How did Guan Yu and Zhang Fei die in real history?

Guan Yu in history.

and Zhang Fei's cause of death is basically the same as the record in **, Guan Yu did defeat Maicheng after defeating the battle, and then was killed by Soochow.

of the governor of Lymon.

Captured alive, and finally decapitated in a different place. After hearing the news, Zhang Fei became particularly angry, so the generals in the army persuaded him with wine, who knew that Zhang Fei became more irritable and whipped the soldiers after drinking, so he was cut off by his own soldiers at night, and the soldiers who cut off his head surrendered to Soochow. <>

In fact, we all know that the difference between the official history and ** is still relatively large, in order to set off some key characters in **, so we will forcibly add some scenes to these key characters, but I have to say that the description of Guan Yu and Zhang Fei's death ** is relatively in line with history. Guan Yu and Zhang Fei should be regarded as one of the more powerful generals in the Three Kingdoms period, Liu Bei.

The reason why the last Shu Han was formed.

The regime also completely relied on the help of these two generals, and the death of these two generals in the end was very embarrassing. <>

At the beginning, after Liu Bei got Jingzhou, he wanted to carry out the next strategic intention, that is, to take Hanzhong, so he entrusted the entire Jingzhou to his general Guan Yu. Note that there is no record of the story of Liu Bei, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei Taoyuan's three alliances in history. After entrusting Jingzhou to Guan Yu, Liu Bei took his soldiers and horses to attack Hanzhong, and at this time, Guan Yu launched the Xiangfan Battle in order to reduce Liu Bei's pressure.

At the beginning, Guan Yu did have the upper hand, flooded the Seventh Army, and captured Yu Ban alive. <>

But then Sun Quan of Eastern Wu.

felt that if Liu Bei succeeded in taking Hanzhong, it would be too much of a threat to him, so he fought with Cao Cao.

cooperated before and after the attack on Guan Yu, and in this way, Guan Yu was defeated by Maicheng. Zhang Fei himself is also an anxious person, and he is also very irritable after hearing that his good brother was killed, plus Zhang Fei often whips the soldiers in his own army in ordinary times, so at this critical moment, Zhang Fei was beheaded by the soldiers under his hands, and the death was also quite aggrieved.

Guan Yu was captured after carelessly losing Jingzhou, and then was executed by Sun Quan; Zhang Fei was because he was short-tempered and killed innocents, and one night when he got drunk, two of his subordinates took the opportunity to take his head and fled to Soochow.

Guan Yu was captured by Lü Meng and then executed by Sun Quan; Zhang Fei was killed by Fan Jiang and Zhang Da while sleeping.

Guan Yu was killed after being ambushed and captured after defeating Maicheng, and Zhang Fei was killed by his generals.

Zhang Fei was killed by his subordinates after whipping the soldiers, and Guan Yu was defeated by Dongwu Lumeng after the defeat of Maicheng, Guan Yu was attacked by the enemy on his back, captured by Pan Zhang's department, and was killed in frustration.

After Zhang Fei entered Shu with Liu Bei, he marched into Xichuan with Zhuge Liang and Zhao Yun and divided the counties into counties.

When he arrived in Jiangzhou, he relieved Liu Zhang's Ba County Taishou Yan Yan.

In 215, in the Battle of Brazil, he defeated the famous Wei general Zhang He, and the county of Brazil has since been secured. Mingqiao Sen.

In 221, Liu Bei was proclaimed emperor, and Zhang Fei was promoted to general of the chariot cavalry, commander of the division, and marquis of Xixiang.

Zhang Fei went to Eastern Wu to avenge the killing of Guan Yu, before sending out the army, he whipped the soldiers after drinking, and the generals could not bear it, so he sneaked into Zhang Fei's camp tent at night, Zhang Fei was killed by his generals Fan Qiang and Zhang Da, and defected to Eastern Wu overnight.

After Guan Yu was in the Battle of Chibi, Liu Bei assisted Zhou Yu of Eastern Wu to attack Cao Ren of Nanjun, and did not send Guan Yu to the north to block Cao Cao's reinforcements.

Liu Bei entered Yizhou, and Guan Yu stayed in Jingxiao.

In the twenty-fourth year of Jian'an, Guan Yu surrounded Xiangfan, Cao Cao sent Yu Ban to come to reinforcements, Guan Yu captured Yu Ban, killed Pang De, and shocked Huaxia, Cao Cao had wanted to move the capital to avoid its sharpness.

Later, Cao Cao sent Xu Huang to reinforcements, and Lü Meng of Eastern Wu attacked Jingzhou again, Guan Yu was attacked by the enemy on his back, captured by Pan Zhang's troops, and was killed in Linfang.

1. Guan Yu was killed by Sun Quan. Sun Quan agreed to Cao Cao's conditions and attacked Jingzhou, captured Guan Yu's family, and captured Guan Yu alive, killing Guan Yu after persuading Guan Yu to surrender.

2. Zhang Fei was killed by his own soldiers. Zhang Fei was guarding in Langzhong, and learned that Guan Yu was killed, so he wanted to avenge Guan Yu, and strictly ordered the army to make white armor in a trembling block, and the soldiers could not make it out at the specified time, so they took advantage of Zhang Fei's drunkenness to kill Zhang Wei Mengfei.

Guan Yu was defeated and took Mai Cheng, and in the end, the father and son were captured and did not give in, and were finally killed.

Zhang Fei was cut off by his subordinates while sleeping and defected to others.

Lao Zhang was indeed killed by his subordinates, and it seems that Zizhi Tongjian and the Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms have records.

Guan Yu's death is similar to what is said in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms.

Guan Yu Jingzhou City was broken and let Dongwu kill him.

Zhang Fei asked his subordinate Fan Jiang and Zhang Da to kill him.

It's the same as written in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms.

Zhang Fei was drunk. It's been a second to be abused by the usual pawn.。

What is written in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is right, that is, that death.

Zhang Fei died of old age. The so-called being killed by his subordinates and cutting off his head are all **. Now people are all ** as history.

Ah!

Well, just a joke.

To look at this question, it is necessary to analyze the personalities, talents, and circumstances of the two of them.

Guan Yu and Zhang Fei are both brave and powerful. Strategically, Guan Yu is a little stronger. Zhang Fei has a much straighter personality. And Guan Yu was very proud.

If you think about it, it is impossible for a person who has a very close relationship with the top leader and is relatively talented, but has an arrogant personality, not to be reused.

The problem comes, under normal circumstances, Guan Yu will naturally handle it well. However, when it comes to major and critical issues, if the judgment is wrong, the handling will be biased, especially in certain situations where others deliberately create them.

When Zhuge Liang asked Guan Yu to guard Jingzhou, he repeatedly instructed him to join forces with Sun to resist Cao, if it weren't for Guan Yu's character, Zhuge Liang would not have done this, because there was no more suitable candidate, and he could only choose Guan Yu, and it was impossible to change (unless Zhuge Liang went by himself), because of the relationship between the first and Liu Bei; There is no one else who can replace Guan Yu's position in Liu Bei's heart. Clause.

Second, Guan Yu's character. When Ma Chao returned to Shun, Guan Yu once wanted to abandon Jingzhou and enter Yizhou to compete with him; The performance of the five tiger generals. And Guan Yu has been outside for a long time, and if he has been in charge for a long time, he will become the first in the world.

There is still time to buffer in normal times, but in an emergency, it is too late. Therefore, when Zhuge Liang heard Guan Yu's attitude towards Sun Quan in Jingzhou, he was ready to go to Jingzhou to replace Guan Yu in person. This is Zhuge Liang's sorrow.

And Zhang Fei's personality is upright, this kind of person is actually liked by every leader, can do things, has a temper, and will be fine when he finishes it. Under normal circumstances, as long as no one frames (Naoto has no scheming), nothing will happen, and who dares to frame the brothers of the supreme leader? And such a lethal and easy-to-use tool without scheming is destined to be by the leader's side for a long time, so there is no risk for this kind of person when the leadership strategy is right.

People like Guan Yu either don't have an accident, or something big happens. In the troubled times of the Three Kingdoms era, it was impossible not to have a big event, so Guan Yu's fate was doomed.

Hope it helps.

Because Liu Bei was afraid of being divided by his brothers, he let Guan Yu guard the outside, and the partisan dispute that had just entered Shu at that time was serious, so no one increased troops to rescue. In addition, Liu Feng and Meng Da were not rescued, and they were copied by Wu Guo and Lu Meng and died. As a result, Guan Yu watched the Spring and Autumn Period every day, which led to myopia, so he didn't dodge Huang Zhong's hidden arrows in the competition with Huang Zhong, which proved his myopia, and finally caused him to be secretly injured by a poisoned arrow when he fought with Cao Renjun.

Leave the root of the disease. In the end, he was killed by Ma Zhong and Pan Zhang. Shi Ran, Liu Feng and Guan Yu were political victims.

Guan Yu was a soldier and a famous man of the misanthropic clan, especially Zhuge Liang. Therefore, Zhuge Liang wanted to seize power and would not save it, and secretly informed Liu Feng that Liu Feng was Liu Bei's righteous son not long after. Liu Bei killed Liu Feng in order to prevent his righteous son from sharing his son's power and Zhuge plotting.

Zhang Fei beat the soldier because of his anger and was killed by his subordinates.

Zhang Fei was in too much of a hurry to avenge Guan Yu and was killed by his subordinates.

It's a matter of history, well,,, what can be the reason.

Guan Yu was at war with Cao Ren in Fancheng. Unexpectedly, Sun Quan took advantage of the situation and sent Lü Meng and his subordinates (Zhu Ran and Pan Zhang) to attack Guan Yu's base in Jingzhou (Gong'an and Nanjun); As a result, Guan Yu, who went out to fight, lacked skills, and when Guan Yu retreated south, Zhu Ran's subordinate Ma Zhong captured the homeless Guan Yu (and his son Guan Ping) and others. Finally, Sun Quan ordered the captives Guan Yu and others to be beheaded.

In the same year, Liu Bei called Guan Yu to take revenge and conquer Eastern Wu, and Zhang Fei prepared to send troops to Jiangzhou in Langzhong.

When he was about to set off, his generals Zhang Da and Fan Qiang**, and even took their heads to Sun Quan, Liu Bei heard that Zhang Fei had a watch, and shouted: "Oh! Fly to death. ”

The later lord Liu Chan was posthumously named the Marquis of Huan.

The torso of his body was buried in Langzhong, and his head was buried in Yunyang, and there were Zhang Huanhou Temple and Zhang Huan Hou Temple respectively.

It's not easy to answer the question, please click [Satisfied] in the upper right corner to encourage, thank you!!

God was jealous of talent, jealous of a person's talent, and let his fate be bumpy, so he took his life early! Generally refers to a person who is very intelligent and outstanding.

The king of Hades told him to die in the Three Classics, and he did not dare to keep people until the Five Classics.

This question is not simple, because of the lack of life.

Zhang Fei was a famous general of the Shu Han Dynasty during the Three Kingdoms period, and his friendship with Liu Bei and Guan Yu was called "friends of life and death". He is brave and good at fighting, and he has the courage of ten thousand people, and later generations will call him and Guan Yu "ten thousand enemies".