Guan Yu died in battle, Zhuge Liang was not sad at all, why did Liu Bei see through it and not say i

Everyone knows Guan Yu, when he was still selling dates, he met Liu Bei and Zhang Fei, and the three of them didn't know each other, so they became brothers. Later, through their own efforts, the three of them made a career, but they were defeated and died when they were in full swing, and the strange thing is that Zhuge Liang was not sad at all when he learned that Guan Yu died because of the battle. Things have to start when Guan Yu was guarding Jingzhou.

At that time, although Cao Cao experienced the Battle of Chibi, his strength was still there.

Ordering the army to advance, Guan Yu led the soldiers to deal with the enemy, and there were victories and defeats on both sides in several encounters, but Guan Yu discovered the weakness of Cao Cao's army. Because of the heavy rain, Guan Yu found that his army was not easy to fight in the water, and their lethality was very small when it rained. Guan Yu then knew that they were not good at fighting in the water, so he ordered the water to be released.

Cao Cao's army was soon overwhelmed by the flood, and things turned out as Guan Yu had predicted.

Cao Cao's army was powerless. At that time, Cao Cao was scared, and Sun Quan also wanted to come over and kiss. But Guan Yu disagreed, so the two conspired together and killed Guan Yu by attacking back and forth.

Zhuge Liang was not sad at all, because he had reminded Guan Yu before that he must have a good relationship with Sun Quan to be able to resist Cao Cao, although Guan Yu nodded. But I didn't take it to heart. Especially when Liu Bei attacked Shudi.

Zhuge Liang was ordered to bring soldiers from Jingzhou to support, only Guan Yu was left to guard Jingzhou, no one was in his eyes, when Ma Chao came to surrender, everyone said that Ma Chao was very powerful. Guan Yu can have such an ending, Zhuge Liang has already guessed it. In fact, Liu Bei is responsible.

He obviously knew that Guan Yu was particularly arrogant, but he didn't stop it. It ended up like that. Zhuge Liang didn't deliberately correct him after knowing it, and he was ashamed of Shu Han's role as a military advisor.

Guan Yu died in battle, why wasn't Zhuge Liang sad at all? Liu Bei saw through it and didn't say it.

That's mainly because they already know Guan Yu's character, and Zhuge Liang is not sad because he has already reached the point where Guan Yu will die in battle.

Because of Guan Yu's personality, Liu Bei also knows in his heart, so he doesn't want to say anything even if he sees through it.

Zhuge Liang's performance was not because he didn't regret it, but because he had expected it and had been mentally prepared, so he was neither surprised nor sad, with his understanding of Guan Yu, this would inevitably happen. Guan Yu's recklessness, the whole country of Shu Han wanted him to give him three points, including Zhuge Liang.

Guan Yu's death Zhuge Liang was not surprised at all, he should have already calculated it, and all this was the result of Guan Yu's own blame, and he couldn't complain about others.

Zhuge Liang couldn't retreat from Guan Yu at that time, but Guan Yu didn't listen to Zhuge Liang's persuasion, and Guan Yu's friendship with Zhuge Liang was not deep.

Because Guan Yu has a very strong temper and doesn't know how to speak, Liu Bei knows that everyone doesn't like Guan Yu.

Liu Bei knows Guan Yu's personality very well, Guan Yu's death Zhuge Liang had already predicted, and all this was the result of Guan Yu's own fault.

Zhuge Liang did not have the crime of "framing" Guan Yu, but he had the fault of "indulgence". There is some secondary responsibility for Guan Yu's death.

1. At that time, although Zhuge Liang was named "General of the Military Division", the actual work he did was mainly to collect taxes, levy troops and transport grain, maintain law and order, take charge of criminal law, punish "disloyalty", eliminate "internal enemies" and so on. In short, Zhuge Liang's work belongs to internal management, and military planning is not within the scope of Zhuge Liang's work.

2. It was precisely because Liu Bei's group underestimated the possibility of Sun Quan's surrender that Liu Bei confidently and boldly proclaimed himself the "King of Hanzhong", causing a group of subordinates to work around him, thus ignoring the "dangerous situation" in Jingzhou. Generally speaking, although Zhuge Liang bears some indirect responsibility for Guan Yu's death, it is impossible for him to kill Guan Yu with a knife.

Because Zhuge Liang did not expect Sun Quan to surrender to Cao Cao. Even Ma Liang, the envoy sent by Liu Bei to Eastern Wu, was deceived by Sun Quan, not to mention Zhuge Liang, a person who was concentrating on internal affairs?

3, Zhuge Liang adopted the strategy of "false and wrongful, clever maneuvering" against Guan Yu, which is indeed true, but if Guan Yu is jealous of Zhuge Liang, it is pure nonsense. Guan Yu, as a military general guarding one side, will not hinder Zhuge Liang's promotion for the time being. Zhuge Liang's real competitor is not Guan Yu, but Fa Zheng.

Fa is Liu Bei's "mastermind", and he once put forward different opinions on Zhuge Liang's "strict punishment and strict law". But even so, Zhuge Liang never thought of "getting rid of" Fa Zheng, on the contrary, he once connived at Fa Zheng's "indiscriminate killing of innocents".

4, Guan Yu and Fa Zheng are Liu Bei's henchmen, even if they make serious mistakes, Liu Bei will not do anything to them. Zhuge Liang knew this, so he never clashed head-on with them.

This also shows that Zhuge Liang is cautious by nature and never does dangerous things. So, how dare he do such a dangerous thing as "borrowing a knife to kill Guan Yu"?

5, Zhuge Liang did not have the crime of "framing" Guan Yu, but he had the fault of "indulgence". Because Zhuge Liang never pointed out Guan Yu's shortcomings, Guan Yu was arrogant, and as a result, he fell for the Wu people and lost his life.

To some extent, Zhuge Liang "killed" Guan Yu, but this "killing" was unintentional and not intentional. This is also a common mistake of Liu Bei's group.

Zhuge Liang. Zhuge Liang (October 8, 181, 234), the word Kongming, the name Wolong (also known as Fulong), Han nationality, Xuzhou Langya Yangdu (now Yinan County, Linyi City, Shandong), the prime minister of Shu and Han during the Three Kingdoms period, outstanding politician, military strategist, essayist, calligrapher, inventor. When he was alive, he was named the Marquis of Wuxiang, and after his death, he was posthumously loyal to the Marquis of Wu, and the Eastern Jin Dynasty regime posthumously named him the King of Wuxing because of his military talent.

Guan Yu is also a figure with more fans in the Three Kingdoms, not only strong in martial arts, but also affectionate and righteous, let me and other ordinary people bow and worship. However, no matter how powerful the characters are, there are times when they make mistakes, and in the end, Guan Yu defeated Maicheng, not only lost the strategic Jingzhou, but also took his own life.

When he learned that Guan Yu was killed, Liu Bei, as the eldest brother, was both sad and angry, and decided to personally lead the soldiers and horses to avenge his brother and ask his eldest brother for an explanation. However, at this time, Zhuge Liang, who has always been on the same channel as Liu Bei, is unusual, and does not agree to avenge Guan Yu, why is this?

It turned out that when Guan Yu went to Jingzhou to take office, Zhuge Liang once made a hexagram for Guan Yu, and saw that he would have a catastrophe when he went, but the heavenly opportunity could not be leaked, and it was inconvenient to say it clearly, so he told Guan Yu to remember to join Wu to fight Cao. However, Guan Yu did not take Zhuge Liang's words to heart, and once said that even if Sun Quan and Cao Cao came to attack together, they would divide their troops and refuse to do so.

At this time, there were also a lot of Eastern Wu strategists, and they knew the importance of Lianwu to resist Cao, so in order to show his sincerity, Sun Quan went to Guan Yu to talk to Zhuge Liang's eldest brother Zhuge Jin, and wanted Guan Yu's daughter to marry Sun Quan's son, but Guan Yu said: "The tiger girl can marry a dog", so as to insult Sun Quan, and said to Zhuge Jin, if it weren't for the prime minister's face, he would beat you out. It can be seen that Guan Yu has no sense of the overall situation at all, and his emotional intelligence is not very high, which directly led to Sun Quan and Cao Cao joining forces to deal with Shu Han, so Guan Yu defeated Maicheng.

Zhuge Liang was not very surprised when Guan Yu said those words that were not salty or light, Guan Yu would not be able to retreat with his whole body, so he was not very surprised when he learned that Guan Yu's head was in a different place, and at this time, the people of Shu Han were panicked, Liu Bei went out with all his strength to take revenge, so he naturally had to leave someone to stay in the rear, otherwise I am afraid that there would be no place to stay, so Wuhou was unwilling to avenge Guan Yu.

Among all Liu Bei's henchmen and favorite generals, Guan Yu's comprehensive ability is undoubtedly the strongest, as early as when he was in Xuzhou, he was able to lead the troops to defend Xiapi alone, and he also had a record of slashing Yan Liang alone, so both his ability to lead troops and his personal force are first-class. So later, when Cao Cao occupied Jingzhou, Liu Bei chose to let Guan Yu lead the main army to retreat by boat and meet at Liu Qi. After the Battle of Chibi, Cao's army was defeated, and the Sun-Liu coalition army took the opportunity to counterattack, Guan Yu cut off Cao's army's grain route, forcing Cao Ren to withdraw from Nanjun, and Liu Bei took the opportunity to seize the territory of Jingzhou south of the Yangtze River.

Guan Yu's excellent performance made Liu Bei very down-to-earth, so when he entered Xichuan, he transferred all the main generals away, leaving only Guan Yu, which shows his trust in him. It's a pity that Guan Yu was too anxious, and before Liu Bei was ready, he launched the battle of Xiangfan without authorization, but was targeted by the red-eyed Lu Meng, and finally died of defeat. After the news of Guan Yu's death reached Chengdu, Liu Bei suddenly fainted, and after waking up, he cried even more.

But Zhuge Liang next to him didn't have a trace of sadness, General Fang had died in battle, why couldn't he be sad at all?

Guan Yu died in battle, why wasn't Zhuge Liang sad at all? Liu Bei saw through it and didn't say it.

Because at that time, Zhuge Liang reminded Guan Yu that he must befriend Sun Quan in order to resist Cao Cao, although Guan Yu nodded yes, he didn't take it to heart.

The so-called arrogant soldiers will be defeated, Zhuge Liang has already seen the end, so when Guan Yu died, his silence was actually expressing dissatisfaction, and his entire plan was burned by Guan Yu.

Guan Yu's death led to the fall of Jingzhou and greatly increased Sun Quan's strength, and the strength of Shu was retreated, laying the groundwork for Zhuge Liang's battle to the death in the future.

When Guan Yu was alive, Zhuge Liang was not on the stage at all in Shu Han. In the biography of Zhuge Liang of the Three Kingdoms, it is clear that the ancestors returned to Yizhou Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Ma Chao are minions, Fa Zheng is the mastermind, and Zhuge Liang is the humerus. It can be seen that militarily Guan Zhangma is the general, Fa Zheng is the military advisor, and Zhuge Liang is responsible for the rear government affairs.

Moreover, there are many internal contradictions in Shu Han, and Zhuge Liang, who is engaged in politics, has no heart to care about Guan Yu's death.

did not implement Zhuge Liang's policy of uniting Wu to resist Cao, can Zhuge Liang not bother him? Guan Yu didn't have Zhang Liao's two shots in Hefei, which shows that the sentence of the general is not Yong, and he also fell into the plan to drop the billet in his early years!

Zhuge Liang: As soon as Yun Chang goes, Shu will be mine! You can sleep peacefully in the future!

Theoretically, Guan Yu's death in battle is only Zhang Fei, and no one will like Guan Yu's temper.

I have thought about this issue many times after reading the Three Kingdoms, but it has always been difficult to say.

One less stumbling block to achieve one's ambitions. ,, Hanshou Pavilion Marquis, there is him in Zhuge Village. It is difficult to have his own prestige and power, Liu Bei will completely rely on him, and no one will dare to oppose him anymore.

Would you like a colleague who has no one in her eyes and is arrogant?

Who says it's not sad? I can't tell you that I'm sad, I'm actually sad, very sad, and secretly crying at night.

Zhuge Liang is a capable person, but it's a pity that there are a bunch of oil bottles around him.

It's not that he wasn't sad, but Guan Yu's death was expected by him.

It's not because he doesn't regret it, but he has expected it a long time ago and has been mentally prepared, so he is neither surprised nor sad, with his understanding of Guan Yu, this will inevitably happen.

After reading "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", many people will think that Guan Yu's death is a bit strange. Cao Cao is in the north, Sun Quan is in the east, Guan Yu went north alone, without any support behind him, didn't he go to die? Guan Yu doesn't understand, Liu Bei doesn't understand, doesn't Zhuge Liang understand?

Why should they die and not be saved?

After Lu Bu's death, Guan Yu can be said to be the first brave general at that time. Cao Cao made him admit that Guan Yu had not met an opponent in ten years and was invincible. In addition, almost all of the first few battles of the Xiangfan War were won by Guan YuTherefore, Liu Bei was very confident in Guan Yu at that time, believing that Guan Yu would not be defeated, so there was no need to go to the rescue.

If we rule out the possibility that Liu Bei killed Guan Yu, then Zhuge Liang would be very reasonable to kill Guan Yu. Everyone knows that Guan Yu and Zhuge Liang are at odds, Guan Yu often bullies Zhuge Liang and doesn't take Zhuge Liang seriously, so Zhuge Liang is likely to deliberately not save him, and just borrowed the hands of Cao Cao and Sun Quan to kill Guan Yu.

Guan Yu guarded Jingzhou, which also made him a thorn in the side of the Wei and Wu families. This was followed by a battle that led to the defeat of Guan Yun's soldiers. After the start of this war, Guan Yu won one after another, fighting all the way to the general.

Beat the test all the way. Until Xu Huang, Wu family Lu Meng went to war, and Guan Yu carelessly lost Jingzhou. At this time, it was difficult for the military situation to reach Zhuge Liang, and it was too late for Zhuge Liang to send someone to rescue him.

In this case, this reason is also perfectly acceptable.

But Liao Hua went to the rescue, but Liu Bei's godson Liu Feng refused to rescue, which is really incredible. In any case, without a clear hint from the top, I don't think Liu Feng would have done this. There are many theories about Guan Yunchang's death, whether it was Zhuge Liang and Liu Bei's "murder" or notThe fact that he "couldn't see the situation clearly and was arrogant" determined his tragic life.

In order to take care of Guan Yu's mood, he also specially sealed him as the head of the general, but Guan Yu did not accept it, in his eyes, this behavior of the eldest brother Liu Bei was arrogance.