How much power did Guan Yu have in Shu? How high is the status?

Updated on history 2024-02-26
31 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Guan Yu's rights in Shu Han are naturally relatively large, and he should be regarded as the second-in-command of the entire Shu Han Group, so to speak, in the entire Shu Han Group, except for Liu Bei, Guan Yu's rights should be the largest, and his status should be the highest. <>

    Many people may have been influenced by the film and television work "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" and think that Zhuge Liang is the actual second-in-command in the Shuhan Group. But in the real history, in fact, things are not like this, in the early stage of Liu Bei's business, in fact, the entire army was jointly managed by Liu Bei and Guan Yu, and Liu Bei's territory at that time was not very large, and there were not many soldiers and horses, so he did not need a third manager. During this time period, it is very important for Liu Bei.

    It wasn't until Liu Bei later took down the four counties of Jingzhou that Zhuge Liang began to have the identity of a "military advisor". <>

    That is to say, when Zhuge Liang first joined the Shu Han camp, in fact, his status was not higher than that of Mi Fang, and later after Liu Bei got the four counties of Jingzhou, Zhuge Liang's status improved a little, but even then he did not have any real power. The second is that before Liu Bei's death, Zhuge Liang had no experience in leading troops to fight alone, he was only responsible for logistics, and the film and television works also completely mythologized Zhuge Liang. <>

    However, at this point, the difference between Guan Yu and Zhuge Liang is relatively large. Whether it is in the early or late Shu Han period, Guan Yu is quite important to the entire Shu Han group, Guan Yu can become a general who stands alone, and when the soldiers are united, Guan Yu is also a unique existence in the army. Of course, later, as Liu Bei's territory became bigger and bigger, and there were more and more soldiers and horses, Zhuge Liang's status in the army naturally became higher and higher, but even so, Zhuge Liang still had no way to compare with Guan Yu.

    If it weren't for Guan Yu being too arrogant, then I believe Guan Yu would not have died so early, and then Guan Yu's achievements in Shu Han would have been higher in the end.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Guan Yu is the second-in-command of Shu, it can be said that he is the first person under Zhuge Liang, Guan Yu is not only Liu Bei's number one thug but also has management talents, and his status in Shu at that time was very high.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Guan Yu is the second-in-command in Shu, second only to Liu Bei in status. Because Liu Bei had already granted Guan Yu the privilege of "fake Jieyue" when he was king in Hanzhong, he could kill anyone except Liu Bei first, and then report to Liu Bei.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    Guan Yu's status in Shu Han is second only to Liu Bei. In the Battle of Chibi, Guan Yu let Cao Cao go, and was originally going to accept the military order and be executed, but in the end he was saved from death because of his relationship with Liu Bei, which shows how high Guan Yu's status is in Shu Han.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Guan Yu's status is very high, second only to Liu Bei, and he can be regarded as Liu Bei's right-hand man, and Liu Bei is like a brother. ranks first among the five tiger generals of Shu State, and basically Guan Yu will be asked to do more important tasks, such as guarding Jingzhou, which shows Liu Bei's trust in him, basically one-third of the troops of Shu are in charge of Guan Yu, which is the same grade as a marshal.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    The status in Shu Han is very high, and he can lead an army alone, and no one dares to resist the other party at that time, and he can easily punish other people, and the emperor will not interfere too much.

  7. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Very high. Because Guan Yu's martial arts are very strong, he is a strong opponent that many people dare not defeat, and he is also Liu Bei's right-hand man. His power is also relatively large.

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Liu Bei didn't understand the job arrangement and messed around with ......In ancient times, the left was respected, and the Han Dynasty has always been sorted by: left, right, front, and back (Sifang generals). (Note: At that time, Guan Yu should be sealed one level higher than other generals).

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    The force is arrogant and strong but not bullying, and the common people like it.

    Brave and loyal, the ruling class likes.

    If there is kindness, it will be repaid, and people in the rivers and lakes like it.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    It's not something you can understand after reading the Three Kingdoms a few times, why Guan Yu is respected. One; Of course, it is a powerful martial arts, this is nothing to say, although it is not as good as Lu Bu, but it is also a rare tiger general. Two; Brave and strategic, going to the meeting alone, and flooding the Seventh Army, all reflect Guan Yu's talent.

    Three; attaches great importance to love and righteousness, and once passed five levels and killed six generals in order to follow Liu Bei, and he is a true man. Four; is also the most important, Guan Yuyi Bo Yuntian, in that era, and even now, the real literati and writers like to respect the righteous, and Guan Yu is familiar with the Spring and Autumn Period, and he is even more aware of the righteousness. Like Jing Ke and Yaoli in the past, they were all righteous soldiers, to put it bluntly, they seem to be spies now, but in that era of heavy scholars, they can all write books, and now it is absolutely impossible.

    Five; Guan Yu's character, which is also very important, is that this character is deeply remembered by the people. Although Guan Yu is arrogant, he has never bullied his subordinates, and someone once commented on Guan Yu and said; Guan Yu is arrogant but not bullying, bullying the strong but not bullying. This is a true portrayal of the other side of Guan Yu's character.

    Just imagine how many years China has developed, people in that era were not all strong bullies, flattering and bullying subordinates, even more so as officials, bullying and oppressing the people, Guan Yu is not, it is rare to be so righteous and awe-inspiring.

    Guan Yu's status is so high not because of his martial arts, courage, but more importantly, righteousness, and that body is completely arrogant, arrogant but not bullying, bullying the strong but not bullying.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    Do you want to ask about the high status in modern society? In fact, his status was not high at the beginning of ancient times, but with the development of society, the ruling class of feudal society increased its propaganda efforts for political needs, and his status also rose, just like Confucius.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    Guan Yu: Former general, false Jieyue, second in the Shu Han army.

    In Liu Bei's camp, Guan Yu is the second oldest in the army (Zhuge Liang is the second person in Liu Bei's camp, so he is not counted), of course, because of political needs, Guan Yu once did the old 3: When Liu Bei won Hanzhong, Ma Chao once surpassed Guan Yu. But when Liu Bei called the king of Hanzhong, Guan Yu was a former general, the only fake festival in Shu.

    In addition, Guan Yu had a short period of surrender to Cao, and his official position was a partial general, which was only lower than Xiahou and Cao Ren at that time, and there was no way for anyone to have a relative. Higher than the first general with a foreign surname. Zhang Liao, who had joined Cao earlier, was a lieutenant at the time. It is conceivable how useful Guan Yu is.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    After his death, he was named [Shouting Hou].

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    Guan Yu has the reputation of a martial saint, in Luo Guanzhong's pen, he punished Yan Liangwen and ugly, passed five passes and beheaded six generals, released water to flood the Seventh Army, and shocked China. Liu Bei became the queen of Hanzhong, and sealed Zhang Zhao Ma Huang as the general of the five tigers, and the second master of Guan was naturally the head of the five Hu manuscripts in terms of qualifications, but how should the actual force of the five people be arranged? We can draw conclusions by contrast.

    First of all, the third brother Zhang Fei's martial arts did not lose to Guan Yu. After beheading Yan Liangwen and ugliness, Cao Cao shocked Guan Gong into a god, but the second master then said: "I'm nothing, the third brother Zhang Yide can take the head of a general in the army, and he is powerful."

    The second master is well aware of the third brother's ability, and it is not easy for Guan Gong, who has always been proud of his self-servant, to say such things, Zhang Fei does have two brushes. Tiger Prison Guan Sanying fought against Lu Bu, Zhang Fei first fought with the world's first general, Guan Yu stepped forward to help Thirty He still couldn't take it. Later, Lu Bu came to Xuzhou, and he had a hearty fight with Zhang Fei, and the two battles were enough to prove that Guan Yu was slightly under Zhang Fei.

    Let's look at Ma Chao again, before Guan Gong heard that Ma Chao returned to his eldest brother, he became douglas, and wanted to enter Sichuan and Meng Qi to compete, but was held down by a letter of praise from Zhuge Liang. Thanks to the fact that the two did not fight, otherwise Guan Yu, who is already old, will definitely not be able to take advantage of the slightest advantage, but may suffer a loss. Ma Chao had fought hundreds of rounds with Zhang Fei in the night battle, although the victory or defeat was not explained in the book, but before the heads-up, Ma Chao had been calling under the city for a long time, and saw that others were sleepy and lacking Zhang Fei before he pulled the horse out of the city, and he played to the end of Liu Beicheng, who looked carefully, lest Zhang Fei lose and Ming Jin retreated, and the details of the description showed that Ma Chao was slightly better than Zhang Fei, and naturally won Guan Yu.

    Speaking of his advanced age, Guan Gongsha did not take advantage of Huang Zhong because the latter was already an old man, and he could only play a knife trick if he couldn't win alone, and he was shot in the helmet by Huang Zhong in the second fight. If Huang Zhong was ten years younger, it would be unpredictable who would win or lose. So the hard power Huang Zhong is at least not under Guan Gong.

    In the end, it was the invincible Changshan Zhao Zilong, Zhao Yun had defeated Zhang Jaw in ten times, and when Han Shui rescued Huang Zhong, Xu Huang Zhang Jaw was afraid to move forward, and he had a draw with Xu Chu. As a reference, Ma Chao and Xu Chu are not superior in heads-up, Zhang Fei is difficult to distinguish between victory and defeat, and it is unpredictable for the elderly Guan Yu to win or lose against Xu Huang, and after a few comparisons, it can be concluded that Zhao Yun is stronger than Guan Yu. Some people will talk about Zhao Yun's draw with Wen Chou, Guan Yu even killed Yan Liang and Wen Chou, what I want to say here is that Zhao Yun was still a teenager when he pk Wen Chou, and his force is far from the peak, and it is basically not a head-to-head confrontation about Zhu Yan Liangwen Chou, winning in the speed of the red rabbit horse and the other party's inability to react and be weak-hearted, it is difficult to prove Guan Yu's true force.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    In the Shu Han group, Guan Yu's status is second only to Liu Bei, that is, the number two person, he has the power of fake Jieyue, that is, he can exercise power instead of the king.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    The number two person of Liu Bei Group is actually Guan Yu. Because Guan Yu has a privilege that Zhuge Liang does not have, that is, fake Jieyue. The so-called false festival can be understood as the power to cut first and then play.

    After all, Liu Bei needs to give Guan Yu a lot of power, because if Guan Yu's authority is limited, after Guan Yu sends someone to Chengdu to ask Liu Bei, the fighter plane will also be delayed, and even lead to a reversal of the situation. Therefore, Liu Bei gave Guan Yu the permission to fake the festival out of consideration for the war. Of course, this permission cannot be given indiscriminately.

    Because once it is given to the ambitious, the ambitious is likely to use this authority to divide one side. Therefore, those who can obtain this authority must have both talent and the trust of the lord.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    Guan Yu's status is second only to Liu Bei. Guan Yu was given a fake festival by Liu Bei, and he could cut first and then play, and his power was very great.

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-20

    Second only to Liu Bei. Guan Gong was the first to follow Liu Bei, and with his own strength, he was only under Liu Bei. Command the three armies. He has a very high prestige in the army, and he can cross Zhuge Liang and directly command the three armies.

  19. Anonymous users2024-01-19

    Guan Yu's status is second only to Liu Bei, and Liu Bei occupies a total of Yizhou and Jingzhou, so he let Guan Yu guard Jingzhou. Guan Yu can kill himself within the jurisdiction, and he can cut it first and then play.

  20. Anonymous users2024-01-18

    I think it's very high. Because Guan Yu is a veteran who followed Liu Bei to fight the country, his status in Shu is very high.

  21. Anonymous users2024-01-17

    Guan Yu's status in Shu Han is very high, because as the head of the Five Tiger Generals, he has a lot of power.

  22. Anonymous users2024-01-16

    In Shu Han, Guan Yu's status is very high, second only to Liu Bei, and Zhuge Liang enjoys the same status, the three armies respect Guan Yu, and the civil officials also rely on Guan Yu, the general. The people of Shu Han all regarded Guan Yu as a martial saint.

  23. Anonymous users2024-01-15

    He can say that he is above one person and above ten thousand, and at that time, as long as he said a word, many soldiers would follow him.

  24. Anonymous users2024-01-14

    About belonging to Liu Bei's camp, but not from Shu.

    1.When Guan Yu died, Shu had not yet been founded, and Liu Bei had not yet been proclaimed emperor About dying in 219 A.D., and Liu Bei was called emperor in 221 A.D., that is to say, when Guan Yu died, Liu Bei did not have the title of emperor, but the king of Hanzhong, so there is no such thing as Shu.

    2.Even if Guan Yu is considered to be the Liu Bei Empire established later, it should not be called Shu State. We are accustomed to saying that the "Wei, Shu, and Wu" Three Kingdoms are not like this.

    At that time, Liu Bei's country name was "Han", and "Shu" was the derogatory name for "Shu Han" in Wei and Wu at that time, so we say that he belonged to Shu Han at most, and it is best to say that it is Han.

  25. Anonymous users2024-01-13

    Guan Yu (160-220), Han Chinese. Born in the Eastern Han Dynasty Emperor Huan Yanxi three years, the word cloud is long, the word is long, and he is a good person in Hedong (now Yuncheng, Shanxi). It has always been the object of folk worship, a famous general of Shu Han during the Three Kingdoms period, a former general, a marquis of Hanshou Pavilion, and a military strategist.

    After his death, he was respected by the people, and experienced the praise of the imperial court, and was regarded as the emperor of Guan Sheng, and Buddhism called Jialan Bodhisattva, and honored as "Guan Gong". A famous general of Shu during the Three Kingdoms period. He was revered as a "martial saint" by later rulers, and was on a par with Confucius, who was known as the "literary saint".

    Later generations have poems praising Guan Yu: an outstanding military strategist and strategist of Shu during the Three Kingdoms period. In addition, Guan Yu is also regarded as a benefactor god by Taiwanese compatriots.

  26. Anonymous users2024-01-12

    Liu Bei, Guan Yu, and Zhang Fei are all from Shu.

  27. Anonymous users2024-01-11

    To be precise, no, when he died, the Eastern Han Dynasty had not yet perished, and he was a member of Liu Bei's forces.

  28. Anonymous users2024-01-10

    Guan Yu was an important general under Liu Bei of Shu Han.

  29. Anonymous users2024-01-09

    Very powerful, warm wine to kill Huaxiong, behead Yan Liang and Wen ugly.

  30. Anonymous users2024-01-08

    Guan Yu is also one of the few generals in the history of the Three Kingdoms who really went into battle alone. Everyone has watched "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" a lot, and they will feel that in real history, the war between the two sides is also a general.

  31. Anonymous users2024-01-07

    Guan Yu is the only one. The one who takes the head of the man in the Hosts. When Yan Liang was beaten.

    Yan Liang saw it. Also sent. Several generals went to intercept Guan Yu.

    None of the results stopped. Here's what the experts say. Afterward.

    It is known as the enemy of 10,000 people. Megatron Huaxia. Three Kingdoms.

    There are several megatrons. That's what you call it. So.

    Guan Yu in the official. It's almost the most powerful of the Three Kingdoms.

Related questions
19 answers2024-02-26

The landlord is asking about the people in the "Romance of the Three Kingdoms"**, right? **Guan Yu in **: arrogant, indistinguishable from wrong, narrow-minded, selfish, disloyal and unjust, focusing on the details and ignorant of the big sections, insufficient success and more than failure. >>>More

4 answers2024-02-26

Since the reform and opening up, China's refrigeration and air-conditioning market has become the focus of the global refrigeration and air-conditioning industry in the world market. After only more than ten years of development, China's refrigeration and air-conditioning industry has become the world's second largest consumer market and the largest producer of refrigeration and air-conditioning equipment, and has made great progress in terms of product variety, quality and technical level. >>>More

26 answers2024-02-26

Eaten by the power of black fire.

As for whether it will be completely dissipated, I don't know, anyway, as long as the plot requires it, the screenwriter can drag anyone up from underground. >>>More

7 answers2024-02-26

Thousands of them.

As vast as a sea of smoke, as many as a cow's hair. >>>More

23 answers2024-02-26

It's very comfortable, my friends run several insurance, what kind of car loan mortgage insurance and the like, the monthly income is five or six thousand, busy to death. There are also those who study architecture, work in construction companies, and usually work in construction sites or groups, about 6,000, which is not bad. Science and engineering students such as chemical plants are all working in enterprises, and undergraduates are trained according to management. >>>More