How did Chu Geliang and Guan Yu die?

Zhuge Liang died of illness and died in Wuzhang Plain. Guan Yu was captured alive by Wu Guo and beheaded without surrendering.

In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, their real body is Sun Quan, and Lu Meng ordered Pan Zhang to kill Guan Yu after catching Zhuge Liang died of illness in the army After the Romance of the Three Kingdoms was defeated and took Maicheng, Guan Yu was captured alive and was killed by Sun Quan Zhuge Liang failed to continue his life with a seven-star lamp, and finally died in Wuzhangyuan.

Zhuge Liang died in Wuzhangyuan, and Guan Gong was executed by Lü Meng in Maicheng.

Guan Yu had excellent records in his life, but he alone could not resist the attack of 10,000 people, under the front and rear attacks of the enemy, and the Shu army was not fully prepared, Guan Yu was only defeated and killed.

When Guan Yu was guarding Jingzhou, Sun Quan pretended to take Zhuge Jin's family as hostages and sent him to Liu Bei to ask for Jingzhou. Liu Bei saw Zhuge Liang's face and promised to return the three counties of Jingzhou first, so he repaired a letter and handed it to Guan Yu, trying to refuse to return Jingzhou through Guan Yu's mouth. After Zhuge Jin returned from defeat, Sun Quan pinned his hatred on Guan Yu alone.

Then Sun Quan thought that since Uncle Liu Huang had promised to return the three counties, he would directly send three ** to the three counties to take office. As a result, he was blasted out by Guan Yu again. At this time, Sun Quan hated Guan Yu even more.

It can be said that Zhuge Liang used Guan Yu as a shield, and blamed Guan Yu alone for the inevitable contradictions between Liu Bei and Sun Quan. Later, he was unable to help Guan Yu in time, resulting in Guan Yu being captured and killed by Sun Quan.

In fact, after the three-legged tripod, if Zhuge Liang is willing to give up a little territory to Sun Quan, in order to dredge the relationship between the two families and work together to resist Cao. Guan Yu will not die, and there may not be a later situation.

Zhuge Liang did not have the crime of "framing" Guan Yu, but he had the fault of "indulgence". There is some secondary responsibility for Guan Yu's death.

1. At that time, although Zhuge Liang was named "General of the Military Division", the actual work he did was mainly to collect taxes, levy troops and transport grain, maintain law and order, take charge of criminal law, punish "disloyalty", eliminate "internal enemies" and so on. In short, Zhuge Liang's work belongs to internal management, and military planning is not within the scope of Zhuge Liang's work.

2. It was precisely because Liu Bei's group underestimated the possibility of Sun Quan's surrender that Liu Bei confidently and boldly proclaimed himself the "King of Hanzhong", causing a group of subordinates to work around him, thus ignoring the "dangerous situation" in Jingzhou. Generally speaking, although Zhuge Liang bears some indirect responsibility for Guan Yu's death, it is impossible for him to kill Guan Yu with a knife. Because Zhuge Liang did not expect Sun Quan to surrender to Cao Cao.

Even Ma Liang, the envoy sent by Liu Bei to Eastern Wu, was deceived by Sun Quan, not to mention Zhuge Liang, a person who was concentrating on internal affairs?

3, Zhuge Liang adopted the strategy of "false and wrongful, clever maneuvering" against Guan Yu, which is indeed true, but if Guan Yu is jealous of Zhuge Liang, it is pure nonsense. Guan Yu, as a military general guarding one side, will not hinder Zhuge Liang's promotion for the time being. Zhuge Liang's real competitor is not Guan Yu, but Fa Zheng.

Fa is Liu Bei's "mastermind", and he once put forward different opinions on Zhuge Liang's "strict punishment and strict law". But even so, Zhuge Liang never thought of "getting rid of" Fa Zheng, on the contrary, he once connived at Fa Zheng's "indiscriminate killing of innocents".

4, Guan Yu and Fa Zheng are Liu Bei's henchmen, even if they make serious mistakes, Liu Bei will not do anything to them. Zhuge Liang knew this, so he never clashed head-on with them. This also shows that Zhuge Liang is cautious by nature and never does dangerous things.

So, how dare he do such a dangerous thing as "borrowing a knife to kill Guan Yu"?

5, Zhuge Liang did not have the crime of "framing" Guan Yu, but he had the fault of "indulgence". Because Zhuge Liang never pointed out Guan Yu's shortcomings, Guan Yu was arrogant, and as a result, he fell for the Wu people and lost his life. To some extent, Zhuge Liang "killed" Guan Yu, but this "killing" was unintentional and not intentional.

This is also a common mistake of Liu Bei's group.

For more information.

There is no clear evidence that Zhuge Liang killed Guan Yu.

Guan Yu's death can be speculated to be related to Zhuge Liang, 1Guan Yu and Liu Bei did not bow down, and Guan Yu's status at that time threatened Zhuge Liang.

2.Guan Yu was too arrogant and dissatisfied with Zhuge Liang.

3.After Liu Bei's death, the power will be divided by Guan Yu.

4.After Guan Yu's death, Jingzhou was turbulent, Cao Cao would definitely come to fight Jingzhou, and Liu Bei would have time to prepare for other things, such as going to Liangzhou and sending troops to Chang'an.

Compared to Guan Yu's death, it has a great impact on Shu, so Zhuge Liang will not do this, and the world that he has worked so hard to fight may send him off.

Unlikely. Zhuge Liang's status at that time was too far from Guan Yu, and he had no chance to harm him.

Guan Yu's death was definitely his own reason.

No, it's Guan Yu who is too conceited and arrogant.

No way! This is wrong!

I don't know about this, anyway, the head is Lu Meng's.

It turns out that Guan Yu is not as good as Lu Meng!!

Whether it's romance or official history.

Since it is a war, there is no fairness.

Who told you that Guan Yu didn't notice? Jingzhou, which robbed others.

Now that people are asking for it, don't blame them for their tricks.

The Three Kingdoms originally looked at the strategy, not who was fierce.

If you don't know this, then your Romance of the Three Kingdoms for so many years has been in vain.

Ping,, because Guan Yu is much older than Xu Chu When Guan Yu was in his 30s, Xu Chu was only in his 20s and had not yet reached his heyday, first of all, let's talk about the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Cao Cao has always been a negative character in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Liu Bei has always been orthodox, it can be said that the protagonist is Liu Bei, who will say that the protagonist is not good, and Guan Yu under him must also exaggerate.

Guan yu. 's death was ostensibly self-inflicted, but in fact, the deeper reason should be attributed to Liu Bei.

All this and Zhuge Liang.

It doesn't matter at all.

Pang Tong. After dying in battle, Liu Bei urgently put Zhuge Liang and Zhang Fei.

Zhao Yun was transferred to Xichuan. Since then, Zhuge Liang has not had much to do with Jingzhou.

To seize Yizhou, Liu Bei took Pang Tong, and Zhuge Liang sat in Jingzhou. In Hanzhong, Liu Bei brought Fa Zheng, and Zhuge Liang's task was to raise grain, grass and soldiers.

In other words, during this period of time, Liu Bei, the fish, spent most of his time swimming in the water of Pang Tong and Fazheng.

Zhuge Liang did not have the power to command Guan Yu to launch this battle, nor could he control Liu Bei's will. Even after the Battle of Xiangfan, Fa Zhengji died, and Liu Bei used the slogan of avenging Guan Yu to conquer Sun Quan.

When Zhuge Liang didn't mean it, but he was helpless. I can only sigh afterwards, if the law is correct, it will definitely be able to stop the lord's crusade to the east, even if it can't be stopped, there will be no such defeat. How sad!

Liu Bei's series of mistakes in the political layout indirectly caused Guan Yu's death.

After capturing Yizhou, Liu Bei's strategic focus shifted to Yizhou. There is nothing wrong with this approach, and it is also the inevitability of the situation.

However, Liu Bei should not forget that Jingzhou is an important support point for the Northern Expedition in the future. Jingzhou is the place of four wars, and since Zhuge Liang and others left, Guan Yu is left to support him. As a military general, Guan Yu is qualified and has enough shocking power.

However, defending Jingzhou requires not only the strength of Kong Wu, but also the strategy, which is precisely what Guan Yu lacks.

What's more, Guan Yu is facing two large groups, both of which have sufficient generals and strategists, such as Dongwu.

Wu Meng, Lu Xun.

Cao Wei's Cao Ren, Xu Huang.

Before taking Hanzhong, Sun Wu.

There is already friction in Jingzhou, Liu Bei should let Zhuge Liang go to Soochow to completely solve the entanglement with Soochow, even if it can't be solved once and for all, at least the big contradiction between the two sides should be eliminated.

An indisputable truth is that Liu Bei is unable to deal with the two battlefields at the same time, so Liu Bei should let Guan Yu make it clear that he should not start the war lightly.

In addition, there was no uninterrupted contact with Jingzhou, and from the time Guan Yu launched the Battle of Xiangfan to the defeat of Maicheng, for several months, neither the instructions and orders of Yizhou nor the rescue in times of crisis could be seen. Just let Guan Yu dance alone, this is a bit abnormal.

It's a pity that Liu Bei didn't do it.

This series of mistakes, coupled with Guan Yu's arrogance and conceit, sent Guan Yu to the point of no return.

has nothing to do with Zhuge Liang, the reason why Guan Yu died was entirely because of his proud and complacent personality.

Yes, Zhuge Liang obviously knew that Guan Yu and Mi Fang's personalities were incompatible, so he shouldn't let them partner up.

I think Guan Yu's death still has something to do with Zhuge Liang, because Zhuge Liang should know that Guan Yu is a relatively arrogant person, so he can't put him in such an important position to defend Jingzhou, and he can't let him face Dongwu alone.

Guan Yu's death is not without doubt:

1. After Guan Yu's death, it stands to reason that Liu Bei should posthumously seal him and give him a nickname, but Liu Bei did not posthumously seal Guan Yu, and Guan Yu's nickname Zhuang Miaohou was posthumously sealed by the later lord Liu Chan;

2, Mi Fang (Liu Bei's brother-in-law) and Fu Shiren are Liu Bei's cronies, and as Guan Yu's subordinates guarding Jingzhou, they are also dissatisfied with Guan's stubbornness, and they watch from the wall at critical moments, so that Guan Yu cannot get assistance; Liu Bei once wanted to establish Liu Feng, but Guan Yu also strongly opposed ......In the long run, the people around Liu Bei will inevitably have a gap with Guan Yu, 3, do you remember the plot of Guan Yu's trip to Huarong Dao? Zhuge calculated that Guan would let Cao Cao go, knowing that he would lose the opportunity to engage in military law, but he still wanted Guan Yu to make a military order, what did he want?

Whether it is a legend or a conjecture, in short, Guan Yu's personality shortcomings have caused many people to be unhappy, and it has determined that many people are willing to die in their hearts.

There is indeed such a saying in the current historical and literary circles, that Zhuge Liang killed Liu Bei's cronies one by one in order to monopolize power, and killed Liu Bei's righteous son Liu Feng, so that Liu Bei had to pass on the throne to the young and weak Liu Chan, and he could achieve the goal of overriding Liu Chan and satisfying his desire for power.

Of course, this is just a family opinion, let's listen to it, as a school of thought, but not all of it. Conspiracy theories are more popular in the current historical world, looking for clues from some clues in history, far-fetched to say that it is a conspiracy, and some people believe that Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang conspired to kill Guan Yu in order to achieve the purpose of limiting Guan Yu's power position from expanding too quickly.

In fact, there is no conspiracy here, Guan Yu's death is indeed his own fault and meritorious service. Zhuge Liang was still relatively young at the time, and his status was indeed not very high, he was in charge of logistics, and he did not have the ability and responsibility to plan the overall situation.

At that time, after Liu Bei's hard battle in the Battle of Hanzhong, he seized Hanzhong with the strength of the country, and began to seal rewards, giving the four generals of the front, right, left and rear, Guan Yu as the former general, Zhang Fei as the right general, Ma Chao as the left general, and Huang Zhong as the rear general. Guan Yu was not convinced, and was unwilling to be in the same ranks with veterans like Huang Zhong, but considering that he did not contribute to the battle of Hanzhong, he had to swallow his anger, and was eager to capture Fancheng and Xiangyang to prove his status as the number one general of Shu, so he gave up the rear defense of Jiangling, and under the paralysis of Lu Meng and Lu Xun's strategy, he continued to send reinforcements to reinforce the front line of Fancheng until Jiangling was lost, and Guan Yu was defeated by Xu Huang on the front line.

It was he who really killed Guan Yu, it was the greed of human nature, his own greed for merit, and he had a fluke mentality and relaxed his guard against Soochow. Soochow has always been despised by others, but it has always been able to achieve victory when people are not expecting.

In July of Jian'an 24, Guan Yu launched"Battle of Xiangfan"Famous in China. It was also the beginning of its downfall; Taking advantage of the emptiness of Jingzhou, Dongwu made a sneak attack and killed Guan Yu. But the Battle of Xiangfan was fought from July to December, what was the Shu Han regime doing?

Until Guan Yu was defeated, Liu Bei did not send a single soldier; Lord Zhuge didn't show him anything"Longzhong pair"Zhong Xiang Liu Bei said that he cooperated with Guan Yu to send troops to Guanzhong. To this end; I specially ask netizens for their opinions: Hypothesis 1 is not Lord Zhuge borrowing a knife to kill.

Hypothesis 2 Lord Zhuge deceived Liu Bei and said; Cao Wei was preparing to crusade against Shu Han and could not divide his troops to save Jingzhou.

Hypothesis 3 Liu Bei hated Guan Yu and did not want to see him great. Kill him with a sword. (This assumption is bold).

It shouldn't be, Zhuge in the official history actually did not have a high status in the early Liu Bei group, and the fledgling burning of Bowangpo and the burning of Xinye were all made up.

Zhuge really played the mainstay in the Later Shu Han Dynasty, which means that Zhuge did not have much power and status to kill Guan Yu in the early stage.

I don't know.

However, Guan Zhang and other veteran bosses died.

Brother Pig is the biggest beneficiary.

From the point of view of the principle that whoever benefits is who starts, it is estimated that maybe, probably, probably, probably.

According to relevant historical records, Guan Yu died at the hands of Lu Xun.

This is just a rumor, Guan Yu was killed by Lu Meng.