After the Battle of Guandu, does Yuan Shao have a chance to turn the tables?

Updated on history 2024-03-11
11 answers
  1. Anonymous users2024-02-06

    After the Battle of Guandu, does Yuan Shao have a chance to turn the tables?

  2. Anonymous users2024-02-05

    The Guandu War was a key battle to consolidate Cao Cao's unification of the north. This war and Yuan Shao and Cao Cao two major power groups clashed for more than a year, and finally Cao Cao attacked the Yuan army grain, so that the Yuan army was in a big mood, the Zhao army defeated 100,000 won army, in the traditional impression of many people, Yuan Shao was completely defeated after the war, and it was only a matter of time before Cao Cao was destroyed, after the Guandu War, Yuan You still had a chance to turn over, but unfortunately did not have this necessary condition. According to the "Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms", Yuan Shao was the elite in this war.

    If Yuan Shao didn't die, he definitely had a chance to overthrow, and Yuan Shao was the main attacker in the Guandu War, so he protected the ground and defended the army, and failed. Cao Cao is different. There is not much food and grassland in itself, and he only has about 20,000 people in the battle of Guandu, and there is a threat from Liu Bei in the south, so it is difficult to quickly attack Yuan Shao in the short term.

    According to Liuzhou, landlords, sake, and Bingzhou, the land of Hebei, the battle of Guandu, and Cao Cao's victory were only strategic advantages and players who took the initiative to attack, but Yuan Shao really had the opportunity to give a fatal blow to Tianfeng and others, strategic defense, core defense Cao Cao and other surrounding areas again. After the Guandu War, Yuanyou still had a chance to turn over, but unfortunately he did not have these two necessary conditions.

    It's the rhythm of being laughed at by your subordinates. This is not the temperament that a male should have. But in "Offering the Emperor Spring and Autumn", the evaluation of the elements is still very high.

    The villain is wide, and the people are virtuous. I said. Women in Hebei are complaining, crying in the poetry alley, for example, or dying.

    According to this sentence, the element is to win the hearts and minds of the people, but the credibility of this book is not high. Deliverable. "Gently fiddling with Han Mo, making heresies indiscriminately, and doing his book.

    In this way, it is fully and indiscriminately implemented on the audio-visual, suspicious afternoon students. Historical sinners, who are not drunk with knowledge, also said: "Therefore, the evaluation of the elements of the book can only be used as a reference, and cannot be believed in all."

    > Tan Zhizhi, you can't stand, take the No. 1 car general. It's the wall, and it's empty. Because Xiao Yu did not clearly establish an heir during his lifetime, the interest groups within Xiao Yu fell into infighting, even if Xiao Yu left the position to the head teacher, the outcome was still not optimistic.

    Sulla's short-lived local warlords were not as good as the empires that had been passed down for many years. He has no popular support base. Once you are handsome, there will be many opponents.

    Cao Cao would not give Yuan Tan such a chance. I always thought that Zhang Xueliang changed the flag, and the biggest reason for not resisting entering the customs was this. Due to the defeat of the official road, the detachment from morality within the group is Xiao Wu's character, and if it can be harmonious, there will be no defeat of the official road, so Cao Cao can become a great politician.

    Although Yuan Shao was defeated, his home is still there, and his recuperation life can still be turned over, I think the root cause of the problem is **, that is, Yuan Shao divided four states for his three sons and nephews**, which is equivalent to saying a division of troops and troops, in fact, whether Yuan Shao enters or enters the institute, several sons will definitely fight with their own territory, because the establishment of the eldest son fully shows that Yuan Shao is not a candidate, and he cannot balance internal unity with the various forces of talent in the group, so as to have the opportunity to win against Cao Cao in the nest, led to the demise of the entire group.

  3. Anonymous users2024-02-04

    After the defeat of the Battle of Guandu, Yuan Shao had a chance to turn the tables. Because Yuan Shao still had a very strong military force after the defeat in the Battle of Guandu, he still controlled many important military places, if Yuan Shao had not died, Cao Cao would not have dared to go north.

  4. Anonymous users2024-02-03

    There is no chance, because his strength is relatively weak, he has relatively few troops, and the geographical location is not very good, which does not benefit him in any way.

  5. Anonymous users2024-02-02

    After the defeat in the Battle of Guandu, Yuan Shao did not have any chance to turn the tables. Because of the defeat in the Battle of Guandu, Yuan Shao lost almost all of his military strength, and most of his advisers left him, and Cao Cao's strength became extremely strong. He could no longer compete with Cao Cao.

  6. Anonymous users2024-02-01

    I think there's a chance. As long as he has the strength, he can continue to recruit troops.

  7. Anonymous users2024-01-31

    The reason for the defeat of Yuan Shao in the Battle of Guandu.

    There are rewards to write a total of 19.

    It's cool. Let's talk about following to become the 29th fan.

    The reasons for Yuan Shao's defeat in the Battle of Guandu are as follows:

    First, Yuan Shao was arrogant and eager to win. Prior to the decisive battle with Cao Cao, Yuan Shao had fought against Gongsun Zan on several occasions, leaving the people exhausted and the storehouse insufficient to save.

    Second, Yuan Shao was stubborn and self-serving, and did not accept advice. When Yuan Shaogang decided to conquer Cao Cao in person, Fu Zhu suggested that he rest and recuperate first, and then send troops when the time was ripe. Yuan Shao did not listen and insisted on attacking Cao Cao, which contributed to the fiasco of Guandu.

    Third, Yuan Shaozhi is talented, narrow-minded, and lacks handsome talent. Although Yuan Shao has the ambition to dominate the world, he has no talent to lead troops in battle.

    Fourth, Yuan's army was not united and fought in the nest. Yuan Shao likes to listen to flattery and is not happy for others to put forward opinions contrary to him.

    Fifth, Yuan Shao was inappropriately commanded militarily. When Cao Cao was stationed in Baima, he went to save Yanjin instead of guarding Baima, and fell into Cao Cao's plan to divert the tiger from the mountain. Xu You asked him to surprise his troops to capture Xu Du, kidnap the Son of Heaven, and coerce the Son of Heaven to crusade against Cao Cao, but he disdained it.

    Cao Cao attacked Wuchao, he abandoned the baggage supply of the whole army, but insisted on attacking the Cao army camp.

    Sixth, Yuan Shao's political and moral defeat.

    Seventh, although Cao's soldiers are few, they are fine; Although it will be few, but brave; Although there are few strategists, they are wise; Cao Cao was short, but smart.

  8. Anonymous users2024-01-30

    First, the Battle of Guandu is a famous example of winning more with less! The reason why Cao Cao was able to defeat Yuan Shao was that Cao Cao coerced the Son of Heaven to order the princes, so he was politically more powerful and justified than Yuan Shao, and Yuan Shao lost his morality!

    Second, Cao Cao sent troops to attack Yuan Shao's black nest, burned Yuan Shao's grain and grass, and messed up Yuan Shao's military morale.

    Third, Cao Cao's internal unity, Yuan Shaojun's heart is unstable, and there are many internal contradictions!

    Fourth, Cao Cao knows people well, and Yuan Shao is just self-serving! Don't give advice!

    Fifth, Cao Cao made good use of his soldiers, Yuan Shao raised troops many times, and the soldiers were tired and didn't want to fight!

    Sixth, Yuan Shao was in a hurry to win and commanded improperly!

  9. Anonymous users2024-01-29

    Yuan Shao listened to Guo Tu's advice in the Battle of Guandu, which led to defeat

    Xu You intercepted Cao's military order and learned that Cao's army was short of food. Offering Yuan Shao, he gathered 400,000 troops, and the soldiers were divided into two routes, one with 100,000 horses and horses feintting to attack the camp, and the other way to collect 300,000 elite soldiers to take Xuchang. Whichever way wins, Cao will be defeated.

    However, Yuan Shao listened to Guo Tu, thinking that this military order was a trap laid by Cao Cao, which led to the missed opportunity in the battle of Guandu. Xu Yu was helpless, and finally defected to Cao Cao, offered advice to Cao Cao, and burned the black nest, which was an important reason why Yuan Shao lost to Cao Cao.

    In addition, Yuan Shao's personality is undecisive, and he also changes orders every day, three orders a day, the previous order has not arrived, and the latter order is issued again, and the soldiers do not know how to deal with it. Xu You suggested that Yuan Shao send troops to attack Xuchang, and Yuan Shao felt justified and gave the order.

    Tian Feng knew that he later asked the lord to suggest not to attack Xuchang at present, but Yuan Shao felt that it made sense and then reissued a new order not to attack Xuchang. It is also difficult to succeed in such a main attack without assertiveness.

  10. Anonymous users2024-01-28

    Since the Western Jin Dynasty, there has been a discussion about why Yuan Shao lost the battle of Guandu, but the conclusion reached for more than a thousand years is very similar. These are the direct causes of Yuan Shao's failure, of course, why Yuan Shao wanted to take back the Han Xian Emperor's purpose is known to the world, Yuan Shao's psychology of wanting to usurp the throne is actually well known, so the people's hearts are on Cao Cao's side, which is the key to Cao Cao's victory, so Yuan Shao's failure is not only for military reasons, but also for a multi-faceted reason, of course, the most important thing is that Yuan Shao is too light and careless, which makes him miss the best opportunity to unify the Central Plains.

  11. Anonymous users2024-01-27

    The reason for Yuan Shao's defeat in the Battle of Guandu:

    1. Yuan Shao is not good at employing people. Yuan Shao, who had all the soldiers and horses of the four major states of Hebei, Qing, You, and the four major states, and had an army of 700,000 to recruit Cao Cao, originally had many brave generals with skills and abilities, such as Zhang He was a fierce general with pure martial arts, unique skills, and able to take charge alone, but he didn't use Zhang He to guard the black nest of grain, but sent a drunken Chun Yuqiong to this extremely important post.

    2, Yuan Shao doesn't need good talents, but even more bad schemes. Later, Xu You surrendered to Cao Cao Xinlu and brought Cao Cao some important military secret information from the Yuan army, which contributed to the Cao army's military plan to attack Wuchao at night, which made the battle take a major turn, thus turning the tide of the war in one fell swoop, and turning Cao Cao's weak army into victory.

Related questions
11 answers2024-03-11

Yuan Shao will still perish. Because a person's character is very important, Yuan Shao's self-righteous character will make him fail. Without Guandu, there may be other battles to end Yuan Shao. >>>More

20 answers2024-03-11

Jizhou, where Yuan Shao is located, is a land rich in money and grain, and Yuan Shao sits on the territory of Ji, Bing, Qing, and Youzhou much larger than Cao Cao, and it is naturally easier to raise grain and grass than Cao Cao.

7 answers2024-03-11

The five reasons for the lack of food in the battle of Cao Caoguandu are as follows: first, the basic plate is too small, and there is only one place, Yanzhou; second, there are many local officials who violate the yang and yin; third, Liu Bei frequently attacked and harassed the rear; Fourth, Cao Cao had just finished attacking Xuzhou before; Fifth, it consumes a lot during transportation.

19 answers2024-03-11

After the defeat, the regime was very unstable, and the Eastern Jin Dynasty quickly went on a northern expedition. >>>More