correcting typos, standardizing the style, replacing the correct sayings, and so on. After that, it is necessary to proofread the staff, and the department director, deputy editor-in-chief and editor-in-chief review, which is what the industry calls three reviews and three proofreadings. Finally, the president of the publishing house also has a pre-press scramble review.

After these processes, there will definitely be costs, that is, editing and review fees at all levels from the president to the president. According to the different levels of the publishing house, the editing fee is high and low, the lowest is about 50 yuan per thousand words, and the highest is more than 200 yuan per thousand words, which is equivalent to the manuscript fee standard.

If calculated according to 100 words per 1,000 words, it takes 300,000 yuan to edit and review the four famous works. However, all the texts of the four famous works are finalized, and if there are typos or sick sentences, they have either been corrected by their predecessors long ago, or they have been treated as fake characters or the like. Therefore, the editing and review process was reduced and 300,000 yuan was saved.

The next step is to typeset the text. If it is a contemporary book, all the typography should be designed from scratch and corrected page by page. Because the specifications are different, ** is also different, on average, about 50 yuan per page.

If the four famous works are typeset according to 16, each page is about 600 words, and this item requires about 250,000 yuan.

It depends on the personal hobby, if the quality of the mouse is well preserved, there is a certain collection value.

The People's Literature Publishing House and the Copying Zhonghua Book Company are the best, one is authoritative, and the other is rigorous. If you are engaged in book collection or you are a lover of literature, it is best to choose the above ones.

I have also seen books published by other publishing houses, most of which have shortcomings, mainly in the following ways:

1. The font size is small, and the content of hundreds of times is only bound in a large book, which is too thick and extremely inconvenient to read. 2. There is no preface, no postscript, no publication note. Which version is not indicated.

In fact, this is a matter of common sense that publishers should have, but they ignore it. For example, "Dream of Red Mansions" has 12 editions such as Cheng Jiaben, which should be indicated) I never buy a book without a preface or afterword, because from this question it can be seen whether the publisher is rigorous and trustworthy.

3. No annotations.

4. There are typos. There are also typos in the genuine version, and the proofreading is not serious.

For the same amount of money, you should buy an authoritative publishing house. Also, don't pay attention to the packaging when buying books. In fact, the books published by authoritative publishing houses do not pay attention to packaging, such as the cover design of books published by the People's Literature Publishing House, most of which are simple and clear, or even only inscribe the title of the book, without a pattern.

But it is the most readable and collectible. Readers should have more common sense about buying books).

The collector's edition published by the People's Publishing House is better, and the edition published by the Shanghai Ancient Books Publishing House is also better, not the luxury edition. Zhonghua Book Company and Yuelu Publishing House are also good.

Buy the older version, the pre-90s version.

The People's Literature Publishing House and Zhonghua Book Company have produced the best, one is authoritative, and the other is rigorous. If you are a book collector or you are a literature lover, it is best to choose the above ones.

It is suggested that you can consider Sanmin Bookstore.