In the battle of Qin and Zhao Changping, was Zhao Kuo really wronged?

Updated on history 2024-03-24
11 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    Zhao Kuo was not wronged, because of Zhao Kuo's wrong command, the Zhao army was defeated, but even without Zhao Kuo, the Zhao army would be defeated, but it would not be like the ending of the Battle of Changping, where 400,000 people were killed, so Zhao Kuo couldn't get rid of responsibility.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    In the battle of Qin and Zhao Changping, Zhao Kuo was really wronged, because at this time, the Zhao army could not win. It's cheap. It doesn't help.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    No, except for King Zhao, his responsibility is the greatest, and if he deals with it in Lian Po's stubborn way, he will not have a fiasco.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Zhao Kuo was the main person in charge of the Battle of Changping, which killed many elite troops of the Zhao State, and Zhao Kuo was responsible for the death of the soldiers.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    The reason is that Zhao Kuo directly led to the weakening of the power of the Zhao State in this war, which led to the demise of the Zhao State, so he was scolded for so long.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    Because after the Battle of Changping, the power of Zhao was weakened, and people thought that it was caused by his incompetence.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    Because of the Battle of Changping, which led to a large number of deaths in Zhao's army, people felt that he was the main responsible.

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    In the fifty-fifth year of King Zhou (260 BC), the Spring and Autumn Warring States Period and even the most tragic battle of Changping in ancient Chinese history ended in the defeat of Zhao.

    After this decisive battle between Qin and Zhao, the 450,000 army of Zhao was annihilated by the Qin general Bai Qi.

    From then on, Zhao was depressed and powerless to fight against Qin, so he could only let Qin be the fish and flesh, and after the war, Zhao Kuo became the sinner referred to by Qianfu.

    People believe that he is the culprit of the defeat of the Zhao State, and there are also "paper talks". So, was Zhao Guo's crushing defeat in the Battle of Changping really because of Zhao Kuo's stupidity?

    In fact, during Lian's command of the Zhao army, the Zhao army was always at a disadvantage when facing the Qin army. Sima Qian recorded in the "Historical Records" that the Qin army defeated the Zhao army as soon as it came into contact with the Zhao army.

    beheaded Zhao Hui's eggplant" Soon the Qin army won a complete victory, "trapping the Zhao army and taking the four lieutenants of Erxiang"; In the second month, Lian ordered the Zhao army to "build a fortress for defense", and the Qin army "attacked its fortress again, took the second lieutenant, broke its formation, and captured the western base."

    In fact, Zhao Kuo's decision to attack in person after leading the army was also the order of King Zhao, which was also the reason why Zhao Kuo chose Zhao Kuo as his general. Didn't Zhao Kuo know that the field battles of the Zhao army were inferior to the Qin army?

    But Zhao Guo's feed was in a hurry, and Zhao Jun died in this way. Anyway, it is death, Zhao Jun can only fight to the death, and there may be a glimmer of life. Therefore, Zhao Kuo chose to risk his life to actively attack the Qin army.

    War has a bearing on the survival of a country and must be treated with caution, and it is not uncommon for the country to "rejuvenate the country in a war and destroy the country in a war in a war."

    The victory or defeat of the war not only affects the life and death of the soldiers, the honor and disgrace of the generals, but also affects the survival of the country. How can you deal with it with child's play?

    Is Zhao Kuo really an incompetent person who can only talk on paper? In my opinion, his defeat was not due to ignorance of military affairs.

    Rather, it lies in his contemptible, arrogant, and arrogant character. Like Xiang Liang at the end of the Qin Dynasty, he has the ability to contain Zhang Han and shock the world, but he also has the disaster of destroying the enemy's soldiers.

    At first, Lian Po, the main general of the Zhao army commanding on the front line, the Qin army led by Wang was too sharp and dealt heavy blows to the Zhao army many times.

    Although the Zhao army was unable to defeat the enemy, they happily held the battle, but they still suffered great losses. King Zhao (Zhao Xiaocheng Wang) thought that Lian was incompetent and blamed Lian many times.

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    Not really. He understands soldiers, but he doesn't know how to apply the art of war to actual tactics, only rote memorization.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Actually, no, first of all, the information is not equal, the Qin State is replaced by Bai Qi, Zhao Kuo doesn't know at all, if he knows, he will definitely fight to the death. Secondly, Zhao's national strength is not as strong as Qin's, Zhao can't afford to drag it out at all, so he can only fight quickly, and finally Zhao Kuo is facing Bai Qi, for a novice, the first time he leads the army to face a god of war like Bai Qi, the possibility of winning is bound to be small.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    He really didn't understand, although he read a lot of military books, but he didn't know how to really use it in practice, which led to a big defeat in the end.

Related questions
14 answers2024-03-24

The Changping battle between Qin and Zhao was more likely to win in any way, and Lian Po adopted a defensive policy, which was indeed a good method when Qin was strong and Zhao was weak, but it was not a long-term solution; Since the Shang Dynasty changed the law, the Qin State rewarded cultivation and warfare, and both the quality of soldiers and grain and grass reserves far surpassed that of Zhao. In this war, both sides invested a lot of troops, and after the end of the war, the number of soldiers killed by Zhao alone reached 400,000, and the daily consumption of these 400,000 people was not a small amount. Lian Po has adhered to the defensive policy for more than a year, and Zhao can be said to have tightened his belt to live, Zhao is not as good as Qin, and its geographical location itself is not rich in food, and it is very likely that Zhao will be consumed to death first in a defensive war. >>>More

3 answers2024-03-24

Because Zhao Guojun at that time fell for someone else's counter-plot, he didn't trust Lian Po very much, so he used Zhao Kuo. Although Zhao Kuo was very talented in military affairs, he had no experience in leading troops to fight, and the main reason for the defeat of the Battle of Changping was because Zhao Guojun replaced Lian Po.

5 answers2024-03-24

The main reason is that Zhao Kuo talks about the army on paper and has no experience, in addition, the victory of Qin and the defeat of Zhao are also historical inevitability.

9 answers2024-03-24

Original text: Zhao Kuo learned the art of war since he was a child, and he said that he could not be a soldier in the world. Try to talk extravagantly about military affairs with his father, luxury cannot be difficult, but it is not good. >>>More

8 answers2024-03-24

Because this is the Qin people to show their attitude, although they have always been regarded as barbarians by the Central Plains countries, but they sent troops to help the Zhao State, not only because the Xiongnu were a common threat; At the same time, it is also a tacit understanding between the party and the other. >>>More