Pang Tong, who is as famous as Zhuge Liang, knew that there was an ambush in Luofengpo, but why did

Updated on history 2024-03-20
30 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-07

    Because Pang Tong has a bad mentality, he is in a hurry to make meritorious contributions, and he can't listen to the advice of others.

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    Because Pang Tong laid a foundation for Liu Bei and wanted to show his talent and ability, he entered Luofengpo.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    Because Pang Tong wanted Liu Bei to be famous, even if he knew that there was an ambush ahead, he was willing to sacrifice his life.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    Pang Tong was killed by an arrow when Liu Bei attacked Luocheng, which is now the area of Guanghan in Deyang City, Sichuan Province, and is also the location of Sanxingdui, where Pang Tong was killed by an arrow fired by the enemy on the battlefield.

    Pang Tong's death must have nothing to do with Zhuge Liang, there are three reasons:

    1. Pang Tong and Zhuge Liang are related. Zhuge Liang's second sister is married to Pang Shanmin, the son of Pang Degong, and Pang Shanmin is Pang Tong's cousin, what do you say is the relationship between Zhuge Liang and Pang Tong? The two are related, Pang Tong can become Liu Bei's adviser, that is recommended by Zhuge Liang, Zhuge Liang recommended Pang Tong to follow Liu Bei, and then harm him, this is not a big move.

    Second, Zhuge Liang was not at the scene. When Pang Tong was shot, Zhuge Liang was still in Jingzhou, hundreds of kilometers apart, and there were no mobile phones, **, and no Internet in that era, Zhuge Liang was in Jingzhou, hundreds of kilometers away, if the remote control was hundreds of kilometers away from the Sichuan battlefield, it would not be possible at all. The current criminal law talks about an alibi, let alone ancient times.

    Third, Zhuge Liang has no motive. Killing people should be called motives, don't think that Zhuge Liang and Pang Tong were both military advisors and generals at that time, and they were both strategists under Liu Bei, just think that Zhuge Liang wanted to kill Pang Tong, this is completely nonsense, and the division of labor between the two under Liu Bei is completely different.

    Zhuge Liang focused on strategy, internal affairs and logistics, Pang Tong focused on strategy, and the two of them were both military commanders, which was just a transitional official position, Zhuge Liang's main task at that time was to manage the four counties of Jingnan, collect taxes, establish grassroots political power, and provide personnel and material support for Liu Bei's front-line fighting army.

    And Pang Tong's main responsibility is to follow Liu Bei to go out to fight and provide strategy, Pang Tong followed Liu Bei to fight in Sichuan together, to Liu Bei finally won Yizhou, of which Pang Tong's credit is the greatest, when Liu Bei attacked Yizhou, Pang Tong provided Liu Bei with upper, middle and lower three strategies, Liu Bei before that, there were no strategists to follow, and the appearance of Pang Tong gave Liu Bei a great role.

    If the division of labor is different, there will be no conflict of interest, and Zhuge Liang will not have the motive to kill Pang Tong. So Pang Tong's death has nothing to do with Zhuge Liang.

    So who is Pang Tong's death related to?

    is related to Liu Bei, not that Liu Bei killed Pang Tong, but that Liu Bei should not push a strategist like Pang Tong to the front line to fight, and he can be shot by an arrow and die, which shows that Pang Tong is very close to the enemy, and there is no need for a strategist to go to the battlefield to fight with weapons, and Liu Bei has a little responsibility for Pang Tong's death.

    If Pang Tong took the initiative to fight on the battlefield by himself, then Liu Bei would not be responsible, and the responsible person could only be Pang Tong himself, as a strategist, it was not his duty to go to the front line to fight, but Pang Tong died on the front line, and he had to be responsible.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    It should have nothing to do with Zhuge Liang's death, because Zhuge Liang would not be so stupid and make others doubt him, so if Zhuge Liang was so-called, he would definitely not die in Luofengpo.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    has something to do with Zhuge Liang, Zhuge Liang feels that Pang Tong is very arrogant, so in the end, Pang Tong's death is inseparable from Zhuge Liang.

  7. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    It has to do with it, because Zhuge Liang's framing will make him die, and he will be forced into a desperate situation by the enemy in the war.

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    Zhuge Liang had already told Pang Tong, why did Pang Tong not listen to the advice and insisted on going to Luofengpo to die? (Pang Tong, Zhuge Liang, Liu Bei, Sima Yi, Lu Ma, Guo Jia).

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    ?Pang Tongyi was to save Liu Bei, the second was that he wanted to die and knew that there was an ambush in Luofengpo, so he wrote a suicide note before he came, and the third was that Liu Bei would lose his basis if he didn't take Xichuan and Jingzhou, and he would be a fish that slipped through the net.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Before Pang Tong died in Luofengpo, Zhuge Liang told him the consequences, why didn't Pang Tong listen?

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    Malaysia's "Fatal Travel" will understand that this is the origin of Ma'an Temple.

  12. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    Talented people are always self-righteous... Geniuses are always proud... I will only believe in myself

  13. Anonymous users2024-01-26

    Because of jealousy of Zhuge Liang, at that time, Zhuge Liang sent a letter to Liu Bei, saying that it was not good to go out at that time, but because Pang Tong was jealous of Zhuge Liang and preferred to send troops, which caused consequences, it was better for him to die, if it was Liu Bei's horse riding at that time, he would have shot Shu Han (the lord of Shu Han), and he died better than Liu Bei's death.

  14. Anonymous users2024-01-25

    Destiny!!!

    Pang Tong followed Liu Bei to take Shu, designed to kill Yang Huai and Gao Pei, and got Fushui Pass. Attacking Luocheng, because of suspicion of Liang wanting to fight for merit, he did not dissuade from Liangshu, entered Luofengpo, and Zhongzhang Ren ambushed and died for random arrows, at the age of Chinese New Year's Eve

  15. Anonymous users2024-01-24

    There is a reason why Pang Tong didn't listen to Zhuge Liang, first of all, let's take a look at the background of this incident. At that time, Pang Tong had just defected to Liu BeiTherefore, Pang Tong has no foundation in Liu Bei's regime. Therefore, Pang Tong needs to prove himself with some merits, so as to truly gain a firm foothold in the Shu Han regime.

    Therefore, after Pang Tong followed Liu Bei, he was eager to prove his talent to Liu Bei. After all, Zhuge Liang and Pang Tong are known as Wolong and Phoenix Chicks. As Wolong, Zhuge Liang has gained a firm foothold in the Shu Han regime and has already reached the princes of the world.

    And Pang Tong, who is as famous as him, has no achievements, which makes the arrogant Pang Tong very unwilling. He thought that if he had the opportunity, he could also be as famous as Zhuge Liang. So Pang Tong finally had a chance to make a contributionHe won't give up just because of this nominal Luofengpo.

    Zhuge Liang persuaded him only to make Pang Tong think that Zhuge Liang was preventing him from establishing his merits. Zhuge Liang was afraid that Pang Tong would threaten his position, so Pang Tong would not easily believe Zhuge Liang's words. Although both of them were in the Shu Han regime, they were both friends and rivals.

    In addition, Pang Tong had just entered the Shu Han regime at that time, and it was the time for him to show his skills. So Pang Tong was a little anxious, after all, although Pang Tong had talent, he was never allowed to be reused by others because of his ugly appearance. Pang Tong has been stumbling for half his life, and finally has this opportunity to prove himself.

    Therefore, Pang Tong will hurry up everything to prove himself, after all, he will learn martial arts and the king's family. Although Pang Tong was not young at the time, he was never able to display his talents.

    Pang Tong's heart to make contributions can't wait, and this is the reason why Pang Tong died in the end. Pang Tong's positioning is that of a military advisor, and a military advisor needs a heart that overlooks the overall situation and cannot be disturbed by some things. Pang Tong has already committed a taboo, so Pang Tong's defeat is also doomed.

    It's just that I didn't expect Pang Tong to end up so miserable, and he died on the battlefield for the first time he led his troops to the battle.

  16. Anonymous users2024-01-23

    Because he wanted to give Liu Bei a reasonable reason to attack Xichuan.

  17. Anonymous users2024-01-22

    First of all, Zhuge Liang didn't tell Pang Tong not to go to Luofengpo in advance, he just said in the letter that observing the heavenly phenomena, this expedition has many disadvantages, let Liu Bei be careful, your proposition is wrong. Secondly, Pang Tong didn't know that there was a place called Luofengpo, and it wasn't until he strayed into an ambush that someone told him that this place was Luofengpo. It can be seen that although Pang Tong is proficient in strategy, he is far inferior to Zhuge Liang in terms of astronomy, yin and yang, etc., and he made a wrong interpretation of Liu Bei's dream before the expedition, which shows that he is not good at interpreting dreams.

  18. Anonymous users2024-01-21

    If Pang Tong hadn't designed to die in Luofengpo, Liu Bei would have no reason to attack Xichuan. You can't be famous. Pang Tong made Liu Bei's great cause of Xichuan finally succeed at the cost of his own death. The plan is good, but the sacrifice is too high.

  19. Anonymous users2024-01-20

    Because Pang Tong's personality is more impatient, and as a "phoenix" who can be as famous as Zhuge Liang, his extraordinary talent also makes him a little arrogant, so he didn't listen to Zhuge Liang's words, plus when he first came to Shuhan, he was not treated because of his short appearance, black and thin, he hoped to prove that he could, prove that Zhuge Liang can't do it, so it is even more impossible to believe everything Zhuge Liang said.

  20. Anonymous users2024-01-19

    On the one hand, Pang Tong thinks that his ability is on par with Zhuge Liang, so he is relatively arrogant, and on the other hand, Pang Tong is eager to show his talent before Liu Bei.

  21. Anonymous users2024-01-18

    Mainly because Pang Tong was impatient and a little arrogant, he was eager to prove himself, so he didn't listen to Zhuge Liang's words, and as a result, he secretly ran to the front line to check in Luofengpo and was killed by the enemy's cold arrows.

  22. Anonymous users2024-01-17

    I think I can win, Zhuge Liang is good at planning, many things have been arranged for his subordinates, and many generals in the Northern Expedition rely on Zhuge Liang's clever plans and fail to really exercise themselves.

  23. Anonymous users2024-01-16

    Of course not, Pang Tong's strength is far worse than Zhuge Liang's, at least his military ability can't be compared, so he can't beat Sima Yi.

  24. Anonymous users2024-01-15

    This is not necessarily, I think Pang Tong's talent is not as good as Zhuge Liang, because it is because of his special caution and jealousy that he will fall into a desperate situation.

  25. Anonymous users2024-01-14

    Pang Tong just didn't die.

    It's nothing more than two outcomes.

    He defeated Zhang Ren. Or be defeated by Zhang Ren.

    It's okay to beat Zhang Ren.

    If you are defeated by Zhang Ren.

    Even if he doesn't die today, he won't be far from death. Why? Because Pang Tong has just arrived.

    has no prestige, but has the position of deputy military division, and the generals will definitely not accept it, so he has to establish merit to convince the generals.

    After he was defeated by Zhang Ren, not only did he not increase his prestige, but also decreased.

    Therefore, he will arrange Liu Bei to send troops again, so that his danger factor will be greater.

    The higher the probability of death.

    If Zhang Ren is defeated, his prestige will increase. He doesn't need to push too hard.

    When he left the division, either he sent troops or Zhuge Liang sent troops. It is also possible that the soldiers will be divided into two ways.

    However, the people of Shu are small and small, and the grain is small, and then the troops are divided, not only are there few soldiers, but the food transportation is also troublesome.

    And what about the state of Wei. The grain in Guanglongxi can feed Cao Wei's army for half a year.

    There is no suspense at all, and there are many talents in the Central Plains. There are a few more talents like Hao Zhao.

    Do they have a way to live?

  26. Anonymous users2024-01-13

    The answer is clear, no. After all, Pang Tong's prestige is not as good as Zhuge Liang, and if Pang Tong is there, it will not be able to bring out Zhuge Liang's intelligence and ability, and it will not be able to achieve the effect of Mr. Luo Guanzhong sublimating Zhuge Liang

  27. Anonymous users2024-01-12

    Pang Tong offered Liu Bei to capture Chengdu, all the way like a bamboo, and broke through quickly, but in the battle against Luocheng, Pang Tong was shot by a flying arrow and died.

  28. Anonymous users2024-01-11

    Pang Tong is known as "Phoenix Chick", he is conceited and talented, and in the process of Liu Bei's crusade against Liu Zhang, he was ambushed and died tragically "falling into Fengpo". The reasons for Pang Tong's tragic death are:1

    I was too conceited, and when someone warned him that there might be an ambush, he still set foot in the dead place; 2.He had the idea of comparing himself with Zhuge Liang and wanted to take down Liu Zhang as soon as possible to prove himself.

  29. Anonymous users2024-01-10

    Pang Tong, who was as famous as Zhuge Liang, died tragically in Luofengpo in the end, which was due to the fact that he rode Liu Bei's white horse, and was mistaken by the enemy for Liu Bei's random arrow shooting.

  30. Anonymous users2024-01-09

    After all, Zhuge Liang had already sent a letter to remind him that the commander who attacked Xichuan was more fierce and less auspicious, but he thought that Zhuge Liang wanted to compete with him, so he had to personally lead the army, march from the small road, and attack Yucheng.

Related questions
11 answers2024-03-20

It doesn't matter, in real history, Pang Tong did not die in Luofengpo, but was accidentally shot by a stray arrow when he and Liu Bei were attacking Luocheng, and Zhuge Liang was guarding Jingzhou, Pang Tong and Liu Bei attacked Chengdu, how could they design and mobilize the enemy to kill Pang Tong thousands of miles away? At the beginning, Pang Tong was recommended by Zhuge Liang to Liu Bei, Zhuge Liang was not there when Pang Tong came to interview, Pang Tong did not take out Zhuge Liang's letter of introduction, Liu Bei saw that Pang Tong was ugly, so he made him a county official, and later Zhang Fei passed by the county under the jurisdiction of Pang Tong and found his talent, Liu Bei went to Pang Tong's place to apologize in the starry night, and asked Pang Tong to return to Jingzhou as a military division, if Zhuge Liang was really afraid that someone would rob him of credit, at that time Pang Tong went to Dongwu for an interview, and hit a wall everywhere, and he was really disheartened and prepared to farm in his hometown, Why did Zhuge Liang introduce Pang Tong to Liu Bei? What's more, no matter how divine Zhuge Liang is, it is impossible to mobilize Zhang Ren's troops to ambush Pang Tong in Luofengpo thousands of miles away, you must know that Liu Bei and Pang Tong's troops were divided into two ways at that time, Zhang Ren wanted to ambush Liu Bei, but Pang Tong insisted on letting Liu Bei take the big road, take the small road by himself, and also rode Liu Bei's Lu horse, and finally the archers were shooting arrows towards Lu Ma, and Pang Tong was a substitute for Liu Bei.

24 answers2024-03-20

Zhuge Liang is called Wolong, Pang Tong is called Phoenix Chick, and Sima Yi is called Tomb Tiger. "Tomb Tiger" is the descendant to Sima Yi to obtain the number, in the official history of Sima Yi is unknown, there is no detailed record.

21 answers2024-03-20

1, Guo Jia. This man is really smart! What a ghost! Wizard! All the tricks he made for Cao Cao were dangerous and strange moves, but they all succeeded! It's unpredictable to use troops. >>>More

23 answers2024-03-20

Zhuge Zhan 263 A.D. (the sixth year of Jingyao Yanxing first year) winter, Wei Zhengxi general Deng Aiqi attacked Yinping (now Wenxian County, Gansu), from Jinggu Road to attack, Zhuge Zhan led Shangshu Zhang Zun (Zhang Fei's grandson), Shangshu Lang Huang Chong (Huang Quan's son), Yulin right governor Li Qiu (Li Hui's nephew) to lead the army to resist, after the vanguard troops were defeated, Zhuge Zhan led the Shu army to retreat to Jinzhu, Deng Ai sent a letter to lure Zhuge Zhan: "If you are willing to surrender, I will definitely seal you as the evil king of Lang." Zhuge Zhan was furious, beheaded Deng Ai's envoy, and led the army to battle. >>>More

6 answers2024-03-20

Interesting! I think it's a pity that you don't choose this one!