The scheming Sima Yi, why did Zhuge Liang s empty city plan?

Updated on history 2024-02-18
18 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Personally, I think Sima Yi was too cautious to be confused by Zhuge Liang's empty city plan, because the situation at that time was very clear. Zhuge Liang is on the offensive. He went out of Qishan and attacked the Northern Wei Dynasty, but he didn't want to be lost by Ma Tan, so he had to retreat.

    When Sima Yi attacked Xicheng, Zhuge Liang only had more than 2,000 troops around him, while Sima Yi had 150,000 troops. Before that, Zhuge Liang attacked the Northern Wei Dynasty at the beginning, and the momentum was like a bamboo, killing Wei generals all the way, capturing the city, and <>

    The Wei army was exhausted by Shu, and the people were panicked, and the Northern Wei government and the opposition were terrified of Zhuge Liang's ferocious offensive. Of course, the Wei soldiers on the battlefield were more afraid. Unexpectedly, in the battle of Jieting, the Wei State turned the tide of the war in one fell swoop, the defensive turned into an offensive, and the Shu army had to retreat from the battlefield.

    The battlefield was gradually moving in favor of Wei, and the commanders were convinced. But it's time to fight. In the face of Zhuge Liang, who has always been cautious and cautious, Sima Yi had to be equally careful.

    Leading the army against Zhuge , Sima Yi planned the battle situation, dispatched troops, and speculated on the opponent's next move.

    Every time he fights, he has to be cautious, because he is facing Zhuge Liang who has a resourceful mechanism. Once lost, it is a sinner through the ages, and now facing Kong Ming who is sitting on the opposite side of the chess table, a lupine scarf, looking at Sima Yi with a smile, the soldiers have arrived in the city, but Zhuge Liang is still not impatient, playing the piano, this kind of practice seems to be inviting the king into the urn, Sima Yi has to think about whether there is fraud in the face of such a scene, because he does not want to attack it, but he is caught in the urn. Of course, this is my idea, and there is also a saying that Zhuge Liang was blocked in the empty city by Sima Yi when he retreated, and at this time, Zhuge Liang stroked the piano at the head of the city to give Sima Yi another signal, if Zhuge Liang died, <>

    Sima Yi will definitely be the same as before and will not be reused, that is to say, Sima Yi's role at that time was used to attack Zhuge Liang, and if Zhuge Liang died, then his role would come to an end. As a wise man in the world, Sima Yi also understood this truth, and withdrew his troops by means of an empty city plan.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Sima Yi is really interesting, I think he is a person who does not play cards according to the routine, so he is afraid that Zhuge Liang will not play cards according to the routine like him, and in the end, of course, he can only choose to be conservative and not attack the city.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Because he is too suspicious, coupled with Zhuge Liang's usual image, he is the kind of person who is comfortable and has a bamboo in his chest, which makes people feel that there will be danger inside, so he will be recruited.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    I think this is actually a psychological war between the two, and the two are very familiar with each other's personality traits, which shows that whoever grasps each other's minds more accurately will win.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    What? He also knew that Zhuge Liang was setting up an empty city plan, but he also knew that if there was no Zhuge Liang, he would not have the meaning of existence, he was to protect himself.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Although Sima Yi is resourceful, he is also suspicious by nature, and Zhuge Liang's image of knowing astronomy and geography in people's hearts makes people can't help but suspect that there must be an ambush in this empty city.

  7. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Sima Yi was suspicious by nature, he wasn't sure if he could come out of the city this time, so he would rather retreat than risk his life to attack the city, which was also due to the character's personality.

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Because this is a duel between two smart people, Zhuge Liang took advantage of Sima Yi's suspicion, Sima Yi was too suspicious and conceited, so it led to Zhuge Liang's empty city plan when he was smart but was mistaken by cleverness.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Although Sima Yi is a scheming man, he has fought with Zhuge Liang many times, and every time Zhuge Liang can turn the crisis into an opportunity to fight back, he has a lot of means, so Sima Yi did not dare to use troops aggressively, and finally fell into Zhuge Liang's empty city plan.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    I think Sima Yi really saw through Zhuge Liang's empty city plan, of course, this is only analyzed from the perspective of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms". If we analyze it from a real historical perspective, the empty city plan itself is not Zhuge Liang's masterpiece, so we have no way to analyze it from a historical perspective.

    So at this time, Sima Yi was also shocked, and after thinking about this, Sima Yi simply pretended not to see the empty city plan, and then turned around and ran, which gave Zhuge Liang a chance, and it could be regarded as giving himself a chance to continue to live. Of course, in fact, this is just ** or some fictional plots in the TV series, there is no such thing in real history, at least in real history, the empty city plan is definitely not Zhuge Liang's strategy, but the strategy of Zhao Yun, another general of Shu Han.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    In fact, with Sima Yi's wisdom, he should be able to see that it was an empty city plan, but for the sake of his own status, he pretended not to know.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    Didn't see through. Sima Yi was bewildered by Zhuge Liang's empty city plan, and he thought that Zhuge Liang had arranged an ambush.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    Yes, he did see through Zhuge Liang's empty city plan, but in order to leave a way back for himself, he pretended to be a plan.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    Yes. Sima Yi also knew about this last struggle, and decided to let Zhuge Liang go once, which also occupied the role of a weak heart.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    Sima Yi obviously saw through the siege boundary, why didn't he expose Zhuge Liang? The truth is emotional.

    Zhuge Liang's siege plan was so simple, but Sima Yi chose to retreat, and the truth behind it was staggering.

    As the saying goes, heroes come out of troubled times, and many heroes have emerged in this era of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. The most representative are Cao Cao and Liu Bei. The duel between Liu Bei and Cao Cao also contributed a lot of wonderful highlights, and as the leader, they naturally have good helpers in their hands.

    The most representative are Sima Yi under Cao Cao and Zhuge Liang under Liu Bei.

    I believe that many friends are very excited about the duel between Zhuge Liang and Sima Yi. Back then, Sima Yi snatched the street pavilion, which made Zhuge Liang very distressed. At this time, Zhuge Liang had no soldiers to use, and in the end he could only perform the siege plan, and he sat alone on the city wall and played the piano.

    In a very tense environment, there was no terrible color, and you could still hear the people singing on the street. (on the other hand).

    Sima Yi was shocked to see this sight, and he was afraid that the city would be ambushed, so he eventually withdrew all his officers. Zhuge Liang waited forcefully for his volunteers to arrive. Here, we can see that Zhuge Liang's plan is on Sima Yi, and thinking about it again, there is another question, didn't Sima Yi notice it?

    In fact, is this a blank city plan?

    In fact, he has already noticed that through Sima Yi's future performance, we can know the truth. Sima Yi is a brave and strategic man. He was even above Zhuge Liang, and Sima Yi's rise represented the revival of his own family.

    Cao Cao's biggest threat is the Zhuge Liang we see. At this time, if Zhuge Liang is torn off, Zhuge Liang will be caught directly. It didn't seem to work to do this, but when he was outside at the time, he solved Zhuge Liang's henchman, and Sima Yi became useless.

    William Shakespeare, Hamlet) can only prosper if he opposes Zhuge Liang again. At this point, Sima Yi is a very caring person.

    He saw Zhuge Liang using siege plans, but did not produce Zhuge Liang's siege plans, which was a good thing for Zhuge Liang and a bad thing for himself. Zhuge Liang knew that Sima Yi would not attack, Sima Yi knew that Zhuge Liang was simply ambushed, and the two of them had fought on their backs to the point of a five-legged horse, this kind of person was terrifying.

    It can be seen from the following events that although Sima Yi suffered defeats many times, he finally defeated Zhuge Liang, and finally his son seized the entire country. Sima Yi's resourcefulness was originally above Zhuge Liang, let's take a look at the official position. Don't think that Sima Yi's failure can be judged by a blank urban system.

    In fact, he didn't lose, but he scored a big victory.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    Of course not. Sima Yi was also very smart, because Sima Yi's army had just experienced the war at that time and was very tired, so he planned and left.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    Because the two are both wise generals, and their strategies are roughly the same, Sima Yi has already seen through Zhuge Liang's strategy.

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-20

    Sima Yi is not a fuel-efficient lamp, his 200,000 troops cannot be withdrawn as soon as he says, since he does not dare to enter the city rashly, but he can also besiege without attacking, and it is not too late to attack after finding out the truth and reality.

Related questions
33 answers2024-02-18

Because after Zhuge Liang died of illness, Sima Yi also faced the contradictions between Cao Wei and the Sima family and the internal strife between the Sima family, and had no time to attack Shu.

5 answers2024-02-18

During the Three Kingdoms, the governor of Wei saw that this old boy was not pleasing to the eye, and he always opposed Zhuge Liang

17 answers2024-02-18

In ancient times, there was a word called chess opponents, two people are quite strong is a very lucky thing, after all, a person standing in a very high position, it is inevitable that there will be some loneliness, this feeling may be the most obvious in the Three Kingdoms era, because there are too many capable people, there are always capable two people fighting together, you can't destroy me, I can't destroy you. For example, Sima Yi and his enemy Zhuge Liang. >>>More

21 answers2024-02-18

It was Pang Tong who joined the battle against Sima Yi instead of Zhuge Liang, I think the ending may be rewritten, of course, it is only possible, and it is not necessarily that Sima Yi will lose to Pang Tong. We can know through "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" that Sima Yi in the battle with Zhuge Liang, in the end, Zhuge Liang died of illness, the army retreated, Sima Yi ended in victory, Zhuge Liang's several Northern Expeditions, and finally declared failure, and a generation of Zhixing also fell, which is really a pity. <> >>>More

21 answers2024-02-18

1, Guo Jia. This man is really smart! What a ghost! Wizard! All the tricks he made for Cao Cao were dangerous and strange moves, but they all succeeded! It's unpredictable to use troops. >>>More