If Zuo Zongtang managed the Beiyang Naval Division, could the First Sino Japanese War be won?

Can't win, the failure of the First Sino-Japanese War is not because the commander's ability is not good, but because of the rotten Qing Dynasty and the feudal forces, even if Zuo Zongtang is in charge, it is difficult to avoid feudal thinking, so it will still be defeated.

The First Sino-Japanese War could not be won. The key to the defeat of the First Sino-Japanese War lies in the backwardness of the First Sino-Japanese War, so even if Zuo Zongtang manages the Beiyang Naval Division, the First Sino-Japanese War cannot be won.

No, because the main reason for the defeat in the First Sino-Japanese Naval Battle was that the equipment was not good, and Zuo Zongtang had no ability to change the situation.

No, the Beiyang Naval Division lost in equipment, not in people.

I don't think so, because the defeated leaders of the First Sino-Japanese War are only a small part of the responsibility, and the main problem is that the Beiyang Naval Division has ships and no artillery, and it can't beat Japan, so it will lose.

In a draw, Zuo Shuai refused to admit defeat, and Japan could not support the long-term war, so it ended in a draw. Li Hongzhang fought a lot worse, he lacked courage, the Qing army had poor discipline, and the generals without courage could not be suppressed!

Impossible, whoever goes, can't win, because, at that time, the Qing court, too corrupt, spent all the money on the construction of garden funds, ten years, the end of the update of equipment, in addition to the faction fight, the army and the harbor defense, Song Xie is late, let whoever goes, it is also difficult, itself, the highest decision, Taicai, Japan is small, but after the Meiji Restoration, morale is high, moreover, the newly built navy and army, nationalism is high, there is no shortage of famous generals in the army, for example, the navy, Togo Heihachiro, army, Oyama Iwa,

No, it's useless for anyone to manage and lead! Putting aside whether we are lagging behind or not, and talking about internal worries, we will not be able to win.

This problem is a bit big, and if you change it at the time, the result will be the same. But if Zuo Zongtang is at the helm of Beiyang for ten years, he will not necessarily lose. Qing **, that is, Cixi is much better to Zuo Zongtang than Li Hongzhang.

In addition, we are not weak in the first Sino-Japanese War, the weak is the generals who lead the troops to fight, none of these generals can do it, they will not lead the troops to train the soldiers, let alone formulate strategies and tactics, and they don't know how to cooperate with the various arms, even the same is true for Iktang Adu. They were all generals who rose from the destruction of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom, the Twist Army and the peasant uprising, but they could not correspond to the modern army.

No, the reason for the failure of the First Sino-Japanese War was that the entire Manchu Qing Dynasty did not have enough understanding of the navy, and Zuo Zongtang also believed that the navy was only suitable for defense.

1 kind. It was because of the lack of training of the Qing army. Even the soldiers of the 8th Banner, on the bow horse, either "missed the target, or wiped the ground".

Therefore, on the land route, the Qing army was originally defended, and the Japanese army attacked, almost a tie, because the commander was afraid and fled, and the Japanese commander calculated the direction of escape and annihilated. The Qing army must have reinforcements. If there are 1 20,000 reinforcements, the new force will come to flank the attack, and it will still win.

It was the lack of gunpowder of the Qing army. The military expenses of the Qing ** were misappropriated by Li Hongzhang to give Cixi a birthday gift, so the training cost was discounted, and the ammunition production cost was discounted. After Deng Shichang's cannonball hit, there was a "cannonball" that could not be fired, and the sailor opened the cannonball, which was filled with sand.

Trying to die with the Japanese ship Yoshino, he sank with 500 shells + torpedoes. From this point of view, the Japanese army had much more gunpowder.

You can't win the battle, but you won't lose it, how can you sink a Japanese **.

Don't say that Zuo Zongtang is managed by Yue Fei, and the Beiyang Naval Division is also defeated. The cannon of the Beiyang Naval Division fired one shell in four or five minutes, and the artillery of the Japanese ** fired five shells in one minute, and each cannon only had three shells.

No, Zuo Zongtang's success in Xinjiang is inseparable from Hu Xueyan's support, and Hu Xueyan seems to have been killed during the First Sino-Japanese Naval War.

It was not possible to win against the Japanese, because at that time, the gap between China's **equipment and the Japanese's **equipment was too far, and Japan's ** was relatively advanced.

This kind of war at the level of national fortune is not capable of turning the tide by changing one or two main generals. It may be a little better in terms of actual results, but it will still lose fundamentally. The backwardness of the Qing Dynasty does not lie in one or two new **, but in the systematic backwardness, especially in the political system, which means that the central nervous system and brain have been broken, and the condition of the limbs and trunk is not very good.

Can't win! The main thing is that international politics actually has a general director, and if China wins, there will be no "Russo-Japanese War" in the future!

No one can manage it. Unless the administrators are Manchus and are skilled in water warfare, the establishment can win.

The real First Sino-Japanese War, the naval division was a small defeat, and the land war was a big defeat, don't think that Zuo Zongtang is smarter than Li Hongzhang, he is in charge of the Beiyang naval division, and he can't get money at all, and the scale may only be thirty percent.

Can't win! The Beiyang Fleet is the fleet of the Li family.

Even if the Beiyang Naval Division is in charge of Li Shimin, it will not be able to win against Japan, after all, the gap between the ** and the ideological gap is there.

**Corruption, it is difficult to win against anyone, and it is also difficult to win against the feudal system against the capitalist system in the system!

General Zuo Zongtang managed the Beiyang Naval Division, and the Sino-Japanese War was sure to win!!

Definitely win, the same **, the person who uses it is the most important!

No, because that's the Qing Dynasty!

Winning or losing is unknown, but there is one thing, Zuo Shuai will not commit suicide in Hong Kong.

As long as there was no Weng Tonggong, the First Sino-Japanese War could be won.

Not to mention Zuo Zongtang, even the right Zongtang can't win, the Mawei Naval Battle, the Fujian Navy Division was wiped out, and the Fujian Navy Division was founded by Zuo Zongtang.

I don't know, but Zuo Zongtang must be very good-looking, even if he loses, he will lose both, and the Japanese will not take much advantage.

This assumption is great! Then the Beiyang Sailor will definitely win! Whenever I see this history, I have a ......feeling of thinking about heaven and earth, and I feel alone and crying

The second reason is that what can really determine the situation of the First Sino-Japanese War is not a war at sea, but a war on land. At that time, the Qing Dynasty army gave all the more advanced equipment to the army, and these navies were actually very lacking in military equipment, and under this premise, it was impossible to defeat the enemy attacking at that time, and naturally could not win the war.

No, the main reason for the failure of the First Sino-Japanese Naval Battle is that the equipment is not strong, which requires money to pile up, and Zuo Zongtang has no way to solve this problem.

No. During the First Sino-Japanese War, many outstanding generals and soldiers emerged, but the root cause of the failure of the First Sino-Japanese War was not equipment or soldiers, but also the decadent and backward Qing rule.

I don't think so, after all, the fundamental cause of the defeat of the First Sino-Japanese War was the corruption of the Qing Dynasty, and this fundamental reason cannot be reversed by the strength of one person.

The First Sino-Japanese War was a turning point between China and Japan in modern times, after this war, Japan began to use the Qing Dynasty's indemnity money to equip itself, so that its strength to a higher level, so that Japan saw the corruption of the Qing Dynasty and made a plan to invade China. In this war, the Beiyang Naval Division led by Li Hongzhang was almost completely wiped out, and people believed that Li Hongzhang should bear the main responsibility for the First Sino-Japanese War, and thought that the result would be better if he was replaced by Zuo Zongtang. So if Zuo Zongtang is replaced to lead the Beiyang Naval Division, can he win the First Sino-Japanese War?

Personally, I don't think so, Zuo Zongtang can't change the factional struggle in the imperial court, the reality that the Qing Dynasty's treasury is empty, Japan's determination to win the First Sino-Japanese War is very great, and the Qing Dynasty has no determination, so Zuo Zongtang can't win the First Sino-Japanese War.

We will definitely be able to win the First Sino-Japanese War. Because Zuo Zongtang has military command ability, and the management of the troops is very strict. In addition, the combat effectiveness of the Beiyang Naval Division is similar to that of the Japanese army, so it can basically win the Sino-Japanese War.

I don't think it's safe to say that we will win this war, but at least the probability of victory is much higher. Even if it fails, the Beiyang Naval Division will not be completely annihilated. When it comes to fighting a war, the manager is very important.

I think we still can't win, because at that time our society was already lagging behind the world, especially in the military, our ** was quite backward, others were foreign guns and cannons, but we were spears.

The reason for the failure of the First Sino-Japanese War was because ** was not strong enough, and even if Zuo Zongtang was the commander, he might not be able to win.

No, the main reason for the defeat of the First Sino-Japanese Naval Battle was that the equipment was not good, and this was not something that Zuo Zongtang could change alone.

Even if he loses at sea, according to Zuo Zongtang's character, he can win or draw on land, prolonging the war and bringing Japan down.

If the Beiyang Naval Division was managed by Zuo Zongtang, the First Sino-Japanese War would not have been able to win against Japan, because Japan was very powerful. In a naval battle, the Qing Dynasty would lose.

I don't think Japan can win the First Sino-Japanese War, because the strength of the Beiyang Naval Division is not as strong as Japan's.

Definitely going to win. Because Zuo Zongtang is a very pragmatic person, he will definitely manage the Beiyang Naval Division very strictly, and he will eventually win this war.