If it wasn t Zhuge Liang who fought against Sima Yi, but Pang Tong, what would the result be?

It was Pang Tong who joined the battle against Sima Yi instead of Zhuge Liang, I think the ending may be rewritten, of course, it is only possible, and it is not necessarily that Sima Yi will lose to Pang Tong. We can know through "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" that Sima Yi in the battle with Zhuge Liang, in the end, Zhuge Liang died of illness, the army retreated, Sima Yi ended in victory, Zhuge Liang's several Northern Expeditions, and finally declared failure, and a generation of Zhixing also fell, which is really a pity. <>

Many people are conjecturing that if Pang Tong at that time was not killed by random arrows in Luofengpo, but had been assisting Liu Bei and had lived until the later stage, if he had fought against Sima Yi at that time, would the result be different from Zhuge Liang, and would he have finally defeated Sima Yi. Personally, I think there is still a possibility, after all, Pang Tong is different from Zhuge Liang, maybe Zhuge Liang can't cure Sima Yi, but Pang Tong may be able to. <>

We know that Zhuge Liang generally takes precautions, always budgeting for the losses in the process before the battle starts, so he strives to minimize the losses in each war. Therefore, the strategy of marching and fighting is generally very cautious, not seeking merit, but seeking no fault. It was Zhuge Liang, who has always been very cautious, that he was able to use the empty city plan to deceive Sima Yi.

And Pang Tong is different, Pang Tong likes to use tricks, that is, he likes to win by surprise, using people's unexpected tricks to quickly solve the battle, so if it is not Zhuge Liang against Sima Yi, but Pang Tong, the chance of winning against Sima Yi is still very high. <>

Of course, these are just our conjectures, history has become history, and the past is no longer repeated, so whether Pang Tong can really win Sima Yi, we can't get an accurate result, we just think that the probability is possible, but it also depends on the will of God, after all, Zhuge Liang had actually trapped Sima Yi with a fire, and he was already certain to die at that time, who would have expected that there would be a heavy rain in the sky, which extinguished the fire and saved Sima Yi.

A ruthless person like Pang Tong will definitely play Sima Yi to death. The main thing is that he is too strong, it can be said that it is particularly scary, and the winner is him.

The final result was nothing more than Pang Tong's death in the hands of Sima Yi, because the national strength of Shu at that time could not compete with Wei.

If this is the case, Shu will still perish, because the gap in military strength between Shu and Wei at that time is somewhat large and cannot be reversed.

There will be no change in the results, because they are all about the same in their wits and thinking, so there will not be much change.

Sima Yi is even more powerful, Pang Tong can't even compare to Zhuge Liang, Zhuge Liang is a person who can't do anything about Sima Yi, so Pang Tong can't be Sima Yi's opponent.

Naturally, it is Pang Tong, Sima Yi is already very difficult to deal with Zhuge Liang, not to mention Pang Tong, who is ten times stronger than Zhuge Liang, so Sima Yi is not an opponent.

If Pang Tong is allowed to face Sima Yi, maybe he will attack in some unexpected ways, but there is a problem that Pang Tong's death is that he was ambushed in his eagerness, and if some of his dangerous moves when attacking Sima Yi are discovered, it is very likely that it will have a fatal impact on himself. And Sima Yi is so forbearing, it may not be so easy for him to fall for Pang Tong easily.

Therefore, if Pang Tong really confronts Sima Yi, it is very likely that the confrontation between the two will not be as long as Zhuge Liang, and it is very likely that one of them will seize the flaws of the other party, or strike unexpectedly, and directly defeat the other party completely. Then in terms of the real win rate, it should also be a tie!

The strategists of the Three Kingdoms, Pang Tong and Sima Yi, Zhuge Liang are powerful, although Pang Tong and Zhuge Liang are equally famous.

As the saying goes, Wolong and phoenix chicks can settle the world with one piece, which shows how outstanding the strength of Zhuge Liang and Pang Tong is. In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Zhuge Liang made many Northern Expeditions, but they were unsuccessful, since Zhuge Liang faced Sima Yi and could not succeed in the Northern Expedition, if he was replaced by Pang Tong, would things change?

First of all, Zhuge Liang, in fact, Zhuge Liang is a political master, and he is also very good at managing the army, but his performance is mediocre in leading the army to fight. In the few battles before Liu Bei's death, Zhuge Liang was not seen, and Zhuge Liang was more in the rear to provide food and troop dispatch.

Sima Yi in the Cao Pi period, mainly reflected political talent, and later Cao Rui Cao Fang period, Sima Yi began to lead the army to fight, and later several wars with Zhuge Liang, it can also be seen that his army command ability is also okay.

And Pang Tong has a strong ability to deal with government affairs, and of course he also has a strategy, and he will be bolder than Zhuge Liang in using strategy. Liu Bei's entry into Xichuan was the plan designated by Pang Tong, and in addition, Pang Tong also participated in the serial plan of the Battle of Chibi.

If you compare these three people from the level of tactical strategy, the three people are about the same, the difference lies in the influence of personality on their tactical decisions, Zhuge Liang acts steadily, likes to fight steadily, and does not like to take risks, so Wei Yan's Meridian Valley strategy was denied; Sima Yi likes to admit cowardice, so Sima Yi often resorts to defensive battles to delay time, so that the Shu army retreats due to insufficient supplies; As for Pang Tong, he dared to take risks, and taking risks meant that failure might occur, so Pang Tong died in Luofengpo, but if Pang Tong participated in the Northern Expedition, there would be a great possibility of adopting Wei Yan's battle plan, and Wei Yan's combat talent would be fully brought into play under the leadership of Pang Tong, and it was possible to achieve the success of the Northern Expedition.

Pang Tong has a very strong ability to deal with government affairs, and he is also very strategic, and he will be more daring than Zhuge Liang in the use of strategy. In addition, Pang Tong also participated in the serial plan of the Battle of Red Cliffs. Although he excelled politically, his military prowess was far inferior to that of Zhuge Liang and Sima Yi, and he often failed to send troops to fight.

Sima Yi was in the Cao Pi period, mainly reflecting political talentWhen Sima Yicai began to lead the army to fight, after several wars with Zhuge Liang, he could also see that his army command ability was also possible. So I don't think Pang Tong can beat Sima Yi.

Moreover, Pang Tong likes to drink, and there is no rule for doing things casually and freely. This is the most important character to abandon when it comes to fighting wars。Although he was strategic, he lacked foresight and was not cautious enough in his marching troops.

And these are in stark contrast to Sima Yi. Therefore, Pang Tong and Sima Yi confronted each other on the battlefield, and the result can be imagined. If you compare these three people from the level of tactical strategy, the three people are about the same, and the difference lies in the influence of personality on their tactical decisions.

When Pang Tong took refuge in Liu Bei, he couldn't get Liu Bei's reuse at first. Because Liu Bei didn't know who this person was, Liu Bei sealed Pang Tong as a county official, and Pang Tong's work ability was very strong, and once Pang Tong completed a year's workload in just one day. was loved by the local people, and after Zhang Fei heard about it, he felt incredible, it must be Pang Tong's sloppy work, so he was so fast.

And Pang Tong is not under Zhuge Liang's talent, but Pang Tong can only give advice at most, if it comes to fighting with soldiers, Pang Tong is less than half of Zhuge Liang. It can be seen in the last battle of Pang Tong that Zhuge Liang wrote a letter to inform Pang Tong to be more careful of the terrain of Xichuan and be careful of ambushes, but Pang Tong did not listen, and finally died in the ambush of the enemy in Luofeng Slope.

At the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty, the struggle between relatives and eunuchs continued, the Han Dynasty declined, and the dynasty became increasingly corrupt. Then the Yellow Turban Rebellion broke out. In the battle to suppress the peasant uprising, Liu Bei entered the official career because of his military exploits.

But soon, General Cao Cao and General Dong Zhuo were defeated one after another, and the world situation gradually evolved into a war between the princes. Liu Bei ran around in the war of war, recovered Jingzhou after the Battle of Chibi, and later entered Shuchuan to attack Hanzhong, and finally established the Shu Han regime.

I think that if Pang Tong had fought against Sima Yi, Shu Han would not have been able to win.

First, the ability of the phoenix is worthy of our doubts

When Pang Tong first became a county official, he was accused of dereliction of duty. It can be seen that this person is very arrogant, which is very different from Kong Ming, his arrogance could not convince the generals, so Wei Yan dared to disobey Pang Tong's orders. In this way, can Mr. Feng Xiao duel with the wise man Sima Yi?

This is obviously impossible.

Second, Shu's domestic and foreign problems made it difficult for its national strength to compete with Wei.

In fact, the internal power of Shu was complex, such as Jingzhou Shizu, Yizhou Group, Eastern Zhou Old Ministry, etc., and these secret contradictory groups would exhaust Shu's internal strength. Zhuge Liang, as a prime minister, was able to balance the internal contradictions of Shu well, because he followed Liu Bei from the beginning and mastered the command ability. On the contrary, Pang Tong's "halfway monk" was unable to convince the public, which made it difficult for him to balance the various interest groups in Shu.

Shu itself is located in the south.

At that time, the economic center was still in the north. The national power of the southern countries could not compete with that of the Cao Wei Dynasty, which unified the Central Plains of North China. From individuals to countries, they all believed that if Pang Tong and Sima Yi fought, Shu Han would not be able to win.

If it is Pang Tong instead of Zhuge Liang who fights against Sima Yi, his chances of winning may not be great, because Sima Yi, Zhuge Liang, and Pang Tong, the three of them are almost the same in terms of battle strategy, but they are different in what they are good at.

For example, Sima Yi, he is good at politics and operational command ability, Zhuge Liang is good at psychological warfare, and he is also a political master. Pang Tong is better at handling government affairs, and he is comparable to Zhuge Liang in terms of strategy, but he is more daring than Zhuge Liang.

As far as the pure analysis of personal situations is concerned, all three of them are very strategic and capable people, and they are comparable in terms of strength. So if it is Pang Tong instead of Zhuge Liang who is fighting against Sima Yi, I don't think his chances of winning are necessarily big, after all, Pang Tong's combat command ability is not as strong as Sima Yi, but he is comparable to Zhuge Liang in terms of strategy, and his courage is still greater than Zhuge Liang.

In addition, the personalities of the three people are also different, each has its own advantages, and also has its own shortcomings, and making good use of the opponent's shortcomings can become the key to turning defeat into victory. We can boldly imagine that Sima Yi is fighting against Pang Tong scene, what I imagine is a draw, maybe Zhuge Liang will come to get involved, and the three of them will fight together, which will be more interesting.

It's still quite funny to imagine, but the scene must have been very tense at the time, after all, there were three giants, but if there was really this war, it would definitely be very interesting. To get back to the point, I think Sima Yi is fighting against Pang Tong instead of Zhuge Liang, and without the cooperation of the right time, place and people, Sima Yi's chances of winning are really not great.

To be honest, I don't think Pang Tong is much stronger than Zhuge Liang. Originally, he went against the sky, went against morality to take Xichuan, became a teacher, was unknown, did not follow the way of heaven at the right time, that is, Pang planned to kill himself, turn things around, and everything was reversed. And then take advantage of the situation to take the land of Xichuan, if it weren't for Pang Tong, I don't think Zhuge Liang would be able to come up with this way to get Xichuan in line with morality.

This plan seems unremarkable, but its power is that it makes the unreasonable all of a sudden a natural! Zhuge Liang may not have known what the effect of Pang Tong's action would be at that time! At the same time, Zhuge Liang's arrangement of troops is naturally the most powerful, and there is nothing wrong with it.

But Sima Yi is similar to him.

I think Sima Yi's chances of winning are still very big, because everyone knows that Sima Yi is a very wise person, and Pang Tong's words didn't show much of his ability because he died early, so I think Sima Yi's chances of winning are a little bigger.

Yes, Pang is still weaker than Zhuge Liang, because Pang Tong's weakness is too obvious, that is, arrogance, so Sima Yi is still more confident in dealing with him.

If Pang Tong was really smart, he would not have died in Luofengpo, and Sima Yi had been on the battlefield for a long time, and his military concepts and troop arrangements were very clever, and ordinary strategists couldn't beat him.

Where is the comprehensive national strength, or Sima Yisheng or Cao Weisheng, just like you can't get out of the line if you throw Messi to the national football team, and you can't get out of the World Cup like throwing Wu Lei to Argentina, as long as you are not mentally retarded, the basic outcome will not change, and Sima Yi's own strength is not bad.

If you look at it from the Three Kingdoms alone, although Wolong and Phoenix are said to be together, the author still subtly influences Wolong is better, so Sima Yi's chances of winning will be greater.

Wolong and Phoenix Chick's ability is basically the same It's just that Feng Chick hung up without having a chance to play Wolong belongs to the conservative Feng Chick radical Feng Chick is immortal Shu should be able to unify the world.

Sima Yi rushed forward, Yuan Ge could dodge with 4 skills, and then 21213 took Sima Yi away, so Yuan Ge defeated Sima Yi.