What do you think of the incident of Emperor Chongzhen s killing of Yuan Chonghuan? What exactly is

It is rumored that Emperor Taiji used a counterplot to capture two eunuchs in the Ming Palace, and then deliberately made the two think that they heard whispers between the Manchu generals, saying that Yuan Chonghuan had a secret agreement with the Manchus, and Huang Taiji let one of the eunuchs return to Beijing. Emperor Chongzhen was plotted to think that Yuan Chonghuan was plotting rebellion. However, some scholars are inclined to believe that Emperor Chongzhen's killing of Yuan Chonghuan was not a successful plan of Emperor Taiji.

Since Yuan Chonghuan was executed after half a year of captivity, it is unlikely that he was killed by mistake in a moment of anger. In fact, the unauthorized killing of Mao Wenlong was enough to make Emperor Chongzhen determined to kill him.

It's a pity that the villain is in charge, if Yuan Chonghuan doesn't die in vain, the Ming Dynasty will still have the hope of defeating the Manchurians.

After Yuan Chonghuan's death, the Ming Dynasty was powerless to resist and was always pressed and beaten by the Qing army, and it was a mistake for Emperor Chongzhen to kill Yuan Chonghuan. If Yuan Chonghuan is still there, the situation outside the border will be stable, and even if Li Zicheng later raises troops, he will have enough energy to deal with it.

The biggest uncertainty is that the wrong thing is definitely the wrong thing, Yuan Chonghuan is the most feared figure in Houjin, but it has also become Chongzhen's fear.

If Yuan Chonghuan is still there, the situation outside the border can be stabilized, since Yuan Chonghuan's death, the Ming Dynasty has been powerless to resist, has been pressed and beaten by the Qing army, Emperor Chongzhen killed Yuan Chonghuan is a mistake at all.

At that time, Emperor Chongzhen fell for Huang Taiji's counter-plot and mistakenly thought that Yuan Chonghuan was going to collaborate with the enemy and commit treason, and at this time Emperor Chongzhen couldn't afford to gamble, so he killed Yuan Chonghuan, which was just a political choice, there was no right or wrong.

The reason why Emperor Chongzhen decided to kill Yuan Chonghuan is very complicated, and the key reason is that Yuan Chonghuan first illegally killed the anti-Qing general Mao Wenlong, and this caused extremely serious consequences.

It's too late to kill, and killing the Ming Dynasty early can continue life. Yuan Chonghuan misled the country, deceived the monarch, called himself Pingliao for three years, Chongzhen poured the power of the country, but only knew that the turtle shrank, and the Houjin bypassed, and did not dare to break it, to the crisis of the imperial city; buy peace with the country's money and grain, and invest in the enemy; Friendly troops were attacked, and the fire was watched from the other side, so that the naval army was destroyed; Fake the holy decree, kill Mao Wenlong, and Houjin has no worries, firearms, cannons, and craftsmen are all in the hands of Houjin; Correspondence with Huang Taiji and others, private peace.

Wrong, use people without suspicion, and suspect people without suspicion. It can only show that Chongzhen is a faint monarch and will not use people to be a king.

Of course not, Emperor Chongzhen's mistakes are too numerous to mention. The biggest problem was that the heir was not determined, and the crown prince was not arranged to go to Nanjing.

There are a lot of mistakes, the most terrible thing is to kill Sun Chuanting and Lu Xiangsheng, and there is to pit the person who presided over the Jin Yi and the military department to death, Emperor Chongzhen is very diligent is Taikeng, from Wei Zhongxian to Sun Chuanting, all the people who can work are dead, leaving a bunch of waste to make money and do nothing, and then the country died.

The biggest one can't be said, he has a lot of tricks. But it is not an exaggeration to say that it is the most lacking in morality.

Is there nothing wrong with killing Yuan Chonghuan, has it been peaceful for five years? The sin of deception! Killing Mao Wenlong to solve the troubles of the Tartars, and having an ambiguous relationship with the enemy Huang Taiji, shouldn't he be killed? Why did Qianlong overturn the case for Yuan Dudu?

The biggest mistake was to kill Wei Zhongxian, otherwise the Ming Dynasty would still be there.

It is difficult to say whether the merits and demerits are right or wrong, and Yuan is the only person who has a general overview of the overall situation, inspires the morale of the army, uses iron-fisted means, and dares to say that he will recover Liao.

At that time, Yuan Chonghuan illegally killed Mao Wenlong, and it was difficult to give an explanation if he didn't kill him, and it was difficult to maintain the internal and external situation if he killed him, and it was difficult to make a choice.

Chongzhen has made too many mistakes, but it does not include the killing of Yuan Chonghuan.

After five years of Pingliao, he couldn't do why he bragged, so the Ming Dynasty wasted five years, and the treasury was hollowed out to support the border with no effect. This is where he should be damned, and he and the little wild boar skin privately negotiated peace, killing the general Mao Wenlong, who gave him the right,

Kill nothing. It may be worse not to kill.

After Zhang Taiyue's death, he searched his home for liquidation, causing the whole family to almost starve to death, and I feel that the civil and military generals behind him no longer trust the emperor, and it is definitely not wrong to kill Dudu, the evidence is conclusive.

It's too late to kill, and the silver has made this disaster over, and any emperor will kill it.

Chongzhen is the second mentally handicapped in history.

Yuan Chonghuan was ineffective because of "ineffective instructions, deception and concealment, theft with city rice, beheading the commander with money, arsoning with the enemy for a long time, and not fighting." When they arrived at the city, the reinforcements were gathered four times and all of them were dismissed. and sneaked the lama and insisted on entering the city" was executed by Emperor Chongzhen in Xishi.