If Zhao Guo had changed to other generals, would it be possible to win in the Battle of Changping?

If you change to other generals, it is impossible to win in this war, there are many factors that determine the war, not only the generals, the longer this war drags on, the greater the blow to Zhao State.

It's hard to say, but it will not be as defeated as Zhao Kuo's command, if you stick to your position and don't attack blindly, you can draw.

Yes, because the difference in military strength between the two countries is not large, and Zhao still has the advantage of geographical advantages, it is not difficult to win.

Battle of Changping. It was a key battle of Songqin that decided the situation in the late Warring States period, and in this battle, the Qin state.

The defeat of Zhao caused hundreds of thousands of Zhao troops to be wiped out, and Zhao was reduced from a country that could compete with Qin to the brink of annihilation. The reason for the defeat of Zhao in the Battle of Changping is attributed by many people to Zhao Kuo, who talked on paper.

Replaced the famous general Lian Po.

So if Zhao Guo didn't change generals at that time, was there any possibility of winning?

In the Battle of Changping, even if Zhao did not change Lian Po, Zhao had no chance of victory. The most fundamental reason for the defeat of Zhao in the Battle of Changping was that Zhao's national strength was inferior to Qin's, and it could not support it in the long-term confrontation of attrition, which led to the emergence of King Zhao.

Zhao Kuo, who advocated attacking, replaced Lian Po, who was holding on to each other. Zhao Guo did not change generals, and still appointed Lian Jiezi, and could not change the fact that Zhao State was short of food, and this premise could not be solved, and Zhao State had no possibility of victory.

Lian Po was the commander in the early days of the Battle of Changping, and the reason why he adopted the method of holding each other firmly is not that Lian Po himself would only fight defensive battles. It was because in the early days of the Battle of Changping, the Zhao army suffered losses in the confrontation with the Qin army, and Lian Po had to adopt a defensive position and drag the battle into a stalemate situation. It can be seen that Lian Po's defensive strategy was a last resort, and he had no choice but to defeat the Qin army quickly.

In the Battle of Changping, it was not only Zhao who changed generals, but Qin also changed generals, and they were replaced by the four famous generals of the same Warring States.

It can be said that in the later stage of the Battle of Changping, the overall strength of the Qin army was improved because of the arrival of Bai Qi.

If Lian Po is not replaced, then he said that the combat effectiveness of the Qin army he will face will only be stronger than the Qin army that he failed to defeat in the early stage, and Lian Po himself actually does not have the certainty of defeating the Qin army, in fact, before Zhao changed the general Lian Po, King Zhao had repeatedly ordered Lian Po to take the initiative, but Lian Po was pushed back and finally had to go to Zhao Kuo. The key reason why Lian Po did not listen to the orders of King Zhao was that he was not sure of defeating the Qin army.

Zhao Guo just doesn't change the general Lian Po, and the final result Zhao Guo will also be a failure, and there is no possibility of victory. Because Lian Po can't win quickly, Zhao Guo can't afford it himself. But it is impossible for Lian Po, as the main general, not to know the reality of Zhao Guo's lack of food, and the high-level officials of Zhao State also know it.

Why are they still against Zhao Kuo, in fact, in their opinion, they are on the party.

It is not the land of Zhao, the Battle of Changping Zhao was originally implicated, since it can't be fought, it is best to withdraw the army. Therefore, even if he does not change Lian Po, it is certain that Zhao Guo will not be able to win, but there are many kinds of losses, and the annihilation of the whole army will not happen.

If Zhao did not change generals in the battle of Changping and Li Mao, I think there would be no possibility of victory, because the leaders in the war played a decisive role, and it also determined whether the war could be won. Trillion of things.

No, because Zhao's national strength is weak and he has no strength to resist, whoever fights can only lose.

There is a possibility of victory, because the main reason for the defeat of this war is because the generals did not command well, so it will lead to such a problem.

If there is no change of general, Zhao still has no possibility of winning Yunqing. Wars are fought with national strength. Qin Qiang and Zhao Cha returned to weakness.

But it certainly won't be so badly defeated. The best ending is that the Qin army will not be able to attack for a long time and temporarily withdraw its troops, but the outcome of Qin's unification of the six countries will not change, and it may be delayed for some days.

Possibly, because everything is variable, there is a good chance that one of these factors will affect the final outcome.

Avoiding the destruction of Zhao and other countries will have a very huge effect, which will lead to a stronger country and stronger military power, so that the whole country will be unified.

It may make the strength of Zhao stronger, so that the people of Zhao can live a good life, and maybe Zhao will unify the six countries, and the land area will become larger and the resources will be rich.

Greatly increasing the strength of Zhao will enhance Zhao's influence, and it can also contribute to Zhao's success, be able to maintain his rule, and can defend against foreign enemies.

The Battle of Changping affected the trend of the entire Warring States, and it was also a turning point for the entire Warring States, and after this battle, the six eastern countries were no longer able to resist the Qin army. So at that time, if the Zhao army had always been led by Lian Po, and the Qin army had been led by Bai, who would have been able to win?

Bai Qi and Lian Po were both the four famous generals of the Warring States. But if many of us rank now, we generally rank Bai Qi first, and Lian Po is ranked last. So for many people, they may still think that Bai Qi can win, and at that time, Qin Jun was also an advantage for Zhao Jun.

Then there is a high probability that the Qin army will win.

If you take all aspects into account, the Qin army does have an advantage, Qin's comprehensive national strength is much stronger than Zhao's, and the Battle of Changping was originally a protracted war, and it was not suitable for Zhao to fight a protracted war at all.

Of course, Zhao actually had every chance to win, and when the Qin army captured the wild king of Korea, in fact, Zhao should have realized that the Qin army was aiming to be on the party rather than the wild king. Then at this time, the Zhao army should immediately assemble a large number of Zhao Han borders, once the Qin army moves, the Zhao army will attack immediately, and the probability of the Zhao army winning at this time is the greatest. After all, the Qin army had just gone through the Battle of the Wild Kings and began to attack Shangdang again.

Plus the Qin army at this time was about 200,000. Therefore, if Zhao Jun had been prepared, he could have won.

But history can't be repeated, and we all know that in the Battle of Changping, Qin and Zhao slowly increased their troops, not realizing that such a big battle would break out at the beginning, which decided the fate of the two countries, and even more so the fate of the entire Warring States.

Lian Po is good at defending, but we all know that the Qin army is good at attacking, especially Bai Qi, Bai Qi has too many large and small battles in his life, and there is basically no defeat. If Lian Po and Bai Qi confront each other together, the result is really hard to say.

But the most likely outcome is a retreat of the Qin army. Of course, the Zhao army will not pursue, in fact, the whole country of Zhao did not think that they would win the Qin army, what they wanted was to force the Qin army to retreat by itself, at the beginning, Lian Po's sticking policy was to force the Qin army to retreat, but he did not expect that the Qin army would be more and more.

But we all know that Lian Po lost his position again and again at the beginning, and the first and second lines of defense have been occupied by the Qin army, which is one of the reasons why King Zhao replaced Lian Po. But as long as Lian Po comes to continue to hold on, and there is a steady stream of grain and grass sent in Zhao State, then Lian Po Shou will definitely be able to hold it, at that time, as long as both sides do not take the initiative to attack, in fact, no one has a chance to win.

But Zhao Guo really couldn't hold on, and the whole country was hoping that this war would end as soon as possible, but Lian Po knew that there would be no chance of winning, so he could only hold on. Then it is a sure thing that Lian Po will be replaced. As soon as Zhao Kuo came up, he took the initiative to attack, but he was surrounded by Bai Qi.

Annihilated.

In the end, it was the Qin State that won, because the strength of the Qin State was much stronger than that of other countries, and the Qin State had an advantage in terms of military strength and economic strength.

The final victory will also make the Qin State win, because they have the determination to win, even if it is consumed, it will be consumed in the end, and the Zhao State is simply not capable of accompanying the Qin State to consume together.

The final victory was won by Lian Po, a very powerful Zhao general.

No. Because of the courage of the Qin State, and the bridge Changpin, it is not only how strong his military strength is, but also because the entire comprehensive national strength of the Qin State is strong, and the Zhao State cannot be compared, no matter how fast it is, it is a loss.

No. Because the national strength of Zhao had declined greatly at that time, it was inferior to Qin, and this war was doomed.

Maybe not. After all, the Qin State at that time was too powerful, and the Zhao State couldn't compare.

<> "During the Battle of Changping, who were the people who fought in Zhao State?

The Battle of Changping was the most crucial battle in the middle and late Warring States period, which accelerated the process of Qin's unification of China. Zhao Guo was killed a total of about 450,000 soldiers, and his vitality was greatly damaged. We can't help but sigh, if it weren't for Lian Po and Zhao Kuolai in charge, would Zhao Guo have a chance to win?

Le Yi has a high status in Chinese history, and even Zhuge Liang is his fan. Le Yi almost wiped out the Qi State at its peak in the first battle, and was ranked among the top ten philosophers of Wumiao, along with Sun Wu, Zhang Liang and others. After the Five Kingdoms were defeated, Le Yi defected to Zhao State, but unfortunately Le Yi did not play in Changping.

The year of Le Yi's birth and death is unknown, the Five Kingdoms have been fighting for more than 20 years since the Battle of Changping, and even if Le Yi does not die, he is probably too old to take on a big responsibility. In addition, King Zhao is jealous of people with strong abilities, Lian is quite loyal and is still suspicious, and Le Yi is so strong and an outsider, so he is naturally not considered.

Tian Dan's experience is similar to Le Yi's, the famous Fire Bull Formation helped Qi regroup, Tian Dan was also suspicious of the King of Qi because of this, and was forced to defect to Zhao State, or in exchange for the city. Although Tian Dan served as Xiangguo, he was alone, and the nobles of Zhao State did not like him very much, so he did not have the opportunity to go to the front line to take charge of the army. The story of Xianghe is well-known, and it seems that during the Battle of Changping, Lin Xiangru should also be "rescued".

It's a pity that Lin Xiangru is seriously ill and is critically ill, and he only advised King Zhao to be fierce before choosing Zhao Kuo, and King Zhao Xiaocheng, who was obedient to Lin Xiangru's words, didn't listen to it this time. In the later stages of the Battle of Changping, Lin Xiangru probably died and did not play much of a role.

Li Mu was the last famous general of the Zhao State, but Li Mu was stationed in Yanmen County to guard against the Xiongnu in the early days. At the time of the Battle of Changping, Li Mu should not be very old, and his qualifications were not deep enough, so it was difficult to enter the high-level of Zhao State to participate in decision-making. When the famous general of Zhao Guo is almost dead, Li Mu will have the opportunity to make an appearance.

The Qin generals Huan Qi were ready to go straight to Handan, the national capital, and Zhao Wang Qian transferred Li Mu back from Daiyanmen to counterattack the Qin army, and there was no room for Li Mu to play before.

Although the Zhao State suffered heavy losses in the Battle of Zhiyan of Changping, from the perspective of historical development, no matter who lost the Battle of Changping, there is no need to sympathize. If Zhao wins, it will also dominate and move towards the road of unifying the six countries. Even though Qin's laws are strict, the monarch of Qin is still much stronger than the monarch of Zhao!