What do you think of Li Shaohong s version of Dream of Red Mansions ?

I think Li Shaohong's version of "Dream of Red Mansions" is also very good.

I think one of the aspects with the highest recognition of Li Shaohong's version of "Dream of Red Mansions" is that director Li Shaohong does not have a certain depth of understanding of "Dream of Red Mansions", and only treats "Dream of Red Mansions" as a costume drama or court drama, but even if "Dream of Red Mansions" is regarded as an ordinary court drama, it can only be called a barely qualified product. Although many people commented that Li Shaohong's version of "Dream of Red Mansions" is not real art, even if it is used as a tool for fame and fortune and making money, it has also laid down experience for the creation of art. Someone must pave the road to success, and Li Shaohong is about a stone to pave the way.

From Li Shaohong's audition of actors to the release of the new version of "Dream of Red Mansions", the voice of criticism has not stopped. Putting aside other aspects of this drama, let's talk about the character modeling, the criticism of the copper coin head is the strongest. Why did Li Shaohong use copper coins? She blindly emphasized that the shooting was very in accordance with the will of the original book, but the original book did not say whose head shape was a copper coin!

After all, it is known as the four famous novels, which shows that "Dream of Red Mansions" is an insurmountable classic in people's hearts, whether it is from a low position or what。In my eyes, "Dream of Red Mansions" is a beautiful picture scroll, an alternate world. I thought that there were such people in reality who lived like them.

It's as beautiful as the daughters of the Grand View Garden.

Li Shaohong recalled: "If I quit again, then "Dream of Red Mansions" will really be over. My biggest impulse to shoot "Dream of Red Mansions" is because it can reflect the style of history and culture, let modern young people understand its cultural meaning, and let the world understand its delicacy, which is still a bit meaningful.

In fact, I think that as long as "Dream of Red Mansions" is filmed, each version has meaning, after all, everyone who has read "Dream of Red Mansions" has their own different understandings and feelings.

It is not qualified to shoot Dream of Red Mansions at all, just talking about Lin Daiyu's understanding completely exposes how low its three-year-old child-like IQ is, what Lin Daiyu only lives for love, Lin Daiyu's casting appearance doesn't matter, Lin Daiyu is ready to go from the sand in the later stage, Lin Daiyu should be sitting in a crooked S-shape, there is nothing to say here about Lin Daiyu, the actor's cultural level is also very low, the host said that the actor Yu Xiaotong of the fake Baoyu is not the image of Baoyu in her heart, 87 is, so she began to quibble, first said that 87 is preconceived, Then buckle the hat to the audience, saying that the audience doesn't understand it well, because if the silver plate in the book is not really the same size as the plate, I am really convinced when I see this, I am afraid that only primary school students will make such a misunderstanding, and this sentence is not to describe Baoyu, I don't know if Yu is weak-hearted, and began to talk nonsense, the host probably didn't pay attention to these, and emphasized again that 87 is the image in his heart, and then Yu continued to quibble, and what he said was almost the same as just now, all that set of rhetoric, I'm really annoyed that these people always say preconceived ideas, 87's Dream of Red Mansions was not the earliest version, and I also filmed Dream of Red Mansions in 45 years, since I was preconceived, why do you say 45 version? And the post-10s also came out with a small drama bone Dream of Red Mansions, and the praise rate is almost catching up with the 87 version, since it is preconceived, why do more people like the small drama bone version than the 10th version?

Except for the Yue Opera movie, Dream of Red Mansions is a real Dream of Red Mansions, and everything else is a garbage dream.

It's not Dream of Red Mansions, it's "Dream of Green Mansions".

Whether it's good or not, it's at ease.

Can a director who can't even watch "Dream of Red Mansions" make a good TV series?

I think it's still very good.

I think Li Shaohong's "Dream of Red Mansions" is quite good.

I don't think this version is that classic.

Personally, I still like this drama very much.

I think this drama is still very good.

I think Li Shaohong's version of "Dream of Red Mansions" is also very good.

Because everyone feels that this version of Dream of Red Mansions does not truly restore this book, mainly because they are not satisfied with this version of Dream of Red Mansions in terms of lines, and change the lines to vernacular.

Because Li Shaohong's version of "Dream of Red Mansions" looks very contrived and makes people feel very uncomfortable.

Because of this Dream of Red Mansions, people feel that the plot is a little violated, and when choosing characters, no one is satisfied with either appearance or ability.

Because everyone thinks that Li Shaohong is very fake, and he is not good-looking, everyone will not like it, because the classics will never be surpassed.

Because many people preconceived that the old version of Dream of Red Mansions is more classic, and the shape and personality of the characters are very good, so in this comparison, the new version is not very good-looking.

Because this version of Dream of Red Mansions was very unsuccessful, and it did not interpret the classics. It's not as good as the old version of Dream of Red Mansions.

Because people feel that Li Shaohong's version of Dream of Red Mansions does not perform the essence of Dream of Red Mansions, nor does it perform the meaning that the author wants to express.

Because many people think that the actors invited by Li Shaohong's version of Dream of Red Mansions are particularly immature, and they have made some changes to Dream of Red Mansions, they don't like this version.

There are two main reasons: 1. The old version is preconceived; 2. The public's aesthetic habits are not suitable for innovative things; 3. Some people have a herd mentality. I think the 2 versions have their own advantages and disadvantages, and I prefer the new version.

1.The new version of "Dream of Red Mansions" is too scripted in terms of storytelling, and too much narration cuts the fluency of the story and weakens the audience's sense of substitution; 2.The characters are not good-looking.

One is that the appearance is not beautiful enough. In terms of clothing styling alone, the screen is full of copper coins. The second is that the character image does not match.

Because people feel that the acting skills of some actors are not very good, and there is a big gap between the costumes and the characters' personalities.

The shooting is unreal, and it is also very messy, there is no beauty at all, and the acting skills of those actors are very ordinary, so I can't watch it.

Set in set! Count in the count! Stone Notes!

I think the failure lies in the story line, the plot, the choice of actors, the acting skills of the actors, the filter of the whole drama, the cast, and the combination of factors that led to the failure of Dream of Red Mansions.

I think the failure is that the choice of some actors is not particularly good, and this version of Wang Xifeng does not look particularly smart, so that the whole show does not have too many highlights.

The choice of characters, many of the actors selected are not very in line with the role, and they are very inferior to the previous version of Dream of Red Mansions.

Needless to say, the makeup is very fake.

Who said that the 10th version of "Dream of Red Mansions" failed? I love it!

Originally, the drama directed by Li Shaohong had great expectations, but I was really disappointed after watching it. I am a lover of Red Mansions, and my feelings when I see the new Red Mansion are:

1.The narration is too verbose, and everything has to be said silently, in fact, some things are good by performance, and those that are too cumbersome can be listened to as radio dramas, which annoys people to death and affects the viewing of dramas.

2.The actors' line skills are too poor, if you look at those new actors reading that line, it looks like a middle school student reading a text, it is not natural and fluent at all, and it is very uncomfortable to listen to.

3.Poor performance. It's okay that Sister Feng doesn't laugh, it's too fake to laugh, and the audience feels embarrassed when she listens to it, so they don't laugh if they can't laugh. The episode I chose Daiyu to watch when she first entered the Grand View Garden, I felt very unhappy.

4.Indeed, the costume is average. Expectations are disappointed.

5.There is a problem with the selection of actors. At the beginning, Taoist monks should not use old actors, two men who play rich farmers and peasants, and they can't imagine that they are fairy bones.

I've only watched a few episodes, I really can't watch it, the actors are too bad, and I don't like the rhythm of the show, it's very draggy.

The biggest failure is that the ending adopts a conservative high-jaw version.

So the ratings plummeted in the second half.

Of course, there are many more, but the so-called most is this one.

The most difficult thing to shoot about Dream of Red Mansions is because of its second half and its too controversial part. Li Shaohong is because he is afraid of being criticized, so he rests on his laurels, and the new version is fundamentally backward in terms of ideology and red learning compared to the so-called old version, so people who understand the Red Mansion and care about the Red Mansion will regret it, and people who know a little and like to watch the excitement are also dissatisfied for other reasons (**, clothing, etc.), and people who don't know much about the story are naturally more interested in the story and require modern tastes to investigate, resulting in a situation where rats cross the street and everyone shouts and beats.

In my opinion, although there is a fly in the ointment, it is not useless, but this script is really not interesting, and it is not worth spending money to shoot.

A good TV series relies on makeup and acting skills, if the makeup is not good, it is a failure. If the makeup is unrealistic, no matter how good the acting skills are, they are doomed to failure, such as fighting, without preliminary preparation, they dare not fight.

The biggest failure was to agree to Tim Yip's styling design, which was doomed to failure at the beginning. And she didn't have a keen sense of it.

The biggest failure of Li Shaohong's Dream of Red Mansions is that Xinhong has been filmed.

Daiyu is fat and Baochai is thin. "Feng Lazi" is not "spicy". "Two wood" not "wood".

There is also a very big failure is Qingwen's performance when she was approached by Mrs. Wang to give a lecture, is that Qingwen written by Cao Xueqin? Qingwen was portrayed as a, I can only say that such a person was killed by Mrs. Wang, and he deserved it! Because this is not Qingwen.

Headwear [the one piece by piece...

**[It's okay to make ghost movies.] 】

Actor [Why do you want to change actors halfway?] 】

The sound effects of the picture sound effects sound a little weird.

The character creation is not good, and the hair is not good-looking.

Hehe, wait for someone to summarize it.

I can't watch it anymore, why doesn't Li Shaohong take a look at it and summarize it.

The faces of the characters are too white, scary, and ghost-like!

I hate Li Shaohong, I hate the new Red Mansion.

The whole drama is miserable, the tone is gloomy, with a weird background** and laughter, like chatting.

As soon as Jia Mu spoke, she danced with her hands, and Tanchun scuffled with Wang Shanbao's family, which was really laughing!

Aside from acting skills and line skills. In fact, the characters in Dream of Red Mansions are described in detail by the original author, so everyone has a default image in their minds, if they blindly pursue innovation, do not take into account the feelings of the public, do not respect the original character image makeup, and rely only on the 3D background, the props that are restored with great effort, and the dialogue copied from the original text, it will not be recognized by the audience. After all, the characters are the heart and soul of Dream of Red Mansions.