With Guan Yu s ability and character, is he suitable to be a fierce general of the three armies or a

To be honest, Guan Yunchang has his character shortcomings, he is only suitable for being a fierce general, not a marshal, and it can even be said that he is unqualified when he is a marshal.

Guan Yunchang, who is a fierce general, can almost be said to be an invincible existence.

Whether it is in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" or from the official history of "Three Kingdoms", Guan Yu's courage can be seen. The three heroes fought against Lu Bu, beheaded Yan Liang, Zhu Wenchou, and killed six generals after five passes, all of which realistically demonstrated their bravery.

Guan Yu is not afraid of pain, let alone death, this is exactly the character that a fierce general must have. When scraping bones to cure poison, Guan Yu smiled freely; When killing Yan Liang, "Yu looked at his cover, spurred the horse to be good among the crowd, and took his head back"; When scolding Sun Quan, Guan Yu said directly: "I can't destroy your evil", fearless, when it is broken, it is broken, it is a necessary quality for a fierce general, and Guan Yu has it.

Guan Yu's personality determines that it is difficult for him to be a marshal.

First of all, "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" clearly evaluates Guan Yu's character as "rigid and proud". A proud person is not easy to listen to the negative opinions of others, and it is difficult for him to become a qualified manager. In fact, it is precisely like this, when Sun Quan wanted to marry Guan Yu, Guan Yu refused with the sentence "The tiger girl has to marry a dog", which directly led to Lu Xun's crossing of the river in white.

In addition, when Guan Yu entered Luoyang, Cao Cao showed Sun Quan's letter to Guan Yu, which was equivalent to directly telling Dongwu about the upcoming sneak attack. But at this time, Guan Yu did not take any countermeasures, which can be said to be determined by Guan Yu's character. It can be said that Sun Quan's sneak attack on Guan Yu's rear directly took advantage of Guan Yu's careless character.

Secondly, Guan Yu is not good at uniting colleagues and subordinates. When Liu Bei canonized the Five Tiger Generals, Guan Yujie raised objections to Huang Zhong (the historical fact is that it is Ma Chao, and it was changed to Huang Zhong in "Romance"), and it was reconciled after Zhuge Liang's persuasion. Such a personality is bound to arouse the disgust of colleagues.

For example, when Guan Yu was defeated in Maicheng, Liu Feng and Meng Da planned to save Guan Yu, but when Liu Bei established an heir, Guan Yu said "My brother has a son, why use a moth".

In the end, turning a blind eye to danger is definitely not the behavior of a good manager. Guan Yu built a beacon tower to avoid a sneak attack by Eastern Wu in the rear, but he was overconfident, and even Cao Cao clearly told Guan Yu the news of the sneak attack of Eastern Wu, Guan Yu was still unmoved. That's definitely not what a good manager should be.

Summary. Some people may say that Guan Yu once flooded the Seventh Army after all, forcing Cao Cao to move the capital to avoid its edge. But after all, it was the luck component that accounted for the majority, and it happened that the skyrocketing Han water gave Guan Yu this opportunity.

And Liu Chan's nickname for Guan Yu "Zhuang Miaohou" can also explain this matter to a certain extent. The interpretation of the law is "the name and the truth are cool", and the name of Qin Hui in the Southern Song Dynasty is "Miao Chou", which shows that the word "Miao" is indeed not a good name.

It is suitable to be a fierce general of the three armies. Because Guan Yu is too upright and doesn't know how to forbear and strategize, it's okay for him to be a general, but if he is a marshal and leads the troops to fight, it is a bit lacking.

Fierce general, because Guan Yu is suitable for charging into battle, but he is too arrogant to make a strategy.

He is only suitable to be a fierce general of the three armies, because his character is too arrogant and cannot get along well with his subordinates.

After reading the description in the following paragraph of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, you will know.

Guan Gong came out with a promise, carried the green dragon knife, got on the red rabbit horse, and led several followers until the white horse came to see Cao Cao. Narration:"Yan Liang punished the two generals in a row, and he was brave enough to ask Yun Chang to discuss.

Guan Gong said:"Let someone look at it. "Treat each other with wine.

Ignore the report of Yan Liang's war. Cao Yin Guan Gong on Tushan**. Cao and Guan Gong sit, and the generals stand around.

Cao Cao pointed to the formation of Yan Liang platoon under the mountain, with a clear banner, guns and knives, strict and powerful, which is said to be Guan Gong:"Hebei people, so majestic! "Guan Gong said:

In my opinion, it is like a chicken and a dog ear! "and said:"Under the cover, the embroidered robe and gold armor, and the person who holds the knife immediately, is Yan Liangye.

Guan Gong raised his eyes and said:"I look at Yan Liang, such as inserting a label to sell the first ear! "said:

Not to be taken lightly. "Guan Gong got up and said:"Although he is not talented, he is willing to go to the army to take his head and offer the prime minister.

Zhang Liao said:"There is no joke in the army, and the cloud chief cannot be ignored. "Guan Gong hurriedly got on the horse, lifted the green dragon knife upside down, and ran down the mountain, the phoenix's eyes were wide open, the silkworm eyebrows were straight, and he rushed straight to the other side.

The Hebei army is like a wave cracking, and Guan Gongjing is running to Yan Liang. Yan Liang was under the cover, and when he saw Guan Gong rushing over, when he wanted to ask, Guan Gong was fast and had already run in front of him; Yan Liang was caught off guard, and was stabbed under the horse by Yun Chang. Suddenly, he got off the horse, cut off Yan Liang's head, tied it to the horse, flew on the horse, and carried the knife out of the battle, as if entering a no-man's land.

The Hebei soldiers were shocked and chaotic without a fight. Cao Jun took advantage of the situation to attack, and the dead were innumerable; Horses and equipment, looting a lot. Guan Gong went up the mountain immediately, and all the generals congratulated him.

The public dedicates the head before the exercise. said:"The general is really a god and a man!

Guan Gong said:"What a way! My brother Zhang Yide took the head of the general in the million-dollar army, like probing the bag and taking the ear.

the big surprise, look back left and right and say:"In the future, if you meet Zhang Yide, you can't underestimate the enemy. "The order is written on the bottom of the robe to remember it. ”

If you compare the comprehensive ability of Guan Yu with all the generals under Cao Cao,At least it can be ranked in the top three. For Cao Cao,Guan Yu is a fierce general he has always wanted but can't get. Although there are not many famous generals in the Shu Han camp, Guan Yu, as the general of the Five Tigers, is very famous in Shu Han, Cao Wei and Eastern Wu.

In addition to Cao Cao, Sun Quan also wanted to recruit Guan Yu, but Guan Yu refused.

If you ask who had the most generals under Cao Cao during the Three Kingdoms period, it must be Cao Cao. Shu Han had five tiger generals, and Cao Wei naturally had themThe five good generals are Zhang Liao, Le Jin, and Zhang HeYu Ban followed Xu Huang.

Although their fame is not as great as that of the Five Tiger Generals, they are also not to be underestimated. In addition, there are two fierce generals who personally guard Cao CaoDian Wei and Xu Chu, they are also all well-known figures in the Three Kingdoms period, not to mentionXiahoudun, Cao Ren, Xiahouyuan, Pang De and Li Dianand many other generals. Shu Han and Eastern Wu did not have as many famous generals as Cao Wei combined, which is why Cao Wei has always been the most powerful of the Three Kingdoms.

Guan Yu and Cao Wei Wujiang Because the Three Kingdoms are relatively far away from now, many documents have been lost, and they can only understand the situation at that time through some biographies and **. Although there are not many records about Guan Yu in history, Guan Yu is from the Shu Han camp after all, so naturally there will be many scenes of fighting with Cao Wei's generals. For example, it is mentioned in the twenty-fifth chapter of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms".When Guan Yu fought with Xu Huang and Xu Chu at the beginning, he directly killed the two of them, which is enough to show that his combat power is above the two.

After all, Xu Huang and Xu Chu are both top generals in Cao Cao's camp, and they still ended up being killed by Guan Yu.

A general under Yuan ShaoYan Liang, as a first-class military general in the Three Kingdoms period, directly defeated the entire Cao Wei camp to the point that no one dared to fight, and finally relied on Guan Yu to successfully kill Yan Liang. It can be seen from this that Guan Yu was basically unstoppable in Cao Wei's camp at that time. Later, he rode five levels and six generals alone, which directly established his prestige.

In addition to this, heonce fought with Yu Ban, one of the five good generals, and directly captured him; is also Pound, who was captured during the battle with Yu Ban, after being defeated and captured, Pang De did not choose to surrender, and finally ended up being killed by Guan Yu and Guan Yu.

The Battle of Xiangfan After the Battle of Xiangfan broke out, Guan Yuhas fought with Cao Ren, Xu Huang, Le Jin and othersAlthough there is no record of the outcome of these battles in history, it can be known from the documents left behind that there is no case of Guan Yu's defeatAt most, it is just a tie, which is enough to see that his strength can rank in the top three in Cao Wei. It's a pity that when Guan Yu won a big victory, he was attacked by Lu Meng, Lu Xun and others of Eastern Wu, and ended up with a defeat in the case of Cao Cao's general Xu Huang being flanked head-on. In the end, he was ambushed by Ma Zhong and ended up being capturedThis is something that many people don't expect.

Guan Yu's knife is fast and heavy, plus the red rabbit horse, the impact is stronger, no one can stop the beginning of the three-plate axe, throughout the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, there are few people who fight with Guan Yu for 30 rounds, or die from the first three knives. Either win or lose, Guan Yu's nemesis is Lu Bu and Ma Chao, I am afraid that this kind of comprehensive ability is strong, and the strength can carry Guan Yu's three knives, endurance and speed can keep up, and Guan Yu will not be able to hit the back.

In the romance, Guan Yu was raised very high, but Cao Cao gave Guan Yu the official position, and Guan Yu made some small contributions since the battle of Guandu, and named him a partial general, worshipping the Marquis of Hanshou Pavilion. and Zhang Liao and Xu Chu, who are also generals under Cao Cao's account, one is a former general and the other is a partial general. The four generals in the front and rear left and right are only higher than the general Pi, that is, the deputy general.

When Wei Yan surrendered to Liu Bei, he was the former adjutant general of the army. In other words, Guan Yu is not as good as Zhang Liao in Cao Cao's heart!

Guan Yu's strength can be said to be one of the best in Cao Wei, but the status of the legion will definitely not exceed the five sons, let alone the commanders of other military regions. Because he is a general, and the old master is still alive, he is still a mortal enemy. Cao Cao is too big to put Guan Yu on the front line to reuse, at most let him do logistics or something, or deputy generals, and even find someone to supervise Guan Yu.

Cao Cao's subordinates were closest to the clan members. The most elite tiger and leopard cavalry and Guanzhong army have always been the generals of the Cao and Xiahou clans. In the army, there must be Cao and Xiahou generals to hold important positions in the army.

There is no doubt that Guan Yu is very powerful, his ability may be the first, but his status can only be below the generals of the Cao clan and the Xiahou clan.

If Guan Yu stays under Cao Cao, he is definitely suspicious and used, the situation is a bit like Zhang Liao, Zhang He, Xu Huang, these generals, Cao Cao is either to add a Cao Xiahou general above them and let them be deputy generals, or he is the main general with fewer troops, Guan Yu, the main general at the level of the war zone, don't even think about it, no way, this is Cao Apu's consistent style of employing people, Liu Bei didn't care about the stain that Guan Yu had surrendered to Cao Cao, he still chose to believe in Guan Yu and treat it the same as in the past, This is Guan Yu's true idea of riding back to Liu Bei's side alone. Because Guan Yu knew Liu Bei too well, and later understood Cao Cao, he finally chose Liu Bei.

Comprehensive ability ranking is lower than Xu Huang Lower than Xiahou Yuan Lower than Cao Ren Lower than Zhang Liao Ranking Five to six On the whole, I look at the handsome talent Strategy The overall situation Cao Cao's camp Xu Huang does not need to question the overall situation everywhere The overall situation is the most important ability to be the first of the handsome talents. Xiahou Yuan is suitable for being a deputy marshal, and the troops are good at frequent surprise attacks and quick attacks, with speed as the core. Cao Ren is brave and strategic, good at guarding, and is very good at motivating his subordinates to create contradictions, attack contradictions, and make morale rise rapidly, and can be entrusted with guarding a domain.

Zhang Liao is courageous, strategic, resolute, and resolute, attaches great importance to the overall situation, and even if there are contradictions with colleagues, he can be tolerant in jointly defending against the enemy, and unite as one. Guan Yu: Cao Cao likes it because Guan Chongxin values righteousness, and Cao Cao himself cherishes it. Guan Yu himself is no problem in commanding this aspect, but in many details, there are many problems, which are fatal, and it can be seen that he will not have too many problems with Liu Bei But once he guards a domain, no one looks at the person in charge The inner expansion desire is very strong Almost in his team, except for the generals who are heroes and cherish heroes, heroes and heroes, most of the strategic think tanks are for work, and they make do with him It can be said that they spoil him Losing Jingzhou It is not the Wei-Wu alliance Not Liu Bei Zhuge Liang It is this arrogance and pride.

Therefore, in Cao Cao's camp, the overall ranking is fifth and sixth.

It is suitable to be a fierce general of the three armies. Because Guan Yu doesn't have much strategy, he is easy to act out of whim. He is only suitable for leading armies in battlefield duels, and if he commands three armies, it will only bury his force.

is definitely suitable to be a fierce general, because he is inferior to many people in strategy, so he is only suitable for war.

With Guan Yu's ability, he is not only suitable for the fierce general of the three armies, but also suitable for serving as the commander of the three armies, he can stab Yan Liang to death in front of the white horse formation, and he can cut off the North Road and flood the Seventh Army in command, and shock China, and finally Cao Cao personally went out to fight, and then sent Xu Huang, Xiahoudun, Zhang Liao and other fierce generals, and Sun Quan sent Lu Meng, Jiang Qin, Pan Zhang and Zhu Ran and others to sneak attack behind their backs, one after another, which eliminated Guan Yu.

In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Sima Yi, Meng Huo, Zhao Yun, Ma Chao, and Zhang Fei are all above Guan Yu.

There are Lu Bu, Dian Wei, Zhao Yun, the abilities of these fierce generals are above Guan Yu, of course, the main thing is martial arts, if you talk about military talent, there should be few people who are stronger than Guan Yu.

In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, the abilities of Zhang Fei, Dian Wei, Lu Bu, Zhao Yun, Ma Chao, Sima Yi and others are all above Guan Yu.

In terms of military ability, Lu Bu is recognized as the number one fierce general of the Three Kingdoms, and he is naturally above Guan Yu. In terms of comprehensive ability, Zhao Yun and Zhang Liao should be good candidates, and they are better than Guan Yu in terms of resourcefulness and relationship handling.