The resourceful Kong Ming, after Liu Bei s death, why did he keep suffering defeats?

Updated on history 2024-03-23
24 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    Because after Liu Bei's death, the rest of the people didn't believe in Kong Ming, so Kong Ming got too few resources, so he always lost the battle.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Because after Liu Bei's death, the strength of Shu quickly weakened, so even the resourceful Kong Ming has been suffering defeats.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Zhuge Liang's military ability was not good. He is good at governing the country, and he did not bring Zhuge Liang with him in Liu Bei's repeated foreign campaigns.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Because Liu Bei defeated all the elites of Shu Han before his death, and the strength of Shu Han is no longer what it used to be, Zhuge Liang will of course often suffer defeats.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    I think Liu Bei didn't listen to Pang Tong's opinion, and chose to use Zhuge Liang's strategy is very likely because he thinksZhuge Liang has been working for a longer time, so he trusts Zhuge Liang more, and in terms of feelings, Zhuge Liang is closer to Liu Bei than Pang TongTherefore, Liu Bei chose to adopt Zhuge Liang's suggestion, instead of Pang Tong's suggestion, plusZhuge Liang was recruited by Liu Bei Sangu Thatched House, so I think the scales in Liu Bei's heart are biased towards Zhuge Liang.

    In fact, Liu Bei has Wolong Zhuge Liang under his command, as well as Feng Xiao Pang Tong, which is actually a very big advantage for Liu Bei, because Mr. Shui Jing said that Wolong and Phoenix Chicks can settle the world if they have one, this sentence shows that Zhuge Liang and Pang Tong's intelligence is very powerful, and their level is comparable. It is also this sentence that letsLiu Bei clearly knew that when he adopted some suggestions, he had to consider which one to adopt, because Zhuge Liang and Pang Tong's opinions would not be completely consistent.

    I think the reason why Liu Bei did not take Pang Tong's opinion on this matteris because he believes in Guan Yu's ability, even if there are Cao Cao and Sun Quan around Jingzhou, he still believes that Guan Yu can defend Jingzhou for himTherefore, Liu Bei adopted Zhuge Liang's suggestion to develop all the forces of Shu on the basis of stabilizing Jingzhou

    But Liu Bei never thought that Cao Cao would unite with Sun Quan to attack Jingzhou, and Guan Yu couldn't parry it alone, resulting in him finally losing his life in Jingzhou, such a thing is a very pity for both Liu Bei and Shu。I think this kind of thing happened because Liu Bei didn't have a good balance between the suggestions of the two capable people, and he was more biased towards Zhuge Liang in many aspects, but Zhuge Liang was not an immortal, and he would make mistakes sometimes.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Because Zhuge Liang has served longer under Liu Bei, and Zhuge Liang is more scheming.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Pang Tong is as famous as Zhuge Liang, but his ability is much worse than Zhuge Liang! Liu Bei obeyed Zhuge Liang's words, but not Pang Tong! Pang Tong is ruthless and unscrupulous, and Zhuge Liang's plan is according to Liu Bei's heart, this is the gap!

    Liu Bei knows that only virtue and merit have a way out, and Pang Tong let him lose his righteousness and take small altruism, of course he won't do it! If Zhuge Liang followed Liu Bei into Sichuan, he would not lose his life without moving rescue soldiers!

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Pang Tong and Zhuge Liang are both very talented, and there will be disagreements.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Because Pang Tong was dead at that time, there was nothing good to listen to, only to listen to Zhuge Liang.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Because Liu Bei himself was more willing to obey Kong Ming, but in the end, he didn't expect it to have no effect.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    This proposition is unclear and a false proposition.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    Whether it is romance or historical facts, Liu Beifang only has the prestige and ability of Guan Yu, if he stays in Jingzhou and does not move, no one in Cao Sun will dare to attack rashly.

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    In the era of the Three Kingdoms, which is full of talents, Liu Bei went from being unarmed to claiming to be the first of his own family, to the three-legged stand, and finally to the establishment of the Shu Kingdom. All these achievements are inseparable from Guan Yu and Zhang Fei's dedication to Zhuge Liang, and even more inseparable from Zhuge Liang invited by the Three Kingdoms. Others describe such a victorious general who "strategizes and wins thousands of miles away", why did he repeatedly suffer defeats after Zhuge Liang's death?

    On the one hand, it may be that he has not properly employed people, and Liu Chan has not cooperated well, on the other hand, it is also because the strength of Shu has been decreasing.

    When Liu Bei was in the White Emperor City, he knew that his son Liu Chan was not the emperor's material, so he handed over many things to Zhuge Liang, his father. He told Zhuge Liang that some people were flashy and unreusable, and Zhuge Liang, who nodded again and again, agreed on the surface, but after Zhuge Liang's death, he didn't take it seriously, and missed a great opportunity, and Zhuge Liang in the later period regretted not listening to the words of the first emperor Liu Bei.

    And Liu Chan, everyone has heard about it, and Liu Adou, who can't help him, is full of no ambition for his family and country, and he just eats, drinks and has fun all day long. It is also useless to have a gentleman like Zhuge Kongming to teach him, and he cannot cooperate with Zhuge Liang in either military or political aspects. In a smart military advisor, you also need someone to support and assist, with such Liu Chan, how can Zhuge Liang achieve victory after victory.

    However, after Liu Bei's death, Zhuge Liang insisted on the Northern Expedition, fought for many years, and made many Northern Expeditions, which consumed a lot of manpower and material resources of Shu. The military strength of Shu was greatly weakened, and others embraced itsuggested that Zhuge Liang let Shu rest and recuperate, but at this time, Zhuge Liang was in a hurry, eager to fulfill the last wish of the first emperor in his lifetime, and wanted to complete his Longzhong pairNegative. The more he was in such a hurry, the more he could not complete the goal of recovering the Central Plains, so Zhuge Liang failed again and again.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    Because Zhuge Liang is not the lord, Liu Bei's son Liu Chan listened to the villain's advice, so he had great restrictions on Zhuge Liang.

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    At that time, Liu Bei's last battle before his death was to crusade against the Sun Wu regime, and he did not listen to the advice that Zhuge Liang had given him before he left, but resolutely tied the military camp together. As a result, Lu Xun on Sun Wu's side burned the company camp, and finally caused serious damage, hundreds of thousands of troops, killed and wiped out the whole army. This battle greatly hurt the vitality of Shu Han, and it was difficult for Qiao women to cook without rice, and at this time, even if Zhuge Liang was an immortal, it was difficult to maintain.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    That's because Liu Bei once led all his family to fight Jingzhou. I made my foundation very weak. Whether it is from the military or the economy, it has not been good for many years.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    Zhuge Liang, as a capable person, can be said to know astronomy and geography. Many people will wonder why after Liu Bei's death, he never won a battle? Many people may say that the strength of Shu at that time was too unworthy of mention.

    Some people will also say that the strength of the soldiers of Shu is really difficult to compete with Cao Wei. But is that really the case?

    After Liu Bei's death, Zhuge Kongming was ordered to take over the task of the future development of Shu Han entrusted by Liu Bei - the restoration of the Han Dynasty, his daily thought was to revive the Han Dynasty as soon as possible, hoping to unify the country, and never slackened during this period. In order to accomplish the great cause of reunification as soon as possible, he made the decision to go north to fight. In order to promote the victory of this war, before going north, Zhuge Liang discussed with Ma Yan.

    He also used a divisive strategy between Sima Yi and Cao Wei, and as soon as this strategy came out, Sima Yi was not favored in Cao Wei, and was immediately suspended, and Cao Zhen replaced Sima Da as a general. Cao Zhen is a puppet, and Zhuge Liang is basically a piece of cake to deal with him. After the start of the war, it was very successful to take the three places of Anding, Tianshui, and Nan'an.

    However, because of Ma Tan, the street pavilion was lost.

    Zhuge Liang slashed the horse with tears, which became the end of Zhuge Liang's Northern Expedition. Later, the Shu Han army, under the command of Zhuge Kongming, began to attack Chencang. However, the defense was extremely well equipped, and the defenders were very tenacious.

    After fighting for more than 20 days, the place was not captured. When the two armies are at war, food and grass are the key. In the battle with Cao Wei, in order to provide sufficient supplies for the army, Zhuge Liang came up with a new trick - wooden cattle and flowing horses, in the continuous war, the supply of grain and grass for Cao Wei's army was extremely insufficient, and the continuous fighting between the two sides caught Cao Wei's commander Sima Yi off guard, and finally defeated.

    On the occasion of the great victory of the Shu Han army, Li Yan, the general who escorted the grain and grass, did not give enough grain and grass in time, and the Shu army had to suspend the process of continuing to advance northward and returned to Shu instead. Later, Zhuge Kongming once again led the army to the north to fight, this time Sima Yi became smart, and resolutely did not go out of the city to face the battle, so as to achieve the goal of exhausting the grain and grass of the Shu army. In the end, the Northern Expedition ended in failure.

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    Because Liu Bei led the elite of Shu Han and was defeated in the Battle of Yiling. lost a lot of troops, and Zhuge Liang fought more with less, so he kept losing the battle.

  19. Anonymous users2024-01-20

    Because of Liu Bei's battle of Yiling, Shu Han was hollowed out, making Zhuge Liang afraid to fight.

  20. Anonymous users2024-01-19

    Because Liu Bei lost all the elites of Shu Han before his death, Zhuge Liang had no soldiers to use, so he kept suffering defeats; Of course, I guessed the reason, because with the weak strength of Shu Han, it was impossible to build that kind of elite troops.

  21. Anonymous users2024-01-18

    Zhuge Liang was more influential when Liu Bei was alive, and after Liu Bei's death, Zhuge Liang was also older, and there were fewer people who believed in him!

  22. Anonymous users2024-01-17

    It was not that Zhuge Liang had failed repeatedly, but because the national strength of Shu Han was weakening, so Zhuge Liang often failed.

  23. Anonymous users2024-01-16

    Maybe he has lost someone who can cooperate with him tacitly, and his strategy will not come in handy.

  24. Anonymous users2024-01-15

    Because Liu Bei defeated all the elites of Shu Han before he died, this is also one of the reasons for Liu Bei's death.

Related questions
15 answers2024-03-23

Han Xin was bound to die and was stubborn and self-serving, and he didn't listen to persuasion, and Zhang Liang couldn't do anything in that situation, so he could only choose Mingzhe to protect himself.

19 answers2024-03-23

Because Fan Zeng was already very old at that time, and Fan Zeng was a person who valued love and righteousness, he felt that even if he left Xiang Yu, he would not be able to go, so he turned to Liu Bang and became an enemy of Xiang Yu, which was a very immoral thing in his opinion.

8 answers2024-03-23

Outside and Wu State to make a good relationship, internal repair, the development of production, the promotion of economy, recuperation, in order to restore Liu Bei and the Eastern Wu war wounded vitality, while paying attention to the military, so that Wei and Wu do not dare to underestimate, the construction of border facilities, strengthen the military force of the critical area, these are to ensure that the Shu Han Dynasty is not destroyed, the Han family can continue, Liu Bei's son can stand on his own This is one of the wishes. >>>More

11 answers2024-03-23

kidnapped Liu Chan, and had no shame to see Liu Bei, Sun Quan also felt that she had no use value, so he didn't want to see her. Sun Shangxiang decided to commit suicide by throwing himself into the river on Xiulin Mountain in Jingzhou City. When I was about to throw myself into the river, I was anxious to urinate, and after urinating, I hesitated again, and after hesitating for a long time, I became a fossil, on Xiulin Mountain in Jingzhou City, Hubei Province. >>>More

25 answers2024-03-23

Yes. Because Liu Bei's three visits to Kong Ming were rumored to be a good story, Kong Ming went out of the mountain because of this, so he was moved.