Emperor Chongzhen was determined to execute Yuan Chonghuan, was it really because he fell for the pl

I don't think this is the real reason, it's because Emperor Chongzhen has long seen Yuan Chonghuan unpleasantly, and he has long wanted to execute him, so he wants to use this excuse to kill him, and he has long been selfish.

History records that Yuan Chonghuan began to be imprisoned in December of the second year of Chongzhen, and was not executed until August of the third year.

It shouldn't be, Chongzhen is also a person with ideas, and he will not be easily fooled, it is estimated that he is already dissatisfied with Yuan Chonghuan, so he will kill him.

That is not the main reason why Chongzhen killed Yuan Chonghuan. Because Chongzhen is suspicious and moody, judging from his various stupid and heart-wrenching behaviors and actions later, it is normal to kill Yuan Chonghuan.

Chongzhen is suspicious and moody, judging from his later stupid and heart-wrenching behaviors and actions, it is normal to kill Yuan Chonghuan.

Emperor Chongzhen did not have a divisive plan, because Yuan Chonghuan began to rise at this time, and his influence also made the eunuch party very unpleasant and became one of Chongzhen's primary targets.

According to the records of Qing history, Emperor Chongzhen seems to have really fallen for the emperor's anti-plot against the emperor, but think about it, how could Chongzhen be so easily fooled by such a clumsy strategy! So,There was another reason why Emperor Chongzhen executed Yuan Chonghuan: Yuan Chonghuan did not fulfill his promise of five years of Pingliao, and he did not listen to Chongzhen's order!

Yuan Chonghuan and Chongzhen promised to level Liao for five years, but he himself understood that the strength of Houjin should not be underestimated, although he had the most advanced ** "red-coated cannon" at that time, but this kind of ** was very powerful to defend on the city gate, if they were transported out of the city and contended with the Qing army, there would be no advantage!

Due to the heavy weight of the Red Cannon, it takes a lot of manpower to transport it out, and the transportation speed is also very slow, so it is difficult to use it in the attack! Then, once the assistance of the red-clothed cannon is lost, Yuan Chonghuan's soldiers and the Houjin army are fighting, which is equivalent to asking for their own death!

And the facts have also proved that Yuan Chonghuan's two head-to-head confrontations with the Houjin Army were both complete victories of the Houjin Army!

For a period of time, the Houjin army was in the stage of lack of food and salary, and there were also disputes within the army, because they did not have enough food supply, some people began to deny the leadership of Huang Taiji, and there was the first civil strife after Huang Taiji succeeded to the throne!

Such a big news, Yuan Chonghuan, as a city general, will not be unaware, he should know that this is a good opportunity for Pingliao, and Emperor Chongzhen once sent someone to send a letter, hoping that he can take the initiative to attack the Houjin army at this timeBut Yuan Chonghuan didn't do anything, obviously didn't take Chongzhen's orders to heart!

Yuan Chonghuan has his own ideas, he just wants to defend as an attack, defend a city, he can always ask the court for money because of the resistance to Liao, and then be happy!

And Chongzhen also has his own ideas,Yuan Chonghuan will not listen to the order at this time, if there is a few more years, he is full-fledged, even if the Houjin army cannot attack it, he Yuan Chonghuan may also have the intention of rebellingSo for Chongzhen, Yuan Chonghuan will definitely die

Emperor Chongzhen's determination to execute Yuan Chonghuan may not be because he fell for the plot, otherwise he would not have killed Yuan Chonghuan eight months after he was arrested, then it is very likely that Emperor Chongzhen really wanted to execute Yuan Chonghuan. Because Yuan Chonghuan did something wrong at the beginning, Emperor Chongzhen was very unhappy.

Emperor Chongzhen is the king of the Ming Dynasty, but he is not a faint king, just because when he took over, the Ming Dynasty was already at the end of the crossbow, but Emperor Chongzhen is still very ambitious, he can bring down Wei Zhongxian has shown that he is capable, for Yuan Chonghuan's death, many people say that Emperor Chongzhen is in the Huang Taiji's counter-plan, so he killed Yuan Chonghuan, in fact, this is not necessarily, because Yuan Chonghuan was imprisoned for eight months from ** to execution. And Yuan Chonghuan is charged with two points, one is that Yuan Chonghuan negotiated peace with the enemy without permission, and the other is that Yuan Chonghuan executed the general Mao Wenlong without authorization.

After Yuan Chonghuan went to Liaodong, he was at odds with Mao Wenlong, and later Yuan Chonghuan killed Mao Wenlong without going through Emperor Chongzhen, which made Emperor Chongzhen very unhappy, and the consequences of killing Mao Wenlong were also unbearable for Yuan Chonghuan, because there was no Mao Wenlong, so the subordinates of Dongjiang Town did not listen to the command, which had a great impact on the situation at that time. It can be said that Yuan Chonghuan is a relatively good military strategist, but in terms of politics, Yuan Chonghuan is indeed not good enough.

When Huang Taiji approached the Beijing Division, Yuan Chonghuan led the soldiers to protect the military division without Chongzhen's consent, which was a taboo for soldiers, and he was not allowed to summon, and heavy troops could not enter the Beijing Division. So Yuan Chonghuan **, and later Huang Taiji wrote a letter to Chongzhen, saying that Yuan Chonghuan colluded with Huang Taiji. In the end, Yuan Chonghuan was executed, and his family was also implicated, in fact, it was all caused by his ignorance of politics.

After Yuan Chonghuan's death, the Ming Dynasty was powerless to resist and was always pressed and beaten by the Qing army, and it was a mistake for Emperor Chongzhen to kill Yuan Chonghuan. If Yuan Chonghuan is still there, the situation outside the border will be stable, and even if Li Zicheng later raises troops, he will have enough energy to deal with it.

The biggest uncertainty is that the wrong thing is definitely the wrong thing, Yuan Chonghuan is the most feared figure in Houjin, but it has also become Chongzhen's fear.

If Yuan Chonghuan is still there, the situation outside the border can be stabilized, since Yuan Chonghuan's death, the Ming Dynasty has been powerless to resist, has been pressed and beaten by the Qing army, Emperor Chongzhen killed Yuan Chonghuan is a mistake at all.

At that time, Emperor Chongzhen fell for Huang Taiji's counter-plot and mistakenly thought that Yuan Chonghuan was going to collaborate with the enemy and commit treason, and at this time Emperor Chongzhen couldn't afford to gamble, so he killed Yuan Chonghuan, which was just a political choice, there was no right or wrong.

The reason why Emperor Chongzhen decided to kill Yuan Chonghuan is very complicated, and the key reason is that Yuan Chonghuan first illegally killed the anti-Qing general Mao Wenlong, and this caused extremely serious consequences.

It's too late to kill, and killing the Ming Dynasty early can continue life. Yuan Chonghuan misled the country, deceived the monarch, called himself Pingliao for three years, Chongzhen poured the power of the country, but only knew that the turtle shrank, and the Houjin bypassed, and did not dare to break it, to the crisis of the imperial city; buy peace with the country's money and grain, and invest in the enemy; Friendly troops were attacked, and the fire was watched from the other side, so that the naval army was destroyed; Fake the holy decree, kill Mao Wenlong, and Houjin has no worries, firearms, cannons, and craftsmen are all in the hands of Houjin; Correspondence with Huang Taiji and others, private peace.

Wrong, use people without suspicion, and suspect people without suspicion. It can only show that Chongzhen is a faint monarch and will not use people to be a king.

Of course not, Emperor Chongzhen's mistakes are too numerous to mention. The biggest problem was that the heir was not determined, and the crown prince was not arranged to go to Nanjing.

There are a lot of mistakes, the most terrible thing is to kill Sun Chuanting and Lu Xiangsheng, and there is to pit the person who presided over the Jin Yi and the military department to death, Emperor Chongzhen is very diligent is Taikeng, from Wei Zhongxian to Sun Chuanting, all the people who can work are dead, leaving a bunch of waste to make money and do nothing, and then the country died.

The biggest one can't be said, he has a lot of tricks. But it is not an exaggeration to say that it is the most lacking in morality.

Is there nothing wrong with killing Yuan Chonghuan, has it been peaceful for five years? The sin of deception! Killing Mao Wenlong to solve the troubles of the Tartars, and having an ambiguous relationship with the enemy Huang Taiji, shouldn't he be killed? Why did Qianlong overturn the case for Yuan Dudu?

The biggest mistake was to kill Wei Zhongxian, otherwise the Ming Dynasty would still be there.

It is difficult to say whether the merits and demerits are right or wrong, and Yuan is the only person who has a general overview of the overall situation, inspires the morale of the army, uses iron-fisted means, and dares to say that he will recover Liao.

At that time, Yuan Chonghuan illegally killed Mao Wenlong, and it was difficult to give an explanation if he didn't kill him, and it was difficult to maintain the internal and external situation if he killed him, and it was difficult to make a choice.

Chongzhen has made too many mistakes, but it does not include the killing of Yuan Chonghuan.

After five years of Pingliao, he couldn't do why he bragged, so the Ming Dynasty wasted five years, and the treasury was hollowed out to support the border with no effect. This is where he should be damned, and he and the little wild boar skin privately negotiated peace, killing the general Mao Wenlong, who gave him the right,

Kill nothing. It may be worse not to kill.

After Zhang Taiyue's death, he searched his home for liquidation, causing the whole family to almost starve to death, and I feel that the civil and military generals behind him no longer trust the emperor, and it is definitely not wrong to kill Dudu, the evidence is conclusive.

It's too late to kill, and the silver has made this disaster over, and any emperor will kill it.

Chongzhen is the second mentally handicapped in history.

Emperor Chongzhen should not have given Inspector Yuan to death, after all, Inspector Yuan did a good job in Liaodong, and the reason why he was executed was because of Emperor Chongzhen's suspicious character.

In 1628, Emperor Chongzhen used Yuan Inspector for the second time, and while serving as the governor of Jiliao, he was also responsible for the defense of the Beijing division and the military command of Jin after the war outside the Guan. Judging from the entire strategic situation, it is an impossible task to complete Pingliao in five years, after all, the Huang Taiji outside the Guanxi has been basically unified, and the overall strength of the Eight Banners Army is above the strength of the Ming Army outside the Guan, so it is not a simple matter to recover Liaodong.

Huang Taiji outside the pass also tried to detour through Shanhaiguan to attack the Ming capital Jingshi from Mongolia, and in 1629 Yuan Inspector returned to the aid of the Beijing Division, and finally defeated the Eight Banners Army that entered the customs and successfully defended the safety of the Beijing Division. Although Huang Taiji's sneak attack was not successful, it still had a deterrent to the Ming Dynasty, and it also played a role in making Emperor Chongzhen gradually lose his trust in Yuan Inspector.

Although the relationship between Mao Wenlong of Phi Island and Houjin is a bit ambiguous, it does not affect Mao Wenlong's role in the Houjin troops, but Mao Wenlong's self-sustaining merit does not know how to converge, which caused Yuan Inspector's dissatisfaction. In addition, Liaodong's military salary is limited and Mao Wenlong's department has to ask for a huge amount, which aggravates Inspector Yuan's dissatisfaction with him, according to Emperor Chongzhen's will, Mao Wenlong's department should also be controlled by Inspector Yuan, but from the actual situation, Mao Wenlong has become a real emperor and does not take Inspector Yuan in his eyes.

In order to unify the government decree, Inspector Yuan got rid of Mao Wenlong without the permission of Emperor Chongzhen, which exacerbated Emperor Chongzhen's dissatisfaction with Inspector Yuan. Although Mao Wenlong was at fault, he did not commit a crime to death, and after his death, Phi Dao also lost its original role of restraint, making the situation in Liaodong more passive.

The suspicious Emperor Chongzhen still chose to believe in himself, and in the face of Yuan Inspector, who held a large army but did not listen to the command, Emperor Chongzhen was unwilling to give him another chance. Yuan Dushi, who had defeated the Houjin army, was executed by Emperor Chongzhen in 1629, ending his glorious life.

The killing of Inspector Yuan deprived the Ningyuan defense line of a qualified commander, and the battle with Houjin became more difficult. After that, Emperor Chongzhen had to exterminate the peasant army, and Hong Chengchou, who was very good at it, was in charge of Liaodong, but it was a pity that Hong Chengchou, who was not stable enough, fell short and was captured.

If Inspector Yuan does not die, the situation in Liaodong is still under control, at least Huang Taiji does not have much to do with the Guanning defense line. In addition, the Hong Chengchou Department of Henan and Shaanxi to suppress bandits does not need to transfer Liaodong, so that Li Zicheng's rebel army will not lose control, and in that case, the Ming Dynasty will not just perish, and maybe the Ming Dynasty will have a turning point.

I think it is indeed wrong, because Yuan Chonghuan was still relatively capable at that time, and he would definitely contribute to resisting the enemy.

Of course he was wrong, because Yuan Chonghuan was a patriotic general, and he fought well, and after killing him, no one would resist the Manchus.

Must die! once boasted that Haikou had been leveling Liaodong for five years, and Zhu Youzhen was stunned. spent two-thirds of the silver of the Ming Dynasty for more than a year, and as a result, not only did the Later Jin regime become more and more stable in Liaodong, but also the Ming Dynasty's control over the land of Liaodong continued to shrink.

Of course, seriously injuring Nurhachi in the bombardment is still a commendable feat, but it has been replaced by a more powerful Huang Taiji. Therefore, from Zhu Youzhen's point of view, Yuan Chonghuan's death is not a pity.

I think the killing was wrong. Although Yuan Chonghuan was guilty, the Ming Dynasty was the time to employ people, leaving Yuan Chonghuan to play a greater role.

If it is dealt with in accordance with the actual situation according to the law, it is enough to kill him by killing the island marshal without permission or bullying the emperor or leading the Qing army to Beijing or stationing in the capital without permission, but if the emperor's relationship is good, these charges can be turned a blind eye, not to mention that at this time he was involved in the party dispute between Qian Longxi and Zhou Yanru.

Kill the wrong one, kill it too late, to kill Yuan Chonghuan before Yuan Chonghuan kills Mao Wenlong, I don't know if Da Ming has been saved, but there is definitely nothing to do with Houjin.

There is no evidence of Chonghuan's rebellion, but according to Chongzhen's character, he speculated that "there will be a coup d'état in the country", so he "wisely" eliminated the trouble.