In the end, why was the situation of the Three Kingdoms broken, and Zhuge Liang s long term plan sha

Before Liu Bei was defeated by Lu Xun at that time, the strength of Shu had already surpassed Wei! The main reason is that most of the troops of Shu were burned by Lu Xun when Liu Bei and Lu Xun were fighting, plus the later Adou, who did not succeed, and Zhuge Liang's conceit, as well as Sima Yi's strength! After their generation, Wei produced Deng Ai and Zhong Hui, two geniuses, and Shu only had Jiang Wei, and there were no more famous generals, at that time, there were no generals in Shu and Liao Hua as a pioneer!

So naturally it is a defeat!

Adou does have a little bit of it, but Zhuge Liang's six out of Qishan is simply an egg hitting a stone.

The war competition is the comprehensive strength of the two sides of the war, the three kingdoms.

The strongest comprehensive strength should belong to the Wei State.

1. In "Longzhong Pair", Zhuge Liang analyzed the situation in the world for Liu Bei, and proposed to take Jingzhou as his home first, and then take Yizhou as a top trend, and then try to take the strategic concept of the Central Plains. After visiting the thatched cottage three times, Zhuge Liang came out of the mountain to become Liu Bei's military advisor, and all the strategies after Liu Bei's group were based on this.

2. Persuade Sun Quan to join forces with Liu Bei and defeat Cao Cao at Chibi.

3. Whenever Liu Bei sent troops to conquer, Zhuge Liang was responsible for guarding Chengdu, providing Liu Bei with enough food and soldiers, such as the Battle of Hanzhong, providing aid for Liu Bei.

In the end, it will still perish, because the reason for the final demise of Shu is not caused by economic factors, if the economy is developed for a long time, then the time of the demise of Shu Han may be earlier, after Cao Cao unifies the north, Eastern Wu will cooperate with Liu Bei, so that it can confront Cao Cao, and then there will be no Sima Yi rebellion.

The Three Kingdoms may become two countries, because Liu Bei's geographical location is different, if the economy is developed, it is easy to defend and difficult to attack, which will make their strength stronger, and Cao Cao is very likely to annex Sun Quan's forces, so that the two countries will be established.

The three countries may fight, the situation of the three kingdoms will not appear, the three countries will recuperate, and the other two countries will join together to destroy the Shu state.

If Zhuge Liang does not go on a northern expedition, but chooses to develop the economy, the three countries will remain neutral and develop separately, and the two sides will prolong this struggle for hegemony.

The three-point world he proposed was only one step in the revival of the Han dynasty, and the ultimate purpose was to revive the Han dynasty, so the Northern Expedition was necessary.

Probably because Zhuge Liang did not gain Liu Chan's trust, Zhuge Liang was afraid that one day he would be executed by Liu Chan, so he stayed away from Liu Chan and went to the Northern Expedition.

Because Liu Bei Baidi entrusted the city to Gu, he entrusted the important task of reviving the Han Dynasty to Zhuge Liang, Zhuge Liang was favored by Liu Bei and loyal to Liu Bei, so in order to complete Liu Bei's last wish, he sent troops to the Northern Expedition many times.

Because Ma Jian was appointed to defend the street pavilion, Ma Tan was arrogant, did not follow the advice of the deputy general, and stationed the troops on the mountain, which was set on fire by Sima Yi and the whole army was annihilated, and the vitality of the Shu army was greatly damaged.

Because of the weather, there was no rain for three months in a row, and the moment he was about to succeed, it began to rain, and Sima Yi was also saved.

First, the gap in national strength between the two countries, Cao Wei is located in the north, and the military and civilians have good physical fitness. Second, the Northern Expedition was far away, and the Shu army's lack of food and grass led to failure. Third, Zhuge Liang's subordinates were short of talent, and Liu Chan refused to let Zhuge Liang win the Northern Expedition.

Zhuge Liang's strategy is to join Wu to resist Cao, take Sichuan as the rear, Hubei and Hanzhong as the strategic front line, first divide the world, and wait for the world to change, then go out of Hanzhong and the Northern Expedition to the Central Plains.

Personally, I admire this strategy, but I have a few questions.

One is to use Jingzhou as the center of strategic defense, not only to guard against Wei, but also to keep an eye on Wu, and these two countries want to unify China and will covet Jingzhou, so at this point it has involved a large part of Shu's national strength, resulting in a weak attack, even if Jingzhou was occupied by Wu later, Zhuge Liang Jiang Wei did not forget to set up heavy troops in the direction of Jingzhou when he was in the Northern Expedition to the Central Plains.

The second is that Zhuge Liang later violated his own plan, when the national strength of Shu was just beginning, he rushed to the Northern Expedition without seeing any changes in the world, and later became poorer and poorer, and was overstretched in terms of financial resources, manpower, especially generals, and the cultivation of strategists.

The third is that the Wushu alliance exists in name only, and there are only interests between countries. Therefore, the two countries have great differences in the handling of many issues.

Therefore, I think that in fact, Zhuge Liang's plan is not a big problem, but later in the implementation of the entire strategy is not effective, coupled with the plan did not catch up with the changes, and many emergencies were not dealt with in accordance with the idea of Lianwu to resist Cao, such as the outbreak of the Battle of Yaoting. In addition, many details may not be well considered, such as employment.

The original plan was to use Yizhou and Hanzhong as the base and source of the policy, and Jingzhou as the peripheral town or frontier position. The general policy is still to reject Cao Wei, Donghe and Sun Wu in the north, and when the situation in the world changes, send a general (in fact, Guan Yu who was later decided) out of Jingzhou to attack Xiangyang, and the other way out of Hanzhong to take Chang'an, so as to achieve the strategic goal of raising momentum on both sides and dividing troops to attack together, and lay a dominant position in unifying the world in one fell swoop. In fact, Zhuge sent Guan Yu to attack Xiangyang and Fancheng was already the beginning of this plan, but Sun Quan, who had always coveted Jingzhou, turned his back on the Sun-Liu alliance at a critical moment and attacked Guan Yu, and Jingzhou was lost, which directly led to the destruction of one of the implementation sites of this plan, so that the plan died.

The plan was indeed exquisitely designed, but it did not take into account the intricate strategic environment of the Three Kingdoms and the intertwined interests and balances, and the foundation of the Sun-Liu alliance was not very solid, and it was a bit rash to send Guan Yu to attack Xiangyang. (Personal opinion, for reference only).

Due to the fact that Wei is very strong. He thought that occupying the capital of Wei would be equivalent to weakening its strength, and wanted to take Chang'an-Luoyang-Xuchang from Hanzhong, and send troops from Jingzhou on the other hand. At the same time, they united Sun Quan to attack on both sides.

After destroying Cao, he will fight with Sun Quan for the world. However, the loss of Jingzhou and the failure to attack Sun Quan greatly reduced Shu's strength, and the possibility of destroying Cao was greatly reduced. After accumulating again, Zhuge went out of Qishan, here I personally think that something went wrong, it was too hasty, and it took a lot of strength to consume Shu.

At this point, Shu's strength has not been much, and he died early, and Shu, the weakest country, can imagine what the result will be.

Attack from Jingzhou and Hanzhong, capture Wei, and attack Wu in the south. However, due to Guan Yu's arrogance being taken over by Eastern Wu, the vitality of Shu was greatly damaged, and the plan fell through.

Because Wei accounted for two-thirds of the world at that time, the original plan was to connect Wu and attack Wei, with Hanzhong and Yizhou as the base. All the way out of the slope valley, the meridian valley approached Chang'an. There was also a large army out of Jingzhou and approached Cao Cao's hometown. In addition, Sun Quan went out of Xuzhou or Yangzhou to contain it.

If you want to ask** Something went wrong, Liu Bei's son ascended the throne is a big mistake!

You not only said Zhuge Liang, but also mentioned the Three Kingdoms, don't talk about history?

Because Zhuge Liang's family is good at strategy, they will be used by others, and they will be hated by others, so they fell into a catastrophe.

Although Zhuge Liang mixed well in the Three Kingdoms of Wei, Shu and Wu, when he fell into a catastrophe, everyone didn't want to be too involved with himself!

The Zhuge Liang family had a great influence during the Three Kingdoms period, not only serving as prime ministers in the Shu Han and Eastern Wu regimes, but also Cao Wei, the common opponent of the two countries, with people from the Zhuge family holding important positions, which can be described as all-conquering and illustrious. However, the fate of this noble family was extremely tragic.

It was because their family was good at strategy and mixed well in the three kingdoms that they were worried that he would become a scourge, so they were all killed.

This is because Zhuge Liang's family is good at using stratagems, and they are all more popular, when they were in the Three Kingdoms, they all held important official positions, but their final outcome was also relatively miserable.

Because he is actually because Zhuge Liang's family is better at strategy, they are more popular at this time, but the ending is also miserable.

During the period of the establishment of the Three Kingdoms, the national situation was very turbulent, and the country was not unified. Either today you will be killed by this, tomorrow you will be killed by that.